Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this pregnancy discrimination?

83 replies

bexboz · 24/12/2023 20:15

My friends (two women in a same sex marriage) were telling me this. Let's call them A and B. They are having fertility treatment at a private clinic. They both want to carry a child. They started with A but had lots of issues and struggles and it has taken several years. In the meantime they decided B should get pregnant, she did with the first round of IUI and is currently about 8 months pregnant. They also decided to continue with A's fertility treatment as they feel like they are running out of time and even if she did get pregnant now, they would be ok with having two babies spaced so close together (for them, better than risking A not getting the chance to carry). Ok so that's their choice - that decision isn't what this post is about....

The discrimination question is about their fertility clinic which has a policy of not allowing babies and pregnant women into the waiting room because it can be upsetting for the other patients. I totally get this, it must be so hard to see. But at the same time it means that A can't have B there ---- - her WIFE - while she goes through all these procedures. It's already so stressful, but B isn't allowed to be there as she is visibly pregnant.

Maternity is a protected characteristic like race etc- it wouldn't be ok so say "no you can't come in because you are gay/trans/asian/ Jewish" so why can they say "no you can't come because you are pregnant" ?

AIBU to think it's really unfair?

OP posts:
Rosiiee · 25/12/2023 11:13

I wouldn’t say it’s discrimation no. I’ve had multiple miscarriages and twice have had to be admitted for surgical management. Both times I had to wait in the waiting room with pregnant women which honestly sucked so bad but the ward staff was kind enough to put me in a single room.

It’s a bit tricky that she’s the wife though and the woman going through fertility treatment should be able to have a support person there. Maybe the clinic could offer a special arrangement like a different waiting area/sneaking her in through the back door. I can see both sides.

KombuchaKalling · 25/12/2023 11:12

ManateeFair · 25/12/2023 11:06

Pregnancy is a protected characteristic but as with all protected characteristics, there are still circumstances where it’s allowable to refuse certain things. This would be one of them.

I don’t really see why A actually needs B there for this, pregnant or not.

(I also think the idea that it’s essential for them both to give birth to children is a bit weird, as it suggests more of an interest in pregnancy than in actual parenthood, but that’s another conversation.)

I’m also intrigued on how they would cope with 2 under 2. I have 8 month old twins so know first hand how hard it is 🤣

ManateeFair · 25/12/2023 11:06

Pregnancy is a protected characteristic but as with all protected characteristics, there are still circumstances where it’s allowable to refuse certain things. This would be one of them.

I don’t really see why A actually needs B there for this, pregnant or not.

(I also think the idea that it’s essential for them both to give birth to children is a bit weird, as it suggests more of an interest in pregnancy than in actual parenthood, but that’s another conversation.)

Floralnomad · 25/12/2023 10:59

It’s not discrimination , it’s their rules . A can take someone else with her .

Treefusis · 25/12/2023 10:57

festivepains · 25/12/2023 05:13

I think they could argue health and safety some how.

If you read that link you will see that you can refuse access or services to pregnant women for THEIR health/safety (for example refuse to allow them on a rollercoaster)- you can’t refuse in case someone else’s feelings are hurt.

festivepains · 25/12/2023 05:13

I think they could argue health and safety some how.

PeloMom · 25/12/2023 05:03

In the clinic I went they had morning slots for pregnant women and afternoon for fertility treatments for the same reason; if that’s the case can they move A’s appointments to times they see pregnant women?

Porridgeislife · 25/12/2023 01:37

My husband wasn’t allowed to attend any appointments with me in 2020-21 when I was having countless rounds of IVF and I coped - as we all did during that time.

Porridgeislife · 25/12/2023 01:36

They’re free to take their fertility clinic to court to prove their rights if they like.

LoreleiG · 25/12/2023 01:23

Amazed at how many legal experts there are on here. No idea but I’d just think ‘fair enough’ if I were the couple.

endofthelinefinally · 25/12/2023 01:16

Sometimes you have to put other people's needs before your own wants. When I was having my dc, husbands didn't get time off work for anything pregnancy related. Paternity leave was 2 weeks. My mum came and sat with me when I was miscarrying my first pregnancy.
Lots of women went through labour without their partner, especially if they were in the forces.
I am not saying it was better, just that it was the way it was.
I had to sit in a queue with lots of visibly pregnant women while I waited for my scan, knowing that I was miscarrying. That was very distressing.

WithACatLikeTread · 25/12/2023 00:59

I had to attend IVF appointments alone as we have no childcare. Plenty in the same position. Rather that than not having been successful and still despairing. They are going to have to manage.

KombuchaKalling · 24/12/2023 23:55

Yesididntdothat · 24/12/2023 23:51

How do you get a baby sitter for a baby that's inside you?

🤣 excellent question

Yesididntdothat · 24/12/2023 23:51

momsybear · 24/12/2023 23:42

Not discrimination. They need a babysitter. Kids shouldn't be at diagnostic screenings and plenty of us went thru multiple scans alone during Covid without a partner by our sides. Not ideal, often terrifying but being a parent is doing what you have to

How do you get a baby sitter for a baby that's inside you?

