Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick friend and boxing day plans . Who is being unreasonable?

187 replies

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 20:21

Name change but long term poster.

Who is being unreasonable about this Christmas day argument please.

Me and DH have had a Christmas day argument that we've tried to put behind us but tbh after a heated spat and some crying in the middle of the day has created an atmosphere and I feel Christmas has been pretty ruined.
I can't tell if my POV was unreasonable or his was.
We both strongly disagree and have had to just agree to disagree and not talk about it, with both of us not understanding each others point of view or priorities.

For context we always do Christmas eve with my DHs family which we did yesterday. Boxing day with mine. Last year we had to cancel to my Grandad last minute. He is getting old and not in great health and I fear we don't have many Christmas' left with him. He will be hurt if we cancel last minute again.

Yesterday we heard the news that a long standing friend (more my partner's friend of 20 plus years but also my friend for about 16) had been rushed to hospital. This is a good but not very close friend to either of us anymore but someone we both care about alot none the less. He is an important person to us. We were told he was unresponsive and feared to have had a stroke. We have been very very worried.

We got a call from another friend today to let us know that he was awake, he's had a serious medical emergency that I won't disclose as its not my medical information and this thread could be outing but he isn't going to die, hospital are investigating why this has happened and looking at sending him home.

Friend was visiting family the other side of the country.

DH offers to go fetch him when he is discharged and bring him back home. This will take a day with all the driving. Obviously this is completely fine with me. Of course he should help. .

The argument happened because he then tells me he might be doing this tomorrow Boxing Day. I say "umm no not boxing day it's my family Christmas" I wouldn't be able to go as I can't drive and we would have to late cancel my Grandad yet again. I explained this. I said it was important to me. I said he could go the next day.

He said I have funny priorities. That my reaction was weird and not ok. Got very annoyed with me. I got upset. Argument happened.

Now if this was still a life and death situation with friend I would have said yes go. If friend had been likely to die I would have told him to set off in the middle of our Christmas dinner if needs be. But to me if hospital are looking at discharging, then this is no longer an immediate emergency / not really even an emergency anymore and he is not at risk of dying and so I think it's great to help friend but it can wait until 27th.

His opinion - That I have my priorities all wrong. That friend needing help as he is in hospital top trumps family Christmas because we could just go another time and friend has been sick in hospital and so is far more important then Christmas or seeing family. He implied strongly that he thought I was selfish and that I only think of myself.

My opinion - That this is no longer an emergency. It would be unreasonable to late cancel my Grandad again. That my family Christmas is important to me and it is as important as his family Christmas (that we never have had to late cancel or miss because he would never allow it). Yes help friend but not at the expense of my family Christmas. Helping him can wait until the next day (which still would have messed up our family time plans but still fair enough friend needs help). I don't think it's selfish to think that my elderly Grandad not being let down again is more of a priority then a non emergency with a long standing but not close friend, this isn't his bestie. I feel upset he can't see this and that he has questioned my ethics and thinks I am selfish.

So am I being unreasonable and I am in fact selfish for thinking that it's not ok to cancel my family boxing day so he can drive across the country to help friend or am I being reasonable to have said hold on no not boxing day you could go in the 27th

Whose priorities are off here?

As it turns out friend isn't in danger of dying but hospital are keeping him for a few days so partner isn't driving there anyway but this argument has definitely soured our Christmas day and I am just really sad about that.

Is it me that's being a dick about this? I honestly don't know and would like some opinions as I don't know what to say. I just feel sad about the ruined Christmas day.

OP posts:
Prometheus · 25/12/2023 21:15

He is being unreasonable but let it be a lesson to never be dependent on a man and to learn to drive yourself.

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:15

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 25/12/2023 21:11

Hoe can it be a 'compromise' you can't do the journey without him?
How selfish 'the argument is a non.issue you're driving me, tough luck'?

I didn't actually say "you are driving me tough luck"

I said "but it's my family Christmas on boxing day and this is important to me" which was an initial reaction with the added context of having to late cancel last year or something along those lines. I would have been open to trying to find a compromise like some of those suggested in this thread but unfortunately he got defensive. I got upset because he snapped at me on Christmas day.Then we found out friend want even being discharged anyway so the whole thing became a none point anyway. Its just create an atmosphere sadly.

