Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU my sister thinks I should call become I come

136 replies

sistersneighbours · 24/12/2023 19:14

My sister and I are neighbours and really close I’ve just moved here in august so this is the first time we’re living this close. My sister expects that I call her and let her know or ask if I can pop in with the kids. I have three children, and she has 2 twin girls aged 5 and a boy.

When we are at her house, I can tell she find it’s hard with all the kids together in one place, her girls are really demanding and difficult, they’re running around screaming all the time, and I think that combined with all the people in the house makes my sister overstimulated, she can’t handle the noise. My kids are older and don’t run around like that.

There have been a few times where we’ve been at hers for a few hours and she said out loud “ I think its time for you guys to go home”, when she’s ill I have offered to come round, clean and cook and help with the kids. She always says no because I will bring my children and “it will be too much”, when she needs childcare I have offered and she says no again for the same reason and asks someone else even though we literally live next to each other.

I have offered her to bring her kids to my house, and she says no because she knows her girls will fight and it will be be chaos.

I moved here to be close to her and her kids, help each other etc.. we can go a whole week without seeing each other and I never expected this living so close to each other. Example : she lives at 35 and I live at 37.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
indianwoman · 25/12/2023 22:37

Why would you stay in her house when she went shopping? Did she go as you wouldn't get the hint and go?

She probably thinks you cleaning her house is criticism that is dirty. I would never clean a family members house unless staying and chip in with helping.

You are obviously over staying your welcome -and she doesn't like it. Go for a coffee in town or invite her over to yours for an hour. Staying for hours in someone's house is just unnecessary.

She's told you what she'd like and you are ignoring her because you don't like it. Well she will fall out with you for good if you don't respect what she's saying to you. Your choice.

GG1986 · 25/12/2023 22:16

Everyone is different, but I hate people(even close friends or family) turning up unannounced! Luckily my sister is the same, so we would always call to check it's OK before going over.

melj1213 · 25/12/2023 21:44

YABU - You seem to think that neighbours = living as one extended household, whereas your sister wants some basic courtesy and boundaries between the two households. You need to sit down with your sister and have an honest conversation as to what your expectations are and what hers are and come to a compromise as to where the boundaries need to be set.

I live literally round the corner from one of my siblings, no more than a 10 minute drive from the other two and 5-15minutes away from 7 of my maternal cousins who all have young children that I regularly babysit for and spend time with socially. I would never ever invite myself over to any of their houses unannounced, even the sibling that lives round the corner gets a quick "I'm on the way home, you in if I stop by for half an hour?" text and I don't stop by unless I get a response in the affirmative. I'd only drop by unannounced if there was an emergency or something was time sensitive which rarely ever happens.

Your sister has asked you to let her know when you want to come round, that is not in any way unreasonable. Nor is it unreasonable for her to not want the same "open door policy" you want and clearly she is having to be explicitly clear as to what that means because if you're as obtuse with her as you are with people on this thread then I have no doubt that she has given you many, many hints that you have ignored.

If one of your children wants to play with one of hers then that does not necessitate your whole family trooping round, it means you text your sister to say "Johnny wants to play with Jimmy, is it ok for him to pop round now? No worries if you're busy" which gives her the choice to say "Yes no problem" or "Actually we're just going out, but we'll be back after 6 if he wants to come over then" or "We're busy today but he can come round any time tomorrow".

Just turning up on her doorstep probably feels too much like she has to justify herself and she's being put on the spot when there's a child standing on the doorstep wanting to play with her own and she doesn't have a good reason beyond "I don't want to right now" especially if she knows that any invite is for your entire family to stay indefinitely unless/until she explicitly says GTFO because you don't take any hints to leave when she clearly doesn't want visitors.

miniatureroses · 25/12/2023 21:35

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 13:09

Yeah I know, I should have listened to him and he even told me I would regret it later. I never expected this kind of distance from someone who've asked me to move near her. I was meant to move anyway, I was meant to move near my mum and other family members. But my sister was the one who suggested I move near her, because we're so close and it would be good for the kids to be around each other. And she lives far from my mum and the rest of the family.

