Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick friend and boxing day plans . Who is being unreasonable?

187 replies

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 20:21

Name change but long term poster.

Who is being unreasonable about this Christmas day argument please.

Me and DH have had a Christmas day argument that we've tried to put behind us but tbh after a heated spat and some crying in the middle of the day has created an atmosphere and I feel Christmas has been pretty ruined.
I can't tell if my POV was unreasonable or his was.
We both strongly disagree and have had to just agree to disagree and not talk about it, with both of us not understanding each others point of view or priorities.

For context we always do Christmas eve with my DHs family which we did yesterday. Boxing day with mine. Last year we had to cancel to my Grandad last minute. He is getting old and not in great health and I fear we don't have many Christmas' left with him. He will be hurt if we cancel last minute again.

Yesterday we heard the news that a long standing friend (more my partner's friend of 20 plus years but also my friend for about 16) had been rushed to hospital. This is a good but not very close friend to either of us anymore but someone we both care about alot none the less. He is an important person to us. We were told he was unresponsive and feared to have had a stroke. We have been very very worried.

We got a call from another friend today to let us know that he was awake, he's had a serious medical emergency that I won't disclose as its not my medical information and this thread could be outing but he isn't going to die, hospital are investigating why this has happened and looking at sending him home.

Friend was visiting family the other side of the country.

DH offers to go fetch him when he is discharged and bring him back home. This will take a day with all the driving. Obviously this is completely fine with me. Of course he should help. .

The argument happened because he then tells me he might be doing this tomorrow Boxing Day. I say "umm no not boxing day it's my family Christmas" I wouldn't be able to go as I can't drive and we would have to late cancel my Grandad yet again. I explained this. I said it was important to me. I said he could go the next day.

He said I have funny priorities. That my reaction was weird and not ok. Got very annoyed with me. I got upset. Argument happened.

Now if this was still a life and death situation with friend I would have said yes go. If friend had been likely to die I would have told him to set off in the middle of our Christmas dinner if needs be. But to me if hospital are looking at discharging, then this is no longer an immediate emergency / not really even an emergency anymore and he is not at risk of dying and so I think it's great to help friend but it can wait until 27th.

His opinion - That I have my priorities all wrong. That friend needing help as he is in hospital top trumps family Christmas because we could just go another time and friend has been sick in hospital and so is far more important then Christmas or seeing family. He implied strongly that he thought I was selfish and that I only think of myself.

My opinion - That this is no longer an emergency. It would be unreasonable to late cancel my Grandad again. That my family Christmas is important to me and it is as important as his family Christmas (that we never have had to late cancel or miss because he would never allow it). Yes help friend but not at the expense of my family Christmas. Helping him can wait until the next day (which still would have messed up our family time plans but still fair enough friend needs help). I don't think it's selfish to think that my elderly Grandad not being let down again is more of a priority then a non emergency with a long standing but not close friend, this isn't his bestie. I feel upset he can't see this and that he has questioned my ethics and thinks I am selfish.

So am I being unreasonable and I am in fact selfish for thinking that it's not ok to cancel my family boxing day so he can drive across the country to help friend or am I being reasonable to have said hold on no not boxing day you could go in the 27th

Whose priorities are off here?

As it turns out friend isn't in danger of dying but hospital are keeping him for a few days so partner isn't driving there anyway but this argument has definitely soured our Christmas day and I am just really sad about that.

Is it me that's being a dick about this? I honestly don't know and would like some opinions as I don't know what to say. I just feel sad about the ruined Christmas day.

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 25/12/2023 23:37

Calliopespa · 25/12/2023 23:29

Op sorry if I’ve missed this, but would you be able to go the day after, or next weekend, to your Granddad? If not, I know it’s a big expense but I think you should pay the 65 pound taxi fare you looked up . Could he manage to either take you or collect you if you could do the other trip by taxi and maybe tweak the timings ? As you say, it could be one of your granddad’s last Christmases and, while it’s a big expense, you have said you would go, you have cancelled last year and to be fair it’s you not driving (and there are lots of valid reasons for that, but it’s still a solid fact) that is really causing the issue here. Like you, I would rather the offer to collect the friend had not been made, but it has, and it’s his right to offer if he feels that way. I know it’s a lot of money in one go, but if you were both driving about day to day you would probably quite quickly have spent that taxi fare in extra fuel that you’ve been saving by always travelling together. I think if it’s just the taxi fare stopping you you could come to regret it. I get that it is a lot but this is an unexpected expense and can be saved elsewhere.