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/12/2023 23:44

Whilst I can see the point you’re trying to make, I think the clinic’s attempts to consider the emotional wellbeing of their clients is a good thing.

Whilst trying to conceive I had to have a number of gynae/fertility tests, appointments etc (NHS) and had to attend them all in the same maternity clinic and waiting area as pregnant women/new mums.

Whilst I understood this was what it was and didn’t take offence, this did make me feel uncomfortable at times, especially as some appointments were to find out if I could even conceive at all. It would have been much more comforting to have had them elsewhere, I think this is what the private clinic are trying to avoid.

momsybear · 24/12/2023 23:42

Not discrimination. They need a babysitter. Kids shouldn't be at diagnostic screenings and plenty of us went thru multiple scans alone during Covid without a partner by our sides. Not ideal, often terrifying but being a parent is doing what you have to

Treefusis · 24/12/2023 23:36

Teder · 24/12/2023 23:13

YABU.

There are situations where you can lawfully discriminate for example; seeking a female only domestic abuse support worker. You can positivity discriminate when seeking to employ a disabled person with lived experience as a peer support worker.

Additionally, given their fertility struggles, you’d think they’d be a tad more sensitive to others who are not as fortunate to be as far along as a pregnancy. Perhaps their memories are short!

I don’t think this situation fits any of the criteria for permissible discrimination.

Id just use a different clinic if I were them, it’s not worth the hassle.

KombuchaKalling · 24/12/2023 23:34

colourfulchinadolls · 24/12/2023 20:45

Yabu.

Your friends aren't infertile or struggling to get pregnant in a heterosexual relationship. They're wanting fertility treatment when one of them is already pregnant due to this being easier for them timings wise. You're being so unreasonable.

They should think themselves lucky that one of them is pregnant.

Well, yeah. The elephant in the room is they don’t have fertility problems technically. I remember being told “l wasn’t trying hard enough and needed to persevere more” by a female married to a woman, who had already got 1 child from
IVF and subsequently had another. Hmmm ok. We had actual real fertility problems, her pep talk was tone deaf and condescending

Teder · 24/12/2023 23:13

YABU.

There are situations where you can lawfully discriminate for example; seeking a female only domestic abuse support worker. You can positivity discriminate when seeking to employ a disabled person with lived experience as a peer support worker.

Additionally, given their fertility struggles, you’d think they’d be a tad more sensitive to others who are not as fortunate to be as far along as a pregnancy. Perhaps their memories are short!

Treefusis · 24/12/2023 23:10

SuspiciousSue · 24/12/2023 23:06

YABU and what’s it got to do with you? Are you actually one of the wives and not a friend? They’ve chosen to be in a same sex marriage and, unfortunately, this means that this rule applies to them you. It can be very upsetting for infertile women to see pregnant women so it’s best to think of their feelings too. Not discrimination.

Chosen to be in a same sex marriage? Like they just got up one morning and decided to be gay?!

UnWilly · 24/12/2023 23:06

Having a protected characteristic doesn't mean you get to do anything anytime anywhere just because

Although there are pregnant women everywhere that women having fertility treatment will see, I think that it will be particularly raw for them while having treatment.

If she needs support at the appointment can a friend or family member not accompany her?

Sounds reasonably balanced and proportionate to me

SuspiciousSue · 24/12/2023 23:06

YABU and what’s it got to do with you? Are you actually one of the wives and not a friend? They’ve chosen to be in a same sex marriage and, unfortunately, this means that this rule applies to them you. It can be very upsetting for infertile women to see pregnant women so it’s best to think of their feelings too. Not discrimination.

Brefugee · 24/12/2023 23:03

Illegal or not - one of them has been through the heartbreak of it not working. And now wants to shove her wife's pregnancy in the face of other women going through the same? with zero consideration of their feelings?

Solidarity? Nope. They need to get, as pp said, their heads out of their arses and stop being babies about it.

Tinkerbyebye · 24/12/2023 23:00

YANBU. And I would have expected A who has had all these issues to be more understanding about why her wife can’t be be there at 8 months pregnant

no it’s not discrimination it’s how the clinic works

Treefusis · 24/12/2023 22:59

WorriedMum231 · 24/12/2023 22:49

A lot of the responses are people throwing their opinion in and not actually answering the question. If pregnancy is a protected characteristic then yes, it is discrimination.

Also, there’s pregnant women every where, so it seems a bit unnecessary.

Very good point.

Yes, it seems the clinic is acting illegally.

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/law-and-courts/discrimination/check-what-type-of-discrimination-youve-experienced/pregnancy-and-maternity-discrimination/

Pregnancy and maternity discrimination

Pregnancy and maternity discrimination at work and outside work, and what counts as unfavourable treatment.

https://www.citizensadvice.org.uk/law-and-courts/discrimination/check-what-type-of-discrimination-youve-experienced/pregnancy-and-maternity-discrimination/

Swipe left for the next trending thread