Where we differ is that with FoS comes responsibility, i'll ask you again, should he, as Home Sec be free to make horrendous (but legal) jokes about Saville & Maddie McCann, the disabled? (i never mentioned Veganism)
Is the bar you set on FoS whether something is legal or not? which is a bit of a weird bar really, because laws are made to stifle FoS & protest.
I thought I had answered: yes, he should be able to make an offensive joke. He should not be able to propose such a thing as policy, or to incite criminality. I do appreciate that the context has a bearing; the fact that he has a position of authority, for example. Perhaps he should be held to a higher standard than others. But for me, the problem is still the principle: if he can be sacked for his legal speech, then anyone can, and this is a bigger issue to me than the fact that he's caused offence.
Yes, the bar for me is legality. If speech comes within the law, then it should be free, regardless of offence caused. I'm aware that there are government attacks on free speech all the time, and efforts being made to change the law so that we have less and less freedom in this respect - I mentioned the bills proposed in Scotland, for example. But I think that these attacks should be resisted. We need more freedom of speech, not less. I would rather live in a society where we have to tolerate idiocy, ignorance and offence, than a society where we are not allowed to express our views, make art or tell jokes. (What happens in such a society when you're offended? If this had happened in China, you wouldn't be able to post about it online. You and your family could be punished for you simply expressing your offence and upset. Arguing against free speech is arguing against your own right to protest speech you don't like.)
(i never mentioned Veganism)
I'm aware. I used that as an example when questioning you about your own feelings regarding freedom of speech, because I assume you're not likely to make a racist or misogynist joke and wanted to pick something that you might find more relatable in order to allow you to consider the point.