Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disagreement with DH about Xmas day protocol with the children

413 replies

Socksforxmas · 23/12/2023 12:02

DH and I have twin boys who will turn 4 in a few weeks and this Christmas feels really special to us with it being the first one that they seem to understand. Previous Christmases they were too young to really get it but this year they're really excited about the whole thing.

We've run into a disagreement about how the format of the day should be. In my household growing up my brother and I would get up in the morning, open our stockings in bed with a parent and then head into the living room to dive into all the presents (opening all of them), have 2-3 hours of playing with our new things before lunch is served and then family activities for the rest of the night (playing games, watching whatever Christmas specials, all with lots of sweet treats, chocolates, nice drinks etc).

For DH it was get up in the morning, open stockings and then open 1 or 2 presents, leave the rest to go on a family walk around the park, come back for lunch, open a few more presents, do a board game of some kind and then opening the rest of the presents slowly throughout the day, watching the queens speech (only TV allowed on the day). They weren't allowed to play with new toys on the day (that's what boxing day is for and Christmas is for family) and there were strict rules regarding how much sweets they were allowed. Also a church visit at some point.

With the exception of going church and watching the queens(kings) speech which he has no interest in doing, he wants to pretty much recreate his parents way of doing Christmas as he thinks it's a good way of teaching the boys about the importance of family time and delayed gratification. I see where he's coming from but tbh it all sounds a bit miserable to me...

Every other day of the year we're fairly strict about our the twins diets, amount of screen time, and teaching them to be patient, respectful of others and they are for the majority of time very well behaved children who abide our rules well. I always thought of Christmas as being the one day a year where they could just go nuts and not have so much restriction and control on them. I'd like them to be able to tear into all their presents right away, have time to play with their new things etc

Aibu to think Christmas should be an exception to the usual strict and fairly controlled environment they're in or do DHs ideas have more merit?

OP posts:
azlazee1 · 23/12/2023 16:27

I'm surprised your husband wants to continue his XMAS traditions. Did he really enjoy getting presents and not being allowed to play with them> I know each family has its own traditions - in our house we did stockings, had breakfast and then opened presents. It should be a day of joy and celebration, not a day of restrictions. Hope you can work this out for your children's sake.

Tandora · 23/12/2023 16:19

nonevernotever · 23/12/2023 12:10

Couldn't you compromise a bit? Do his morning with stockings, a couple of presents, walk and then lunch, and do your afternoon opening the rest of the presents and playing with them, the nearly evening for nibbles and board games?

This. Nobody is right or wrong it’s just a diff way of doing things. Just find a compromise between the two?

SauronsArsehole · 23/12/2023 16:18

nonevernotever · 23/12/2023 12:10

Couldn't you compromise a bit? Do his morning with stockings, a couple of presents, walk and then lunch, and do your afternoon opening the rest of the presents and playing with them, the nearly evening for nibbles and board games?

Yea this!

opening small presents in the morning and saving the big presents for after lunch and having a walk (unless they have bikes then bikes first for the walk!) seems like a great compromise.

kids are going to struggle with the waiting but DO benefit from having things in smaller chunks can aid in preventing overwhelm, tantrums etc and as you have twins this could be even worse

could you separate gifts and start a tradition of the morning Xmas stocking and the ‘after lunch Xmas sack’ with board games and play after present opening.

when DC was little I separated but we’d do half Xmas day which were my gifts , half Boxing Day which were extended family gifts. Because we’d set this up early we didn’t have any tantrums over the waiting of the gifts.

TheShellBeach · 23/12/2023 16:15

Why would you go for a walk?

KenIsAnAccessory · 23/12/2023 16:14

Interesting the comments re him being middle class/stuck up.

I was a council estate kid and we were made to space our gifts out through the day, roughly one every hour and a half.

Anyway, your way is soooooo much more fun. I learned this after initially being horrified that this is what DHs (middle class!) family do.

Your suggested compromise is good, or alternatively ask to do it your way this year to see if I likes it? I bet he will!

misskatamari · 23/12/2023 16:04

YANBU! DHs Christmas sounds so controlled and depressing. Where’s the fun and the joy? No way would I be putting all these tiles and restrictions in! Your way 100%!

Fernsfernsferns · 23/12/2023 16:01

Socksforxmas · 23/12/2023 14:05

He does sound really joyless - is he normally like that?

Honestly, no. He's a bit of a black sheep in his immediate family for being a lot less stuffy and stuck up. He's normally pretty down to earth and probably a lot more the 'fun' parent than me most of the time. It was honestly a bit of a shock to me when he said he wanted to do Christmas this way because it's very at odds with the fact that he usually criticises many aspects of how he grew up and has a lot of resentment towards his dad in particular for many things.

Not read all the posts here but this is about the deeper question of building your own family.

you both have a subconscious belief that the way your family did it when you were young is the right way.

it is about bringing this to the surface and taking it over and then agreeing which bits of your childhood traditions you bring in, maybe with some new ideas too, to create your own family traditions

personally I don’t think spacing out present opening necessary makes kids appreciate them more.

and I like Xmas for being a time when kids can do more of what they choose eg open all their presents at once if they want to

now they are a little older me of mine does this then goes back through to choose what to play with first. The other likes to play as they go so takes longer to open everything

neither way is ‘better’

NotARealWookiie · 23/12/2023 16:01

We used to have stockings first thing and “tree presents” (family and friends) just after lunch. On the years we didn’t even sit down for dinner until 3/4 it was such a long slog… this said I do think it’s nice to save a few presents for the afternoon, could you compromise with some before lunch and some after lunch?

SussexLass87 · 23/12/2023 15:53

His version of Christmas Day sounds like such a lot of hard work, you'll all be miserable (not just the kids!)

Playing with the new toys together sounds like a lovely way to spend the day (and get the family time that he's focussed on)

AintNoPartyLikeANumber10Party · 23/12/2023 15:50

@Socksforxmas my mother had a similar set format for Christmas Day - which was the same when we were little and adult. She probably still does it exactly the same way, but I wouldn’t know… as I’ve not attended her joyless, rigid Christmas in over 30 years.

And even she didn’t insist we had to keep new toys in their packets until Boxing Day - that’s insane. 🤯

Tell your DH to reconsider his Christmas routine.

Cherrysoup · 23/12/2023 15:49

Your Dh sounds like Victorian dad. Is he really intending to ban the children from playing with their new items on Christmas Day? How sadistic. That’s a horrible cruel ‘tradition’. Going for a walk, lovely, but that alone ticks his ‘delayed gratification’ box, particularly if, like me, you have bouncy dogs who don’t care about presents. They’ll have to wait to play with toys if you leave the house. Do you have family staying?

ButterflyOil · 23/12/2023 15:47

It’s so interesting how many people hold resentment for things their parents did but then go on to do the same thing to their own kids. The pull of family ‘tradition’ can be incredibly strong.

I think your compromiser sound good. I’d talk to him about how he felt at Xmas and did he actually enjoy them and feel joy? And if not why he thinks it’s a wise idea to repeat a pattern like this. As for the kids going feral, honestly it’s a but more likely they’d rebel as they got older (maybe like another ‘black sheep’ your husband might know ;)) if they are too strictly regimented.

A but of excitement and indulgence for one special day of the year is not going to harm your kids. What’s more likely to harm them is this feeling of being restricted, control and restraint of natural excitement. They only have very few truly magical Xmases, tell your husband to let them be exuberant little kids for this one day - god knows we all get too little of that in life!

ClareBlue · 23/12/2023 15:46

I think we might be a bit strange. We did one family present Christmas Eve, stocking no restriction am at anytime after 7am. Tree presents one after church then rest after 2pm dinner and keep one family prrsent for evening and one for boxing day. Ours never had an issue with it. Would never had had the all at once free for all. I notice they are all doing the spread over 2 days as adults now. It seems it's whatever you are used to and liked as a child or probably more what you didn't like, is the important factor.

minicheddars87 · 23/12/2023 15:45

mycatcontrolsmylife · 23/12/2023 15:38

I suppose every day's a party for your little darlings who presumably are sat in front a screen eating nothing but nuggets and wotsits all day when they're not throwing a tantrum in the Asda sweets aisle...

😂🤣😂🤣👏🏻👏🏻

Somepeoplearesnippy · 23/12/2023 15:43

This is a chance for the two of you to compromise and make new traditions. Don't waste time quarrelling about which families habits were better - make plans to take the best of both each way and combine them into something that works well for all of you. It will change over time to become your own traditions.

When D.C. were little they used to be overwhelmed by having too many new presents and special food all at once so we evolved a practice of just opening stockings on Christmas morning. They had the day to play with those smaller presents and enjoy family time and church. On Boxing Day when the house was quieter they opened wrapped presents from us and relations and had time to really appreciate them. They were quite shocked when they went to school and discovered other families opened everything on Christmas morning. They felt sorry for the children who only had one special day at Christmas. They are in their 30s now and we still do it that way.

Prometheus · 23/12/2023 15:42

I had the same discussion with DH when we first had kids. He is from a middle class family and did the whole delayed gratification thing- had to eat a big breakfast, get showered and dressed before opening any presents. I’m from a working class family and it was dive into the presents whilst wearing PJs and drinking Buck’s Fizz. Happy to say that my way won out 😀

mycatcontrolsmylife · 23/12/2023 15:40

I'd do your idea but spreading the presents over morning and lunchtime. But I agree with some comments about trying to let your sons lead to an extent.

JustAGirlScotland · 23/12/2023 15:39

Christmas is all about spending fun relaxing time with family - not rules!

Growing up, my parents were careful with my diet however Christmas was a noted exception!

The very idea of telling small children they have to wait to open gifts they've probably been looking forward to for weeks sounds completely controlling and miserable all round.

Can your husband HONESTLY say he enjoyed his childhood?

mycatcontrolsmylife · 23/12/2023 15:38

Bumblebeestiltskin · 23/12/2023 15:08

If their day-to-day life is, as you say, 'strict and controlled', aka joyless, why bother giving them one day a year that's full of joy? They'll only feel worse when they go back to joyless on boxing day.

I suppose every day's a party for your little darlings who presumably are sat in front a screen eating nothing but nuggets and wotsits all day when they're not throwing a tantrum in the Asda sweets aisle...

theduchessofspork · 23/12/2023 15:35

We always opened most of them after dinner, for both of us as kids and now with the kids - which I think makes sense because it’s dark so you can’t go out, plus daytime guests are there

We opened a couple in the morning, and went out for a run around at some point.

Wasn’t at all joyless but not letting a child play with a present they’ve opened really is - that is strange

Nitw1t · 23/12/2023 15:24

Do you have to decide on advance? Can you not take the twins' lead a bit?

I grew up in a "presents all at once before lunch" house. But now we're a "stockings in the morning first thing and then one gift at a time throughout the day" house. It's just evolved that way over the years (DCs are 7 and 9). DC1 used to get a bit overwhelmed doing all at once (I think the year he was 4/nearly 5 it took us days to open his presents because he didn't like the pressure!), and DS2 likes to play with everything as it comes out.

At 4 yo, I'd definitely want to keep some telly time on the agenda to encourage some down time, and keep a little control on the chocolates (one of mine would eat himself sick at that age, given a totally free rein).

margotrose · 23/12/2023 15:19

FastingBitchFace · 23/12/2023 15:16

That gives a reason and focus for it, otherwise it's just enforced fresh air without the fun of a park.

But the walk could be to the park so the kids can play, or to the beach (if you're nearby) or to somewhere with a nature trail, or somewhere for them to ride bikes/scooters or play football etc.

A walk doesn't just mean trudging around your estate for an hour!

MikeRafone · 23/12/2023 15:18

Waiting to open Xmas present until Xmas day is the delayed gratification. They’ve waited during December and the build up to Xmas

to then ban the children from playing with the toys they have received is not delayed gratification.

also not all the toys will be from your dh, other people will have given gifts, to ban the children from being allowed to play with gifts from others is over the top nonsense and unnecessary

Wtfammaduck · 23/12/2023 15:18

Let the kids go wild first thing.

It makes the day an anti-climax dragging it all out over hours.

FastingBitchFace · 23/12/2023 15:16

Miyagi99 · 23/12/2023 13:13

Some people loved walking as a child, I know I did (still do) but we always had a dog.

That gives a reason and focus for it, otherwise it's just enforced fresh air without the fun of a park.

Swipe left for the next trending thread