OP posts:
ErikaReadsTheDailyMail · 25/12/2023 21:15

ManateeFair · 25/12/2023 20:55

Mumsnet, the only place in the world where people think you’re subhuman if you can’t drive, and also where they assume that if both partners can drive, they must automatically be able to afford to run two cars.

Not sure anyone is implying it's subhuman to not drive, just that if you are asking the regular favour of a lift, and the lift-givers plans need to change last-minute, that they are not treated like a pariah.

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:12

Mrsttcno1 · 25/12/2023 21:10

It sounds like he got defensive because you said “no you can’t do that” point blank though? I’d have gotten defensive as well if DH just point blank told me I couldn’t do something?

If it was me I would apologise for that yes, because putting my DH & I into that situation if DH just immediately shut it down like you did of course that’s quite selfish. Especially if the only reason DH wanted/needed me was to be his taxi there and back.

Thanks. I will think on this point and apologise for that.

OP posts:
Sunshineismyfavourite · 25/12/2023 21:12

I don't think you're being unreasonable here OP. You have said that sick friend has family close by as he was visiting them. I would expect someone from his family to bring him home rather than rely on a friend - I know someone has already asked this question. I wouldn't want to rely on a friend to leave their own family on Boxing Day to pick me up, even if it was from hospital.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 25/12/2023 21:11

Hoe can it be a 'compromise' you can't do the journey without him?
How selfish 'the argument is a non.issue you're driving me, tough luck'?

Mrsttcno1 · 25/12/2023 21:10

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:08

There may have been compromises yes.
However we never got to the stage of trying to work out a compromise because he got defensive. I got upset at his reaction and then before long we found out friend isn't actually being discharged for a few days anyway so the argument is now a none issue and we are just going to my Grandads.

However there has been an atmosphere. He clearly thinks I'm selfish. So I was trying to work out if I was being unreasonable or he was or neither as if it's me I would apologise

It sounds like he got defensive because you said “no you can’t do that” point blank though? I’d have gotten defensive as well if DH just point blank told me I couldn’t do something?

If it was me I would apologise for that yes, because putting my DH & I into that situation if DH just immediately shut it down like you did of course that’s quite selfish. Especially if the only reason DH wanted/needed me was to be his taxi there and back.

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:08

Mrsttcno1 · 25/12/2023 20:57

I think YABU mainly because you’ve said yourself he’s only really needed as your lift there, and that’s a bit shit. It’s not impossible to get there otherwise, it’s more expensive, but not impossible. Is there not a compromise possible? Can DH drop you off there first early on and then you can taxi back? Or the other way round, taxi there and then stay until DH can come collect you?

If not, then I’d say he goes to get friend and see family the following day. It sounds like this is a big family affair, not just your grandad, so you cancelling doesn’t cancel the whole day it just means you guys won’t be there which isn’t ideal but you can just go visit the following day instead?

There may have been compromises yes.
However we never got to the stage of trying to work out a compromise because he got defensive. I got upset at his reaction and then before long we found out friend isn't actually being discharged for a few days anyway so the argument is now a none issue and we are just going to my Grandads.

However there has been an atmosphere. He clearly thinks I'm selfish. So I was trying to work out if I was being unreasonable or he was or neither as if it's me I would apologise

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 25/12/2023 21:07

Realistically the options are:

A) DH takes you one way and then taxi the other, whichever works better for everyone there/back

B) Pack overnight bags, see if DH will do the driving but across more days, sleep on sofa once there

C) Taxi and stay overnight so public transport back as usual 27th

Speak to DH and try and come to a middle ground compromise if possible

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 25/12/2023 21:06

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:02

I agree with this.
Unfortunately I have been having lessons but have not passed my test yet so unfortunately there is currently only one legal driver and one car.

Well yes, but that's still a significant heavy load on your dp.
'Do what me and my family want on boxing day or you'll RUIN it for everyone, despite no one else offering to help out that could"
'?

Zanatdy · 25/12/2023 21:06

I don’t think he needs to rush there to help if not even a really close friend - sounds like this guys got other people to help him too. But not driving is massively inconvenient and times like this show why

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:04

tokesqueen · 25/12/2023 20:59

Not really the point but it could be somewhat unwise to grow old 'in the sticks'. How does he plan to cope as he becomes frailer? What's his financial situation? Could he halve you at a taxi?

