Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having to do prayers on Christmas Day

560 replies

Fretfulmum · 25/12/2023 23:50

DH is Christian and he and his family are quite religious- goes to church weekly etc. I’m not Christian and I don’t attend church or do anything religious, I’m pretty much an atheist. We hosted DH’s parents and siblings and partners today. His parents wanted to do prayers before Christmas lunch. I told DH I’m not happy about having to do it but just let them get on with it whilst I sat there. In the evening, they wanted to do more. I’d had enough and I left the room without saying anything and let them crack on with it. Half way through the DC (toddlers) realised I wasn’t there and left the room to see where I was so they missed some of it. DH was so angry with me that I didn’t partake as it was a “whole family unit” thing and it disrespected his whole family? Apparently I ruined the day and now he’s sleeping in the spare room. AIBU that’s it my house and if I don’t want to do religious prayers that I sit out and go into another room ?

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/12/2023 13:53

For me it is a personal thing about trying to be the better person than others

That might have read better if you'd left off the last two words, 1dayatatime ...

Puzzledandpissedoff · 26/12/2023 13:48

Yeahno · 26/12/2023 11:28

I think a lot of people are imagining a quiet grace sort of prayer. That is not what is happening here. No one should be forced to say any sort of prayer especially the chanting almost aggressive type. It's probably odd to describe a prayer as aggressive but I grew up in a family like that. The more you can out pray the last session or person the better. I am an atheist now. I would have walked away too.
Also all the prayer doesn't make them good people, it's all a performance.

Very well said, from another who originally thought we were talking about a simple grace

You were also spot on about the performative aspect, and given these are people who tried to pressure OP into being "more religious" it wouldn't be a surprise if a certain amount of it was done for her "benefit"

By all means observe whatever practices you want, but don't try to impose them on others, and especially not when invited to their homes unless it's been agreed beforehand

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 13:41

Mumsnet needs to make new rules in the new year for this site. A checkpoint thing (like the robot check or something) where people must check off that they have indeed read ALL of the OP's posts/replies at that point. And, that logic and replies must be based on those posts. We have far too many people replying who are too lazy to take the time to read all OP posts, and who lack basic comprehension and reasoning skills.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 13:37

Jibo · 26/12/2023 13:33

As I said, their behaviour is irrelevant and anyway all they've done is want to take a few minutes to think about the true meaning of Christmas. Really not a big deal to sit with them and mentally plan next week's meals or whatever whilst that goes on! Would have been better than OP upsetting the DC's grandparents and falling out with her DH.

Yet again, and many people have told you this - Sitting quiet and "mentally plan next weeks meals" was....not....an.....option! They wanted her to fully participate, hold hands, chant, recite - THE WORKS. This is not about a quiet prayer of a minute or so. You haven't read the OP's posts and you do not get it. Sitting quietly was not an option. So your replies are completely irrelevant to the topic. And her ILs behaviour is not 'irrelevant'. It is the entire topic. Especially since they bullied the OP in her own home. It is in fact, solely about their (and her H's) behaviour.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 26/12/2023 13:34

Plenty of Muslims etc buy their kids gifts etc at Xmas, which kind of shows how far removed it us from Christianity these days.

Jibo · 26/12/2023 13:33

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 26/12/2023 11:13

They've shown her no consideration.
No non-believer has to listen to 5 minute long prayers if they choose not to, in their own house.

As I said, their behaviour is irrelevant and anyway all they've done is want to take a few minutes to think about the true meaning of Christmas. Really not a big deal to sit with them and mentally plan next week's meals or whatever whilst that goes on! Would have been better than OP upsetting the DC's grandparents and falling out with her DH.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 13:29

Elphame · 26/12/2023 13:13

So if you came to my house for one of my religious celebrations, would you pray to my deities?

Yes, good point. If your ILs were Wiccan, would you pray to their deity Pan (or whatever they call it), @yhk ? After all, it may be 'meaningless to you', but if it meant a lot to your hosts, would you? What about satan? I find that Christians are the biggest most selfish hypocrites out. They expect non-believers to pray, but if they asked you to pray to Pan or Diana the Goddess or whatever, you'd find that blasphemous and wouldn't participate. Would you? Be honest here!

akittencalledjesus · 26/12/2023 13:25

Jesus wept.

