Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disagreement with DH about Xmas day protocol with the children

413 replies

Socksforxmas · 23/12/2023 12:02

DH and I have twin boys who will turn 4 in a few weeks and this Christmas feels really special to us with it being the first one that they seem to understand. Previous Christmases they were too young to really get it but this year they're really excited about the whole thing.

We've run into a disagreement about how the format of the day should be. In my household growing up my brother and I would get up in the morning, open our stockings in bed with a parent and then head into the living room to dive into all the presents (opening all of them), have 2-3 hours of playing with our new things before lunch is served and then family activities for the rest of the night (playing games, watching whatever Christmas specials, all with lots of sweet treats, chocolates, nice drinks etc).

For DH it was get up in the morning, open stockings and then open 1 or 2 presents, leave the rest to go on a family walk around the park, come back for lunch, open a few more presents, do a board game of some kind and then opening the rest of the presents slowly throughout the day, watching the queens speech (only TV allowed on the day). They weren't allowed to play with new toys on the day (that's what boxing day is for and Christmas is for family) and there were strict rules regarding how much sweets they were allowed. Also a church visit at some point.

With the exception of going church and watching the queens(kings) speech which he has no interest in doing, he wants to pretty much recreate his parents way of doing Christmas as he thinks it's a good way of teaching the boys about the importance of family time and delayed gratification. I see where he's coming from but tbh it all sounds a bit miserable to me...

Every other day of the year we're fairly strict about our the twins diets, amount of screen time, and teaching them to be patient, respectful of others and they are for the majority of time very well behaved children who abide our rules well. I always thought of Christmas as being the one day a year where they could just go nuts and not have so much restriction and control on them. I'd like them to be able to tear into all their presents right away, have time to play with their new things etc

Aibu to think Christmas should be an exception to the usual strict and fairly controlled environment they're in or do DHs ideas have more merit?

OP posts:
GenXisthebest · 23/12/2023 12:47

Socksforxmas · 23/12/2023 12:28

I'm slightly amazed by how many of you have managed to guess that DH is from a very posh, middle class family based on his Christmas 😂😂 He is indeed, whereas my background is working class council estate. I never really knew of anyone doing Christmas too differently to how my family did until I met DH.

In theory compromising could work but we're still disagreeing on exactly how to compromise, although some suggestions I've seen already could work out! I'm definitely repeating some of these to him when he's back from work.

If I were you OP, I'd focus on the bit about them not being allowed to play with their new toys on Christmas Day. That's the bit that I wouldn't be able to compromise on personally. The bit about opening them more slowly, with family stuff going on in between, could be the bit you give him in return. And maybe meet in the middle regarding how many sweets they're allowed?

SmileyClare · 23/12/2023 12:46

Delayed gratification is having an advent calendar, counting down the days of the month until Christmas isn’t it? That’s a long wait for a 4 year old!

Its not giving gifts and then stopping them enjoying them. There’s no positive lesson for a child in doing that.

ManateeFair · 23/12/2023 12:45

presents anyway because everything gets thoroughly examined before he starts on the next one

Haha, my brother and I were both like this. Used to drive my sister, who is ten years older than me, mad. When I was about nine, she said “Mum, if you’ve got Manatee books, just remember to put them at the bottom of her pile so she opens them last. Otherwise she’ll read all from cover to cover before she actually opens anything else and we’ll still be here at Easter.”

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 23/12/2023 12:45

We spread presents out throughout the day, simply because it means then that each present is given more attention, rather than being cast aside in search of the Big Shiny. However, it might be worth putting the unopened presents aside somewhere with four year olds, because the constant 'is it time for another? IS it? IS IT? Well, WHEN??' might drive you mad.
I am not an advocate of the 'dive in, rip it all open' school of thought, but rationing too strictly might be a nightmare, which is why I'd do stockings, breakfast, some presents, dinner, some presents (which have been put away out of sight), walk, play - then maybe one last and final present before bed.

Nagado · 23/12/2023 12:45

He wasn’t allowed to play with his new toys until Boxing Day? That’s insane!

Point out to him that he’s not in charge and he doesn’t get to unilaterally decide what happens on Christmas Day. If he doesn’t want to go along with your plans, then fair enough, but that means that a compromise has to be reached between you.

We’ve got a two year old with us this year who is getting very excited about Santa, even though he doesn’t quite understand it means new toys yet. He has been spoilt rotten so we’re going to be guided by him. If he opens one present and wants to ignore the rest and spend the day playing with it, or the box it came in, then that’s fine with us. We just want him to have a lovely, lovely day. There’s not much point in going to all the trouble of building up excitement and a bit of magic, just to make the day full of rules and restrictions.

EveryOtherNameTaken · 23/12/2023 12:45

nonevernotever · 23/12/2023 12:10

Couldn't you compromise a bit? Do his morning with stockings, a couple of presents, walk and then lunch, and do your afternoon opening the rest of the presents and playing with them, the nearly evening for nibbles and board games?

Yep. This is what I would do. Good compromise.

ExtraOnions · 23/12/2023 12:44

I’m the youngest of 5 … I have such happy memories of Christmas Mornings in the 70s/80s, where we would all just dive in. Paper everywhere, happy squeals, lots of “what did you get” or “this one’s for you .. absolute mayhem .. it was brilliant.

lots of parents seem to think that Christmas is about them, and how much enjoyment they get around present opening … it’s not about you folks..

FedUpMumof10YO · 23/12/2023 12:44

I never get why people insist on a walk on Christmas Day 🤷‍♀️

PotatoAloo · 23/12/2023 12:44

There's a time and a place for teaching delayed gratification. Christmas Day ain't it.

There are 364 other days for that (well, maybe 363 - unless they're not allowed to have fun on birthdays either?).

Also, teaching kids that "family time" and "fun time" are entirely separate things is not very wise imo.

Friedfriedplantain · 23/12/2023 12:44

You go and see, then you say time to go and have a walk or do whatever now, presents in a bit?

Benibidibici · 23/12/2023 12:44

Maybe remind your DH that the royals don't wait til after the speech to have their presents, they have them on Christmas eve along with loads of other people in Europe.

laclochette · 23/12/2023 12:43

I think both ways have their merits, try not to put value judgements on either as it won't help either of you. I know he's doing that already so that goes for him too! Ultimately we always internalise what's familiar as what's right and then find ways to postrationalise that.

Perhaps there's a compromise, as others have said. Maybe stockings and gifts from Santa in the morning and then gifts from other people after lunch and a walk? We always saved some gifts until after lunch and it actually made the day more fun as it wasn't all over in the morning, from a kid's perspective. It also made making the list of who gave what to whom, for writing thank you letters, a bit less difficult and chaotic!

It isn't that hard to find a middle ground here from an objective point of view, it's the emotions swirling around it that are making you both set up camps at opposite ends of the spectrum.

SgtJuneAckland · 23/12/2023 12:43

DS naturally opens presents throughout the day, birthday this year took him a week, he likes to play with/use things as he opens them and when we're at home for Christmas we all like to go for a walk on the beach ,so it wouldn't be a hardship here

SmileyClare · 23/12/2023 12:43

Christmas should be an exception to the strict and controlled environment they’re usually in

Is this the first time you’ve butted heads about parenting?
I get the impression your dh is a bit draconian.

ChimChimeny · 23/12/2023 12:42

Boomboom22 · 23/12/2023 12:15

Stockings on their own, civilised breakfast then all presents but 1 at a time, with the paper recycling as you go piling them up so they know what they have.

this is how.We do it and both did as children so someone could write a list.of who bought what so.We can thank them.

We went to the in-laws one year, DD (age 5/6) was made to wait to open her big pile.of presents until BIL, SIL and DN arrived and it was torture for her, they were late as well which just prolonged it. So having a pile of presents they aren't allowed to open is going to lead. To.some tantrums I reckon

CherriesInChocolate · 23/12/2023 12:42

Nip out today and buy some gorgeous lingerie, maybe an adult toy for couples. Gift them to him on Xmas Eve ‘for later’. When he thinks he’s on a promise let him know you’re just helping him practice delayed gratification.

Dibblydoodahdah · 23/12/2023 12:40

Ours is a combination of both DH’s and my family traditions. DCs open their stockings and their main present from us on waking up. The rest of the family presents under the tree are opened after lunch. They can play all day except when eating dinner, although they do enjoy family board games and family computer games on the Switch so there is plenty of family time. When I was a child everything was opened first thing in the morning and it drives my DF crazy that the kids (and him) have to wait until after lunch. I
much prefer our way of doing it though and the DC never moan.

Friedfriedplantain · 23/12/2023 12:40

When I was little we got up, were allowed to just look at presents to see if Santa had been, bundled off to church (Catholic mother lol) back, were allowed to open stockings, long wait till late lunch, then presents.

Apart from church in the freezing cold, I don't think I'd have changed it. We were a large family without much money and my mum worked so hard on finding us small gifts so we'd have more to open but that weren't too rubbish. She wanted to see us do it.

Would hate to just let my kids just go and open presents first thing because I would have hated that, having it all over so quickly. Also because we don't buy a huge amount. DC get bought more toys and things through the year than I ever did, they get nice presents to make Christmas special but not loads of them. But I don't dole out through the day either and it's nothing to do with teaching self-control, I just want a nice calm atmosphere and to spread out the fun a bit. We do stockings, breakfast, presents, lunch, and they're always allowed to get out and play with whatever they want.

When we go to my parents' Christmas is very noisy with all my adult siblings and their kids which is lovely too, my kids seem to like both kinds of day in different ways.

mrsjg · 23/12/2023 12:40

I prefer your idea of how it should go, pretty much like mine was growing up except we opened stockings with the present.

Stresa22 · 23/12/2023 12:39

I still remember my first Christmas with middle class DH family and not opening gifts until after 4pm. Of course everyone started drinking at breakfast!

ManateeFair · 23/12/2023 12:38

They weren't allowed to play with new toys on the day

That’s genuinely horrible. Imagine opening the present of your dreams, aged four, and then being told you weren’t allowed to play with it. It’s not teaching them anything except that Daddy likes withholding nice things from you, on the one day of the year when everyone’s meant to have fun.

Fair enough if people want to open their ‘stocking’ presents in the morning and their ‘tree’ presents later, but spinning it out throughout the day and not even letting them play with any of it just seems unnecessarily mean.

Last time I saw my dad he was reminiscing about how much he used to enjoy Christmas morning when we were kids/teens and we all used to open our presents together, and then how he used to like helping us set up whatever complicated thing we’d got that required assembly, or playing a new game with us, or sitting with us and looking through new books with us etc.

Pallisers · 23/12/2023 12:36

Dh's family were a bit like this. His father sat in state and handed out presents one at a time. It lasted all afternoon and evening after lunch. (mind you even dh's parents never came up with a ban on actually using or playing your presents on xmas day - that is bizarre).

My family had stockings in the morning - opened them in our parents rooms. and then later opened presents. not in a frenzy but not at a glacial pace either. Then the rest of the afternoon was for playing/reading/talking/whatever. We tend to do that except we include a walk too and have dinner rather than lunch.

I've had an otherwise lovely family christmas with dh's extended family but tbh the opening of presents went on all day long and I found it very tedious. no focus on playing a game or talking or being together just as if the entire point of christmas was the things we got.

(Also I think maybe we didn't give enough stuff to our kids to make it last all day.)

We were out with two other married couples last night and all of us were saying how you come together with 2 different ideas of christmas traditions and then you figure out what your family will do - then your kids grow up thinking this is the best way to do christmas, meet someone else, and the whole figuring it out for your own family starts again.

One lovely memory I have of Christmas day was my mum upturned the rules. So every day of the year we were expected to ask for treats. On christmas day if we said "may I have some chocolate" she would pretend to get cross with us because the rule was you couldn't ask for it - you just took it. It felt very exciting to a small child.

Teaching delayed gratification to a 4 year old on christmas day - why that day of all days??

margotrose · 23/12/2023 12:36

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 23/12/2023 12:20

So how does that work when a child wants to see if Santa has been?
Are we assuming it's the stocking from Santa? Because plenty of children get a stocking and other gifts from the big man.

If I did a stocking for my 4yr old up in bed he would still want to see if Santa had eaten the mince pie and drank the whisky in the living room. How do you drag a child away from that?!

It was my "normal" so it's just what I was used to. We never did presents before breakfast so I never expected it, really. Yes, I was excited but actually it meant that excitement lasted all morning rather than all the presents being done with by 7am.

Kids adapt to whatever you choose.

Benibidibici · 23/12/2023 12:34

I don't mind a walk at some point, and i agree with trying to properly engage with the kids rather than putting tv/screens on, board games etc are fun (my kids love board games).

But i hate trying to spread presents through the day. All the fun is the running downstairs to find father christmas has been and enjoying opening. We try and do stockings then breakfast then tree presents, but we are definitely getting stuck into those presents by 8.30am

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 23/12/2023 12:34

Your DH obviously has fond memories of the way his family did Christmas and didn’t find it miserable or he wouldn’t be wanting to replicate it

I'm not sure - he says it a good way to teach them about delayed gratification. That isn't necessarily fond memories.

Christmas is delayed gratification anyway. We made our cake in October, and decorated it yesterday and DD (4) knows she can't eat it yet. As she gets older she'll be more aware that we have presents in the house that she can't have yet. I think it's completely pointless and mean to give a 4 year old a toy to unwrap and get excited about, and then say "nope, no playing until tomorrow!"