So yeah, I never expected this kind of distance from my sister when she's the one who suggested the move. I thought we would see each other a lot more than we do, and I thought she would have accepted my help. I've been here since august and she's been to my house 3 times, which is weird since we're sisters and neighbours and I do listen to her, and I've haven't seen her for a week because I'm just waiting for her to initiate contact and let me know when she wants to see me.

I never expected things to be like this, but I love my house and love the area, so I'm not going to move.

The thing is, it's not help if it's unwanted. My mother used to do this sort of thing and I really resent it, even now if I think about it. It felt really violating and intrusive and I was supposed to appreciate the 'help' that wasn't even needed. It was really about her need to feel she was helping than about me needing help.

NearlyMonday · 25/12/2023 20:30

You don’t teach your kids that they can just invite yourselves to other people’s houses. If your kids ask to go to someone else’s, you so, ‘no, it’s rude to invite yourself to other people’s house-we can invite them here’.

This

Shinyandnew1 · 25/12/2023 17:36

sistersneighbours · 24/12/2023 19:17

My kids will asks me if they can go to their house and play PS5 with her boy, but I have to say no because I don't know if we're allowed to come and honestly I don't feel like calling and asking if we can come over. I can just tell she doesn't like it when all the kids are together and it's a shame, cuz they're cousins

You don’t teach your kids that they can just invite yourselves to other people’s houses. If your kids ask to go to someone else’s, you so, ‘no, it’s rude to invite yourself to other people’s house-we can invite them here’.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 25/12/2023 17:26

Lots of questions…

Do you ever invite her or kids to yours?
What happens when you call or text?
Do you go over to help with the kids or just send them?
Does she ever call to pop in to yours?

Toddlerteaplease · 25/12/2023 17:19

I love my sister. But would hate to live so close to her. Maybe she's not overly happy you live next door.

Riverstep · 25/12/2023 16:50

I think this is just difference of people. Some dont like visitors turning up unannounced, others aren’t bothered. My parents would find it hilarious if I contacted them to ‘arrange’ a visit, I have always just popped to their house whenever I felt like it and it was the same with my grandparents when they were alive. Everyone else I whatsapp first, including my sister. It isn’t unreasonable of your sister to want a phone call.

pictoosh · 25/12/2023 15:58

"for instance my sister left last week to do some shopping, her house was a mess. And instead of sitting there in a messy house until she came back, I started cleaning the kitchen so it was ready for when she got back with the shopping."

See to me, I think why are you sitting in her house when she's gone out? I'd go home.

momonpurpose · 25/12/2023 14:43

My ex MIL used to come over and clean my house. I absolutely hated it. It made me deel like I was t doing a good enough job. Of course I'd pretend I loved it at the time

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 13:09

Newestname002 · 25/12/2023 10:47

@sistersneighbours

OP You should have heeded your brother's advice and not moved next door to your sister - who sounds stifled by the amount of attention she receives from you. Next door is so close- maybe a few doors down or the next street would have been better: you'd still be close but not in her pockets. Also, if your sister prefers do, please, call and check she's OK for a visit before turn up and don't overstay... 🌹

Yeah I know, I should have listened to him and he even told me I would regret it later. I never expected this kind of distance from someone who've asked me to move near her. I was meant to move anyway, I was meant to move near my mum and other family members. But my sister was the one who suggested I move near her, because we're so close and it would be good for the kids to be around each other. And she lives far from my mum and the rest of the family.

So yeah, I never expected this kind of distance from my sister when she's the one who suggested the move. I thought we would see each other a lot more than we do, and I thought she would have accepted my help. I've been here since august and she's been to my house 3 times, which is weird since we're sisters and neighbours and I do listen to her, and I've haven't seen her for a week because I'm just waiting for her to initiate contact and let me know when she wants to see me.

I never expected things to be like this, but I love my house and love the area, so I'm not going to move.

OP posts:
Tattletwat · 25/12/2023 11:19

Globules · 25/12/2023 11:10

You've completely missed the point. Like I said in my post, I understand other people prefer a call or to prearrange. That's fine and their call. I'm not judging or accusing them of being wrong, like your post and others. I appreciate we're all different. You seem to be unable to do the same without being rude about the difference of opinion.

The day I spoke of was a day of being in the house. No plans were changed. People joined us in that day. We were comfortable enough with each other as a group of popper inners to say no on the doorstep if we didn't want them there. As did people with us if we turned up at theirs. I don't know what is so difficult to understand about that. Just because it's not your way, there's no need to be rude.

I haven't been rude at all reread my post, you are taking it as rude as I don't agree with you, worst I said is I you need some empathy. So no I am not being rude so stop stating I am.

You are assuming people would tell you, when in reality a lot are too polite saying behind closed doors I am sick of these just turning up.

Globules · 25/12/2023 11:10

Tattletwat · 25/12/2023 10:44

Your entire post says why you don't think people have lives as you think it's great to stop what you are doing for someone who just randomly shows up and change and cancel plans.

You might like it and find it wonderful but majority of people don't and have things to do.

If you think it's unreasonable to ask people to call and ask if it is convenient for them then you need to get some empathy.

People might be having a shitty day, mental issues, family issues or just want some privacy and you turning up is last thing they need.

You've completely missed the point. Like I said in my post, I understand other people prefer a call or to prearrange. That's fine and their call. I'm not judging or accusing them of being wrong, like your post and others. I appreciate we're all different. You seem to be unable to do the same without being rude about the difference of opinion.

The day I spoke of was a day of being in the house. No plans were changed. People joined us in that day. We were comfortable enough with each other as a group of popper inners to say no on the doorstep if we didn't want them there. As did people with us if we turned up at theirs. I don't know what is so difficult to understand about that. Just because it's not your way, there's no need to be rude.

PuffyShirt · 25/12/2023 10:58

Assuming this is for real, you sound way too much, OP.

I would absolutely hate this level of attention and find it completely intrusive. Respect her boundaries.

Newestname002 · 25/12/2023 10:47

@sistersneighbours

OP You should have heeded your brother's advice and not moved next door to your sister - who sounds stifled by the amount of attention she receives from you. Next door is so close- maybe a few doors down or the next street would have been better: you'd still be close but not in her pockets. Also, if your sister prefers do, please, call and check she's OK for a visit before turn up and don't overstay... 🌹

ChihuahuaMummy · 25/12/2023 10:46

Did you go into your sister's house to clean without her knowing or were you already there when she went out?

Tattletwat · 25/12/2023 10:44

Globules · 25/12/2023 08:14

People who just pop round don't get that people have life's and might have other stuff to do and can't spend most of their day with them, if you have been there hours and she's telling you to go home you have been their too long.

I find this very sad @Tattletwat I'm a popper inner. 10 years ago I was part of a group of popper inners. Why on earth would you think that us popper inners don't understand people have lives and other stuff to do?

I found it a wonderful surprise to open the door to a friend (and sometimes their children too). If I had somewhere to go, I'd tell them. If I could spare them an hour, I'd tell them. If they were very welcome to stay most of the day, I'd tell them.

One memorable Saturday, I already had a planned morning playdate of mum and two children round my house. Kids were happily playing. A couple turned up for a cuppa unexpectedly about 20 mins before the other family were going to leave. One thing led to another, and I ended up feeding 4 children and 5 adults cheese on toast for lunch. We sat chatting and playing until about 4pm. It was grand.

I'd have felt comfortable telling all the people in the room that it was time to leave if I'd needed to. Even if I had told them, it may not have meant they'd been there too long. Part of the popping in culture is that you're happy to see someone for a short time rather than not at all.

I truly understand my wonderful afternoon sounds like the idea of hell to many of the posters on this thread. But for me, and people like @sistersneighbours , it's wonderful and it works. Popping in is a fabulous way to maintain real relationships imo. I don't accuse and judge those who disagree with me, like some posts on this thread are.

Your entire post says why you don't think people have lives as you think it's great to stop what you are doing for someone who just randomly shows up and change and cancel plans.

