Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Home Secretary "jokes" about spiking his wifes drink with Rohypnol

387 replies

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 09:41

As the other thread has been automatically hidden

"James Cleverly has apologised for joking about spiking his wife’s drink with a date rape drug in comments made at a Downing Street reception.
The home secretary’s remarks came just hours after the Home Office announced plans to crack down on spiking, when someone puts drugs into another person’s drink or directly into their body without their knowledge or consent.

Cleverly told female guests at the reception that “a little bit of Rohypnol in her drink every night” was “not really illegal if it’s only a little bit”, the Sunday Mirror reported.
He also laughed that the secret to a long marriage was ensuring your spouse was “someone who is always mildly sedated so she can never realise there are better men out there”."

So much to say about this

Home Office | Politics | The Guardian

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/home-office

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 10:10

jasflowers · 26/12/2023 09:33

So he could tell a joke about Saville and Maddie McCann and that would be ok? as its "just a bad joke".

Thats the problem with your argument, the bar isn't low, its not there, the Health sec can make jokes about the disabled, education sec raise the roof with some crackers about kids and SENDs.

With Freedom of Speech comes responsibility & jokes about rape and drink spiking are just as offensive.

You've not really developed your argument, you've just moved the goal posts as each part of your defence of Cleverly becomes more and more ridiculous.

I haven't moved the goalposts. My view is based on the principle of freedom of speech. He hasn't broken the law, incited criminality, or proposed these things as policy. He made a joke. Okay, some people were highly offended and fair enough. But that's the problem with freedom of speech. People are free to say things that others find offensive. Even things they find absolutely horrendous or revolting. Unfortunately, that is the price we have to pay in return for our own freedom of speech.

To me, freedom is a more important and significant value than offence. Someone could be offended by the things you say - should they have the right to shut you down? Should you be at risk of losing your job because you make a joke about vegans or something else you personally think is funny, but others disagree? I would say no you shouldn't, and I'd defend your right to make that joke, even if I thought it was unfunny, offensive, inappropriate, rude, or ignorant.

Alternatively, do we say that no one should be allowed to say anything that another person finds offensive? Where would you draw the line? Would you apply this to kids? To under-25s? Should people be allowed to say offensive things in their own homes, but not in public places? Should penalties for offending someone stop at being sacked, or should it become a criminal offence? Is it only some people's offence that matters - should you be allowed to offend men but not women, for example? Tories but not labour voters? Should artists be allowed to make art that offends people? What about the people who are not offended? Do their opinions matter?

What I'm trying to get at is that once you start policing speech and limiting freedom of expression, you risk every kind of speech, for every person. We've already seen some of these examples in real life, e.g. with bills limiting speech within the home, or censoring dramatists and performers in Scotland.

The problem is that, imo, freedom of speech has to be absolute. Either everyone has that right, or no one does. That's why people like me defend the right to speech of people we dislike, even when the content of that speech is offensive or downright repugnant.

So no, not moving the goalposts. Just trying to explain the principle.

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 10:08

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/12/2023 23:08

Staunch feminism poster or Tory supporter?Hmm

Oxymorons. Much like the increasingly embarrassingly named Mr. Cleverly.

jasflowers · 26/12/2023 09:33

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 20:06

I don't see any contradiction here? I say people shouldn't be punished for telling jokes, even bad ones. Whether or not they are at their own or others' expense. Or even if they are tasteless and perhaps offensive, as I say in my original comment.

Please quote some of my other comments, as I think I developed my argument quite effectively Grin

So he could tell a joke about Saville and Maddie McCann and that would be ok? as its "just a bad joke".

Thats the problem with your argument, the bar isn't low, its not there, the Health sec can make jokes about the disabled, education sec raise the roof with some crackers about kids and SENDs.

With Freedom of Speech comes responsibility & jokes about rape and drink spiking are just as offensive.

You've not really developed your argument, you've just moved the goal posts as each part of your defence of Cleverly becomes more and more ridiculous.

