Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is madness and not safe?!

385 replies

chocolateaupain · 24/12/2023 16:33

17 year old DD is saying she is going out this evening to meet an 18 year old lad who she's never met before and knows nothing about. We live in the middle of nowhere- apparently he's "getting dropped off" near our house and she's "going for a walk" with him. She's chatted to him over FaceTime and text and they have mutual friends apparently but essentially she knows nothing about him. She plans to just walk around in the dark and cold in a rural area with him (lots of unlit areas). I've told her this is madness and to meet him somewhere lit and safe like a pub / cafe / restaurant for a proper date. She won't listen.

Am I overreacting?!

OP posts:
chocolateaupain · 25/12/2023 11:53

I also don't get the crying and puking, but maybe I'm just of a different generation

Or maybe just lacking in empathy for a very stressed and overwhelmed mother who's been holding everything together singlehandedly for too long and this was the final straw that tipped her over the edge. Lack of empathy isn't a generational thing, it's a personality thing. 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
chocolateaupain · 25/12/2023 11:51

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 25/12/2023 11:39

The speech at their wedding is writing itself: “I knew he was a good’un from their very first date because…”!!

Merry Christmas 🎄🎅

😂😂

Well... he has to pass several more "mum tests" before he can marry her😬😂 so we'll see about that!

OP posts:
Raincloudsonasunnyday · 25/12/2023 11:39

The speech at their wedding is writing itself: “I knew he was a good’un from their very first date because…”!!

Merry Christmas 🎄🎅

ChristmasSteps295 · 25/12/2023 11:23

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 25/12/2023 11:06

100% agreement.
At 16, I did similar to OPs daughter. I was sexually assaulted.
This was a man who lived a few streets from me, in a very small town, and had multiple shared friends.

That wasn't your fault.

taylorswift1989 · 25/12/2023 11:14

EerieSilence · 25/12/2023 10:55

Applause to your adventurous spirit. People like you usually even have a very romantic moment or they end up in the Crime section of newspapers. But you're an adult and her daughter is 17.
And I can fully understand OP and her reaction if her DD suddenly came up with this idea.

I get it. I don't get why you wouldn't invite the boyfriend in, instead, though - seems like the safest thing to do - way safer than sending her out in a taxi or letting her wander the fields alone with him. I also don't get the crying and puking, but maybe I'm just of a different generation. (Gen X, the feral ones.)

I do think part of growing up is learning to take risks and to work out which risks are acceptable to you. Ideally, you have some guidance with that when you're still young. But I tend to react against the idea that everything is so dangerous for girls and women that we should just sit at home and talk to no one in case they rape and murder us. You have to be bold and brave if you want to have an exciting life. Sometimes your risks will pay off, and other times they won't. But even if you never take a risk, you can't guarantee you'll always be safe from harm. You have to decide, for yourself, what kind of a life you want to have, and then be brave.

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 25/12/2023 11:06

EerieSilence · 25/12/2023 10:55

Applause to your adventurous spirit. People like you usually even have a very romantic moment or they end up in the Crime section of newspapers. But you're an adult and her daughter is 17.
And I can fully understand OP and her reaction if her DD suddenly came up with this idea.

100% agreement.
At 16, I did similar to OPs daughter. I was sexually assaulted.
This was a man who lived a few streets from me, in a very small town, and had multiple shared friends.

EerieSilence · 25/12/2023 10:55

taylorswift1989 · 25/12/2023 08:42

Erm... I actually did this a few months ago. We matched on an app, talked on the phone, he drove over to where I was staying and we went for a moonlit walk through the fields. It was lovely.

Not that I'm accusing the OP of being a controlling bitch. Although I do think the hysterical reaction, crying, swearing and threatening to puke was all a bit extra.

Edited

Applause to your adventurous spirit. People like you usually even have a very romantic moment or they end up in the Crime section of newspapers. But you're an adult and her daughter is 17.
And I can fully understand OP and her reaction if her DD suddenly came up with this idea.

chocolateaupain · 25/12/2023 10:12

Whenthebirdssing · 25/12/2023 07:57

Just read this while waiting for everyone to wake up and I feel compelled to just say what horrible replies to your post. I’m quite shocked. So glad your DD is ok and had a lovely time. It’s great she can talk to you about how it went and say that you were right. A sign you have done a most excellent job of parenting! 🎄

Ah thank you so much! This seems to be the majority opinion from what I've read so far (only skimmed this morning briefly as I've obviously been enjoying a lovely Christmas morning with my two girls and my lovely man 🥰). So I can safely ignore all the other guff (😂) and enjoy my Christmas thanks to you lovely lot!

Merry Christmas! 🎅🏻🥂

OP posts:
Minfilia · 25/12/2023 09:55

My 15 year old daughter saw no problem at all with going abroad on her own to meet a group of online friends 🤦‍♀️ fortunately she did listen when I told her all of the reasons why that was a horrendous idea…

She did eventually go abroad alone at 16 after we met and vetted the 18 year old boy she was seeing and he’d stayed in an air bnb nearby, then with us a couple of times first. He was actually a great kid.

My 17 year olds currently think it’s great to go out driving with their friends between 11pm and 1am.

They really do make bad decisions at that age because they see no danger!

taylorswift1989 · 25/12/2023 08:42

EerieSilence · 25/12/2023 06:32

TBH, I wonder how many of those women who are full on accusing OP of being a controlling bitch would go on a Tinder date in the middle of a very unpopulated countryside, in bad weather, with nobody to come to help fast should their date turn into a creep.
Please, share with us your delightful romantic experiences, dear ladies.

Erm... I actually did this a few months ago. We matched on an app, talked on the phone, he drove over to where I was staying and we went for a moonlit walk through the fields. It was lovely.

Not that I'm accusing the OP of being a controlling bitch. Although I do think the hysterical reaction, crying, swearing and threatening to puke was all a bit extra.

Whenthebirdssing · 25/12/2023 07:57

Just read this while waiting for everyone to wake up and I feel compelled to just say what horrible replies to your post. I’m quite shocked. So glad your DD is ok and had a lovely time. It’s great she can talk to you about how it went and say that you were right. A sign you have done a most excellent job of parenting! 🎄

ripplingwater · 25/12/2023 06:58

Well done OP- glad it all worked out and he sounds like a very sensible lad too, agreeing with you.

I am lol at all the hysterical posts about why is she close to her aunt and why is she "acting out" etc. She's a teenager, I was exactly the same at her age, I just wanted to meet boys. Looking back I was an idiot but you can't see it at that age, you just think you know best about everything. Happy Christmas and ignore the witches on here!

shearwater2 · 25/12/2023 06:35

Well done, OP. Teens can be incredibly pig headed and daft at times while generally lovely. This will be a time she'll look back on and be glad you put that boundary in place.

EerieSilence · 25/12/2023 06:32

TBH, I wonder how many of those women who are full on accusing OP of being a controlling bitch would go on a Tinder date in the middle of a very unpopulated countryside, in bad weather, with nobody to come to help fast should their date turn into a creep.
Please, share with us your delightful romantic experiences, dear ladies.

ChaToilLeam · 25/12/2023 06:23

Glad all is well, OP. Enjoy your Christmas! 🎄

Ohthatsfabulousdarling · 25/12/2023 06:16

@chocolateaupain So glad to have read the updates. Teens are so thick headed sometimes (even the good ones with engaged and loving parents!)

It's also really lovely to hear that she listened to her Auntie... Sometimes advice needs to come from anyone but mum because obviously we're always overreacting lol.

Sorry about a lot of the responses you've had here though. I'm assuming that many either haven't had teens themselves, or their little darlings were very good liars. Teenagers can be stupid at the best of times... what really matters is that DD saw sense and compromised which wouldn't have happened if you weren't a caring mother with a good bond with your daughter.

littleblackcat27 · 25/12/2023 06:10

chocolateaupain · 24/12/2023 16:59

Right auntie has now talked to her - she's convinced her this is madness and she's now getting a taxi to a local pub instead and meeting him there, and a taxi home. I've told her she goes nowhere on foot with him - just taxi there and then home. The pub is only 5 mins away.

