Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Home Secretary "jokes" about spiking his wifes drink with Rohypnol

387 replies

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 09:41

As the other thread has been automatically hidden

"James Cleverly has apologised for joking about spiking his wife’s drink with a date rape drug in comments made at a Downing Street reception.
The home secretary’s remarks came just hours after the Home Office announced plans to crack down on spiking, when someone puts drugs into another person’s drink or directly into their body without their knowledge or consent.

Cleverly told female guests at the reception that “a little bit of Rohypnol in her drink every night” was “not really illegal if it’s only a little bit”, the Sunday Mirror reported.
He also laughed that the secret to a long marriage was ensuring your spouse was “someone who is always mildly sedated so she can never realise there are better men out there”."

So much to say about this

Home Office | Politics | The Guardian

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/home-office

OP posts:
Exasperatednow · 24/12/2023 11:28

Charlie2121 · 24/12/2023 11:21

Wait until you see what is about to replace them at the next general election. It’s a horrifying prospect.

You must live in a different universe to those that need to use public services like the nhs, education or those on the bread line.

Kirstyshine · 24/12/2023 11:28

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 10:43

Yes, I'm not opposed to their being consequences for speech. But those consequences generally being other people get to argue against you. Maybe your wife is pissed off with you, or your friends don't want to hang out with you because you always say stupid shit.

Losing your job is a punishment and it's a silencing tactic. And it sets a precedent. Now you can say something that others find offensive and lose your job, too.

Indeed, this has been happening to women for quite some time now.

I think you’re right.

crumblingschools · 24/12/2023 11:28

@beastlyslumber in a survey by OFSTED looking at child on child abuse, 92% of girls said sexist name calling and 80% of girls said inappropriate or unwanted comments were made in their peer groups. When boys were questioned they were more likely to see this as banter and not a problem. Is this the sort of freedom of speech you want? Do you want the majority of girls to have to put up with this sort of behaviour?

Havanananana · 24/12/2023 11:27

What happened to Sunak's promise, made on his first day as PM, that he would lead with "integrity, professionalism and accountability?"

Perhaps lieutenant colonel Cleverly's banter stems from his time at Sandhurst in the Army - an organisation that coincidentally was also under scrutiny in today's Guardian: ‘It was a hunting ground’: women and sexual assault in the UK armed forces | Rape and sexual assault | The Guardian

‘It was a hunting ground’: women and sexual assault in the UK armed forces

Two years on from the government response to an inquiry into women’s lives in the forces, those who serve still face a culture of violent misogyny

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/dec/24/it-was-a-hunting-ground-women-and-sexual-assault-in-the-uk-armed-forces

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/12/2023 11:27

It really does make you wonder what he says in private if that’s what he, the Home Secretary in charge of policing, thinks is an acceptable thing to say in public in front of journalists.

jasflowers · 24/12/2023 11:27

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:00

No, I don't think it's wise. If I was his boss I'd be concerned about his judgement, yes. I would think he was very stupid, and he would be reprimanded. Maybe given some media training. Maybe given some education on the criminal use of rohypnol and the effect on victims.

I mean, I'm not Sunak, so it's hard to answer. I imagine he may well bow to pressure and axe the guy.

I'm a woman who thinks that free speech is an incredibly important right for women to retain and defend, so my answers are based on that.

Freedom of speech is of course vital & Cleverly still has that right, he can make jokes about pretty much anything really BUT with freedom of speech comes responsibility and consequence,

He is the Home Secretary, that his judgement/morals is so poor, should be of concern to all of us.

The message to many people will be its ok to belittle women, whoever you are.

No wonder the Tories voted against making Misogyny a hate crime.

whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 11:26

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:22

Appreciate the discussion, everyone. I have to go and do xmassy things now so if you @ or quote me, you probably won't get a response for hours or even days, so might not be worth bothering! I think you know what I'm saying, anyway.

You repeatedly replied to my posts, even taking the time to copy and paste snippets, but refused to give your thoughts on the examples I put to you a number of times.

Despite me giving my thoughts on your example directly.

And now you're bailing? When you took the time to reply to everything else I asked?

Interesting. You clearly don't stand by the courage of your convictions, which is heartening in a way.

As you haven't answered, I assume you don't want to reveal that in the other examples you do think that a sacking is the natural consequence.

It sounds like at least you believe people should lose their job if they make such a 'joke' about black or disabled people. Just not raping women.

