Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not let him take our DC?

87 replies

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:26

Spent today with DHs family. My mum hasn't been feeling well recently so she's avoided coming today which I was gutted about. We may possibly be able to see her tomorrow but depends how she is.

My husband usually alternates Christmas with his ex but this year its been decided he's going to go up tomorrow to hers to see DSC for a couple of hours and take their presents round. This was because her family are over this year for the first timenin a long time at Christmas and DSC wanted to stay there to see them which I'd fair enough.

DH has been going on about this visit all day and wants to take our shared child with him so siblings can see each other at Christmas. Our child is 4.

I've told him I'm not comfortable with that and he should go by himself (which is fine) but I don't want him to take our toddler.

There isn't the option of me going which is another thread. Me and his ex don't really see eye to eye... at all. And whenever I try and get involved in anything like this I'm told I'm not their mum. Which is fine I don't try to be but then by the same token I don't want my little girl going for however long to play families at this woman's house either and leaving me home alone.

DD isn't bothered, or hasn't said as such, that we haven't seen DSC yet and is used to them coming and going so isn't like she'd be desperate to go with him.

I just think it's a weird thing to do when it's not a friendly situation between us (her and DH don't get on either 99% of the time). I understand why he wants to go and am fine with that but draw the line at being okay with him taking DD too. I asked if ex would even want that anyway considering she seems to hate me so much and was told that apparently she'd "love to see DD". Just think it's odd unless everyone gets along and can ALL be together.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
zaffa · 26/12/2023 14:28

The thing is OP what is being proposed is what is happening with your DSC on every contact visit with you. They are expected to spend family time with someone who doesn't like their mum. I'm sure EXW had no intention of mothering DD, she will be visiting somewhere with her dad.

I do have a DSS and a DD (also four). In this scenario I wouldn't really like it but I wouldn't stop it. DD loves her brother and she is super curious about his life when he's at his mum's. And I imagine DSS (he is 15) would love to show her round the house etc.

And yes, the relationship with DH and his ex is acrimonious, and DSS lives with us so maybe DD is more used to having her brother around and would be missing him at Xmas, but fundamentally what you're being asked is not really different to what she is asked to do when they come visit you.

Iwasafool · 26/12/2023 14:26

pugsinblankets1 · 26/12/2023 12:10

Sorry pressed send way too soon, I meant to say yes they come here because I live with their dad. It would be comparable if we split up and I lived separately from their dad. There is no doubt in my mind she wouldn't want them coming to my house.

It's not ended up a problem as DD didn't want to go with DH anyway, she was crying and clingy so wasn't going to force her. We've had a nice morning together.

Have you played a part in that decision? I hate it when adults use children as weapons.

Iwasafool · 26/12/2023 14:24

GrumpyPanda · 25/12/2023 22:40

Oh it's stepmum-bashing time again. Funny how it's never the ex who's expected to be the "bigger person."

OP YABU to post this in AIBU, these threads always attract the same sort of poster. YANBU to oppose a trip that's chiefly for the ex to play happy families with your DD - as you say the siblings will see each other soon enough. Also - if there's a chance your mum might make it today, surely she'd want to see her granddaughter?

Well to be fair the ex is the bigger person when she lets her kids go and spend time with the OP. She might find that hard just like the OP finds this hard. The thing is these two women are adults and I hope they behave in a civilised manner to each others children, if the ex doesn't then the father needs to step in and make sure it stops.

I don't see anything to indicate this visit is designed so the ex can play happy families with the OP's DD. She might like it, she might hate the idea but realises it is good for her children to see their father and their sibling.

purpledaze24 · 26/12/2023 14:16

Good that your dd made her own decision as it should always be hers, not yours or your DH’s. This is the kinda shit you sign up for when you choose to date someone who’s already had a family with someone else. it was your decision so you just gotta suck it up and accept this woman will for the next few years at least be some part of your life and try to put your kids first

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 26/12/2023 13:40

I don’t get why the 4 year old can’t go, think it will be nice, let him take him

SleepingBeautySnores · 26/12/2023 13:25

I'm pleased that you got to spend the time with your daughter, she clearly voted how SHE wanted to spend HER day!

berksandbeyond · 26/12/2023 12:23

this is what you’ve chosen when you chose to be the second family 🤷🏼‍♀️
YABU

Greenfinch7 · 26/12/2023 12:20

Glad it all worked out for you.
Of course I understand the obvious thing that you live with their dad! I was making a more general point- that in blended families kids often spend time with adults that hate one of their parents (or both of their parents). If everyone shows kindness, sensitivity, and emotional maturity, that can work out well for the children though, and is not necessarily terrible.

pugsinblankets1 · 26/12/2023 12:10

Sorry pressed send way too soon, I meant to say yes they come here because I live with their dad. It would be comparable if we split up and I lived separately from their dad. There is no doubt in my mind she wouldn't want them coming to my house.

It's not ended up a problem as DD didn't want to go with DH anyway, she was crying and clingy so wasn't going to force her. We've had a nice morning together.

OP posts:
pugsinblankets1 · 26/12/2023 12:06

Greenfinch7 · 26/12/2023 11:43

You keep saying that you don't think a child should spend time in the house of a woman who hates her mother, but your SCs spend time with you very regularly, and you obviously hate their mother (sounds like with good reason!).
I am just pointing out that step families often lead to situations where kids spend time with someone who hates one of their parents. When done well, sibling bonds can still be strong.
To me, it sounds like your DH's ex-wife is being reasonably good about letting your DD visit and not making it unpleasant for her, so seems like a good thing for her to go.