Yes, it's a partially a Christian festival but it's been a pagan festival for much longer, simply something Christianity chose to co-opt. Everyone saying the OP was rude for leaving the room are deliberately missing the fact she left ahead few mins before without making any fuss: normally the advice on here is to quietly retreat and not make a scene, yet now it seems that the only acceptable way to deal with excessive displays of belief is to actively participate.

It's not remotely the same as a wedding or a funeral. Atheists go to those and can quite easily not participate in the prayers and the hymns.

And to the PP calling the OP a racist: a description of what sub type of religious prayer was involved is not racist. It's simply descriptive to an audience who will be predominantly familiar with the CofE or RC faiths.

Forcing people to actively participate in overt displays of religion generally has the opposite effect. It's her own home FFS, leave the OP in peace, like she left the relatives to pray in peace. She didn't try to stop them, she simply chose to not participate without making a scene.

Even saying Grace: why would I thank a God I don't believe in for the food I got by working hard for the money I have? Fuck that for a game of toy soldiers.

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 13:23

Good for you @1dayatatime don't strain your neck looking down at me from your high horse though - A&E have enough to deal with! 😂

1dayatatime · 26/12/2023 13:20

@CandyLeBonBon

Nothing wrong with a bit of bacchanalian debauchery to brighten up a dismal time of year, so I'm sure your po-faced opinion as to whether or not we're 'doing Christmas right' will make not one jot of difference!

If ever there was a post that could be less persuasive of joining Christianity, I'd like to see it! You've even managed to sneer at atheists who aren't in-believing correctly!!

+++

So imagine as a non Muslim I went along to an Eid al Fitr event because it would brighten up my day, it's free food and I also really like Vimto (actually I really do like Vimto). I then start to question whether Eid should really just be a Muslim celebration, its origins and criticise the Muslim religiousness and helping out those less fortunate of Eid. When I get pulled up for this I then respond that what right do Muslims have to tell me that "I'm not doing Eid right" and that they have dissuaded me from becoming a Muslim.

My personal aspirations stretch a little further than the bacchanalian debauchery of getting pissed and pushing up my BMI at Christmas.

You are right though that my personal opinion that Christmas has both a Christian religious element and a helping out those less fortunate element will not make a jot of difference to the majority.

I really couldn't care less whether my views dissuade you from Christianity or Islam or becoming a Jedi Knight For me it is a personal thing about trying to be the better person than others, which reassuringly from your post doesn't seem to be a particularly high hurdle.

TriOptimim · 26/12/2023 13:19

derxa · 26/12/2023 12:59

I bet the OP reminds the DH that it was her hooooooooome daily.

Another insulting assumption about OP needs on absolutely fuck all.

Elphame · 26/12/2023 13:13

yhk · 26/12/2023 01:16

It's fair enough if you don't believe that Jesus is God and don't wish to celebrate His birth on 25/12.

However, knowing how much this means to your husband and in-laws, it's not a big deal to sit through it and maybe even participate in the prayers. The prayers are meaningless to you, but worshiping Christ is important to them.

I'm a Christian and Christmas Day is primarily about worship for me. I not fond of the commercialisation of Christmas but I participate in it as it keeps my family happy.

So if you came to my house for one of my religious celebrations, would you pray to my deities?

MsPavlichenko · 26/12/2023 13:13

Yo are entirely reasonable, and your husband is not. His sleeping in the spare room is in fact an attempt to control/punish you for not doing as he/his family expected. It’s abusive.

I am an atheist. In another person’s house I sit quietly during a prayer as I do at weddings/funerals etc. I don’t sing hymns/carols either although I enjoy listening to them especially at Christmas. In fact I think it would be disrespectful to join in rather than not. I respect other people’s faith, but I don’t share it. Joining in an act of worship as a non believer seems to me to almost mock it.

If others asked to pray in my home, I’d probably agree but certainly would remove myself/ask them to move elsewhere. If they did so without asking I’d be unimpressed.

