Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having to do prayers on Christmas Day

560 replies

Fretfulmum · 25/12/2023 23:50

DH is Christian and he and his family are quite religious- goes to church weekly etc. I’m not Christian and I don’t attend church or do anything religious, I’m pretty much an atheist. We hosted DH’s parents and siblings and partners today. His parents wanted to do prayers before Christmas lunch. I told DH I’m not happy about having to do it but just let them get on with it whilst I sat there. In the evening, they wanted to do more. I’d had enough and I left the room without saying anything and let them crack on with it. Half way through the DC (toddlers) realised I wasn’t there and left the room to see where I was so they missed some of it. DH was so angry with me that I didn’t partake as it was a “whole family unit” thing and it disrespected his whole family? Apparently I ruined the day and now he’s sleeping in the spare room. AIBU that’s it my house and if I don’t want to do religious prayers that I sit out and go into another room ?

OP posts:
ARockIsASlowSlowCooledOffFlameAndACradle · 26/12/2023 06:25

@MrsTerryPratchett If you can bring back multi-day festivities I'll be with you all the way! In celebration of any Gods that can take on the Gods of the Market Place.

MrDirtyBear · 26/12/2023 06:09

YANBU, it's typical bullying, expecting you to subjugate to peer pressure on such a principle. Absolutely normal disregard of non religious views and revealing that, frankly, Christians often do not practise the values they preach.

Instead, I would hope that in future they check their behaviour, give you space in an often suffocating world to not be co opted. It's not like you went out of your way to blaspheme or call them on their collective, erm, fantasy.

Sadly you can't win I suspect, if you are as servile as some expect you to be, to satisfy their arrogance it will get worse, you will have no voice. If you stand up for yourself even with constructive disengagement you'll be seen as awkward but at least you have a voice.

As for your husband. Words fail me, he doesn't have your back and doesn't respect your attempt to draw a reasonable line. In short, he owes you a big fat apology. He chose to marry someone outside his faith, if he wasn't prepared to compromise on this, and can't act as a peacemaker then he's not going to have your back full stop.

I'd hate to be in a relationship that isn't equal or based on mutual respect, and I don't envy the work you have cut out for you.

Ti's the season for the veneer of Christian tolerance to wear thin, tralalala... la la la laaaaah.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 26/12/2023 05:48

Ponderingwindow · 26/12/2023 05:45

For all the people saying that it is just polite to sit quietly or even participate, what of op had decided to give a 5 minute talk on axial tilt in honor of the solstice? Would the family have been obligated to sit politely and listen to her lecture?

I get what you're saying but that isn't the same thing. Christians still believe in axial tilt. She wasn't having lunch with a bunch of flat earthers.

Ponderingwindow · 26/12/2023 05:45

For all the people saying that it is just polite to sit quietly or even participate, what of op had decided to give a 5 minute talk on axial tilt in honor of the solstice? Would the family have been obligated to sit politely and listen to her lecture?

Ponderingwindow · 26/12/2023 05:37

The real problem is that you left your children in the room. You should have taken them with you instead of leaving them there thinking prayer is a benign choice.

I would be very uncomfortable with people praying in my home. I sit quietly if they pray in their own, but doing it in my home is unreasonable. Of course, I never would have married a man who didn’t feel the same way. I wouldn’t want the father of my children telling them they should pray.

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 26/12/2023 05:36

I am Christian and don't think you were BU. Here is my slightly different take on it. There shouldn't ever be a sense of compulsion with prayer and things like that. And as people with faith in a higher power, my belief is that because of our faith Christians have to carry the burden of having broad shoulders and extending a lot of grace in not getting offended by every little thing other people do. We all have boundaries. If you had sat there and said "Why do we have to do this?!" that would be completely different because that is interfering in their prayer time. Everyone has a right to make their choice.

I think if your husband is being honest, it's perhaps an emotional reaction in him, a feeling of being disappointed but unfortunately it's just one of those things. I took myself off to church on my own yesterday and was I secretly a bit disappointed that my dh and dsd didn't want to come? Yes but I didn't say that nor would I ever put that on them. Of course it would mean the world to me if they did. I tend to focus on the positives so where they have joined in I've just said " thanks so much, it means a lot to me!" rather than focusing on the majority of the time when I know neither of us is going to budge.

Ultimately I know me having a go isn't going to change anything. Everyone is free to choose and in a way, I'd rather someone only be there joining in if they genuinely want to, rather than sitting there going through the motions, but completely closed off and not meaning anything. Just going through the motions to keep the peace is ultimately pretty worthless and it's better they spend their time actually doing something that is meaningful for them in that moment.

Dh and I have had many discussions about this and he has said he respects my faith and my reasons for it but feels guilty doing things out of pretence and I actually think that shows integrity and is quite respectful.

EsmeSusanOgg · 26/12/2023 05:32

5 minutes is quite long for prayers. Grace should be a quick thing. It also sounds like the evening prayers wer elonger than 5 minutes if the kids had time to notice missing mum and wander off.

strawberrysea · 26/12/2023 05:31

Good for you.

Your kids were probably grateful for an excuse to leave the room.

LaurieStrode · 26/12/2023 05:30

shearwater2 · 26/12/2023 05:15

I don't understand grown adults (supposedly) imposing their religious beliefs on people they are staying with. How selfish, rude and thoughtless.

Edited

Agree.

They should have stepped outdoors or gone to an unused room or something rather than take over the main room of the house.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 26/12/2023 05:25

I'm an atheist married to a Christian.

I would not take part in the prayers but I wouldn't leave the room.

You were really rude and disruptive.

NumberTheory · 26/12/2023 05:15

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 26/12/2023 05:07

This. Honestly, I don't understand grown adults (supposedly) who can't put up with something for a few minutes to accomodate someone else's beliefs. How did people get so selfish?