LorlieS · 25/12/2023 23:13

@TooBigForMyBoots Indeed. Not sure you can in fact be both? I'm definitely one but definitely NOT the other, and what James Cleverly said is both abhorrent and unacceptable.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/12/2023 23:08

Staunch feminism poster or Tory supporter?Hmm

ScremeEggs · 25/12/2023 02:31

I've just been reading the thread and finding it interesting that a staunch feminism poster has been tying themselves in knots to try and minimise what he said, or try to pass off as.a joke /free speech
I get you want people to be free to say what they like when it's something you agree with like trans issues, , interesting it doesn't seem to stretch when it comes to matters of racism free speech for example. The silence /vagueness/pretending they're suddenly busy with Christmas stuff when challenged despite regularly posting speaks volumes.

Abitofalark · 25/12/2023 01:05

It's good to see that women's groups are speaking out. From the Mail:

"James Cleverly is facing calls to quit after joking about spiking his wife's drink with date rape drug as domestic abuse campaigners blast 'sickening' comments and say 'no wonder women don't feel safe'"

"But women's rights group the Fawcett Society said the comments were 'sickening' and called for Mr Cleverly to resign."

"Domestic abuse charity Women's Aid said it was vital for ministers to take the problem of spiking seriously."

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12898169/James-Cleverly-facing-calls-quit-joking-spiking-wifes-drink-date-rape-drug-domestic-abuse-campaigners-blast-sickening-comments-say-no-wonder-women-dont-feel-safe.html

crumblingschools · 24/12/2023 22:50

Exactly @cakeorwine

Still waiting to hear from posters who think these sort of jokes are fine, what schools should be doing or should girls should just accept male ‘banter’

Maggiethecat · 24/12/2023 22:40

Waffle, waffle, obfuscate

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 20:58

Schools are trying to crack down on mysogynistic comments in the classroom. What message does the Prime Minister thinks it sends when the Home Secretary makes so called jokes about spiking his wife with date rape drugs?

OP posts:
whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 20:51

In the world of employment, people can lose their jobs for inappropriate comments in the workplace. Does the Prime Minister think that the Home Secretary is fit for his role after making jokes about drugging and raping women, especially as the 'jokes' were told at a Downing Street event?

And also:

What message does it send to women of the country if on the same day your party announces measures to tackle drink spiking and sexual assault, one of the most senior cabinet members in the same party makes jokes about drink spiking and rape at a Downing Street event?

PerkingFaintly · 24/12/2023 20:30

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 20:11

This is an interesting question for PMQs

In the world of employment, people can lose their jobs for inappropriate comments in the workplace. Does the Prime Minister think that the Home Secretary's comments about spiking were appropriate?

(I can hear the answer now)

Well indeed.

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 20:11

This is an interesting question for PMQs

In the world of employment, people can lose their jobs for inappropriate comments in the workplace. Does the Prime Minister think that the Home Secretary's comments about spiking were appropriate?

(I can hear the answer now)

OP posts:
beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 20:06

PerkingFaintly · 24/12/2023 19:14

Also, this is a written medium. We can see that defending him is exactly how you started.Xmas Hmm

beastlyslumber · Today 10:17
But wasn't the joke at his own expense? He was saying, I'm punching above my weight here/I'm a loser and hope my wife never realises it. He wasn't actually saying, it's funny to spike women's drinks. He was saying, it's funny I'm such a loser compared to my wife.

Either way, okay, it was tasteless and perhaps offensive, but I don't think it's a punishable crime to tell a tasteless or offensive joke. It shouldn't be, anyway. Everyone says dumb things or makes stupid jokes sometimes. I don't really want to live in a society where people are punished for making jokes, even bad ones.

beastlyslumber · Today 18:50
[...] I'm not defending JC or what he said.

I don't see any contradiction here? I say people shouldn't be punished for telling jokes, even bad ones. Whether or not they are at their own or others' expense. Or even if they are tasteless and perhaps offensive, as I say in my original comment.

Please quote some of my other comments, as I think I developed my argument quite effectively Grin

SpecialCharacters · 24/12/2023 20:03

We not still doing ‘at least they know what a woman is’?

Maggiethecat · 24/12/2023 19:58

I used to think he was a sensible minister, willing to do the interview circuit when shit was hitting the fan at various times, especially in the BJ era.
I realise, after the Stockton comment and now this, that although he may think he’s smart or funny he’s just a complete asshole.

verdantverdure · 24/12/2023 19:30

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 10:17

But wasn't the joke at his own expense? He was saying, I'm punching above my weight here/I'm a loser and hope my wife never realises it. He wasn't actually saying, it's funny to spike women's drinks. He was saying, it's funny I'm such a loser compared to my wife.

Either way, okay, it was tasteless and perhaps offensive, but I don't think it's a punishable crime to tell a tasteless or offensive joke. It shouldn't be, anyway. Everyone says dumb things or makes stupid jokes sometimes. I don't really want to live in a society where people are punished for making jokes, even bad ones.

He said his wife was a victim of his violence and coercive control and a little bit of that isn't illegal.

PerkingFaintly · 24/12/2023 19:14

Also, this is a written medium. We can see that defending him is exactly how you started.Xmas Hmm

beastlyslumber · Today 10:17
But wasn't the joke at his own expense? He was saying, I'm punching above my weight here/I'm a loser and hope my wife never realises it. He wasn't actually saying, it's funny to spike women's drinks. He was saying, it's funny I'm such a loser compared to my wife.

Either way, okay, it was tasteless and perhaps offensive, but I don't think it's a punishable crime to tell a tasteless or offensive joke. It shouldn't be, anyway. Everyone says dumb things or makes stupid jokes sometimes. I don't really want to live in a society where people are punished for making jokes, even bad ones.

beastlyslumber · Today 18:50
[...] I'm not defending JC or what he said.

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 19:09

PerkingFaintly · 24/12/2023 19:02

No one's falling for your "free speech" straw man, beastlyslumber.

I'm not sure why you think it's a straw man or why you think I'm trying to fool anyone. I set out my arguments very clearly and cogently, if I do say so myself, a few pages back. Maybe I'm right, maybe I'm wrong. We could figure that out, if you were willing to go beyond name-calling and engage in conversation. But hey ho. I can't be arsed to get into a back and forth with someone who doesn't have the capacity for thoughtful discussion. It's Christmas, I'm happy, nothing terrible has happened, so I shall wish you well.

BIossomtoes · 24/12/2023 19:04

PerkingFaintly · 24/12/2023 19:02

No one's falling for your "free speech" straw man, beastlyslumber.

Too bloody right they’re not.

PerkingFaintly · 24/12/2023 19:02

No one's falling for your "free speech" straw man, beastlyslumber.

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 18:50

Just to be clear, in response to some of the more recent comments, some of which I am assuming are intended to include me:

  1. I'm not defending JC or what he said. I'm defending his right to speech. As Voltaire said (he stole this from English novelist Evelyn Beatrice Hall, a woman): "I wholly disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it." You may disagree with the principle of free speech, but it's an established principle that an educated person ought to be familiar with. It's disingenuous to pretend that people defending free speech are actually defending the content of that speech.
  2. I'm a woman. I've been posting for years on MN under this name (and years before that under other names). Accusing people who you disagree with of being men, as though women all think the same way, is unbelievably sexist and misogynist. Women are people, too. We are individuals with our own minds, thoughts, and opinions. We disagree with each other all the time. Since I have been polite, and mostly patient, and willing to set out my argument and defend it without resorting to any deliberate logical fallacies or silencing tactics, I think accusing me of being a MRA, TRA or other kind of troll is very weak indeed.
  3. I hope you're all having a lovely Christmas eve. Luckily we are in a position to be able to debate and discuss these matters openly and without fear, when so many women in the world have been silenced and have no voice, and even, in many cases, no vote. So I'm very grateful for our disagreements.
SerendipityJane · 24/12/2023 17:24

GothConversionTherapy · 24/12/2023 17:19

Rishi can sack him surely ? Would it be usual for a PM to make a statement or get involved ? Not that he seems to do much of anything.

Rishi can't sack anybody. Even if he had the power.

His previous Home Secretary was actively briefing against the very police force she was supposed to oversee and didn't get sacked. This is a mere bagatelle in comparison.

You really have to wonder what you would have to do to get sacked. Even waving your willy around in public doesn't count as an offence in Toryland.

GothConversionTherapy · 24/12/2023 17:19

Rishi can sack him surely ? Would it be usual for a PM to make a statement or get involved ? Not that he seems to do much of anything.

SerendipityJane · 24/12/2023 17:13

I wonder if any women or group have started a petition for Sunak to take action.

Why ? Would it make a difference ? Has it ever made a difference ?

If over6 million signatures on an official government petition can disappear into thin air, what chance will your paltry tens of thousands have ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread