Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who outstay their welcome

38 replies

Bedbouncer · 25/12/2023 14:53

Thinking of one particular couple (close relatives) who I love to pieces and always enjoy seeing - but they just don't go home! If I invite them round I have to write off the whole day (to midnight) and I always end up feeling relieved when they go - and guilty for feeling relieved - because it seems inhospitable somehow.

AINBU if you -suspect you may be these people - please go home like an 2 hours earlier than you are thinking of doing? Even people who love you like their own space!
AIBU - if you like them as much as you say you do - you will be glad they stay a long time. You are an inhospitable grouch!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 26/12/2023 21:07

SM4713 · 26/12/2023 02:01

@Bluela18 Personally when I go to anyone's home I usually say just let me know when it's time to go or what time would be a good time for us to leave.

Why can't you just read regular, social ques such as it being late, coffee has been served etc to say you are leaving? The host then has the option to say 'Yes, it was lovely seeing you' OR 'No, please stay for another drink' etc.

Those aren't "standard", though.

I personally don't know a single person who drinks coffee after lunchtime/early afternoon, unless maybe they had to pull an all-nighter at work/uni. None of my friends would dream of serving coffee in the evening. Coffee is exclusively a "get going in the morning" (or maybe sometimes a "perk you up during the post-lunch slump") drink in my world. I'm sure plenty of people do still drink coffee at night, but the whole ritual of post-dinner coffee feels like a very 1970s thing to me, it's something I've only seen in old movies and TV shows.

"Late" is also completely subjective. Some people consider 4pm to be late. Some people consider midnight to be early. I had elderly relatives who used to invite you for lunch and were pretty clear they wanted you gone by 3pm at the latest, and I have friends in their 20s for whom a "standard" get together starts at 10pm and goes on till 4am; ducking out at 2am would get you labelled a lightweight. There can't be a universal standard for what's considered late, since an elderly person's idea of "late" is going to be very different from a 22yr old's idea of "late."

Isn't the standard time to stay somewhere like 2 or 3 hours. That's a meal, chatting, and a last coffee or tea before going?

Depends on the situation. If I was invited for lunch or dinner by people I didn't know too well I'd probably aim for 2-3 hours, yeah. But if I tried to leave my best friends' house after three hours they'd be mortally offended and think they'd done something horribly wrong. A standard visit to these particular friends is at least six hours. I'm meeting one of my oldest friends tomorrow (who I only see once or twice a year, since she moved abroad) and we'll easily be together for eight hours minimum. But I have two other friends who are insanely busy and kind of chaotic and disorganised, and I frequently have hang outs that last for less than hour, and that is "standard" for those two particular friends.

The idea that there's some kind of Universal Standard Friendship Socialisation Time is just weird. Everyone is different, everyone's life is different, so how can you expect everyone to treat socialisation the same?

Glipsy · 26/12/2023 02:55

If you’re a couple, the answer to this is one of you goes to bed. Super cheerily ‘love you all so much! Will let you carry on but I’m knackered, see you next time!’

Either they leave at that point or else that starts the clock and the other one can then do a ‘well, I better head up to join x’ in 30 min/an hour/10 min.

obvs the general rule is that whoever’s family/friends are the overstayers has to do the late shift.

doesn’t work if it’s brunch I guess but that’s the time to have a vet appointment/trip to the dump/rock climbing lesson so tends to be easier than evenings

RantyAnty · 26/12/2023 02:36

Isn't the standard time to stay somewhere like 2 or 3 hours
That's a meal, chatting, and a last coffee or tea before going?

SM4713 · 26/12/2023 02:01

@Bluela18 Personally when I go to anyone's home I usually say just let me know when it's time to go or what time would be a good time for us to leave.

Why can't you just read regular, social ques such as it being late, coffee has been served etc to say you are leaving? The host then has the option to say 'Yes, it was lovely seeing you' OR 'No, please stay for another drink' etc.

Bluela18 · 26/12/2023 01:36

Personally when I go to anyone's home I usually say just let me know when it's time to go or what time would be a good time for us to leave. Unfortunately some people are not aware they are outstaying their welcome so you have to be clear, just say ah it's been so good seeing you but I'm going to have to call it a night in about say 20 mins I'm shattered or need to be up early.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/12/2023 01:31

& My Dad used to go upstairs, reappear in his pyjamas and start using the vacuum cleaner.

AppleChristsBirthdayMacchiato · 26/12/2023 01:31

You're not unreasonable but it is tricky if people don't say.

I love my best friends but they make passive aggressive comments and look aggrieved if I leave before 11pm (when they know it takes me 90 mins to get home), but they also bitch about other guests they've had who have stayed too long so it's like... what do you WANT?

Everyone has a different idea of what a reasonable length of stay is so be really explicit before hand.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/12/2023 01:28

friends of friends have a "goodbye" playlist - every song you could think of that's about saying goodnight/goodbye etc

Have never asked friends how many tracks of it they've heard.

Boatlifeisnotallinstagram · 26/12/2023 01:25

My old Dad had this down to a fine art. They would have people over for dinner. Say at 1800. At 2200 all the lounge and dining room lamps would turn off. He put them all on timers 😁. He'd then jump up, clap his hands together, thank everyone for coming and apologise that it must be bed time, he'd herd them out and that was that. Him and Mum did that for years!

Prayfortheangels · 26/12/2023 01:23

Why do so many people on mumsnet have no backbone?

Morewineplease10 · 26/12/2023 01:11

Oh god, my former in laws were dreadful for this. I don't miss that!

Even when I eventually started giving a window of time they'd still stay later and make sarcastic comments about how they were expected to leave! Err, yes, you are!

SM4713 · 26/12/2023 01:07

We had this just today! My mum was hosting Christmas lunch with my help. My SIL's mother gets invited, but is Jewish and never comes. This year, she called on Christmas EVE to say she would be coming!

All guests left except her! SIL's mother kept saying 'Now don't let me over stay my welcome, tell me when to go!'

NO- its not the host that needs to tell you to f&ck off. My mum was yawning, we were all knackered and this woman stayed there! After several offers of coffee, I suggest we all go for a nap- it was only then that she left.

shampooing · 26/12/2023 00:50

mrlistersgelfbride · 25/12/2023 21:38

YANBU. It's very frustrating.

I knew MIL was coming today but she turned up at 8:10am to watch DD open her presents and she's still here 13.5 hours later.
Had enough and just want to relax now!

Oh my goodness, I suppose I can be thankful my MIL is not an early riser (though she is hard work in very many other ways) but anyone coming to my door at that time I just wouldn’t answer!

TinyKittenPaw · 26/12/2023 00:40

I agree with giving times to leave - it can really help, inviting people for over but saying I’ll have to go out at x time, or finish at 10 because I have a big day tomorrow or promised to do something with DD.

Just make it clear you have some commitment at a certain point a couple of hours after their visit.

Cheeseplantalltheway · 26/12/2023 00:32

They are not outstaying their welcome if you are still being welcoming though. How will they know unless you tell them?

İt is not inhospitable to express your own needs.

WesselCups · 26/12/2023 00:28

I usually just stand up and tell them it's time to go and get them their coats before standing at the open front door.
My mother in law took offence the first time I did this, but her sensibilities aren't my problem.

Canisaysomething · 26/12/2023 00:27

When you invite them give them a start and finish time. “Hey we’d love you to come over from 2pm to 4pm tomorrow if you’re free” or something like that. I do this as standard for all guests. I hate giving open invitations.

Bedbouncer · 26/12/2023 00:10

Said relatives clearly don't have the ability to sense when is an appropriate time to leave. Often they are still there for HOURS after all other guests leave. I feel like specifying an end point is inhospitable- but maybe IABU

OP posts:
TheSuggestedAmendment · 25/12/2023 23:53

I had friends I had to stop inviting - you’d invite them for coffee and they and their DC would still be there at lunch every time. They were generous and would gladly have reciprocated - but that just isn’t how I organise my time. A coffee means coffee. Please leave.

Ponoka7 · 25/12/2023 23:53

My sister (67) is one of those people. It's sad because people are no longer inviting her because she takes it as a joke. She is becoming more lonely but it's her own doing. She'd be welcome at any time if she respected boundaries. She caused my DD to shout at her on Christmas Eve. It was upsetting for everyone.

VikingLady · 25/12/2023 23:47

Mills86 · 25/12/2023 21:04

Going against the grain above but I really don’t think adults should require clarification. Surely it’s pretty basic people skills to know when to fuck off home?

Nope, not all of us. I have no idea when I should go - totally cannot tell. So I make sure to always tell hosts that, and ask them to please tell me when it's home time.

Easy when there's a bunch: you can just leave in the middle.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/12/2023 22:29

Smiling at the suggestions to make an end time clear in advance; IME it just doesn't work with the dedicated overstayers, like my late, exMIL who's sit ... and sit ... and sit, even in the face of heavy hints on the day

In the end exH and I had to get really blatant and bring in the coats - "let me help you on with this" - and even then she'd remember someone else who'd died/was in hospital who we absolutely had to hear about on her way to the door

80skid · 25/12/2023 21:52

I wish I'd got an answer for this. My in laws bring their kids and usually stay after they're over tired and awful. They're also empty handed guests and never reciprocate hosting, but quick to help themselves to refreshments. Sadly DH doesn't get as enraged as I do, so I find sometimes it's best to just have errands or other arrangements.

mrlistersgelfbride · 25/12/2023 21:38

YANBU. It's very frustrating.

I knew MIL was coming today but she turned up at 8:10am to watch DD open her presents and she's still here 13.5 hours later.
Had enough and just want to relax now!

Gcsunnyside23 · 25/12/2023 21:24

If it's nighttime I wouldn't care but if it's daytime then I would make plans to see them but tell them a time you're only free to as you have 'insert plan/lie' at this time