Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not let him take our DC?

87 replies

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:26

Spent today with DHs family. My mum hasn't been feeling well recently so she's avoided coming today which I was gutted about. We may possibly be able to see her tomorrow but depends how she is.

My husband usually alternates Christmas with his ex but this year its been decided he's going to go up tomorrow to hers to see DSC for a couple of hours and take their presents round. This was because her family are over this year for the first timenin a long time at Christmas and DSC wanted to stay there to see them which I'd fair enough.

DH has been going on about this visit all day and wants to take our shared child with him so siblings can see each other at Christmas. Our child is 4.

I've told him I'm not comfortable with that and he should go by himself (which is fine) but I don't want him to take our toddler.

There isn't the option of me going which is another thread. Me and his ex don't really see eye to eye... at all. And whenever I try and get involved in anything like this I'm told I'm not their mum. Which is fine I don't try to be but then by the same token I don't want my little girl going for however long to play families at this woman's house either and leaving me home alone.

DD isn't bothered, or hasn't said as such, that we haven't seen DSC yet and is used to them coming and going so isn't like she'd be desperate to go with him.

I just think it's a weird thing to do when it's not a friendly situation between us (her and DH don't get on either 99% of the time). I understand why he wants to go and am fine with that but draw the line at being okay with him taking DD too. I asked if ex would even want that anyway considering she seems to hate me so much and was told that apparently she'd "love to see DD". Just think it's odd unless everyone gets along and can ALL be together.

OP posts:
Travis1 · 25/12/2023 23:08

OddityOddityOdd · 25/12/2023 23:01

If she hates you that much why is she willing to let her children stay with you? It makes no sense. You say she hates you so you don't want your child there without you but she is willing to let her children come to you.

It’s hardly that she’s ’letting’ them go
to OP though is it? It’s contact with their father, but different to ops daughter randomly rocking up at this woman’s house who has no relationship with her.

@pugsinblankets1 i wouldn’t be comfortable with this either. Why does your husband think it’s ok?

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 23:07

@AnneLovesGilbert My ex's new wife told my kids my baby was going to be born a "mental retard." She still sees my kids.
And where exactly are the "scare tactics," in my post?!!

Dawndayda · 25/12/2023 23:07

OddityOddityOdd · 25/12/2023 23:01

If she hates you that much why is she willing to let her children stay with you? It makes no sense. You say she hates you so you don't want your child there without you but she is willing to let her children come to you.

Because she has to? Her kids are going to see their dad and their dad obviously lives with the OP.

Dawndayda · 25/12/2023 23:05

I don't think that you are unreasonable at all. I would absolutely never in my lifetime allow my children to go to my DSC's mum's home when she hated me and had been awful to me for years. No way would I trust that person to have my child in their home, particularly without me around.

AdobeWanKenobi · 25/12/2023 23:02

This is another one of those AIBU posts where the OP just wants everyone to agree with her.

OddityOddityOdd · 25/12/2023 23:01

If she hates you that much why is she willing to let her children stay with you? It makes no sense. You say she hates you so you don't want your child there without you but she is willing to let her children come to you.

WhatsInStoreFor2024 · 25/12/2023 22:58

Your title says to 'not let him'

How can you 'not let' him? It's his kid too

AnneLovesGilbert · 25/12/2023 22:57

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 22:52

@pugsinblankets1 As hard as it is (and trust me, I know - see post above), I think you should try to put siblings seeing each other before the fact that your hubby's ex "hates" you.

Not sure what’s up with the scare quotes. If you don’t believe OP that’s your problem. Do you abuse women having miscarriages if you like them? That would be very odd. She’s supporting the sibling relationship when the DSC will be at her home in a few days. That’s where her responsibilities end.

AnneLovesGilbert · 25/12/2023 22:54

What’s with people suggestion OP benefits from her DD being gone for hours? I like my DC, it’s not a treat having them be elsewhere. It’s Christmas, I want them here and being together. Nothing OP has said suggests her child being away will be some sort of gift for her. Bizarre.

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 22:52

@pugsinblankets1 As hard as it is (and trust me, I know - see post above), I think you should try to put siblings seeing each other before the fact that your hubby's ex "hates" you.

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:49

BelieveInYourElf · 25/12/2023 22:47

Let him take her, you play happy families with all the children together quite often, I don't hear her complaining and I suspect she doesn't like it.

Enjoy the P&Q

Have you read my posts at all? She's done nothing but complain about me since I met DH years ago!

OP posts:
Iouis · 25/12/2023 22:48

YABU

Tacotortoise · 25/12/2023 22:48

Fwiw I was the child from my father's second marriage and I loved visiting my big sister at her home (she was with us eow, so "home" was very much with her mum). I got to meet her half brother, and see her pets and it just helped me to understand this whole big part of her life that otherwise I never saw. All children who are part of complex families, as your daughter is, have to come to terms with how things are and how they fit in.

