Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Home Secretary "jokes" about spiking his wifes drink with Rohypnol

387 replies

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 09:41

As the other thread has been automatically hidden

"James Cleverly has apologised for joking about spiking his wife’s drink with a date rape drug in comments made at a Downing Street reception.
The home secretary’s remarks came just hours after the Home Office announced plans to crack down on spiking, when someone puts drugs into another person’s drink or directly into their body without their knowledge or consent.

Cleverly told female guests at the reception that “a little bit of Rohypnol in her drink every night” was “not really illegal if it’s only a little bit”, the Sunday Mirror reported.
He also laughed that the secret to a long marriage was ensuring your spouse was “someone who is always mildly sedated so she can never realise there are better men out there”."

So much to say about this

Home Office | Politics | The Guardian

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/home-office

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 02/01/2024 09:36

The first amendment

Is irrelevant in the UK ...

FourEyesGood · 02/01/2024 09:25

cakeorwine · 02/01/2024 07:11

So:

Sunak considers the matter closed.
However - Cleverley is doing the media rounds today - so this will be interesting to see if it's raised.

He was on the R4 Today programme this morning talking to Mishal Husain about the immigration targets. She raised the issue of this ‘joke’ at the end of the interview and he blustered his way through some stuff about his track record of championing women. She was clearly unconvinced, as was I.

puncheur · 02/01/2024 09:16

@beastlyslumber you have hugely misunderstood the first amendment. Do you really believe that eg slagging off about your employer online will not get you sacked because “it’s free speech innit?”

The first amendment limits government from imposing restrictions on free speech. It certainly doesn’t limit employers from punishing employees for spouting shit.

cakeorwine · 02/01/2024 07:11

So:

Sunak considers the matter closed.
However - Cleverley is doing the media rounds today - so this will be interesting to see if it's raised.

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 17:49

"Free speech" isn't "consequence"-free speech though is it?

James Cleverly exercised his right to free speech when he said it.

No one stopped him saying it.

No one interfered with his right to say it.

They merely reported that he said it.

And people have opinions about him saying it.

Mine is that there should be consequences for. Home Secretary that tells people that a little bit of drugging women isn't illegal.

verdantverdure · 26/12/2023 17:44

I had a part time job in a pub once and a barman was let go for joking about "roofies".

I hold the Home Secretary of the United Kingdom to a higher standard than a casual barman.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/12/2023 12:47

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 11:21

I mean, I could be wrong, but I'm clearly not dim. Or part of a contingent, for that matter! I'm kind of a lone voice on this thread.

So, you know, maybe try to argue without the use of ad hominem? I've been pretty patient and open to explaining my points and answering questions. Name calling isn't going to change anyone's mind, least of all the person you're trying to insult.

It seems a bit contradictory to champion unrestricted expression yet be offended by someone exercising that right.

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 12:09

PerkingFaintly · 26/12/2023 12:05

Oh.

Apparently Sunak was at the Downing Street reception where Cleverly was sounding off in this charming vein about drugging women.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-67813689

Although to be fair there's nothing to suggest Sunak heard him.

He can't have heard him - because otherwise he would have immediately pulled him up on it ?

It's inconceivable he could have heard it and agreed, isn't it ?

You can tell always tell more about someone from the company they keep than what they say.

PerkingFaintly · 26/12/2023 12:05

Oh.

Apparently Sunak was at the Downing Street reception where Cleverly was sounding off in this charming vein about drugging women.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-67813689

Although to be fair there's nothing to suggest Sunak heard him.

PerkingFaintly · 26/12/2023 12:02

Well, Cleverly has made excellent use of his freedom of speech to tell us who he is.

And when someone tells you who they are, believe them.

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 11:47

GothConversionTherapy · 26/12/2023 11:43

Even in the US free speech is qualified, the classic example is not shouting "fire" in a crowded theater, because real harm could come of it (stampede). And it has never meant freedom from consequences anywhere.

There are also secrecy laws. And libel laws.

Roussette · 26/12/2023 11:47

I'm kind of a lone voice on this thread

Maybe you need to wonder why you are?

GothConversionTherapy · 26/12/2023 11:43

Even in the US free speech is qualified, the classic example is not shouting "fire" in a crowded theater, because real harm could come of it (stampede). And it has never meant freedom from consequences anywhere.

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 11:21

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 11:09

Nobody thoughtful is a free speech absolutist. There have always been limitations to free speech which are necessary to safeguard everyone's freedoms

All human rights are qualified. Something the ever dim "what about out rights ?" contingent are unable to understand.

I mean, I could be wrong, but I'm clearly not dim. Or part of a contingent, for that matter! I'm kind of a lone voice on this thread.

So, you know, maybe try to argue without the use of ad hominem? I've been pretty patient and open to explaining my points and answering questions. Name calling isn't going to change anyone's mind, least of all the person you're trying to insult.

GrammarTeacher · 26/12/2023 11:21

He is free to make crass offensive jokes. He is not free from the consequences. He has quite literally been involved in legislation that is meant to tackle this issue and then jokes about it!
THIS culture is precisely why sexual assault is effectively decriminalised.

