Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wicked is the worst musical theatre EVER

296 replies

imsofancy · 23/12/2023 23:30

Just returned for taking my 13 and 15 year olds to see Wicked at the Apollo in London.

OMG this is the worst show I have ever seen!

The storyline is weak, the singing is screechy and the songs forgettable. Kids hated it too.

We had great seats which cost me +£300, but sooo wish we had left during the interval. I didn't because I think it is rude to the actors but you couldn't pay me to sit through this again.

We go to the theatre a lot and have seen many musicals and straight drama productions. But I wouldn't recommend this show to my worst enemy.

AIBU Wicked the musical is an abomination?

OP posts:
Runnerduck34 · 24/12/2023 09:02

Me and my girls loved wicked so I vote yabu!
Maybe cast wasn't as good on night you saw it- different productions/ casting does make a difference.
I love " popular" and "defying gravity".
But not everyone has the same taste and musicals can be a bit like marmite- love them or hate them.
I think as tickets soo expensive it impacts how you feel about it as expectations are very very high.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 24/12/2023 09:01

Yanbu I hated it, I far as I could tell the show was just one long screechy song, dreadful show.

LittleFishyEyes · 24/12/2023 08:58

Closerandcloser · 24/12/2023 00:14

I saw Phantom of the Opera in London years ago and hated that. Grim miserable sets, the same song/ tune throughout, no one notable in the cast, and I’m sure there were two Christine’s at one point. All in all a poor production that night

And to add insult to injury, I took the advice of the Cab Driver who took me there, and didn’t wait in the queue of taxis at the end of the production, but started walking in the direction he said, it supposedly being easier to pick up a taxi that way

But there were no taxis, or people. Only cars on busy roads, no shops or houses

It was through sheer luck that a taxi dropped some people at their home, and I hurriedly stepped over, and asked if he could take me

It was a wonder I wasn’t murdered that night, I was completely alone in a deserted area

I can't think of anywhere within 10 min walk of Haymarket that is deserted and has a reputation for murdering tourists.

It's one of the busiest parts of town, even at 10pm when the show finishes.

piscesangel · 24/12/2023 08:55

It sounds like it must be very dependent on the cast being good - we did enjoy it but saw it many years ago with Idina Menzel in the lead.

(Would generally say I'm happy watching anything on a stage but as per pp had to leave LOTR musical in the interval - a very low point!)

bruffin · 24/12/2023 08:53

VerticalSausages · 24/12/2023 08:35

Curious to know why some people hated Hamilton - thanks to one PP who explained their view. I thought it was amazing. Such energy in the music right from the beginning, clever word play. Totally engaging throughout despite a fairly serious plot.

Les Mis on the other hand left me cold.

Every body has different tastse I'm not sure why people who start threads like this are so offended that other people like something they dont.
I go to the theatre a lot, I love Hamilton, Les Mis, SIx, Phantom etc seen them all a few times. There is only one show which left me cold which was Everybody Talking about Jamie yet i know it was really popular.

Echobelly · 24/12/2023 08:52

My husband didn't like it all, I thought it was OK but I agree the music is very unmemorable.

peachgreen · 24/12/2023 08:52

So much of it depends on the cast you get. I saw Hamilton twice – once with the original cast, and once in the West End about a year into its run. The first was life-changingly brilliant, the second was dull and hugely disappointing. There’s huge variation.

That said, I don’t like Wicked as a show either – hate the music, a lot of it is in that very top register that I find uncomfortable to listen to.

I’m a bit of a musicals obsessive – went to the theatre two or three times a week when I lived in London and at least one of them would have been a musical. IMO the best are Operation Mincemeat, Waitress and most Sondheims. The recent production of Cabaret is astonishing, although I imagine it depends on what leads you get – I saw Fra Fee and Amy Lennox and it was truly special. Hadestown was great. Parade is amazing. I loved Come From Away. Some of the revivals of older musicals can be really fun – Guys and Dolls is good (although I preferred Chichester one from a few years back), the Old Vic’s High Society was great – but they can also be absolute duds. Controversially I didn’t like Matilda – the lyrics are so clever but it’s too fast to hear them.

For me the worst of all is jukebox musicals. I haven’t seen many because I deliberately avoid them but the ones I have seen were dire. &Juliet is still the only show I’ve ever walked out of. In general I think the big West End shows are usually disappointing – I don’t understand how or why they end up hanging around and continuing to sell tickets but there we are.

Jill23 · 24/12/2023 08:51

I’m not a big fan of musical theatre- but some are better than others. Wicked, however, is the worst! Completely agree, OP.

zizza · 24/12/2023 08:49

YANBU to say you didn't like it - even if I don't understand that sentiment 😋

I think you either love musical theatre or don't. I've seen many shows and loved most of them. Saw Wicked twice back when my kids were younger over 12 years ago I suppose - loved it and love the soundtrack. But as others have said, it would also depend who the leads are as to how good I felt it was on the day.

I find it really hard to say what my favourite musicals are but these are in my top selection:

Come From Away
Les Mis
Dear Evan Hansen
Miss Saigon (original production better for songs, latest one for staging)
Matilda
Book of Mormon (very naughty with it's themes but I laughed so much)
Operation Mincemeat

CocoPlum · 24/12/2023 08:49

YABU, DD and I saw it in the summer (cheap kids week seats). I cried, i got goosebumps and at least once a week she asks when we can go again!

Trusttheprocess1 · 24/12/2023 08:48

Oh God, I’d nearly forgotten about Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. Horrendous !

PotBelliesGiveGoodLoving · 24/12/2023 08:47

I thought musicals were all about the subtext :-)

YouOKHun · 24/12/2023 08:45

I’ve sat through Cats and Phantom of the Opera, both with someone determined to make me see the light regarding musicals as I find them generally toe curling, I don’t really know why. The person trying to convert me went to everything, more than once, but said to me that she wasn’t so keen on Wicked. Given her levels of tolerance for musicals it must be bad.

Trusttheprocess1 · 24/12/2023 08:45

YANBU- it is absolutely crap! Sadly, so many West End hits are but there’s so much hype that utter garbage keeps being churned out. All I kept thinking was that I could be at Matilda; which is a wonderful show and everything a musical should be!

dullandgrey · 24/12/2023 08:42

Agreed, I wasn't a fan. Found it quite boring!

IIdentifyAsInnocent · 24/12/2023 08:41

@imsofancy ive been saying this for years!! I went to see it and my ears hurt from the screeching!!! It's an awful musical!!

CoatOfArms · 24/12/2023 08:39

Haven't seen Wicked, but have seen a lot of musicals as my kids are big fans. Saw Cats a few years ago and yes it's weird and there isn't much of a storyline but we enjoyed it nonetheless. Not a Les Mis fan. Loved the spectacle of the Lion King and enjoyed Matilda too. Probably my favourite though was Hairspray - just a joy. Although that might have been because it was the first thing we saw post-pandemic and the audience was just so giddy to be allowed out again.

VerticalSausages · 24/12/2023 08:35

Curious to know why some people hated Hamilton - thanks to one PP who explained their view. I thought it was amazing. Such energy in the music right from the beginning, clever word play. Totally engaging throughout despite a fairly serious plot.

Les Mis on the other hand left me cold.

Denimdenimdenim · 24/12/2023 08:34

YABVU. I love the show.

HeadNorth · 24/12/2023 08:30

I love musical theatre, I've seen many of the shows mentioned disparagingly on this thread (Wicked, Phantom, Mormon etc) and loved them all. They are hugely popular shows that have run for years, so I don't think you can call them 'shit', but fair enough if they are not to your taste. We all like different things. I cannot imagine anjoying a football match but obviously millions do and spend a lot of money on tickets. Chacun a son gout Grin

bigbadbarry · 24/12/2023 08:29

I’m taking my teens this summer! It’s coming back

Pottedpalm · 24/12/2023 08:29

I saw Wicked on Broadway about 15 years ago and didn’t enjoy it much; rest of the family loved it.
i just don’t like the shouty style if singing these days, especially the kids. Matilda was an assault on the ears. I did enjoy one about Motown as the singing was wonderful.

bigbadbarry · 24/12/2023 08:28

ItsNotOkItsNotTheEnd · 24/12/2023 07:34

YABU. Bat out of hell is the worst musical by far.

100%. Absolutely dreadful

Hobbesmanc · 24/12/2023 08:26

We love Wicked and have been to see it several times. Musicals are our treat to ourselves and we are rarely disappointed in the West End. Cabaret last month was spectacular as was Moulin Rouge. Back to the future was amazing.

9 to 5. The Dolly Parton backed musical of the film was a proper dud and we only once left a show at half time and that was a dire version of Fame in Manchester.