What do you do if someone you know dies or gets married? Do you stand outside the church in case there is praying which will offend your sensibilities?

It wasn’t the middle of a service. She didn’t get up from the table when they were sat for a meal and the other adults wanted to pray. She didn’t make a fuss, she just didn’t stay when three adults were doing something she wasn’t included in. It’s no ruder than leaving to do something else when everyone else wants to watch Coronation Street or the King’s Speech.

shearwater2 · 26/12/2023 05:15

I don't understand grown adults (supposedly) imposing their religious beliefs on people they are staying with. How selfish, rude and thoughtless.

StarlightLady · 26/12/2023 05:13

OP, l totally get where you are coming from. Your husband is being unreasonable by such a childish reaction.

Genuine question though, does this difference in attitudes impact with other parts of your relationship?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 26/12/2023 05:07

Hermittrismegistus · 26/12/2023 00:00

Christians want to say prayers during a Christian festival. Shock horror.

This. Honestly, I don't understand grown adults (supposedly) who can't put up with something for a few minutes to accomodate someone else's beliefs. How did people get so selfish?

What do you do if someone you know dies or gets married? Do you stand outside the church in case there is praying which will offend your sensibilities?

Tilllly · 26/12/2023 04:36

I'm religious
DH is not

He pops in and out of church if he's collecting me, or fayres, social events
He knows most there and vice versa, happily socialises

If there's a prayer, he'll sit quietly. He doesn't say Amen and no one would expect him to

Your in-laws wanted you to join in? Are they quite mad? I'd be a bit offended if my DH joined in something he doesn't believe

Is your DH in a mood because in laws had a go at him?

Christmasdistress · 26/12/2023 03:52

I think you were totally justified.

You didn't inflict your beliefs on them, and you were in no way disrespectful, just quietly removed yourself.

They have no rights to inflict their beliefs on you, nor insist on different behaviour to accord with their beliefs, which would be disrespectful to you, and somewhat controlling to insist on.

If their father wanted the DC to pray, he should have managed that (which apparently he didn't, as they ran off), not expected you to facilitate it.

I'm pretty shocked by how many pp seem to think that you should have just sucked up unreasonable expectations in order to keep the peace!

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 03:51

Tomatoshish · 26/12/2023 03:45

Yanbu to not join in. But yabu not sit patiently for 5 minutes. I know its your own home
. But it is also DHs and you knew they where all religious. So no surprise.

Maybe because we are religious (not christian) we are more tolerant of others praying. I can't pray when on my period like.l other ladies In our faith, so it's common for us to not all pray at the same time and for others to excuse themselves to pray or pray in the same room and we wait.

It's 5 minutes. Patience is important.

But DH and his family expect OP to join in with their prayers. It’s one thing to ask someone to respect your faith, it’s another to require active participation, particularly when you’re a guest in their home.

Tomatoshish · 26/12/2023 03:45

Yanbu to not join in. But yabu not sit patiently for 5 minutes. I know its your own home
. But it is also DHs and you knew they where all religious. So no surprise.

Maybe because we are religious (not christian) we are more tolerant of others praying. I can't pray when on my period like.l other ladies In our faith, so it's common for us to not all pray at the same time and for others to excuse themselves to pray or pray in the same room and we wait.

It's 5 minutes. Patience is important.

SpecialCharacters · 26/12/2023 03:33

Missingmybabysomuch · 26/12/2023 03:30

YANBU to not.want to actively join in with praying but YABU to make such a point of leaving the room rather than just sitting quietly and respectfully whilst your religious family pray for a few mins during a religious festival.
It is just exercising tolerance and respect. I have friends of different faiths and I would do the same if they wanted to pray.

But they expect her to actively participate. Quietly the room a couple of minutes beforehand seems less confrontational than staying but refusing to participate when urged.

NumberTheory · 26/12/2023 03:31

RantyAnty · 26/12/2023 03:16

You were rude to leave the room.

I've sat through lengthy prayers by late FIL Italian Catholic and big wig at the church many many times.

You having done one thing doesn’t make someone else doing something different rude.

JaninaDuszejko · 26/12/2023 03:30

RantyAnty · 26/12/2023 03:16

You were rude to leave the room.

I've sat through lengthy prayers by late FIL Italian Catholic and big wig at the church many many times.

In your own atheist home?

Missingmybabysomuch · 26/12/2023 03:30

YANBU to not.want to actively join in with praying but YABU to make such a point of leaving the room rather than just sitting quietly and respectfully whilst your religious family pray for a few mins during a religious festival.
It is just exercising tolerance and respect. I have friends of different faiths and I would do the same if they wanted to pray.

JaninaDuszejko · 26/12/2023 03:27

MIL has a deep Christian faith. When she visits for Christmas DH takes her to midnight mass on Christmas Eve. That's us accomodating her faith. I would not be happy with a prayer session in my own house (not that she would ever do that).

When DH takes the DC to visit her she wants them to go to church but DH knows he has to allow them to say no if they don't want to (which has happened now they are teenagers, and happened because they were pushed to take part in the Eucharist so a similar but not as extreme overstepping of boundaries).

Christianity is a proselytising religion, overstepping the boundaries of non-Christians is what it does. You need to hold firm and discuss with your DH your boundaries that he needs to respect and insist his family respects.

NumberTheory · 26/12/2023 03:26

Also, making you sit through 5 minutes of prayer at the table before eating was pretty rude when it’s not their house and it’s not your custom, though more difficult if your DH had wanted to as well. That’s something that should have been discussed before hand and some compromised made.

Nextweektoo · 26/12/2023 03:25

Nevermind today, what will you do about the children?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread