Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU my sister thinks I should call become I come

136 replies

sistersneighbours · 24/12/2023 19:14

My sister and I are neighbours and really close I’ve just moved here in august so this is the first time we’re living this close. My sister expects that I call her and let her know or ask if I can pop in with the kids. I have three children, and she has 2 twin girls aged 5 and a boy.

When we are at her house, I can tell she find it’s hard with all the kids together in one place, her girls are really demanding and difficult, they’re running around screaming all the time, and I think that combined with all the people in the house makes my sister overstimulated, she can’t handle the noise. My kids are older and don’t run around like that.

There have been a few times where we’ve been at hers for a few hours and she said out loud “ I think its time for you guys to go home”, when she’s ill I have offered to come round, clean and cook and help with the kids. She always says no because I will bring my children and “it will be too much”, when she needs childcare I have offered and she says no again for the same reason and asks someone else even though we literally live next to each other.

I have offered her to bring her kids to my house, and she says no because she knows her girls will fight and it will be be chaos.

I moved here to be close to her and her kids, help each other etc.. we can go a whole week without seeing each other and I never expected this living so close to each other. Example : she lives at 35 and I live at 37.

OP posts:
Globules · 25/12/2023 09:39

I still live a 10 min drive from her @sistersneighbours I see her about once every 3 months for a couple of hours. It's always planned 3+ weeks in advance. I leave her to plan it, as she doesn't like my way of doing things, nor has tried to adapt to meeting me halfway, so it's all organised her way.

We have a great time when we do get together, but we saw each other more when we lived 2 hours apart.

AngelinaFibres · 25/12/2023 09:38

Your sister is frantically pushing back because you aren't respecting anything she says. No one ever comes to my house unannounced. I would never go anywhere without texting first. I was a single parent for many years. My eldest son would become over excited and manic if lots of people came at once. It was exhausting at the time and it took hours for him to come down again. Listen to her. She has told you what she and her children can cope with. LISTEN.

BettyPhuckzer · 25/12/2023 09:24

Namechange4234 · 25/12/2023 07:04

Why don't you have her 3 kids at yours to give her a break?

This ^

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 09:13

When I'm on the phone to my mum, she asks me if I'm at my sisters house, and if I tell her I'm at my own house " one time too many" she will ask me " don't you guys see each other" so sometimes I lie and say we saw each other yesterday Blush

OP posts:
SEG152 · 25/12/2023 09:09

You are being unreasonable. Sending a text asking if it’s a good time to pop round is a perfectly reasonable request.

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 09:07

Honestly only MN people will dislike it if you help with their housework, don't know anyone in real life who would be happy if I do their dishes 😂. It's like I just come in and start cleaning, for instance my sister left last week to do some shopping, her house was a mess. And instead of sitting there in a messy house until she came back, I started cleaning the kitchen so it was ready for when she got back with the shopping. And she was happy and really appreciated it.

And I wouldn't just pop in if it was a friends house, but given that we're sisters and neighbours I thought there would be an open door policy, I would be happy for her to pop in whenever she want. But she's not like that, and that's okay.

I've realised that living so close to each other is not really a good idea, we've had arguments about other stuff aswell. I should just have listened to my brothers advice when he warned me about moving next door to her.

One time when my kids were at their dads house, I texted her around 4pm that I would pop in later, she didn't reply. I got to her house around 7pm ish, and she got angry and asked me why didn't I tell the EXACT time I was coming around and not just "later" . I never expected this kind of hostility tbh .

@Globules I'm curious to know how is your relationship with your sister now? Do you still live close to her?

OP posts:
gotomomo · 25/12/2023 08:47

I can't believe anyone turns up at someone's house without calling first! Of course ask

AndyPandyismyhero · 25/12/2023 08:45

I hate it when people 'pop in' and I don't do it to anyone. I prefer a quick call first, even if it's to say 'we are in the area, can we call in?' I live literally a two minute walk from ds and sil. I still call before going round. I have a key to their home. I wouldn't dream of using it without express permission. I also don't just take it upon myself to do their housework - I always ask if I can help at all, but if they say no, then I concentrate on spending time with the dgcs, giving ds and Dil the opportunity to do their own housework knowing the dgcs are safely occupied.
My dsis is like you, open door policy, happy for people to call in without notice and like you, she doesn't seem to understand that we are not all the same. We don't see each other very much.

MintJulia · 25/12/2023 08:30

Why not just call first, as she asks? That is the obvious answer.

Poor love sounds very stressed.

AlwaysGinPlease · 25/12/2023 08:26

The very thought of someone just turning up makes me feel annoyed. Of course you should call.

Globules · 25/12/2023 08:14

People who just pop round don't get that people have life's and might have other stuff to do and can't spend most of their day with them, if you have been there hours and she's telling you to go home you have been their too long.

I find this very sad @Tattletwat I'm a popper inner. 10 years ago I was part of a group of popper inners. Why on earth would you think that us popper inners don't understand people have lives and other stuff to do?

I found it a wonderful surprise to open the door to a friend (and sometimes their children too). If I had somewhere to go, I'd tell them. If I could spare them an hour, I'd tell them. If they were very welcome to stay most of the day, I'd tell them.

One memorable Saturday, I already had a planned morning playdate of mum and two children round my house. Kids were happily playing. A couple turned up for a cuppa unexpectedly about 20 mins before the other family were going to leave. One thing led to another, and I ended up feeding 4 children and 5 adults cheese on toast for lunch. We sat chatting and playing until about 4pm. It was grand.

