Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick friend and boxing day plans . Who is being unreasonable?

187 replies

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 20:21

Name change but long term poster.

Who is being unreasonable about this Christmas day argument please.

Me and DH have had a Christmas day argument that we've tried to put behind us but tbh after a heated spat and some crying in the middle of the day has created an atmosphere and I feel Christmas has been pretty ruined.
I can't tell if my POV was unreasonable or his was.
We both strongly disagree and have had to just agree to disagree and not talk about it, with both of us not understanding each others point of view or priorities.

For context we always do Christmas eve with my DHs family which we did yesterday. Boxing day with mine. Last year we had to cancel to my Grandad last minute. He is getting old and not in great health and I fear we don't have many Christmas' left with him. He will be hurt if we cancel last minute again.

Yesterday we heard the news that a long standing friend (more my partner's friend of 20 plus years but also my friend for about 16) had been rushed to hospital. This is a good but not very close friend to either of us anymore but someone we both care about alot none the less. He is an important person to us. We were told he was unresponsive and feared to have had a stroke. We have been very very worried.

We got a call from another friend today to let us know that he was awake, he's had a serious medical emergency that I won't disclose as its not my medical information and this thread could be outing but he isn't going to die, hospital are investigating why this has happened and looking at sending him home.

Friend was visiting family the other side of the country.

DH offers to go fetch him when he is discharged and bring him back home. This will take a day with all the driving. Obviously this is completely fine with me. Of course he should help. .

The argument happened because he then tells me he might be doing this tomorrow Boxing Day. I say "umm no not boxing day it's my family Christmas" I wouldn't be able to go as I can't drive and we would have to late cancel my Grandad yet again. I explained this. I said it was important to me. I said he could go the next day.

He said I have funny priorities. That my reaction was weird and not ok. Got very annoyed with me. I got upset. Argument happened.

Now if this was still a life and death situation with friend I would have said yes go. If friend had been likely to die I would have told him to set off in the middle of our Christmas dinner if needs be. But to me if hospital are looking at discharging, then this is no longer an immediate emergency / not really even an emergency anymore and he is not at risk of dying and so I think it's great to help friend but it can wait until 27th.

His opinion - That I have my priorities all wrong. That friend needing help as he is in hospital top trumps family Christmas because we could just go another time and friend has been sick in hospital and so is far more important then Christmas or seeing family. He implied strongly that he thought I was selfish and that I only think of myself.

My opinion - That this is no longer an emergency. It would be unreasonable to late cancel my Grandad again. That my family Christmas is important to me and it is as important as his family Christmas (that we never have had to late cancel or miss because he would never allow it). Yes help friend but not at the expense of my family Christmas. Helping him can wait until the next day (which still would have messed up our family time plans but still fair enough friend needs help). I don't think it's selfish to think that my elderly Grandad not being let down again is more of a priority then a non emergency with a long standing but not close friend, this isn't his bestie. I feel upset he can't see this and that he has questioned my ethics and thinks I am selfish.

So am I being unreasonable and I am in fact selfish for thinking that it's not ok to cancel my family boxing day so he can drive across the country to help friend or am I being reasonable to have said hold on no not boxing day you could go in the 27th

Whose priorities are off here?

As it turns out friend isn't in danger of dying but hospital are keeping him for a few days so partner isn't driving there anyway but this argument has definitely soured our Christmas day and I am just really sad about that.

Is it me that's being a dick about this? I honestly don't know and would like some opinions as I don't know what to say. I just feel sad about the ruined Christmas day.

OP posts:
itsmylife7 · 26/12/2023 12:26

As usual people are nit-picking on the post.

The friend in hospital HAS family there. He will be discharged to HIS family, who he is visiting.

So WHY is OP'S husband trying to be the ' Knight in shining armour ' ?

He's putting the friend who has FAMILY right near him, above his own family.

Bet if OP said the FRIEND was a Women the replies would be different!

OP make passing your test a priority for your own good. You won't need to rely on your husband then.

Calliopespa · 26/12/2023 12:20

Lemonfoxtrot · 26/12/2023 11:33

You seem to be getting a lot of criticism for not having a driving licence, but the issue here is how far down the list of priorities you and your family are to your DH.

The friend ( even if he has been discharged on Boxing Day) had plenty of other options. It’s a nice thing to do, but not at the expense of your family.

It seems it’s more important for your DH to look like ‘the hero’, as opposed to less glamorous responsibilities to his family.

Yes this is a reasonable take on it, put like that.

