Totally agree, @SkankingWombat Especially the bolded:
Learning those skills doesn't make them princesses or ladies, it makes them decent and useful human beings. Why would you choose not to teach them to sew a button back on or to be thoughtful and generous towards others in their lives?
Even as little kids we at least made a card. I still have a small food tin that I'd painted gold, and sprinkled with glitter and glued on dry pasta (painted gold) that my mother used to hold cosmetic brushes and the like for the next 40 years; since she died I have it. Must've been maybe 5 when I made it? Clearly not without instruction but the fact is we were expected to think of others.
If nothing else kids can draw a card or write a heartfelt note to mother. Young teens can do a LOT more. Not only coming up with a thoughtful material gift, but helping with the prep, decor, cooking, cleaning, serving at table or serving parents some wine and cheese in the evening. 13 and 15 are ten years past the time they should be thinking only of themselves and what they "get."
We were more excited about watching adults open our little gifts than we were about getting them.
When I was quite young, a department store in town had a room set aside; kids would be given an envelope to hold a list of people to purchase for, and their money (money supplied by parents, grandparents or from their own stash of birthday and Christmas money, or from doing chores) and there would be a selection of modestly priced gifts such as gloves, earrings, wallets, cufflinks for men (shows you how long ago that was) -- ladies in the private room would help children budget their available money and get out of there with gifts.
It seems to me that this would be a good thing for a women's institute or other local group to do -- create a "gift room" where kids can shop privately, to teach them the value of budgeting, spending and giving to others. Little baubles, inexpensive items could be donated or provided at reduced cost by area merchants. It really does give children a sense of pride.