Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Endocrinologists are the real solution to weight loss?

57 replies

noyodo · 25/12/2023 13:23

Gastric sleeves and even Gastric By pass result in gaining back the weight within 5 years.

AIBU to think the only real solution is to see an endocrinologist to see what is causing/driving weight gain?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 26/12/2023 16:24

They need to sort out the issues that cause them to eat too many calories and stop them from exercising.

Of course there can be vicious circles - insulin resistance /poor blood sugar control 'crashes' can make someone feel they need to eat -> weight gain, worse insulin resistance, harder to exercise.....that sort of thing.

Mumaway · 26/12/2023 15:43

Food is driving the weight gain. It is the rare case where an endocrine disorder truly drives it. Spare the endocrinologists.

EllaPaella · 26/12/2023 15:42

bellac11 · 25/12/2023 14:12

Do people in the UK have more hormonal issues/weight gain caused by medication/under active thyroids than people in other countries?

America, UK and Australia (and a few others) have the highest levels of obesity and we also eat the worst diets, overly processed and food freely available.

Coincidence?

I have autoimmune underactive thyroid. I didn't gain a lot of extra weight, when I started treatment I was probably just under a stone over what I had consistently been throughout my 20's and 30's. You wouldn't have looked at me and thought I was overweight. It took two years to get prescribed the appropriate dose of levothyroxine and get my TSH to the right levels and then I quickly lost that extra weight within about 3 months. So yes, my thyroid dysfunction did play a part in gaining weight but in my experience it was only a small amount. That may be totally different for others though. I also agree with a PP who said that if you have an underactive thyroid you would have other symptoms, not isolated weight gain.

Christmassss · 26/12/2023 15:40

A few cubes of cheese when hungry may seem silly but it’s useable fats that satiate you. Instead we’re fed low fat shite rammed with carbs we can’t burn and we crave more.

I agree with this, I now snack on cheese, nuts or I fry an egg. I avoid the rubbish carbs and the even nastier diet fizzy drinks.

TwentyThreeFifteen · 26/12/2023 15:34

As someone who blamed my weight on my underactive thyroid for years, it turns out that it was just simple over eating.

Once I got to grips with needing far few calories I lost over 3 stone. I’m thinner post menopause than I was as a slim 20 year old.

Movinghouseatlast · 26/12/2023 15:27

Some women put on weight due to menopause, some don't.

I put on 3 and a half stone during perimenopause. I was going to the gym 5 times a week doing exactly the same intensity of exercise as before, I was eating healthily as I did before. In my case it was oestrogen depletion thst caused my weight gain. My metabolism changed. I can only eat 1200 calories a day to .
maintain my weight these days.

A menopause specialist explained that my body was desperate for oestrogen so creates fat which contains it.

PalePurplePumpkin · 26/12/2023 15:17

Many of my friends of the same/similar age are overweight/obese but do very little exercise and eat too many cakes/biscuits/fatty foods or drink far too much alcohol.

Same and they've been like that most of their adult lives, except now they're putting it down to 'inevitable weight gain' due to menopause 🤷‍♂️

ohtowinthelottery · 26/12/2023 15:12

Whilst the change in hormones due to the menopause is partly responsible for some weight gain and redistribution of fat, and some people have underactive thyroid or PCOS, for the majority their weight problem is down to the fact that they do very little/no proper exercise and they eat/drink too much. I'm pushing 60 and just outside a healthy BMI - something that has only happened with the menopause but I exercise 3 or 4 times a week and eat mostly healthy food. Many of my friends of the same/similar age are overweight/obese but do very little exercise and eat too many cakes/biscuits/fatty foods or drink far too much alcohol. So I doubt an endocrinologist could help them. They need to sort out the issues that cause them to eat too many calories and stop them from exercising.

lljkk · 26/12/2023 14:59

It's estimated that approximately 12% of Americans have a thyroid disorder.

Did people in 1920s-1950s America not get thyroid disorders, or much less often? Why were Americans much more slender then? Changing ethnic composition, maybe? But then why are the whitest Americans (flyover states) the biggest people on average?

Which lifestyle changes since 1950s led to more thyroid disorders in Americans? Do Mormons get more obesity than people in Colorado? Why are people in OK so much fatter than people in CO? DC is notoriously one of the poorest most deprived populations in USA, yet self-reported least fat.

AIBU Endocrinologists are the real solution to weight loss?
PortiaWithNoBreaks · 25/12/2023 17:09

Furthermore, thick midsection is not the preserve of menopausal women given the high % of women who are overweight or obese pre menopause who have no waist either.

Preworkouttingle · 25/12/2023 17:08

Hormones play a small part. Reality is we are very lazy in modern society. A lot of women my age in the gym, weight training and cardio (I’m a boxer) and none of us are fat. 90% of it is diet and exercise levels. Sugar is in EVERYTHING and it makes you hungry. A few cubes of cheese when hungry may seem silly but it’s useable fats that satiate you. Instead we’re fed low fat shite rammed with carbs we can’t burn and we crave more. I think we need to take the sting out of the words “greedy” and “lazy” as it’s not the fault of the individual, it’s how society has been steered. Less downtime for exercise, more healthy food that’s designed to keep you eating, and no health care in place freely available to educate. Just my thoughts.

PortiaWithNoBreaks · 25/12/2023 17:05

noyodo · 25/12/2023 13:26

For instance belly fat due to menopause is la biological process so that you lose your waist to show men that you are no longer fertile. Hence, it is hormonal it driven weight gain.

Oestrogen plays a key role in where fat is stored in women. When oestrogen levels start falling, fat is more likely to be stored around the middle than the hips. Plus, fat cells themselves produce small amounts of oestrogen.

ErrolTheRednosedDragon · 25/12/2023 17:05

What's is the man's excuse?

Maybe decreasing testosterone?
But men can of course have some of the same endocrine problems as women - hypothyroidism, insulin resistance.

WavingCatsandDogs · 25/12/2023 17:03

Christmassss · 25/12/2023 16:40

I’m 54 and have lost two and three quarter stone since July by cutting down on carbs.

Carbs do cause insulin spikes or something like that, which causes weight gain. Hopefully somebody more knowledgeable can explain.

Fiscus · 25/12/2023 16:58

@lljkk, ya, I was very slender as a youth (up until I had babies l, I think I went up to a 24" waist post babies), and then I guess the body changes a bit, I was always broad shouldered and thin-hipped though.

There are certainly endocrinological reasons for weight gain in many people, it's not as simple as food in - food out.

I've always been pretty slender and there's nothing particularly exceptional or virtuous about my behaviour compared to my more sturdily built contemporaries, certainly height helps, but 50-odd years of observation tells me that there's more to weight than a very simple explanation

DysonSphere · 25/12/2023 16:50

If your thyroid medication levels and hormones levels are right you will not need to skip normal meals to maintain your weight. I do not skip meals now my medication levels are correct (i.e. not just what a lab test says but what my body shows me it needs)

There's also a theory that not eating in the morning is detrimental to your cortisol levels and puts the body into starvation mode (where it then down regulates your metabolism because it thinks there's a scarcity of food)

Cholesterol is high in people with hashimotos because the metabolism is often down regulated, there is inflammation (antibodies to your own thyroid tissue) and most importantly your body makes steroid hormones from your cholesterol, and isn't getting enough so raises it. The queen of hormones pregnenolone is made from your cholesterol, so aiming to get it low if you are not adequately treated isn't necessarily something to aim for in and of itself. Once adequately treated it should and often does come down naturally. In the past your cholesterol levels was one of the markers doctors measured to see how well your treatment was progressing. Sad to say that knowledge has disappeared with the development of thyroid lab testing, which is held up to the detriment of ongoing symptoms.

That said everyone has to do what they think is best. There's an ongoing debate about whether intermittent fasting for e.g. is helpful or not, some say it's helpful for inflammation some say no...cardio exercise is good or not etc etc etc...theres always controversy!

IVbumble · 25/12/2023 16:41

It can be difficult to work out how little we need to eat particularly in relation to portion size.

I had polycystic ovaries, early menopause aged 40 & am currently on medication for nerve pain a side effect of which can be weight gain. I did put on weight until I started the 16/8 fasting plan of eating.

I lost a stone between October & December in 2022 and another half stone by Feb 2023. I do eat 'treats' from time to time but maintain the fasting 90% of the time otherwise I know that weight would just go back on.

Christmassss · 25/12/2023 16:40

I’m 54 and have lost two and three quarter stone since July by cutting down on carbs.

WavingCatsandDogs · 25/12/2023 16:40

noyodo · 25/12/2023 13:26

For instance belly fat due to menopause is la biological process so that you lose your waist to show men that you are no longer fertile. Hence, it is hormonal it driven weight gain.

Interesting!

What's is the man's excuse? 😆

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/12/2023 16:38

gotomomo · 25/12/2023 16:16

The vast majority of people with excess weight have it due to eating to much, the only solution is to eat less. You don't need a dr to tell you this. A combination of a better diet and less overall is the solution

It's estimated that approximately 12% of Americans have a thyroid disorder. That's 20 million people. It's not an insignificant number by any means.

And of course this is only one disorder that affects weight. There are countless others. And indeed medication often causes weight gain.

Rocksonabeach · 25/12/2023 16:27

My thyroid has failed. The only diet that works for me is tiny meals x2, no carbs, soup that’s it

gotomomo · 25/12/2023 16:16

The vast majority of people with excess weight have it due to eating to much, the only solution is to eat less. You don't need a dr to tell you this. A combination of a better diet and less overall is the solution

lljkk · 25/12/2023 16:14

5'9" with a 22" waist? wow.

If endocrinology is the solution, then does that mean that people who never got fat in spite of no / almost no medication, had magically good endocrinology numbers? I'm struggling to buy that. The people I know age 60+ who are not fat are very conscious about daily getting what exercise they can do comfortably ... and portion control.

Friend almost 40yo, lovely person, struggles with obesity, openly owns that she just plain eats too much. No hormone blame required.

CoatOfArms · 25/12/2023 16:01

GreigeO · 25/12/2023 15:56

What is an endocrinologist?

https://letmegooglethat.com/

educatingrati · 25/12/2023 16:01

I think we massively ignore hormones to our detriment; not just in terms of weight, but behaviour too. Depression, anger, fatigue, motivation....I'm sure all of the emotions are much more locked up in hormones, than anything else.