Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal grandparent gifts

278 replies

JustAMinutePleass · 25/12/2023 10:51

I have an only child. My siblings have 2-3 kids a piece. Just found out my parents set a £30 budget for my child’s present and bought £300 pianos as a ‘shared gift’ for each set of gc for each sibling. I asked why my son didn’t also get a piano (or even a larger budget equal to a proportion of the others) when he’s the only one of their 6 gc actually learning the piano and was told I was ungrateful.

I’m so, so pissed off. Bear in mind I’m hosting christmas as I’ve done for years. Aibu to kick them all out and call it a day?

OP posts:
payens · 27/12/2023 11:57

Lifeasiknowitisout · 25/12/2023 11:12

So nobody wanted a piano.

Pianos are really crap gifts if you don’t want one. Focus less on the cost. And more on the actual gift.

Was your son’s gift something he wanted?

I do disagree that your child should get more because you are hosting. If you don’t want to host, don’t. If you can’t afford it. Don’t do it. I wouldn’t. But that doesn’t mean your kids should get bigger presents.

Assuming there’s a back story of similar behaviour here, you should have, already, stopped hosting.

If there’s no back story and you usually all get one, you might need to have think about it more there will be a reason

She didn't say her child should get more because she hosts, she wants the children to be treated equally. What's wrong with that. The grandparents ABVU.

Drfosters · 27/12/2023 09:56

@Teenagehorrorbag what would you think though if there are 2 families and one has 2 children so £60 spend but the other family has 6 children so £180 spend. The first set of children are going to notice that grandparents lavish a lot of money on their cousins than they ever do on them. Not all cousins are wonderfully close and they do notice.

@Messyhair321 could the difference between the way your parents treat your children just be a product of how many grandchildren that have? My in laws have 12 grandchildren in total. Mine are the eldest. Over the years I have seen the amount of love and attention decline because as the numbers increased the GP tried to be equal and that has been an eternal source of upset. Perhaps your parents wanted to preserve the strong relationship they had with the eldest and rather than dilute that relationship. Might seem unfair to you but having been on the other side of things I can tell you having lots of attention and love from GP and then having it reduced to a gift card at Xmas and birthdays as they don’t have the time to search for individual presents is a bit upsetting.

Doodlesplodge17 · 27/12/2023 09:51

Oh I’ve told her, don’t worry, she just doesn’t care.
we more than make it up to them though.

Emotionalsupportviper · 27/12/2023 09:18

Doodlesplodge17 · 27/12/2023 08:42

My sisters kids and step kids were rigged out with clothes, accessories and expensive Lego sets, my kids got £25 and 10 minutes of their Nans time yesterday, I feel your pain, the unfairness is awful and very noticeable by my children this year, it’s so sad for them 😢

It is awful for them (70 years ago I was the "neglected" child). It destroys confidence and self-esteem.

TBH, I ended up despising that particular grandmother - and I still can't forgive my parents for allowing it . They were well aware of the disparity, and would often say how unfair it was that she favoured the others and ignored me, but never said a word to her.

vickylou78 · 27/12/2023 09:16

Are the other grandchildren older? As in our family we have naturally spent less on the children when they are younger and happy with a large plastic toy. But as they get older more specific and expensive gifts are more likely. But it all evens out over the years.

Ie. What I'm wondering is is that it may be likely all the other children also had a £30 budget when they were 4?
Or Do they always have hundreds spent on them?
And your dc may have a year later on where they have something more expensive as a one off for something very specific.
I think I would've just had a chat about this rather than having a big fall out.

Doodlesplodge17 · 27/12/2023 08:42

My sisters kids and step kids were rigged out with clothes, accessories and expensive Lego sets, my kids got £25 and 10 minutes of their Nans time yesterday, I feel your pain, the unfairness is awful and very noticeable by my children this year, it’s so sad for them 😢

Soontobe60 · 27/12/2023 06:45

Boysnme · 26/12/2023 19:59

It’s easy to spend £500 on Xmas dinner for 15 people if you are providing all food and drink.

I do it almost every year - I spend maybe £200 including drinks.

Gillypie23 · 27/12/2023 06:07

I don't think your child should get more spent on them because you host. I do agree should have same amount as cousins.

Lollipopsicle · 27/12/2023 04:45

Well done for telling them to go OP. It’s nice to see someone with a backbone on MN for a change. I’d like to think your siblings not only stuck around but stood up for you as well. Don’t ever host your parents again.