Oh I see it is now ( and has been all along?!) a total non issue anyway. Tbh it’s been slightly confusing. As you say OP, you have had to repeat a lot which people then understandably skim read…

ArchetypalBusyMum · 25/12/2023 23:35

It's dead simple.
His way is a win-lose situation (friend or grandad).
Your way is win-win situation (friend and grandad)

Why would you pick win-lose when you can have win-win!!

No need to pit the importance of one person over the other at all, that's a self imposed (and therefore completely unnecessary) competition.
Obviously if friend was dying etc it would be different, but that's not the situation you have.

Calliopespa · 25/12/2023 23:29

Op sorry if I’ve missed this, but would you be able to go the day after, or next weekend, to your Granddad? If not, I know it’s a big expense but I think you should pay the 65 pound taxi fare you looked up . Could he manage to either take you or collect you if you could do the other trip by taxi and maybe tweak the timings ? As you say, it could be one of your granddad’s last Christmases and, while it’s a big expense, you have said you would go, you have cancelled last year and to be fair it’s you not driving (and there are lots of valid reasons for that, but it’s still a solid fact) that is really causing the issue here. Like you, I would rather the offer to collect the friend had not been made, but it has, and it’s his right to offer if he feels that way. I know it’s a lot of money in one go, but if you were both driving about day to day you would probably quite quickly have spent that taxi fare in extra fuel that you’ve been saving by always travelling together. I think if it’s just the taxi fare stopping you you could come to regret it. I get that it is a lot but this is an unexpected expense and can be saved elsewhere.

Beautiful3 · 25/12/2023 23:29

This person has family? If so, they'd be the ones colle ting him, surely?! I don't understand why your husband's inserting himself?! And cancelling your plans. Kind I'd sounds like he's trying to get out of going.

Cherrysoup · 25/12/2023 23:27

Why, if he is no longer someone you see much, was your Dh going to drop everything to go and get him and why was he the chosen one? I don’t think you’ve even spoken directly to the friend? I think your Dh is being really unreasonable.

Pp could at least read the OP’s posts-click see all to read them, rather than her endlessly repeating herself about why she doesn’t drive.

ExTheCheater · 25/12/2023 23:17

Surely your friend has people closer who can help rather than someone on the other side of the country. Hospital could arrange transport if he can't get in a taxi.

Figgygal · 25/12/2023 23:15

I've no idea why your dh is inserting him into this scenario in the first place given their friendship has drifted and friend has family nearby to support.
I'd be pissed off too he'd just discarded your plans and family on boxing day

Quitelikeit · 25/12/2023 23:13

Yabu

I also don’t understand how you cancelled grandads Xmas last year - I mean you keep calling it a family Xmas so where was the rest of the family? Or is it just your family who go to visit him on Boxing Day?

You could have hosted him
at your house and let aunt bring him, but your husband could also have dropped you off and you could have got a taxi back

You jumped the gun without thinking it through and that’s really what caused the row

SapphireSeptember · 25/12/2023 23:06

It's Boxing Day, there's not a lot of public transport. Where I am there's no trains or buses. OP has said the buses she normally gets aren't running.

NotARealWookiie · 25/12/2023 23:01

Can you get any public transport to get you closer and then taxi? So that it’s cheaper than the £65 taxi each way?

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 22:58

Sirian · 25/12/2023 22:56

YANBU. You only cancel family Xmas for a dire emergency. If it was his own mother or sibling then fair enough. But it’s a friend, and not even a close one. The friend could quite easily be discharged to his own family and DH could do him the favour of collecting him another day. TBH if he isn’t a close friend then I’d say an entire day is too much to invest anyway - he has his own family, let them sort him out!

He was once a close friend but is now more of an old friend. Very much loved and important to us but it's been well over a decade since they were close friends.

OP posts:
kiminodrink · 25/12/2023 22:58

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Sirian · 25/12/2023 22:56

YANBU. You only cancel family Xmas for a dire emergency. If it was his own mother or sibling then fair enough. But it’s a friend, and not even a close one. The friend could quite easily be discharged to his own family and DH could do him the favour of collecting him another day. TBH if he isn’t a close friend then I’d say an entire day is too much to invest anyway - he has his own family, let them sort him out!

kiminodrink · 25/12/2023 22:55

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 22:54

OhwhyOY · 25/12/2023 22:47

Oh it has finally clicked for me why you've been saying he didn't need to go immediately to collect friend when discharged. You mean your DH plans to bring friend back to where he/you live NOT to where the family he's visiting are. So he could have gone back to family, stayed with them however long, then DH could have brought him back home. I don't know if your posts were unclear, I'm dim, or a bit of both,but I finally got there. I'm which case I'd say yanbu.

Yes. DHs plan was to drive hours across to the other side of the country to collect friend from his families to bring him back to where friend lives in a city an hour away from us in the opposite direction then drive home so an all day trip. Hospital would have discharged friend to his families where he was visiting when this emergency happened. Friend would have been completely fine until the 27th. DH and his group of friends just thought it would be nice to try and get sick friend home as sick friend would prefer (or assumed to prefer as it turned out) to come home then stay with family.

My post might have been unintentionally unclear as several people seemed to misunderstand the same point so don't worry

OP posts:
mrsbyers · 25/12/2023 22:52

Could you get dropped off in the morning by him before he heads to friends ? Possible to stay at grandads overnight and then DH can pick you up on 27th if needed - might be nice to spend that time with him and let DH do is thing

LifeIsHardAlways · 25/12/2023 22:49

Your husband is being an idiot, your old friend can have their family deal with them. You should still have Boxing Day with your family tomorrow.

OhwhyOY · 25/12/2023 22:47

Oh it has finally clicked for me why you've been saying he didn't need to go immediately to collect friend when discharged. You mean your DH plans to bring friend back to where he/you live NOT to where the family he's visiting are. So he could have gone back to family, stayed with them however long, then DH could have brought him back home. I don't know if your posts were unclear, I'm dim, or a bit of both,but I finally got there. I'm which case I'd say yanbu.

kiminodrink · 25/12/2023 22:44

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

kiminodrink · 25/12/2023 22:42

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 22:42

Cupcakekiller · 25/12/2023 22:37

People have given compromises like he drops you off, you stay overnight and he either picks you up on 27th or you get home via public transport but you haven't replied. Or you could go to your grandad's on the 27th instead unless you're both back at work?

I have replied to all those comments quite a few times saying that those could be good compromises but we never got to that stage because it turned out friend isn't being discharged yet so DH isn't going and we're just going to be Grandads. I made the post to see who if anyone was being unreasonable with their perspective on the situation. Not looking for solutions as that has been resolved. I think I even said that friend want being discharged now in the OP :)

I stopped replying to repeat replies addressing this and a few other points as I'm just repeating myself over and over and people can read the updates at the end of the day :)

OP posts:
Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 22:38

This reply has been deleted

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

Friend hasn't actually directly asked for help. DH offered.

Also what I didn't realise at the time the argument unfolded is that DH and his group of friends hadn't even actually spoken to friend in hospital about it all this they had just decided by talking between them all that this was the plan of action and DH would drive on boxing day to go get sick friend so sick friend could come home his own home. Their plan was to take another friend with them who would then drive sick friends van home.
When someone had actually spoke to sick friend it turned out sick friend wouldn't be discharged for a few days anyway due to hospital wanting to observe him. (as the emergency that has now passed was serious and they are not sure what caused what happened, friend whoever is awake and functioning and not in danger of dying now, no longer in ICU and on a normal ward etc) 😕

And yes that was my stance. That this wasn't an emergency that couldn't wait until the 27th. If it had been an emergency. If there was a chance friend wouldn't make it. Or he was going to be fully stranded or anything like that I would have never have objected.

I don't think he ever particularly wants to visit my family at Xmas or any time. But tbh I don't really want to visit his but I always do as it's important to him. Also tbh I don't get the impression that if this had been on Xmas eve we would have been potentially cancelling his family Xmas plans.

OP posts:
Cupcakekiller · 25/12/2023 22:37

People have given compromises like he drops you off, you stay overnight and he either picks you up on 27th or you get home via public transport but you haven't replied. Or you could go to your grandad's on the 27th instead unless you're both back at work?

kiminodrink · 25/12/2023 22:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

JANEY205 · 25/12/2023 22:12

I agree with you 100% OP!

why does it HAVE to be your DH going to collect if this isn’t even a close friend and he has family he is close with that can bring him home? Smacks of your husband inserting himself into the situation or using it as an excuse. He already has plans. Your grandad is important. He isn’t the friends only option but he is yours.