Great solution OP - lots of people who haven't read the full thread might like to take note.

I hope she had a good time and Merry Christmas to you OP!

Nanaof1 · 25/12/2023 05:52

Bookist · 24/12/2023 17:57

Let me guess, oldest is from a different relationship and you, DH and youngest are a lovely happy family that she has to tag along with and she's bottom of every priority list for everything ever?

This was my first thought too. Also, does the 17 year old have such a close relationship with her Auntie because her Mum is now so focused on her nice, new little family? I think I would feel I had failed as a Mum if I had to rely on other adults to 'talk sense' into my own DD.

Funny, I would think I failed as a human being if I jumped on a mom needing some comfort, advice and a place to vent. I'd also think myself not very intelligent if I didn't realize that Aunts are frequently the favorite sounding board for a female teen and more likely to listen to her, tell her your problems, confide in her etc. Finally, I'd also think less of myself if I behaved like the above, since, making assumptions about others just makes an ass of u.

But, you do you. FFS

ChristmasSteps295 · 25/12/2023 04:40

I hate to say this at Christmas but I suspect OP has had a hard time because of her aggressive and hysterical responses.

I get being protective. It didn't sound like the smartest idea, no. But nearly vomiting with stress? Effing and blinding at anyone who has a difference of opinion? Insisting her daughter is one step away from being raped and murdered? Refusing to have this murderous rapist in the house? Ranting about her Christmas being ruined by her selfish daughter? Unnecessary rants about Christmas presents? It's all a bit much, isn't it?

I'm another one who was living away from home at DD's age. While it would have been nice to have someone looking out for me, I really wouldn't have taken kindly to someone getting so worked up they were about to puke. I'm not convinced that kind of reaction would have brought anything positive to my life. I just hope DD isn't put off sharing any personal information or details of her plans or whereabouts ever again.

As expected, it was a storm in a teacup anyway.

Mouse82 · 25/12/2023 03:43

Trust your gut, we have instincts for a reason.

time4aNC · 25/12/2023 03:24

Glad she’s home safe and saw some sense!

You sound like a great mother OP based on your comments. I’d have no idea how I would ever handle this situation. ----

mantyzer · 25/12/2023 02:21

I know she is back home safe.
But this is exactly the kind of thing I would have done at her age. And nothing bad ever happened. I was raped at 16 by a long term boyfriend who my mum would have liked me to marry. But the random more risky things I did always turned out fine.
I think it is important to be aware of risks, but also have courage. I knew too many women in my early twenties who would not go out after dark alone or go perfectly ordinary places they saw as dodgy.

swimsong · 25/12/2023 00:43

anxiousnanna · 24/12/2023 18:33

today? or in life in general? only you can answer that

Edited

You really won't give up on your inappropriate & wanky pop psychology, will you?

WandaWonder · 25/12/2023 00:01

You would rather not invite him in and would rather have her out with him

I think you have your priorities are wrong

Superduper02 · 24/12/2023 23:59

chocolateaupain · 24/12/2023 20:10

She's just come home. Smiling and happy, saying he was lovely and a real gent who stayed with her til her taxi arrived before be left himself. And she actually said she could now see where I was coming from and she was glad to be indoors in the warm rather than waking the streets in the cold and dark. I asked her how she'd feel if her little sister (who's she is fiercely protective of) said she was doing similar in 15 years time - she shook her head and was like absolutely not. I see your point mum.

So relieved! And sounds like this lad might be alright as well, maybe I'll warm to him. but god help him if he upsets my baby 😂

Thanks to those who were helpful and supportive.

Merry Christmas! 💕🥂

Very pleased to hear your DD is home safe! Such a stress but glad she understands where you were coming from. She was probably too excited to see her dreamboat date to think that he could be anything less than a lovely person. It's your job to think about these things. Well done all round.