You might like it and find it wonderful but majority of people don't and have things to do.

If you think it's unreasonable to ask people to call and ask if it is convenient for them then you need to get some empathy.

People might be having a shitty day, mental issues, family issues or just want some privacy and you turning up is last thing they need.

BlastedPimples · 25/12/2023 10:40

Did you and your sister discuss your moving so nearby?

feathermucker · 25/12/2023 10:30

Listen to her. I get overstimulated sometimes and it's really unpleasant to live with. Respect her boundaries and you'll find you have a much better relationship.

Eekmystro · 25/12/2023 10:20

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 09:07

Honestly only MN people will dislike it if you help with their housework, don't know anyone in real life who would be happy if I do their dishes 😂. It's like I just come in and start cleaning, for instance my sister left last week to do some shopping, her house was a mess. And instead of sitting there in a messy house until she came back, I started cleaning the kitchen so it was ready for when she got back with the shopping. And she was happy and really appreciated it.

And I wouldn't just pop in if it was a friends house, but given that we're sisters and neighbours I thought there would be an open door policy, I would be happy for her to pop in whenever she want. But she's not like that, and that's okay.

I've realised that living so close to each other is not really a good idea, we've had arguments about other stuff aswell. I should just have listened to my brothers advice when he warned me about moving next door to her.

One time when my kids were at their dads house, I texted her around 4pm that I would pop in later, she didn't reply. I got to her house around 7pm ish, and she got angry and asked me why didn't I tell the EXACT time I was coming around and not just "later" . I never expected this kind of hostility tbh .

@Globules I'm curious to know how is your relationship with your sister now? Do you still live close to her?

I would take a step back if I were you. Maybe let her lead on the contact more. See if you can reach a middle ground of contact that works.

Maybe the little things are turning to arguments because you’re seeing each other too much for what she can manage so she is over reacting about the small things.

Eekmystro · 25/12/2023 10:18

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 09:13

When I'm on the phone to my mum, she asks me if I'm at my sisters house, and if I tell her I'm at my own house " one time too many" she will ask me " don't you guys see each other" so sometimes I lie and say we saw each other yesterday Blush

Why though. Why not just say “no, I don’t visit too often because she finds visits stressful”.

Do you have issue with being a people pleaser?

WalkingInTheAir13 · 25/12/2023 09:48

From one extreme to another.
Neither one of them bodes well for a good sisterly relationship..

MimiGC · 25/12/2023 09:45

It sounds like your sister finds her twin girls particularly difficult. Why don't you offer to have one of them round to yours occasionally (then the other one next time)? That way your sister, the girls themselves and their brother get a break from their constant fighting...just an idea.

MySecret21 · 25/12/2023 09:42

sistersneighbours · 25/12/2023 09:07

Honestly only MN people will dislike it if you help with their housework, don't know anyone in real life who would be happy if I do their dishes 😂. It's like I just come in and start cleaning, for instance my sister left last week to do some shopping, her house was a mess. And instead of sitting there in a messy house until she came back, I started cleaning the kitchen so it was ready for when she got back with the shopping. And she was happy and really appreciated it.

And I wouldn't just pop in if it was a friends house, but given that we're sisters and neighbours I thought there would be an open door policy, I would be happy for her to pop in whenever she want. But she's not like that, and that's okay.

I've realised that living so close to each other is not really a good idea, we've had arguments about other stuff aswell. I should just have listened to my brothers advice when he warned me about moving next door to her.

One time when my kids were at their dads house, I texted her around 4pm that I would pop in later, she didn't reply. I got to her house around 7pm ish, and she got angry and asked me why didn't I tell the EXACT time I was coming around and not just "later" . I never expected this kind of hostility tbh .

@Globules I'm curious to know how is your relationship with your sister now? Do you still live close to her?

The more you say OP the worse things get.

You are massively overstepping the mark and being really inapprorpriate.

She probably didn’t text you back because she didn’t want you to go over there. She needs a break!

No wonder your sister is seeming stressed and you are arguing with each other.

You need to really re-think your attitude and your approach because this is not going to end well if you carry on behaving the way you are.