I also agree the argument was multi-faceted (and probably was easy for them to conflate the layers a little after a couple of glasses of wine) as it involved the collision of priorities and ideals and the more prosaic considerations of scheduling and transport. I don’t suspect DH was trying to avoid granddad’s, but probably was swept up in a rescue mission without thinking. I think he actually would have liked to have done both ( ideal), but the scheduling at first was a problem ( practicality). I don’t think OP really minded him going, but she had no way of then carrying out her priority.
Relationships do have these collisions. Moreover, things always get heightened at Christmas because there is a lot of build up and expectation. OP it’s great you go to your Grandad when the rest of your family sounds quite fractured. Have a lovely day with him. I can see both dh’s pov and yours, and also understand driving isn’t always as easy for some as for others for all sorts of reasons. However, going forward, I think building up an emergency taxi fund is a good idea as you don’t want to find yourself trapped at some point. Give grandad and DH big hug: they are clearly both really important to you in so many ways.

Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 12:18

DixonD · 26/12/2023 12:12

Well you can’t drive if you haven’t passed your test.

Well exactly. What I meant is I know how to drive and could drive the car technically but I would need DH to come still to sit in the passenger seat because I haven't passed my test and so obviously need a driver to take me out on a provisional license. So either way I need DH to go in the car

OP posts:
DixonD · 26/12/2023 12:12

Crayolaslug · 25/12/2023 20:44

It's physically impossible to get to my Grandads without him driving unfortunately. There's no way for me get there on a public holiday without driving. It's hard to get to even on a work day. Grandad lives in the sticks. Takes 4 countryside buses that come infrequently to get there and several hours on a regular week day.

But if I could drive or get there another way this wouldn't have come up as although I would have been sad he wasn't coming I would have just gone without him and not said "hold on not boxing day"

It's also not the first Christmas he's let me down. We canceled last Christmas last notice because of a problem that came up for him. So it would be the second year in a row.

I can drive but unfortunately failed my test and so haven't yet passed unfortunately

Well you can’t drive if you haven’t passed your test.

Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 12:08

Lemonfoxtrot · 26/12/2023 11:33

You seem to be getting a lot of criticism for not having a driving licence, but the issue here is how far down the list of priorities you and your family are to your DH.

The friend ( even if he has been discharged on Boxing Day) had plenty of other options. It’s a nice thing to do, but not at the expense of your family.

It seems it’s more important for your DH to look like ‘the hero’, as opposed to less glamorous responsibilities to his family.

Yes. This is why I felt upset. I don't think the reasons why I can't drive are massively relevant and I have gone over and over why I can't yet drive in the thread, but the fact is to me I can't drive and so DH had made a commitment to me to drive me and our children to my Grandad in boxing day. Just like I made a commitment to him to do his family Xmas Xmas eve.

To me the priorities in this situation were in order.

  1. Emergency situation with friend
  2. Not letting my Grandad down for the 2nd year running
  3. Important but no longer an emergency situation with friend.

To him it was clear that even though the situation with friend had down graded to no longer an emergency and could have waited until the 27th, it was clear that him having commited to driving us to something he knows we were dependent on him to be able to do wasn't that important a commitment to him but most importantly he thinks it's completely fine to just late cancel on my Grandad at Christmas for the second year in a row.

OP posts:
Lemonfoxtrot · 26/12/2023 11:33

You seem to be getting a lot of criticism for not having a driving licence, but the issue here is how far down the list of priorities you and your family are to your DH.

The friend ( even if he has been discharged on Boxing Day) had plenty of other options. It’s a nice thing to do, but not at the expense of your family.

It seems it’s more important for your DH to look like ‘the hero’, as opposed to less glamorous responsibilities to his family.

ILoveMyCaravan · 26/12/2023 10:58

This is something that my DH would have done. He doesn't do it any more, but it's taken a lot of work to stop doing shit like this.

If this "friend"'was visiting family, why on Earth can't one of them collect him from hospital?

ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/12/2023 10:52

Remind, not remove

ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/12/2023 10:52

Sounds like he's got caught up in things and his emotions hadn't adjusted to the fact that it needn't be so urgent to collect friend.
I think if you draw his attention to the fact that boxing day for the friend is optional and go from there, maybe the friends would even prefer another day for whatever reason, the issue could be solved and later when everyone is sorted and calm you can reflect on where it went wrong and remove him you aren't a cruel mean person who doesn't care about friends!

Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 10:41

WonderingWanda · 26/12/2023 10:33

This doesn't sound like a healthy relationship to be honest. My dh would've offered to drop me off on his way, even if it was out of his way and I would have been understanding that he was needed somewhere else. It sounds more like he is looking for excuses to get out of spending Christmas with your family and you've both dug your heels in. I doubt this is an isolated example of you two not getting along. Is there a power imbalance in your relationship.