BelieveInYourElf · 25/12/2023 22:47

Let him take her, you play happy families with all the children together quite often, I don't hear her complaining and I suspect she doesn't like it.

Enjoy the P&Q

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 22:47

PS. Also to add, ex-husband's new wife vey much dislikes me and has been extremely nasty to hubby and I. Imagine this is fuelled by my abusive ex spinning her lies and also partly by her naivety (she's 16 years younger than ex).
She makes the choice to have very, very little to do with the boys (despite living with them the majority) and tbh that's fine with me. I know she says nasty stuff about me to my sons but I also know my sons are now of an age where they don't accept it and will call her out.

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:47

Obviously I meant teen DSC chose not to spend Christmas with their sibling not our 4 year old. I assumed that would be clear. As I said in my OP, I don't think she'd care if she waited a couple more days to see them.

I agree sibling bonds are important which is why we are planning our own special day when they come to us later this week. I don't agree that our DD needs to be in the company of someone who hates me in order to create a bond with her siblings.

OP posts:
OdeToBarney · 25/12/2023 22:44

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:40

These kids are siblings and should be allowed spend Christmas time together

And yet they chose not to.

She's just turned 4, she can't choose! One minute she's a toddler, and the next she is capable of choosing who to spend Christmas with?!

YABVU and selfish. Hth.

DiaNaranja · 25/12/2023 22:42

To be honest, I do think it would be nice for your child to spend some time with her half siblings over Xmas. For your DH to have all his children together for a few hours would probably mean alot to him, and make Xmas really special for the kids. I'd also personally love to have a child free few hours on boxing Day to kick back, tidy up, reorganise or just chill out by myself, so I'd totally be taking him up on the offer myself! When you got together with your husband, got married, and had a child, you would have been aware he already had children, and must have known that there would be situations that maybe are less than ideal for you, but important for the kids. Blended families require everyone to be able to compromise at times, and put the children at the forefront of decisions like this, to make for healthy, happy relationships all round. Creating strong relationships between your child and her half siblings is important, and his ex is willing to facilitate this by welcoming your child round, so it would seem silly to deny DD that opportunity.

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 22:41

I think all sibling relationships are important, but feel like it's even more important to strengthen bonds as much as possible if siblings don't live together as the "norm."
My teenage sons only see their 3 yo (half) sister EOW as that is when they are here with us. Unfortunately the rest of the time they live with my ex-husband. But we try as much as we can to make that quality time. I would say, despite everything, they have a good bond ❤️

GrumpyPanda · 25/12/2023 22:40

RowanMayfair · 25/12/2023 22:31

'Swan off' is weird manipulative language to use to describe a man going to see his children. YABU, he wants to take his DC to spend time with her siblings, his other DC. The ex's opinion on you has nothing to do with it. Be the bigger person.

Oh it's stepmum-bashing time again. Funny how it's never the ex who's expected to be the "bigger person."

OP YABU to post this in AIBU, these threads always attract the same sort of poster. YANBU to oppose a trip that's chiefly for the ex to play happy families with your DD - as you say the siblings will see each other soon enough. Also - if there's a chance your mum might make it today, surely she'd want to see her granddaughter?

AnneLovesGilbert · 25/12/2023 22:40

My DSC mother has never acknowledged mine and DH’s DC exist so it wouldn’t be an issue here.

YANBU at all. My children don’t spend time with people who hate either of their parents, that’s obviously mad, and you’re perfectly reasonable to say no to DD being away for a chunk of Boxing Day or within any distance of someone who you don’t get on with.

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:40

These kids are siblings and should be allowed spend Christmas time together

And yet they chose not to.

OP posts:
pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:39

Oh I have no desire to be invited. I just think it's odd I'm supposed to happily wave my child off to a woman's home who's been horrible to me for years. I'm not going to go into every scenario here but she really seems to harbour some strong negative feeling towards me for years and years and I've never been anything but pleasant. If it gives context at all, this is a woman who was absolutely hideous toward us when we miscarried a pregnancy. That's the shit I've put up with for years.

OP posts:
cansu · 25/12/2023 22:38

You and his ex dislike each other. You have no desire to see each other. Your dd would no doubt have a nice time. Why would you make an issue about this? Very odd and a bit petty tbh

Gcsunnyside23 · 25/12/2023 22:37

I think I agree with OP, I wouldn't want my daughter going if I wasn't welcome also. Yes it'd be lovely if all the siblings could see each other but the kids decided to stay with their mother longer to see family so hardly bothered about seeing their sister on Xmas day either. If husband wants to go fair enough but don't think the 4 year old needs to go also