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 11:19

Nobody thoughtful is a free speech absolutist. There have always been limitations to free speech which are necessary to safeguard everyone's freedoms

I'm not an absolutist. I agree that there should be a limit when it comes to incitement to criminality. I also think that pornography should be limited and strictly regulated.

I would love the UK to have something like the first amendment in the US.

Is it too much to expect that he should weigh every word he utters?

To be fair, I do think that he should be a lot more careful. There's a time and place for jokes and he misjudged this. As I said earlier, I think he should be reprimanded and reminded of his position.

His joke could lead directly to more such crimes against women as he gives the impression that these crimes are somehow acceptable.

No, I don't think people are that stupid. I don't think anyone hearing that joke would be persuaded to drug and rape a woman if he wasn't already going to do it. There's no evidence I'm aware of that jokes lead to violent actions.

But let's say you're right. Should all jokes about drugging and raping women be banned, on that basis? What if they are jokes told by women who have been victims of this? Should they also not be allowed to joke about it, in case they influence someone?

Are you seriously arguing that the HS should be free to indulge in saying whatever he wants regardless of the potential consequences?

That's not exactly what I've argued. I've said he shouldn't be sacked for his joke.

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 11:09

Nobody thoughtful is a free speech absolutist. There have always been limitations to free speech which are necessary to safeguard everyone's freedoms

All human rights are qualified. Something the ever dim "what about out rights ?" contingent are unable to understand.

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 11:09

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 11:00

Yes, the bar for me is legality. If speech comes within the law, then it should be free, regardless of offence caused.

Once again, if there was a point, you missed it by a country mile.

Cleverly is part of a government that has legislated legal free speech out if existence. So he can fucking well be treated as he treats others. Not given a free pass ...

That's your point? That free speech has been attacked by this government, so he should be hoist by his own petard?

Okay. There is a certain poetic justice to that, I guess.

But for me, it means joining in with the attack on free speech. Siding with the government on curtailing speech. So I'm not going to do that. Because it's a right I think is vitally important. And maybe people like JC will come to understand that when they see their own freedom of speech under attack. It shows clearly that either everyone has the right to free speech or no one does.

Livingtothefull · 26/12/2023 11:04

Thelnebriati · 26/12/2023 10:18

I don't know any feminists who are free speech absolutists; because absolute freedom for one group always leads to loss of freedom for another. And feminists are aware that never ends well for women and children.

Sexual harassment is not acceptable. Calling it a joke or a free speech issue doesn't change that.

100%. We know what total freedom of speech will lead to: an environment where women are compelled to put up with a hostile and oppressive environment due to constant male banter. Woman have successfully won sex discrimination cases when they have been forced to work in environments like this.

Nobody thoughtful is a free speech absolutist. There have always been limitations to free speech which are necessary to safeguard everyone's freedoms - eg the European Convention on Human Rights recognises this. https://lordslibrary.parliament.uk/freedom-of-speech-challenges-and-the-role-of-public-private-and-civil-society-sectors-in-upholding-rights/

And the Home Secretary is not just 'people'. He holds one of the Great Offices of State and has overall responsibility for law & order in this country. Is it too much to expect that he should weigh every word he utters? His joke could lead directly to more such crimes against women as he gives the impression that these crimes are somehow acceptable. Are you seriously arguing that the HS should be free to indulge in saying whatever he wants regardless of the potential consequences?

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 11:04

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 10:50

Is the bar you set on FoS whether something is legal or not?

That's immaterial in the UK now. Remember thanks to this government "legal but harmful" material is cause for action.

And I certainly consider Cleverlys remarks harmful.

Well, yes, this really exemplifies the problem.

Who gets to decide what's harmful? If it's you, then great! But if it's someone else, that's a problem. Right?

What if your legal speech is considered harmful by someone or some group? What happens when there's a dispute over whether speech is harmful or not? Some people think saying 'men aren't women' or 'meat is murder' is harmful, but many would disagree. Who gets to choose? Why does that person or group of people get so much power over the others? How do they decide what constitutes harm when no laws have been broken? What if someone pretends to be harmed but they're not? Should there be some way of quantifying harm - e.g. loss of income, loss of health, other consequence? But what if someone claims to have hurt feelings? Is that enough? How many people need to have hurt feelings to determine that speech to be harmful?

It's an absolute disaster. Freedom of speech is not without its ethical issues, true. But for me, I see it as a protective mechanism. It defends society as a whole by upholding the principle that every individual has the right to express their views in any way they see fit, as long as they do not incite criminality. Unfortunately it does mean that we need to hear things we find unpleasant or offensive. Luckily, it also gives us the means to argue against those things and persuade others to our view, exposing bad and wrong ideas and stripping them of their power over time.

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 11:00

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 10:56

Where we differ is that with FoS comes responsibility, i'll ask you again, should he, as Home Sec be free to make horrendous (but legal) jokes about Saville & Maddie McCann, the disabled? (i never mentioned Veganism)

Is the bar you set on FoS whether something is legal or not? which is a bit of a weird bar really, because laws are made to stifle FoS & protest.

