Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having to do prayers on Christmas Day

560 replies

Fretfulmum · 25/12/2023 23:50

DH is Christian and he and his family are quite religious- goes to church weekly etc. I’m not Christian and I don’t attend church or do anything religious, I’m pretty much an atheist. We hosted DH’s parents and siblings and partners today. His parents wanted to do prayers before Christmas lunch. I told DH I’m not happy about having to do it but just let them get on with it whilst I sat there. In the evening, they wanted to do more. I’d had enough and I left the room without saying anything and let them crack on with it. Half way through the DC (toddlers) realised I wasn’t there and left the room to see where I was so they missed some of it. DH was so angry with me that I didn’t partake as it was a “whole family unit” thing and it disrespected his whole family? Apparently I ruined the day and now he’s sleeping in the spare room. AIBU that’s it my house and if I don’t want to do religious prayers that I sit out and go into another room ?

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:09

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 13:04

Do you think that because you haven’t read the OP’s posts?

Possibly. I will go and do due diligence.

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:08

Fretfulmum · 26/12/2023 00:22

The prayers are quite intense. It’s not the Lords Prayer type, it makes me feel a bit uncomfortable if I’m being honest.

You are right that this is part of something deeper. I don’t get on that well with the in laws for various other reasons. I think they and DH should also respect my want to not partake if I hold differing religious views.

We agreed for DC to learn about both of our religions (although I’m not religious at all), and then they could choose what they want to do when they’re a bit older. We do celebrate my main festivals in the year too but it’s mainly me who does something little for the DC, nothing like Christmas celebrations.

Sigh, if they are happy clappy it can be a bit of a pain, true. They should bear in mind your feelings as well as theirs, too.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/12/2023 13:08

I've honestly never known a thread like this for not reading the OP's posts; it's all there, but still some stampede to comment on things which have already been clarified, often repeatedly

Why on earth do some do this - I mean, what the heck's the point?? Confused

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 13:04

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:01

I do not think they are doing this, I think they merely expect that their belief is accepted. Walking out is very rude.

Do you think that because you haven’t read the OP’s posts?

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:03

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 12:59

I would have no objection to sitting quietly with my hands folded during prayers.

This was not an option.

As for DCs, they have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it

That is not the OP’s responsibility.

Denying DCs religious knowledge is just as bad as forcing it on them.

Nobody is doing this.

All this information is in the OP’s posts.

DC's have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it.
Educating your DCs is the responsibility of both parents. Understanding religion is about being educated. How can you decide you are an atheist if you don't know what you are rejecting?

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 13:02

NB Christmas is a Christian festival in a world where Christianity is persecuted.

In the U.K. it is a secular and religious festival and Christians are not persecuted.

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:01

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 03:16

So why doesn’t that flow both ways? Why can DH’s family not respect that OP does not want to actively participate in their prayers?

Why is it okay for someone to demand that you worship their god?

I do not think they are doing this, I think they merely expect that their belief is accepted. Walking out is very rude.

Lesserspottedmama · 27/12/2023 13:01

You’ve embarrassed your husband and made yourself look crass and ill-mannered. How hard is it just to sit quietly for a couple of mins, completely lacking in respect for the family you’ve married into. Very arrogant and ignorant, it’s like something a teenager would do.

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 12:59

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 12:54

I have taken part in Hindu prayers in my time, and also worship. Also attended mass many times - though not taken communion as I am not in communion with Rome. Neither atheist nor agnostic but a cultural Christian. I take part in change ringing, too, and understand that when I ring bells I am carrying out an act of worship as well as having fun. I would have no objection to sitting quietly with my hands folded during prayers. I'd be happy to teach my DCs about Christmas etc and read stories about it, too (did to my now adult children who are both atheists, their grandfather on my side was a lapsed RC, on the other side a Hindu - I also taught them about Hinduism, as well as reading Greek, Norse and Egyptian myths to them). I think you were rude to walk out. Had you arranged to be doing something else that is ok, if discussed. As for DCs, they have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it, so that they can choose to believe or not. It is not, as some people have suggested, a problem for the future, but a necessity you need to grasp. I'd start by acquiring a good children's Bible and some good versions of the Nativity - there are lots. Denying DCs religious knowledge is just as bad as forcing it on them. It's not forcing to read them stories so that they are aware of the Christian heritage, which will come in useful whatever they decide about belief (try reading Lord of the Flies, or Lord of the Rings, without an understanding of the Christian mythos; this applies to most English novels btw).
NB Christmas is a Christian festival in a world where Christianity is persecuted. I think it is reasonable for those who believe to say prayers. Were I them I would keep things short - God (if he exists) perfectly understands family dynamics and that Christmas is about being happy and with family as well.

Edited

I would have no objection to sitting quietly with my hands folded during prayers.