Whilst this is a valid point. He does live near my aunt who helps him and I don't think making my Grandad move house is a quick solution to this particular boxing day disagreement 😅

OP posts:
NearlyMonday · 25/12/2023 21:04

tokesqueen · 25/12/2023 20:59

Not really the point but it could be somewhat unwise to grow old 'in the sticks'. How does he plan to cope as he becomes frailer? What's his financial situation? Could he halve you at a taxi?

You’re absolutely right, it’s not the point at all and is not helpful to the thread

2dogsandabudgie · 25/12/2023 21:03

OP - Why does your husband want to take his friend all the way home and not back to his family that friend was visiting. Where does the friend want to go?

sonjadog · 25/12/2023 21:03

Get him to drop you off, then stay overnight, and get public transport back if it is running a normal timetable on 27th, get a taxi, which would be half of the price of a return trip, or your DH comes and gets you on 27th.

DGPP · 25/12/2023 21:03

Your DH is being unreasonable and trying to wiggle out of the family party. I’d be pretty cross.
this friend can be discharged to family as you say and then your DH can drive to him on the 27th to collect him.
mots important not to let your grandad down again especially if he’s frail. I think your DH is in the wrong

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:02

Sensibleandboring · 25/12/2023 21:00

Sounds a bit like the issue is there is only 1 car or 1 driver otherwise you could both do your own thing? Both events seem quite important

I agree with this.
Unfortunately I have been having lessons but have not passed my test yet so unfortunately there is currently only one legal driver and one car.

OP posts:
Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 21:01

festivepains · 25/12/2023 20:58

You said there was a taxi

I could book a taxi. I would have to book a family car to fit all 3 children's car seats in and then taxi to my Grandads. That would be about a £50 taxi there and a £50 taxi back on a regular day so I imagine more each way on boxing day unfortunately

Unfortunately I just don't have that money to just spend like that without pre budgeting so unfortunately a taxi isn't a viable option to get to my Grandads at this time.

OP posts:
Sensibleandboring · 25/12/2023 21:00

Sounds a bit like the issue is there is only 1 car or 1 driver otherwise you could both do your own thing? Both events seem quite important

phoenixrosehere · 25/12/2023 21:00

festivepains · 25/12/2023 20:58

You said there was a taxi

Which she said they couldn’t afford.

phoenixrosehere · 25/12/2023 20:59

ManateeFair · 25/12/2023 20:55

Mumsnet, the only place in the world where people think you’re subhuman if you can’t drive, and also where they assume that if both partners can drive, they must automatically be able to afford to run two cars.

Right. OP’s thread is going to be mainly focused on her not being able to drive despite mentioning she failed her test (which happens to many) and that she usually gets around with the feet she was given and a bus pass (again something many do without supposedly upsetting their spouses who knew of this before they became exclusive) instead of this friend who will be with their FAMILY that they were visiting to begin with.

tokesqueen · 25/12/2023 20:59

Not really the point but it could be somewhat unwise to grow old 'in the sticks'. How does he plan to cope as he becomes frailer? What's his financial situation? Could he halve you at a taxi?

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 20:58

SleepingStandingUp · 25/12/2023 20:37

I don't think yabu but was he thinking DFriend will be spending a night in a hotel after being discharged from hospital as hell have no where to go?

DHs friend has a loving family to go to who he was visiting before the emergency.

If friend legitimately had absolutely no where to go and needed my DH to get him then we wouldn't have the conversation I would have just said ok.

Wishing I had made that clear in my original post now. Over looked that detail in my post it seems and now everyone thinks friend can't be discharged or has nowhere to go.

OP posts:
festivepains · 25/12/2023 20:58

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 20:44

It's physically impossible to get to my Grandads without him driving unfortunately. There's no way for me get there on a public holiday without driving. It's hard to get to even on a work day. Grandad lives in the sticks. Takes 4 countryside buses that come infrequently to get there and several hours on a regular week day.

But if I could drive or get there another way this wouldn't have come up as although I would have been sad he wasn't coming I would have just gone without him and not said "hold on not boxing day"

It's also not the first Christmas he's let me down. We canceled last Christmas last notice because of a problem that came up for him. So it would be the second year in a row.

I can drive but unfortunately failed my test and so haven't yet passed unfortunately

You said there was a taxi

Decisionsdecisions43 · 25/12/2023 20:58

The not driving thing is a bit irrelevant anyway. Even if you did drive, if you only have one car then the argument would be about who has priority and gets the car.
FWIW I think you were right to stick to your original plan. If the friend was stranded in a hospital nowhere near home or family then that would be completely different.