I thought I had answered: yes, he should be able to make an offensive joke. He should not be able to propose such a thing as policy, or to incite criminality. I do appreciate that the context has a bearing; the fact that he has a position of authority, for example. Perhaps he should be held to a higher standard than others. But for me, the problem is still the principle: if he can be sacked for his legal speech, then anyone can, and this is a bigger issue to me than the fact that he's caused offence.

Yes, the bar for me is legality. If speech comes within the law, then it should be free, regardless of offence caused. I'm aware that there are government attacks on free speech all the time, and efforts being made to change the law so that we have less and less freedom in this respect - I mentioned the bills proposed in Scotland, for example. But I think that these attacks should be resisted. We need more freedom of speech, not less. I would rather live in a society where we have to tolerate idiocy, ignorance and offence, than a society where we are not allowed to express our views, make art or tell jokes. (What happens in such a society when you're offended? If this had happened in China, you wouldn't be able to post about it online. You and your family could be punished for you simply expressing your offence and upset. Arguing against free speech is arguing against your own right to protest speech you don't like.)

(i never mentioned Veganism)

I'm aware. I used that as an example when questioning you about your own feelings regarding freedom of speech, because I assume you're not likely to make a racist or misogynist joke and wanted to pick something that you might find more relatable in order to allow you to consider the point.

Yes, the bar for me is legality. If speech comes within the law, then it should be free, regardless of offence caused.

Once again, if there was a point, you missed it by a country mile.

Cleverly is part of a government that has legislated legal free speech out if existence. So he can fucking well be treated as he treats others. Not given a free pass ...

beastlyslumber · 26/12/2023 10:56

Where we differ is that with FoS comes responsibility, i'll ask you again, should he, as Home Sec be free to make horrendous (but legal) jokes about Saville & Maddie McCann, the disabled? (i never mentioned Veganism)

Is the bar you set on FoS whether something is legal or not? which is a bit of a weird bar really, because laws are made to stifle FoS & protest.

I thought I had answered: yes, he should be able to make an offensive joke. He should not be able to propose such a thing as policy, or to incite criminality. I do appreciate that the context has a bearing; the fact that he has a position of authority, for example. Perhaps he should be held to a higher standard than others. But for me, the problem is still the principle: if he can be sacked for his legal speech, then anyone can, and this is a bigger issue to me than the fact that he's caused offence.

Yes, the bar for me is legality. If speech comes within the law, then it should be free, regardless of offence caused. I'm aware that there are government attacks on free speech all the time, and efforts being made to change the law so that we have less and less freedom in this respect - I mentioned the bills proposed in Scotland, for example. But I think that these attacks should be resisted. We need more freedom of speech, not less. I would rather live in a society where we have to tolerate idiocy, ignorance and offence, than a society where we are not allowed to express our views, make art or tell jokes. (What happens in such a society when you're offended? If this had happened in China, you wouldn't be able to post about it online. You and your family could be punished for you simply expressing your offence and upset. Arguing against free speech is arguing against your own right to protest speech you don't like.)

(i never mentioned Veganism)

I'm aware. I used that as an example when questioning you about your own feelings regarding freedom of speech, because I assume you're not likely to make a racist or misogynist joke and wanted to pick something that you might find more relatable in order to allow you to consider the point.

SerendipityJane · 26/12/2023 10:50

Is the bar you set on FoS whether something is legal or not?

That's immaterial in the UK now. Remember thanks to this government "legal but harmful" material is cause for action.

And I certainly consider Cleverlys remarks harmful.

jasflowers · 26/12/2023 10:40

@beastlyslumber To me, freedom is a more important and significant value than offence. Someone could be offended by the things you say - should they have the right to shut you down? Should you be at risk of losing your job because you make a joke about vegans or something else you personally think is funny, but others disagree? I would say no you shouldn't, and I'd defend your right to make that joke, even if I thought it was unfunny, offensive, inappropriate, rude, or ignorant

But he isn't being shut down, he has the freedom to say these jokes, to make fun of real life situations, jokes about processed food is hardly the same as a woman taken to hotel room and gang raped, with little or no memory but knowing full well she has been repeatedly raped, guilt ridden, shamed & terrified of pregnancy and STI's, with almost zero chance the men involved will never be caught.

Where we differ is that with FoS comes responsibility, i'll ask you again, should he, as Home Sec be free to make horrendous (but legal) jokes about Saville & Maddie McCann, the disabled? (i never mentioned Veganism)

Is the bar you set on FoS whether something is legal or not? which is a bit of a weird bar really, because laws are made to stifle FoS & protest.

Thelnebriati · 26/12/2023 10:18

I don't know any feminists who are free speech absolutists; because absolute freedom for one group always leads to loss of freedom for another. And feminists are aware that never ends well for women and children.

Sexual harassment is not acceptable. Calling it a joke or a free speech issue doesn't change that.