I'd have felt comfortable telling all the people in the room that it was time to leave if I'd needed to. Even if I had told them, it may not have meant they'd been there too long. Part of the popping in culture is that you're happy to see someone for a short time rather than not at all.

I truly understand my wonderful afternoon sounds like the idea of hell to many of the posters on this thread. But for me, and people like @sistersneighbours , it's wonderful and it works. Popping in is a fabulous way to maintain real relationships imo. I don't accuse and judge those who disagree with me, like some posts on this thread are.

JussathoB · 25/12/2023 07:40

@Poppyseason love your post, you talk sense it seems to me.
OP, please be prepared to compromise and make some adjustments to when/ how you meet with your sister. You want to play the long game don’t you? As the children grow up and needs change, different activities etc will work well so approach this considerately. Then all of you can benefit in the short and long term.

Namechange4234 · 25/12/2023 07:04

Why don't you have her 3 kids at yours to give her a break?

miniatureroses · 25/12/2023 06:58

You both clearly want different things. Maybe she feels you being so available has disrupted the routine and life she had built and got used to? I couldn't handle this. Check if it suits her for you to go over and stay shorter. She might be wanting to do something and finds she can't because you're there.

crumblingschools · 25/12/2023 06:37

I expect the reality is very different to the fantasy you both had when moving closer was first discussed.

Maybe, easier once the children are older and slightly more independent.

How far away are the rest of your family?

Esmerelda2024 · 25/12/2023 06:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Just1MoreMinute · 25/12/2023 06:22

You need to respect her boundaries. I’m sure you’d expect her to respect yours too.

PralinaChocs · 25/12/2023 06:20

Are you more of an extrovert than she is OP? My sister loves having people pop in and stay for chunks of the day. She gets energy from being around other people - it recharges her batteries and helps her feel calm and happy.

I'm completely the opposite. I need a full battery in order to want to have people around, no matter how much I love them. And then I enjoy their company for a while, and then my battery is drained by the social interaction, and I need them to go so I can recharge with alone time. People coming over unexpectedly and staying for hours is deeply unwelcome, even if they are people I love, because it disrupts all my plans and I'll be exhausted for ages afterwards.

I now limit and put very clear boundaries around visits from people who are likely to stay for hours to try to avoid that outcome.

AGoingConcern · 25/12/2023 06:03

I think you’ve gotten the message that YABU so I won’t belabor that point.

It seems like you’re interpreting your sister setting clear boundaries (call first, keep visits short, say goodbye when things have gotten overwhelming) as her pushing you away. My suggestion is to reframe this as your sister telling you how you can spend time together that will actually feel enjoyable & leave her looking forward to the next visit.

Respecting people’s boundaries fosters better relationships. Being resentful or oblivious to boundaries will ultimately push them away.

Tattletwat · 25/12/2023 05:59

She isn't being unreasonable asking you to call first. She might be busy when you call round.

People who just pop round don't get that people have life's and might have other stuff to do and can't spend most of their day with them, if you have been there hours and she's telling you to go home you have been their too long.

Respect her wishes it's not she doesn't want to see you, it's she wants space too.

Having to host someone all the time is exhausting.

Somepeoplearesnippy · 25/12/2023 05:54

Moving closer to her was a lovely thing to do. It will give your children and their cousins a chance to build a really strong bond independent of your relationship with your sister. Step back and let that happen.

momonpurpose · 25/12/2023 05:42

KateyCuckoo · 24/12/2023 19:18

Yes you need to learn boundaries.

It sounds like maybe you have overstepped

MySecret21 · 25/12/2023 05:18

sistersneighbours · 24/12/2023 19:24

Yes this was her idea, she doesn't live near our family. Her ex partner doesn't really help with childcare, so she's been on her own for a while. and she asked me to move near her so we could help each other and our kids could grow up together.

Your posts make me feel suffocated just reading them!!

There’s a difference between moving closer to someone and moving next door to them!

I absolutely adore my sister but there is no way I would want to live next door to her and have the set-up you seem to have imagined would happen between you and your sister.

If my sister felt she could drop in when she liked for hours on end with her children it would soon become a very very unpleasant situation.

And just the thought of her coming in and doing housework….washing up and hoovering etc, well that horrifies me. It crosses a major line in terms of what is acceptable and appropriate.

YABVVVVVU.

I think you need to take a massive step back otherwise your relationship with your sister is going to end up very damaged.

Santasbeltbuckle · 25/12/2023 05:18

I moved a couple of roads away from my parents once. My mother absolutely took it that it meant she could drop in whenever she wanted at whatever time she wanted. At the time I had a stressful job and would engineer time to WFH when it was a rare perk, only to find she would take my being at home as meaning I was in and available to chat, have coffee at any time, when the reality was I was compressing hours of work into 6 hours so I could do the school run and be there for my DD. I had to put a padlock on my side gate and buy a curtain for the front door because if I didn’t answer the door to her, she would come round the back to check if I was in and if I was ignoring her. I tried to explain my pov to her but she just ended up being offended so ridiculously I ended up taking an office locally so I could work in peace and do the school run.

If you had asked her at the time, I expect she would also think it was odd she should check before coming round. The fact is, if I have made time for myself, I should be able to enjoy it as I see fit, not spend it on activities I don’t want to do. You seem to think your sister needs help, but maybe she is just fine. Maybe she has a point about how her kids react when they interact with yours. You want to be the Waltons when she might not feel the same way. Please listen to what she is saying. You may be piling more stress onto her than you realise or intended to do.

WandaWonder · 25/12/2023 05:12

Just because you have a scenario in your head doesn't mean it will happen, calm down a little and call ahead sounds like the grown up thing to do

Swipe left for the next trending thread