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 11:25

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:20

I don't understand the distinction you're making. You're saying that he can say what he likes, because he has freedom of speech. But if he says what he likes, he should be sacked for it?

Maybe our idea of consequences are different. I believe your idea of a fair consequence for speech you dislike is one which is damaging to the principle of free speech. As I said above:

"Sacking someone because their speech is considered 'wrong' goes way beyond fair consequences. You're attacking not only his personal freedom of speech, but creating/reinforcing a culture in which everyone understands that saying the 'wrong' thing could cost them their career."

We have seen this 'consequence' meted out to women over and over again in the past decade. I do not think it's a fair consequence of speech, unless that speech is libelous, plagiarised, or incitement to a crime.

If someone in power is making sexist or racist jokes in the workplace, what does that mean for the people who work for them?

We have seen it with the police

Met officers joked about raping women, police watchdog reveals | Metropolitan police | The Guardian

The IOPC said the messages showed attitudes that left ethnic minority and female staff in fear and could show officers being discriminatory to their colleagues and staff. The officers also shared a series of racist messages.

Of 14 officers investigated, two were sacked for gross misconduct. Misconduct was proven against another two, with one officer receiving a written warning, while another four faced measures to improve their performance.
Bas Javid, a deputy assistant commissioner with the Met, said he was “angry and disappointed”, felt “disgust and shame” and added “It’s clear we have a lot of work to do to ensure bullying and discrimination does not exist in any part of the Met.
“We recognise that there is need for real change in the Met.”
The IOPC said it reviewed thousands of messages and some officers tried to defend them claiming that they were “banter”, an excuse that was not accepted.

This is part of the culture out there.

There are consequences and leadership should come from the top.

Met officers joked about raping women, police watchdog reveals

Met denies culture of misogyny as damning report reveals sexist, racist and homophobic messages sent as ‘banter’

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/feb/01/met-officers-joked-raping-women-police-watchdog-racist

OP posts:
whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 11:23

@beastlyslumber

I don't understand the distinction you're making. You're saying that he can say what he likes, because he has freedom of speech. But if he says what he likes, he should be sacked for it?

I'm at a loss as to what you don't understand about the distinction.

I've added the distinction I mean to your words:

"He can say what he likes, because he has freedom of speech. But if he says something grossly offensive / in direct opposition to the code of conduct of his job he should be sacked for it."

That's what I believe.

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:22

Appreciate the discussion, everyone. I have to go and do xmassy things now so if you @ or quote me, you probably won't get a response for hours or even days, so might not be worth bothering! I think you know what I'm saying, anyway.

Charlie2121 · 24/12/2023 11:21

GothConversionTherapy · 24/12/2023 11:15

This government is the biggest group of pigs I've ever seen. I wonder what the reaction in the room was.

Wait until you see what is about to replace them at the next general election. It’s a horrifying prospect.

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:20

whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 11:14

I believe he had every 'right' to make such a disgusting joke. As you say, freedom of speech means we can say what we want.

I believe he should be sacked for what he said while using his right to free speech. Because there are consequences to the words he chose to use.

Why are you not understanding that those two beliefs aren't mutually exclusive?

I don't understand the distinction you're making. You're saying that he can say what he likes, because he has freedom of speech. But if he says what he likes, he should be sacked for it?

Maybe our idea of consequences are different. I believe your idea of a fair consequence for speech you dislike is one which is damaging to the principle of free speech. As I said above:

"Sacking someone because their speech is considered 'wrong' goes way beyond fair consequences. You're attacking not only his personal freedom of speech, but creating/reinforcing a culture in which everyone understands that saying the 'wrong' thing could cost them their career."

We have seen this 'consequence' meted out to women over and over again in the past decade. I do not think it's a fair consequence of speech, unless that speech is libelous, plagiarised, or incitement to a crime.

ofestivetree · 24/12/2023 11:20

Should be arrested

whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 11:20

@beastlyslumber

Sacking someone because their speech is considered 'wrong' goes way beyond fair consequences. You're attacking not only his personal freedom of speech, but creating/reinforcing a culture in which everyone understands that saying the 'wrong' thing could cost them their career.

I'll ask again because as mentioned, I directly answered when you asked my thoughts on your example so it would seem fair you do the same.

What if he made a 'joke' about black people being abused in police custody hours after announcing measures to reduce racism in the force?

What if he made a 'joke' about physically disabled people being easier to sexually assault hours after announcing measures to reduce the abuse of disabled people?

In these two examples, do you think he should lose his job?

Charlie2121 · 24/12/2023 11:19

ru53 · 24/12/2023 11:11

Jimmy Dimly as John Crace calls him…

It is mortifying that these idiots represent us on the world stage. This current iteration of the Conservative Party is beyond scraping the barrel. We need serious, competent, professional politicians for serious times.

Edited

You’d better hope that Labour don’t win the next GE then otherwise you are going to be seriously disappointed.

cakeorwine · 24/12/2023 11:19

GothConversionTherapy · 24/12/2023 11:15

This government is the biggest group of pigs I've ever seen. I wonder what the reaction in the room was.

I do wonder.
Especially as it was a group of female journalists.
And he is a man of power and influence.
I wonder if they spoke about it afterwards?

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 24/12/2023 11:18

Pleased there's such a spread of views here. Someone has to be devils advocate.

whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 11:18

@beastlyslumber

You also cut off a section of my post where I asked your thoughts on a question, as I responded directly to your version of the same question.

I think you thought your question would be a gotcha or I'd wriggle out if answering it. But I didn't, I answered directly.

It would be great if you could do the same.

Here it is again:

I asked you for your thoughts on an example and you said "Well, first of all, he didn't make any of those 'jokes'."

What if he made a 'joke' about black people being abused in police custody hours after announcing measures to reduce racism in the force?

What if he made a 'joke' about physically disabled people being easier to sexually assault hours after announcing measures to reduce the abuse of disabled people?

In these two examples, do you think he should lose his job?

OP posts:
RainbowZebraWarrior · 24/12/2023 11:16

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:05

Is that so? Who decided those are my choices of what to think? Could I not think what he said was 'wrong' in some respect but that there shouldn't be consequences? Could I not think that there should be consequences, but not the ones that you think there should be? I'm pretty sure there are many different ways to think about this issue.

However, I answered above what I would hypothetically do if I were Sunak. I think that broadly answers what you're asking me here.

I see we crossed posts, and you detailed your thoughts in an another response, thanks.

I'm not telling you what to think or what your specific choices are, but you answered that with your other post, so no worries.

Thanks again for your thoughts.

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:16

What almost everyone on this thread is arguing is that the deeply unpleasant Mr. Cleverly faces consequences for how he chose to use his freedom of speech.

Nah, that's just semantics.

"You have freedom of speech. Unless you choose to use it in a way that we don't like." That's not freedom. That's a threat.

I do agree that speech can have consequences. But I think those should be natural consequences based on what you've said. You make a stupid joke, you get humiliated by your friends. You make a joke that offends people, the media expose you for being a dickhead. I think that's all fair enough. People can then discuss the issues and decide what they think. More discussion of this particular issue is not a bad thing, as clearly there is little public understanding.

Sacking someone because their speech is considered 'wrong' goes way beyond fair consequences. You're attacking not only his personal freedom of speech, but creating/reinforcing a culture in which everyone understands that saying the 'wrong' thing could cost them their career.

GothConversionTherapy · 24/12/2023 11:15

This government is the biggest group of pigs I've ever seen. I wonder what the reaction in the room was.

whatsitcalledwhen · 24/12/2023 11:14

beastlyslumber · 24/12/2023 11:10

I agree in the right to freedom of speech. I also think he should lose his job for what he said while exercising his freedom of speech.

You keep suggesting the two beliefs are mutually exclusive and that if people believe in freedom of speech, they shouldn't believe he should be sacked. You can believe both things are true without those two beliefs clashing at all.

Interesting @whatsitcalledwhen . So you don't think that being sacked for making a joke is an attack against your freedom of speech?

So what is the basis on which you think Cleverly should lose his job? Not because of what he said, okay. What then?

I believe he had every 'right' to make such a disgusting joke. As you say, freedom of speech means we can say what we want.

I believe he should be sacked for what he said while using his right to free speech. Because there are consequences to the words he chose to use.

Why are you not understanding that those two beliefs aren't mutually exclusive?

SerendipityJane · 24/12/2023 11:12

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 24/12/2023 11:12

Not RTFT but isn't his wife ill with cancer? He is my local MP unfortunately

Sadly reminds me of Boris previous wife.

SerendipityJane · 24/12/2023 11:12

So you don't think that being sacked for making a joke is an attack against your freedom of speech?

What planet would you like to live on where there are no consequences for your actions. We should sent a probe there. (Probably an anal probe)