This was not an option.

As for DCs, they have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it

That is not the OP’s responsibility.

Denying DCs religious knowledge is just as bad as forcing it on them.

Nobody is doing this.

All this information is in the OP’s posts.

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 12:54

I have taken part in Hindu prayers in my time, and also worship. Also attended mass many times - though not taken communion as I am not in communion with Rome. Neither atheist nor agnostic but a cultural Christian. I take part in change ringing, too, and understand that when I ring bells I am carrying out an act of worship as well as having fun. I would have no objection to sitting quietly with my hands folded during prayers. I'd be happy to teach my DCs about Christmas etc and read stories about it, too (did to my now adult children who are both atheists, their grandfather on my side was a lapsed RC, on the other side a Hindu - I also taught them about Hinduism, as well as reading Greek, Norse and Egyptian myths to them). I think you were rude to walk out. Had you arranged to be doing something else that is ok, if discussed. As for DCs, they have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it, so that they can choose to believe or not. It is not, as some people have suggested, a problem for the future, but a necessity you need to grasp. I'd start by acquiring a good children's Bible and some good versions of the Nativity - there are lots. Denying DCs religious knowledge is just as bad as forcing it on them. It's not forcing to read them stories so that they are aware of the Christian heritage, which will come in useful whatever they decide about belief (try reading Lord of the Flies, or Lord of the Rings, without an understanding of the Christian mythos; this applies to most English novels btw).
NB Christmas is a Christian festival in a world where Christianity is persecuted. I think it is reasonable for those who believe to say prayers. Were I them I would keep things short - God (if he exists) perfectly understands family dynamics and that Christmas is about being happy and with family as well.

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 12:42

ohdamnitjanet · 27/12/2023 09:46

You know why we celebrate Christmas don’t you? You were rude, but your dh isn’t exactly showing Christian forgiveness. He sounds a bit twatty tbh.

Because it corresponds with traditional mid winter celebrations particularly the solstice.

That is why so much emphasis is placed on Christmas when it isn’t the most important holy day in the Christian calendar.

TriOptimim · 27/12/2023 12:12

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 08:13

@GuessItsANameChange

It's not comparable. I've happily joined multi faith prayers. If it was prayer to something I don't believe I'm I'd probably direct the prayer to the god I believe in silently in my head.

But the point is OP is atheist. It's a protected belief and deserves respect certainly but her belief is there is no God. So she's not offending her beliefs in that 5 minutes she's just doing something she considers pointless. It's not comparable to ask if a Christian would prey to a different god to humor others because the very act is against their faith.

Right. So atheists should have to say words they disagree with but not Christians. But it's always atheists who are disrespectful to Christianity.

TriOptimim · 27/12/2023 12:09

comfyshoes2022 · 27/12/2023 02:01

I have at various points in life been present for people praying in different faiths to mine ( Jewish and Muslim vs Christian). I do not speak the words but I have no problem being present quietly while others are praying. I don’t think it would make a difference whether it was in my home or somewhere else. I would even do it for a fairly extended length of time provided that it was on a one-off or occasional (as in, yearly or less) basis. So I am sorry but guess I do feel YABU. This just seems like being respectful of family members’ beliefs and not a particularly large sacrifice.

But she was expected to speak the words though.

akittencalledjesus · 27/12/2023 09:53

ohdamnitjanet · 27/12/2023 09:46

You know why we celebrate Christmas don’t you? You were rude, but your dh isn’t exactly showing Christian forgiveness. He sounds a bit twatty tbh.

Yes. We celebrate it because of religions and traditions that predate Christianity selfishly hijacking it as their own.

If you have a tree, tinsel, lights etc then your Christmas isn't solely Christian. HTH.

ohdamnitjanet · 27/12/2023 09:46

You know why we celebrate Christmas don’t you? You were rude, but your dh isn’t exactly showing Christian forgiveness. He sounds a bit twatty tbh.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/12/2023 09:35

I'm fecked if I'd put up with elongated praying at the table. The only necessary response is shut up and eat before it gets cold

Good luck with that, if - as it appears here - there's a performative aspect to this

With some, all that's likely to achieve is an even longer chant/whatever

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 09:05

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 08:13

@GuessItsANameChange

It's not comparable. I've happily joined multi faith prayers. If it was prayer to something I don't believe I'm I'd probably direct the prayer to the god I believe in silently in my head.

But the point is OP is atheist. It's a protected belief and deserves respect certainly but her belief is there is no God. So she's not offending her beliefs in that 5 minutes she's just doing something she considers pointless. It's not comparable to ask if a Christian would prey to a different god to humor others because the very act is against their faith.

Atheism isn’t just neutrality - some kinds of Christianity can have offensive elements e.g lack of tolerance & sexism or doctrine that some find toxic eg on original sin. Obviously there are massive differences in Christian beliefs, but it should be possible to understand why quietly leaving the room could have been the best option in the circumstances.