Well if the whole questioning priorities and him getting huffy hadn't happened and so I hadn't then started crying (which tbh was an over reaction on my part to him being huffy, but it was Christmas Day and the desire to have a perfect day and not a day where we started bickering or arguing and the fact id drunk a couple of glasses of wine took over and I just started crying. I did explain many times that I was crying because he had got shitty with me not that to manipulate him into not going to help friend etc ), and if he had responded to my 'not boxing day surely" stance something like "I know this is important to you so we need to do this so can i pay for a taxi, or i could drive and drop you off before leaving" or something then although i would have felt sad he was no longer coming I would have been ok and understanding about him going to help his friend.

Unfortunately though that's not what happened as we had a row about priorities and he didn't offer out any alternative solutions other then canceling my Grandad.😕

OP posts:
WonderingWanda · 26/12/2023 10:33

This doesn't sound like a healthy relationship to be honest. My dh would've offered to drop me off on his way, even if it was out of his way and I would have been understanding that he was needed somewhere else. It sounds more like he is looking for excuses to get out of spending Christmas with your family and you've both dug your heels in. I doubt this is an isolated example of you two not getting along. Is there a power imbalance in your relationship.

ZenNudist · 26/12/2023 10:32

Irs good you are learning to drive. I think you both have a point but his friend needing help trumps family Christmas. I think you need to get one of your family to collect you. I've driven an hour there and another hour back to pick up dsis on boxing day before because she can't drive. Maybe get picked up and stay with family or get a £65 taxi back. That's not too bad one way.

Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 10:17

ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/12/2023 10:06

Well said op. He was unreasonable.

You didn't see (and there wasn't one) the need for a conflict of choice = nothing wrong with your values.

He wouldn't release his grip (maybe deliberately or maybe unconsciously) on the idea that boxing day has to be the day for grandad or friend = created artificial conflict of loyalties.

Your argument was impossible because he thought it was an argument about what was more important. You thought (rightly) it was an argument about sensible scheduling choices.

Thank you for this. This is how I saw the situation. 🙂

OP posts:
Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 10:16

As for all the saviour complex comments. I do think DH wanting to drive to help friend came from a place of caring for his friend and wanting to help. We have been very worried about this friend. I also think he probably got swept up with his other friends in this rescue mission idea because he just wanted to help.

I don't think badly of him for wanting to help. I have no issue with him driving to fetch friend. Just I didn't understand why it was so much if an emergency that it had to mean our boxing plans got canceled when we could do both and not let my Grandad down and he could go drive to friend on the 27th. And his reaction of questioning my priorities as if it was a moral failing of mine to not be like "of course friend top trumps my Christmas" caused the argument as he couldn't see why friend didn't top trump family and i didn't understand why not late canceling my Grandad again didn't top trump helping friend in a no longer emergency situation that could wait until the 27th.

I appreciate that I am dependent on him driving me and he can refuse to drive and go do something else but it also this is an arrangement to drive me and our children so an important family event that he knows i cant get there on public transport. So whilst he can just choose not to ultimately he would be choosing to drop a commitment to his family that he had made at the last minute to do something for someone else.

OP posts:
ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/12/2023 10:13

@Disturbia81 that's my suspicion too.
His position would be reasonable if he was open about that and discussed a work around. Not admirable for a grown man to behave like a teenager and use tactics to try to wriggle out of something. (If that's what he's doing, op might know).

Disturbia81 · 26/12/2023 10:10

Sounds like he just doesn't like seeing the dysfunctional family and was happy to have a reason to get out of it, knowing it wouldn't happen another day.
YANBU

ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/12/2023 10:06

Well said op. He was unreasonable.

You didn't see (and there wasn't one) the need for a conflict of choice = nothing wrong with your values.

He wouldn't release his grip (maybe deliberately or maybe unconsciously) on the idea that boxing day has to be the day for grandad or friend = created artificial conflict of loyalties.

Your argument was impossible because he thought it was an argument about what was more important. You thought (rightly) it was an argument about sensible scheduling choices.

Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 10:04

There is also a lot of speculation about my family asking why they can't come get me or drive me somewhere or drive my Grandad to me or rearrange Christmas. I don't want to go into the ins and outs of my family but my family is pretty dysfunctional and no there is no way anyone would be coming to get me or helping me or driving me anywhere. If it wasn't for my Grandad I would have been far more likely to cancel however my Grandad is old and I know looking forward to seeing me and I late cancelled last year so like in context of having to do that I do not want to late cancel on him again this year.

There is a comment about needing to visit my Grandad more often so boxing day wouldn't matter. That is fair and something I feel bad about often but as I have explained he is very hard to get to on public transport and it takes hours so whilst I do visit I don't visit as much as I would like as it's very hard to fit visiting around work and school pick up and all that. Buses don't run on Sundays. DH offers to drive sometimes. But yes I should visit him more often but I mostly keep in touch with him by phone and visit a few times a year and so I know seeing Grandad on boxing day is important to him and he would be very disappointed if I late cancelled again.