AliceOlive · 27/12/2023 03:40

Can you share your samosa recipes?

Sceptre86 · 27/12/2023 01:18

The biggest issue is them treating you unfairly as a child and now doing the same to your child. My wonderful father in law used to have a saying that God keep away anyone who meant him ill. I make the same prayer/wish. You have a choice as to whether you allow this or not, do not allow it. Your child deserves better and if you have to go lc or nc then be it.

I made samosas for Christmas too, we had to cancel hosting as I'm ill but my freezer is well stocked.

Teenagehorrorbag · 26/12/2023 23:43

I think its tricky working out present budgets but would generally think GPs should buy per child not per family. So £30 per child would be a total of 90 for one of your siblings families and 60 for the other (while being 30 for your DC).

Between siblings it's harder and maybe each family should spend the same amount per other siblings' children? Otherwise sibling A with one child spends more on sibling Bs family if they have several, etc. But I think it should be discussed and agreed up front.

In your case it seems your DPs have gone way above for your siblings, but are their children older? As PPs have said, maybe 4 is too young for them to want to give a piano? (And if you need one now, get an electronic keyboard. Ours was free from freecycle but they aren't silly money, take up less space and don't need tuning....).

Messyhair321 · 26/12/2023 23:40

I'd be pissed right off about this. I get it too, my children were (&are as adults) treated differently by the same grandparents, my parents are just weird & lavish gifts onto my older two (my children are all now adults but they've always done it), & my youngest they barely notice. I'd be surprised if they even know when his birthday is.
It's very unfair & I'd be furious. So you think they believe that your child is ok in some way that the others aren't? No excuse for treating them differently whatever but that's the only thing I can think.

I'd definitely have to say something like "why are you treating your grandchildren differently from each other?" They'll notice as they get older won't they?

fatimashortbread · 26/12/2023 21:41

Your child shouldn’t necessarily get more but they should get the same or similar

Lollypop701 · 26/12/2023 21:24

op you’re doing fine… you’ve told them you find their attitude disrespectful. Siblings agree . Keep it up!

vickidoodah · 26/12/2023 21:23

Really? This is your take from this? Odd …

vickidoodah · 26/12/2023 21:22

really? This is your take from this? Odd…

PorpoiseWithPurpose · 26/12/2023 20:55

My son got a single toy worth £30 and even that was given begrudingly.

How was it given begrudgingly?
Did they toss it at him?!!

Boysnme · 26/12/2023 19:59

Soontobe60 · 26/12/2023 06:34

I wonder how old your nephews and nieces are. I think the biggest mistake you’re making is that you’re placing monetary values on gifts. You’re clearly forgetting what Christmas is all about.
I bet your piano-playing 4 year old was really happy you took his present off him and threw his grandparents out with it. And who on earth spends £500 on cooking for a few people?

It’s easy to spend £500 on Xmas dinner for 15 people if you are providing all food and drink.

Juststopamoment · 26/12/2023 19:49

Don't host again! Sounds to me like they take advantage of you? Are you the eldest?

Devondumplin20 · 26/12/2023 19:26

Just saw the update so deleted my earlier post

fetchacloth · 26/12/2023 18:59

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/12/2023 10:14

TBH - I think I'd sooner buy my child a piano than spent FIVE HUNDRED POUNDS hosting an ungrateful family.

Same here.
No way would I be offering to host again, or be guilt tripped into it.

GotMooMilk · 26/12/2023 18:32

The fact that your siblings sided with you is great and shows they understand and can see your point. If they really wanted to support you they should speak to your parents and even return the pianos (appreciate this is tricky as gifted to the kids so can understand why they wouldn’t/couldn’t but still).

mandlerparr · 26/12/2023 18:31

if it will make you feel better, the other kids gifts may have cost more, but they don't seem like they put much thought into those gifts either. I mean, they got them the exact same gifts, that they have to share, that odds are will not be used for more than a month. I was wondering if they were doing it because you only have the one child and that seems to be the truth.
Stay strong and don't host.

EerieSilence · 26/12/2023 18:27

Christmasisspecial · 26/12/2023 06:26

Sorry OP, your update changes my vote. This really isn't about your fertility. Please say your tantrum was away from the children. Do you often have tantrums like this on special occasions? Christmas day? You've blown this way out of proportion.

You mean that she called up her parents publicly on their double standards? That’s a tantrum? No, that’s her not being a doormat.
Well done, OP.