MrDirtyBear · 26/12/2023 13:03

Always good when someone is prodded into reading wikipedia, regurgitate it on a thread undermining their original line of argument.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 13:01

derxa · 26/12/2023 12:59

I bet the OP reminds the DH that it was her hooooooooome daily.

I doubt she does but she should at times like this where he is bullying her to participate in something against her beliefs. You can be damn sure she doesn't expect and bully him to participate in something against his beliefs!

derxa · 26/12/2023 12:59

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 12:56

@JillwithaJ Please read all of the OP's posts, not just the first one, in a thread with several pages. It was a ten minute (2 x 5 minutes) religious performance, and she wasn't allowed to 'sit quiet', she was expected to hold hands, participate, recite and chant. Being quiet and contemplative was not an option. And this, is in OP's own home! That she owned before she met her 'D'H.

I bet the OP reminds the DH that it was her hooooooooome daily.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 12:59

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 12:54

OMGWHY DON'T PEOPLE READ THE FULL THREAD (or at least OP's posts) 😭

Mumsnet really need to do something about this, it is getting way past absolutely ridiculous. On every thread, people reply to the title and don't read the OP or they don't check to see if there are further responses from the OP before replying. It is frustrating and a waste of people's time. There should be a *Read all the OP's responses before posting warning you need to 'check off' as a pre-posting thing.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 12:56

JillwithaJ · 26/12/2023 12:51

It seems that you are aggressively opposed to Christianity. Did you not know you were marrying into a Christian family? Have they recently sprung it on you?
Is a few minutes of quiet thought and contemplation on Christmas day extreme?

@JillwithaJ Please read all of the OP's posts, not just the first one, in a thread with several pages. It was a ten minute (2 x 5 minutes) religious performance, and she wasn't allowed to 'sit quiet', she was expected to hold hands, participate, recite and chant. Being quiet and contemplative was not an option. And this, is in OP's own home! That she owned before she met her 'D'H.

Mumsntfan1 · 26/12/2023 12:55

What religion are you. You saw you're an atheist but follow some cultural celebrations from a religion.

Zarah123 · 26/12/2023 12:54

JillwithaJ · 26/12/2023 12:51

It seems that you are aggressively opposed to Christianity. Did you not know you were marrying into a Christian family? Have they recently sprung it on you?
Is a few minutes of quiet thought and contemplation on Christmas day extreme?

It wasn’t quiet though. There was chanting and OP was expected to hold hands with them.

They need to respect it’s OP’s home and let her leave the room.

CandyLeBonBon · 26/12/2023 12:54

OMGWHY DON'T PEOPLE READ THE FULL THREAD (or at least OP's posts) 😭

basculin · 26/12/2023 12:54

JillwithaJ · 26/12/2023 12:51

It seems that you are aggressively opposed to Christianity. Did you not know you were marrying into a Christian family? Have they recently sprung it on you?
Is a few minutes of quiet thought and contemplation on Christmas day extreme?

By what measure is not wanting to join in with prayer and quietly leaving beforehand "aggressively opposed to Christianity"?

SoreAndTired1 · 26/12/2023 12:53

WickDittington · 26/12/2023 12:45

You realise 'Christmas' or Yule, is not an original religious holiday but a pagan one, right? Christmas means different things to different people.

You realise 'Christmas' or Yule, is a religious holiday. Pagan doesn’t mean “no religion.” Quite the reverse. You need to learn a bit of history.

I do know my history. I have studied pagan religions extensively. Pagan also means non-believer, an absence of belief, as well pagan regarding non-Christian but religious (such as Wicca). Pagan has historically, and still is, been used to describe the absence of belief. Or, Atheism.

Both are accurate.

JillwithaJ · 26/12/2023 12:51

It seems that you are aggressively opposed to Christianity. Did you not know you were marrying into a Christian family? Have they recently sprung it on you?
Is a few minutes of quiet thought and contemplation on Christmas day extreme?

CurlewKate · 26/12/2023 12:48

Just ticking off my bingo card.

"Why do you celebrate Christmas if you re an atheist?"
"Christmas Eve s a pagan festival anyway."
"Why should children be taught about religion?"
"Just show some respect-a few prayers won't do you any harm."
"This is a Christian country."

Swipe left for the next trending thread