OP posts:
Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 09:58

There is an awful lot of speculation happening in this thread about my finances and my family. I can't reply to every individual post about it and I don't really feel like to disclosing all the fine details of my personal life but I just want to say that we don't have shared finances at all. His ability to decide to spend petrol money to drive across the country has no barring on my personal ability to conjure up over £100 in taxi fairs at the drop of the hat.

It's possible he would have paid for i me to get a taxi maybe but as I've said quite a few times in this thread we never got to the stage of trying to work out a compromise on the situation because my gut reaction was to say "boxing day is important to me so not boxing day surely it can be on the 27th" and he reacted by questioning my priorities and implied I had bad ethics and then I started crying because he'd got short and shitty with me on Christmas day and then we had a row about priorities.

I made this thread to work out if it was indeed me that had terrible priorities like he implied, or if instead I was being reasonable to ask him to wait. Not really to ask for solutions to the predicament due to it not being relevant anymore as he doesn't need to go.

OP posts:
ArchetypalBusyMum · 26/12/2023 09:44

Crayolaslug · 26/12/2023 01:26

This is how I felt about it yes. Once we found out friend is no longer in ICU and were under the impression hospital were going to discharge him to me that means he is well enough to leave hospital in which case the situation while has no doubt been awful for friend and a big worry for his loved ones and friends, is no longer an emergency, and friend has family to stay with, so there was no reason to rush there on boxing day and the 27th would be fine. Thus I am not letting my Grandad down last minute again and DH can go help his friend.

If friend was dying or it was possible he could die or even if friend was being discharged but was completely stranded then I wouldn't have just said of course go. I mean if friend was dying I would literally have been fine with him leaving in the middle of Christmas dinner. Of course I wouldn't mind that.

But if friend was well enough to be discharged then to me there was no need to let anyone down. Boxing day plans could still go ahead and DH could still go fetch friend.

Exactly.
No need for sky high emotions and a massive row involving questioning your fundamental values because your values aren't part of the decision if it isn't based on weighing up one person over another.
He created that clash when it could have been entirely avoided by choosing another day (which would have not affected anyone negatively so was a valid choice).
Your DH was either manufacturing a reason not to go to Grandad, or missing the basic logical point entirely.

MumblesParty · 26/12/2023 07:07

Your DH is just trying to be a hero, because that is preferable to spending the day being an ordinary person with your family. And there was no logic to the plan he and his friends concocted. Someone who’s been staying near family and got admitted to hospital wouldn’t surely prefer to be discharged back to said family, to recover a bit before making their way home.

Your DH wanted to be a hero, and when you essentially took his superman cape off him, he had a tantrum!

YANBU, but what this episode does show is that you need to book another driving test asap OP, so you can be more independent.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 26/12/2023 06:25

Famousinlove · 26/12/2023 02:07

I find it really weird that your DH and his mates decided among themselves that the friend would want to leave the hospital and immediately travel hours home (to be on his own?)
Assuming he gets along with his family, wouldn't his sudden illness mean he would want to spend some time with them upon leaving hospital and perhaps even extend his stay so they can look after him..?

Me too, it's such a weird thing to do. It's not kind or caring deciding for someone else and he'd be better near the hospital and with family. I don't think they even considered he might not be up to a long drive or might need care after being discharged. I thought and a lot of people probably did too that the friend was all alone there because otherwise DH and the other friends actions don't make sense. I don't know if it's wanting to play the hero or get out of Christmas at the ILs.

Fourecks · 26/12/2023 03:07

I voted YANBU purely because of the way your H reacted. If he hadn't tried to make out you were selfish, you could have had a calm discussion. I think PP was right that he (and his friends) wanted to leap in and play the hero.

Congratulations on pushing through your driving anxiety and good luck with the test. Once you have passed, don't fall into the trap of letting him drive all the time, or you will find yourself out of practice.

SALWARP2023 · 26/12/2023 03:06

You need to learn to drive. Simple. Also, you should be seeing your grand dad often enough that Boxing Day would not matter. My DH has unexpectedly been in hospital for 6 weeks and the hospital is difficult to get to so where would I have been if I'd never made the effort? Also, I'm wondering if you work? OK the taxi isn't cheap but not having the financial wriggle room for an emergency is not good.

Spartak · 26/12/2023 03:01

If the friend has had an emergency hospital stay, including a spell in ICU, he is likely to not be up to spending hours being driven across the country.

He'll likely be tired and hungry so may well prefer a few days recuperating with family to care for him and to sleep, rather than returning home alone to fend for himself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread