Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having to do prayers on Christmas Day

560 replies

Fretfulmum · 25/12/2023 23:50

DH is Christian and he and his family are quite religious- goes to church weekly etc. I’m not Christian and I don’t attend church or do anything religious, I’m pretty much an atheist. We hosted DH’s parents and siblings and partners today. His parents wanted to do prayers before Christmas lunch. I told DH I’m not happy about having to do it but just let them get on with it whilst I sat there. In the evening, they wanted to do more. I’d had enough and I left the room without saying anything and let them crack on with it. Half way through the DC (toddlers) realised I wasn’t there and left the room to see where I was so they missed some of it. DH was so angry with me that I didn’t partake as it was a “whole family unit” thing and it disrespected his whole family? Apparently I ruined the day and now he’s sleeping in the spare room. AIBU that’s it my house and if I don’t want to do religious prayers that I sit out and go into another room ?

OP posts:
Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 18:00

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 17:57

I’d assume that most (of not all?) Christians are agnostic. Gnosticism doesn’t seem to be compatible with the Christianity (not least, the concept of faith).

Gnosticism refers to the practice of the spiritual perception of reality rather than material reality. It's the basis of aestheticism in the sense of subduing the body to the spirit and is also the source - eventually - of a lot of misogyny surrounding women since women are very clearly of earth. To be agnostic is to be in two minds or unsure and open to opinion on whether God exists.

Ponderingwindow · 27/12/2023 17:58

As an atheist, I don’t reject the concept of something unseen. We could be brains in jars. We could be a complex computer program. The world might have been created in 6 days. I can’t disprove all sorts of things. I reject the concept of worship. No being is worthy of my worship, even if that being has something to do with my existence. Every sentient mind is just as important as any other.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 17:57

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:51

There is no evidence. The battery of faith alone is required - as St John of the Cross pointed out, there will be no answer. I am vaguely agnostic btw.

I’d assume that most (of not all?) Christians are agnostic. Gnosticism doesn’t seem to be compatible with the Christianity (not least, the concept of faith).

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 17:23

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/12/2023 17:09

The problem of evil. That's my proof.

Tbf, that applies to one particular God, not all Gods.

I do agree though. I don’t think that the existence of a benevolent, omniscient and omnipotent god is compatible with the world we live in and am wholly unconvinced by the attempts to rationalize it.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/12/2023 17:09

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:36

I do not believe anything without evidence, that includes being atheist. You will know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence?

Edited

The problem of evil. That's my proof.

MrDirtyBear · 27/12/2023 16:55

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:36

I do not believe anything without evidence, that includes being atheist. You will know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence?

Edited

What evidence do you have that the tens of thousands of other gods and religions that you've rejected aren't the right one?

Atheists just go one further.

I'll add those that make extraordinary claims must supply extraordinary evidence.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 16:52

thankyouforthedayz · 27/12/2023 16:41

OP massive drip feeding here! You should not have to participate in or even sit silently through anything that you dont want to, in your house or anyone else's. But you handled it badly, because you did a vanishing act which unsettled your toddlers and undermined their participation. You knew the prayers were starting because you left the room to let them "crack on" and although your house has multiple rooms and you don't announce your departure from a room, in this case you should have done because you knew you were leaving deliberately. "It's lovely to share Christmas with you but I'll leave you to pray, I'm going to lie down/ wash the dishes/ etc DCs Mummy's going to be in x room, but you stay and have prayers with Granny/Daddy etc". If DH can't be honest with his parents about the faith practice in your house you shouldn't be expected to collude with him misleading them.

But she has already made clear to all of them that she is not a Christian, and they still get annoyed or angry if she doesn’t pray. Ultimately, they are not tolerant people and I don’t think choosing the least confrontational way of avoiding participation is necessarily wrong, not least at a family get-together.

No doubt if the OP had expressed that she didn’t want to actively join in, and a DH or his family got annoyed, posters would be asking “could you not have just quietly taken yourself into another room before they got started?”

thankyouforthedayz · 27/12/2023 16:41

OP massive drip feeding here! You should not have to participate in or even sit silently through anything that you dont want to, in your house or anyone else's. But you handled it badly, because you did a vanishing act which unsettled your toddlers and undermined their participation. You knew the prayers were starting because you left the room to let them "crack on" and although your house has multiple rooms and you don't announce your departure from a room, in this case you should have done because you knew you were leaving deliberately. "It's lovely to share Christmas with you but I'll leave you to pray, I'm going to lie down/ wash the dishes/ etc DCs Mummy's going to be in x room, but you stay and have prayers with Granny/Daddy etc". If DH can't be honest with his parents about the faith practice in your house you shouldn't be expected to collude with him misleading them.

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 16:25

SoreAndTired1 · 27/12/2023 13:22

You should have done that BEFORE responding, that way you wouldn't have made such an idiot of yourself!

I did not know that you could till someone pointed it out. Now I have.

SpecialCharacters · 27/12/2023 16:24

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:36

I do not believe anything without evidence, that includes being atheist. You will know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence?

Edited

I think you’re referring to ‘strong atheism’ here - which is an explicit rejection of the possibility of the existence any god(s). That’s one type of atheism that, I agree, is not evidence based. It’s also not very widely believed - even the likes of Richard Dawkins shy away from it.

Most atheists simply do not believe in a god, as opposed to actively rejecting the possibility.

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:51

akittencalledjesus · 27/12/2023 15:50

Yes, I do know that. But there has been nothing, anecdotal or otherwise, that gives me any reason to believe in some sort of higher power.

People have been trying to prove the existence of a god for hundreds of years and have managed to produce nothing. So what am I supposed to do with that?

There is no evidence. The battery of faith alone is required - as St John of the Cross pointed out, there will be no answer. I am vaguely agnostic btw.

akittencalledjesus · 27/12/2023 15:50

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:36

I do not believe anything without evidence, that includes being atheist. You will know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence?

Edited

Yes, I do know that. But there has been nothing, anecdotal or otherwise, that gives me any reason to believe in some sort of higher power.

People have been trying to prove the existence of a god for hundreds of years and have managed to produce nothing. So what am I supposed to do with that?

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:36

I do not believe anything without evidence, that includes being atheist. You will know that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence?

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 15:32

1dayatatime · 26/12/2023 22:12

@LittleRedSnidyHood

"Hmmm, I think it's a bit rude imposing your religion on a non religious house."

+++

I completely agree but I would go further and question why is the religious Christian festival of Christmas being imposed on a country where the majority are not Christian.

And if for the majority it is just about time off work, booze, eating and presents then let's at least be honest about it and rename it

We don't impose Christmas, people embrace it. Unfortunately, because for most the religious element has gone, both the Christian element and the pagan bits (not that many, but some), the entire thing has been roped into the consumer society and drives the economy. It is difficult to row back from this sort of capitalism but we need to, if only to make the planet less polluted. Christianity has been the religion of the UK - and most of Europe - for over a thousand years so it is hardly imposing a festival on people. It is now celebrated as the Saturnalia, the feast of the returning sun, but it might be better if we actually remembered why we are celebrating, esp. currently.
All that aside, two things strike me from the OP's posts. The first is that the festivals of her religion don't get the same treatment as Christmas, and I think they should. The second is that her in-laws strike me as the sort of people Jesus called the Christ condemned as all show and no substance. Lots of prayers and attendance at church, ostentatious praying at Christmas, not just grace. I hope they do good works somewhere, if not, why not?
Glad someone mentioned one can read all an OP's posts in one go, did not know that until now and used to plough through, which always causes disjuncts.
NB Renaming Christmas has been suggested and every time has been greeted with disapprobation even by those who do not see it as a religious festival. I think doing that would mean we would consign to the dustbin the last festival we have left in this country, for we hardly celebrate Easter much and Whitsun has gone down the pan. About time we revived them all instead, perhaps.

akittencalledjesus · 27/12/2023 15:23

How can you decide you are an atheist if you don't know what you are rejecting?

Easy. No one has provided me with evidence that the god they believe in is real because there is no evidence beyond anecdotal, which isn't reliable because of confirmation bias.