Yes they come here, because I live with their dad.

OP posts:
MySecret21 · 26/12/2023 11:49

A 4 year old is absolutely not a toddler.

But YANBU.

If the stepchildren are coming to yours in a few days anyway, then I don’t see why your 4 year old needs to go with your DH now.

I would have thought your DH would have enjoyed the opportunity to have some quality time alone with his other children anyway.

Greenfinch7 · 26/12/2023 11:43

You keep saying that you don't think a child should spend time in the house of a woman who hates her mother, but your SCs spend time with you very regularly, and you obviously hate their mother (sounds like with good reason!).
I am just pointing out that step families often lead to situations where kids spend time with someone who hates one of their parents. When done well, sibling bonds can still be strong.
To me, it sounds like your DH's ex-wife is being reasonably good about letting your DD visit and not making it unpleasant for her, so seems like a good thing for her to go.

TeenLifeMum · 26/12/2023 11:34

I think it’s important for dc to see their dad’s “other life”. Blended families are complicated so only you know what’s safe and where you trust dh to challenge bad behaviour if the mum bad months you.

Anywherebuthere · 26/12/2023 11:30

StoorieHoose · 26/12/2023 11:22

He will see all his children together- in his own home with the Op. the older ones will be there in a few days

What happens if the 4 year old gets clingy and shy? Hangs around her dad's neck all day and the older ones don't get time to interact with their dad?

But theres nothing wrong with the DH taking the DD to the DSC house either. I'm sure they'l love to have her there, in their environment for a change.

I have been around lots of children over the years. I've never known any child to not get over initial shyness within half an hour or so. And these are siblings, she'l most likely be fine with them. And her dad will know how to deal with it.

I'm sure there will be plenty of time for them to all interact with each other.

No need to think up scenarios and 'what ifs' when they havnt happened.

Neriah · 26/12/2023 11:28

pugsinblankets1 · 25/12/2023 22:31

Yes they are and we'll see them in a few days. At our house. I don't think she needs to be involved with a woman who hates her mother.

You clearly don't like her either!

So it's OK for her children to come to yours, but not the other way around? You are teaching your daughter your dislike of her siblings mother. You think at 4 she won't know? She does.

Based on this both you and the ex are being unreasonable. Get over it - make family time about the children and not yourselves.

StoorieHoose · 26/12/2023 11:23

Has anyone asked his ex if she is okay with the 4 year old coming along?

StoorieHoose · 26/12/2023 11:22

Anywherebuthere · 26/12/2023 11:19

I think its lovely that he wants to take the DD to see her siblings at their home. It'l be nice for him to see all his children together too.

You keep saying you don't want your DD in the company of someone who hates you. If the ex said that too and stopped her children coming to your house then the siblings will never see each other and form bonds.

Don't stand in the way of your childs sibling relationships.

I'm assuming you and the ex are kind and decent to each others children even if you don't like each other.

And no your DH isnt swanning off. He wants to spend time with all of his children.

He will see all his children together- in his own home with the Op. the older ones will be there in a few days

What happens if the 4 year old gets clingy and shy? Hangs around her dad's neck all day and the older ones don't get time to interact with their dad?

SecondUsername4me · 26/12/2023 11:21

Would the 4yo enjoy it? If so, that's the end of it. Off she goes.

Anywherebuthere · 26/12/2023 11:19

I think its lovely that he wants to take the DD to see her siblings at their home. It'l be nice for him to see all his children together too.

You keep saying you don't want your DD in the company of someone who hates you. If the ex said that too and stopped her children coming to your house then the siblings will never see each other and form bonds.

Don't stand in the way of your childs sibling relationships.

I'm assuming you and the ex are kind and decent to each others children even if you don't like each other.

And no your DH isnt swanning off. He wants to spend time with all of his children.

Tistheseason17 · 26/12/2023 11:16

YANBU - I don't put my children with my not so DM as she is a narcissist and would erode any confidence they have. Just make sure you're not a hypocrite and don't speak badly of DSS's mum in front of any of the siblings.
Siblings will all be together in a couple of days.

StoorieHoose · 26/12/2023 11:16

Surely the older children will want a day with their dad and then have time with the younger sibling at her own house later in the week?

I see no reason for the OPs daughter to go to her partners ex's house when she will be seeing her older siblings in their shared house in a day or so

Let the older children have a day with just their dad

SeatonCarew · 26/12/2023 11:03

I think YANBU OP, given the children all see each other regularly and will be seeing each other again in a couple of days. As ex's family are over, the focus will naturally be on her family this time.

SpongeBob2022 · 26/12/2023 10:49

It must be pretty rubbish to be kids stuck in the middle of a family where the adults don't get on. I'm not suggesting it's your fault.

I think the scenario where at least the children are embraced and included as a group is a positive one under the circumstances and I would be putting my own feelings aside and viewing it that way. Hopefully it sets the tone for future events too.

TheShellBeach · 26/12/2023 10:49

Are you worried that your husband will get back with his ex-wife?

Were you the OW?

ZombieGirl86 · 26/12/2023 10:46

I'm with you OP. Perhaps dh uses dd as a buffer between him and ex?