The OP is not talking about all Christians and all atheists, she is discussing a specific group of people.

It seems that in this case her actions have exposed different expectations that should have been honestly discussed, and that is a good thing.

MrDirtyBear · 27/12/2023 08:45

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 08:13

@GuessItsANameChange

It's not comparable. I've happily joined multi faith prayers. If it was prayer to something I don't believe I'm I'd probably direct the prayer to the god I believe in silently in my head.

But the point is OP is atheist. It's a protected belief and deserves respect certainly but her belief is there is no God. So she's not offending her beliefs in that 5 minutes she's just doing something she considers pointless. It's not comparable to ask if a Christian would prey to a different god to humor others because the very act is against their faith.

Incorrect. It would be offending my beliefs and my absence of faith to participate in such a ceremony. Its an act of subjugation. Its a removal of an equal right.

It's a line of reasoning that always ends with atheists being pushed around by the religious. Some go along with it, others don't.

Equally some of us don't like the mockery that it requires. If you demand that I disrespect someone else's religion by making bibble bibble noises under my breath in order to mimic an act of prayer you would find me verbose on how it would be poor manners.

All for the aesthetic that everyone in a room is of one faith? Come on. It doesn't take much effort to treat atheists with a modicum of respect and give them back agency in social situations.

Freedom from religion please.

Citrusandginger · 27/12/2023 08:27

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 04:08

Yes I think you are unreasonable. It's Christmas they are Christian. But take the religion out of it because that always has atheists showing no respect for Christianity. Your own husband wanted you to stay in the room for 5 minutes to be with him for something that is important to him and has been important to him for a long time. Yes you are unreasonable. What if he had asked you to come see something important to him in the garden or watched him play a song on an instrument would you refuse because you don't want to put shoes on or his taste in music sucks? No you humor him because he's your husband and that is important to him

But it seems that the DH's religious behaviour escalated somewhat in the presence of his wider family.

It sounds to me as if OP and her DH have tolerated each other's beliefs up to now. Today, in the presence of family members he sees infrequently, the DH went along with their preference for extended prayer. That is also OK, even though it isn't usual for him.

The bit that is very definitely not OK is expecting OP to go along with this and sulking because she didn't.

PurpleBugz · 27/12/2023 08:13

@GuessItsANameChange

It's not comparable. I've happily joined multi faith prayers. If it was prayer to something I don't believe I'm I'd probably direct the prayer to the god I believe in silently in my head.

But the point is OP is atheist. It's a protected belief and deserves respect certainly but her belief is there is no God. So she's not offending her beliefs in that 5 minutes she's just doing something she considers pointless. It's not comparable to ask if a Christian would prey to a different god to humor others because the very act is against their faith.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 27/12/2023 07:59

I refer back to my reply. So called Christians on this thread - many of your responses are so unhelpful, hostile and unloving. You represent what you supposedly follow very poorly. You even misuse scripture to put this woman down and that's not ok. All this does is polarise things even more, well done!

sashh · 27/12/2023 06:04

Castlerock44 · 27/12/2023 03:12

How dare those Christians want to pray on the most important date in their calender. 🥺 All religions have their practices that should be respected.

Christmas IS NOT the most important date for Christians.

OP

It is down right rude to try to force you to take part in a religious event you do not believe in in your own home.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 05:06

Also, why does “well you married into a Christian family” keep popping up, but not the opposite?

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 04:55

Workworkandmoreworknow · 27/12/2023 04:42

For 5 minutes, knowing that you had married into a religious family and it was one of the most important days in the religious calendar, you were rude to walk away.

I am atheist but get that Christmas is about more than Santa for many people. It's not difficult to respect that for 5 minutes. And especially not when it literally involves sitting there.

You should apologise and then put in place a plan going forwards otherwise it is going to become a thing in your marriage.

You seem like yet another that hasn’t read the OP’s posts. She isn’t being asked to merely sit in the room, she’s being asked to participate in their prayer by chanting things that she finds objectionable.

AgentJohnson · 27/12/2023 04:52

If they are like this with you, imagine the pressure your kids will be under. The issue is your DH says and does the right things when his parents aren’t around but resorts to a deferential little boy when they are around.

Once he’s done sulking you need to reiterate that you are not Christian and this isn’t news to him. If he wants someone who is Christian or a wife that will be dictated to in her own home by his parents, then he needs to decide if being married to me is something he can ‘live’ with.

I grew up in a Christian house and when in the company of others I will lower my head and use the time to think about random stuff. However, in my own home, I will not be dictated to by guests and go along with things because my other half lacks a backbone. Good luck with you children ‘choosing’ their own path with a father and PIL like yours.