To turn it around: as a rational human being, how can you decide you believe in something for which there is no real & objective evidence?

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/12/2023 14:52

How can you decide you are an atheist if you don't know what you are rejecting?

This is such bollocks. Firstly, it's shoved down our throats from everywhere from birth. Secondly, it's evangelising nonsense. "Just let me tell you the good news so you can decide". No ta, I'll teach my children all about culture and difference and belief myself without having to pray to do it. And about religion in the same way I teach them about addiction and stamp-collecting. Some people do it, they feel some comfort doing it, it brings them joy but I don't need to try stamp-collecting or heroin to know it's not for me. And it can be benign but it's also caused some horrifying behaviour and justified a lot more.

I hope everyone teaches everything from the Inquisition to the Nazis before their children 'decide' to believe.

JesusdroveaHonda · 27/12/2023 13:37

Cancel the prayers, OP!

Seriously, does anyone else feel this thread is becoming the new "cancel the cheque"? 😁

SoUtterlyDoneIn · 27/12/2023 13:30

If you have no beliefs about prayers at all then the only real life actual outcome is whether or not Christmas goes smoothly.

If on the other hand you would like people to respect what you believe so you don't feel like a hypocrite, it becomes a different conversation. A conversation about how people should respect each other's beliefs.

SoreAndTired1 · 27/12/2023 13:28

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/12/2023 13:08

I've honestly never known a thread like this for not reading the OP's posts; it's all there, but still some stampede to comment on things which have already been clarified, often repeatedly

Why on earth do some do this - I mean, what the heck's the point?? Confused

Yes, they juust show what fking ignorant idiots they are. Jaysus, it doesn't take long to read all the OP's replies via Read all before responding. It's just basic courtesy and common sense. Some on her are pig ignorant and lazy. They embarrass themselves. And they completely waste their own time replying about something that was cleared up pages/days ago. I mean, truly, how fking hard can it be, to check all OP responses before posting? It's just wasting everyone's time and shows such ignorance, laziness and disrespect.

SoreAndTired1 · 27/12/2023 13:22

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:09

Possibly. I will go and do due diligence.

You should have done that BEFORE responding, that way you wouldn't have made such an idiot of yourself!

SoreAndTired1 · 27/12/2023 13:21

Lesserspottedmama · 27/12/2023 13:01

You’ve embarrassed your husband and made yourself look crass and ill-mannered. How hard is it just to sit quietly for a couple of mins, completely lacking in respect for the family you’ve married into. Very arrogant and ignorant, it’s like something a teenager would do.

@Lesserspottedmama You embarrass yourself by not READING THE FUCKING THREAD or at least OP's posts, before responding. It was a ten minute (2 x 5 minutes) religious performance, and she wasn't allowed to 'sit quiet', she was expected to hold hands, participate, recite and chant. "Sitting quietly" WAS NOT AN OPTION!!!! And this, is in OP's own home! That she owned before she met her 'D'H.

SoreAndTired1 · 27/12/2023 13:19

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:01

I do not think they are doing this, I think they merely expect that their belief is accepted. Walking out is very rude.

Please at LEAST read the OP's posts BEFORE responding. She didn't walk out. She left the room minutes before the second session. Jesus fujking christ!

shearwater2 · 27/12/2023 13:10

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:03

DC's have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it.
Educating your DCs is the responsibility of both parents. Understanding religion is about being educated. How can you decide you are an atheist if you don't know what you are rejecting?

I see it the other way round. You don't have to believe in anything by default and besides, kids are taught about different religions at school, plus the dad can explain his own to his kids if he wants to. The mum has no duty in this regard and can give her own views. When they are adults they can decide what the believe in, or not.

Merrymouse · 27/12/2023 13:09

Grammarnut · 27/12/2023 13:03

DC's have a right to know about their father's religion and to be taught about it.
Educating your DCs is the responsibility of both parents. Understanding religion is about being educated. How can you decide you are an atheist if you don't know what you are rejecting?

The OP is not preventing her husband from teaching her children about his beliefs, or preventing them from taking part in the prayers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread