Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would it upset you if people thought you were grandparents and not parents?

238 replies

familiesarrggghhhhh · 23/12/2023 10:52

This has happened twice to me now. First time in after school club, gave the names of my DC and the lady said “are you the grandma” - erm no I’m not

then last week we were at a park with the DC on their bikes, a couple in their 70’s walked past and said “it’s lovely coming out with the grandkids isn’t it”

I was mortified. I’m 43 so yes I’m an older mum. I have 4 year old twins. My DH is 51 but I honestly don’t think I look like a grandma.

AIBU to be upset and feel a bit down by it or is it just part and parcel of being an “older” mum. But then I think this isn’t 30 years ago, I was 38 when I had my twins (ok I turned 39 when they were 4 weeks old 😂)

we definitely didn’t plan it this way, we went through 5 rounds of IVF to get our twins.

just feeling a little sensitive as I’m also right in the middle of peri menopause, and this just feels like another kick in the teeth

OP posts:
SquashPenguin · 23/12/2023 16:37

I swear the average age of a mum where I live is about 17, at least it feels that way in my antenatal clinics. I’m 37 so I feel ancient up to them. But at the same time I honestly couldn’t care less! Just enjoy making them feel awkward when you point out their mistake 😆

Asparagus1 · 23/12/2023 16:37

My friend is 7 years older than me, in her early 40s, her hair has gone fully light grey. Twice when we’ve been out together people have thought we were mother and daughter! I think sometimes people don’t even look at people properly and have just thought she’s older because of the grey hair!

I had children young and my eldest is 17, people have thought we were sisters in the past!

Try not to be upset about it x

WhichIsItWendy · 23/12/2023 16:33

Tandora · 23/12/2023 16:06

I reckon it’s more common for a dad to have a kid at 47 (they would not necessarily even be first child) than at 16 or below (even in the previous generation), but I may be wrong! Either way one is not obviously way more common than other.

Edited

I agree, neither is probably much more likely. Hence someone who's 50 with a 4 year old as a first child (or twins) needs to expect that SOME people will assume they're a grandparent. In the same way many people have rightly assumed he's the dad at other times.

NaughtybutNice77 · 23/12/2023 16:31

Assuming they're making these comments because you look physically older than your years then yes I'd be upset, however if I'd always looked a bit older I would have learnt to live with it by now I think.
Let's say you look 50...plenty of grandmas, less mums at that age so reasonable assumption. Is there anything you can do to improve your physical looks? What about your cloithing/style? If there is, is it worth the effort needed? Only you can decide.
Statistically some of us will look older, some younger and some about our actual age. Similarly some will be prettier than average, and some will be downright ugly.
I'm wondering if this isnt something you've had a lifetime to get used to. Maybe you've always looked a little older but looked 'matched' to your husband so no comments. I mean, what would they even say. Or maybe having 2 young children at your age (stress of infertility?) has aged you and your now noticing. If this is the case make some time for you if you look 'unhealthy'. If not its business as usual. You seem to have what you wanted, a husband and children...

mumsytoon · 23/12/2023 16:28

I don't think it's your age. I'm an older mum too but this is normal now. I do think kids age you though. I did this myself. Assumed the mum was the grandma. I genuinely thought so though.

familiesarrggghhhhh · 23/12/2023 16:23

Thank you everyone

it’s all so subjective isn’t it. When I look back 5 years ago I do think I look very different. Twins are brutal, and throw in some health conditions, periods of extended stress, various hospital admissions it has taken its toll. Im trying to get HRT but as usual with the GP’s at the moment it’s very difficult.

sorry I really didn’t mean to drip feed, I do need a I lose weight but I regularly have my hair highlighted and my eyelashes & brows dyed.

I guess it just comes with the territory, I will try to grow a thicker skin and laugh it off

OP posts:
Calliopespa · 23/12/2023 16:13

familiesarrggghhhhh · 23/12/2023 11:01

To be honest I think I’m very sensitive about my looks at the moment, I don’t feel particularly great, and I could do with losing a stone (or two). Maybe it’s the kick up the butt I need

I’m not sure it’s got as much to do with your looks as their expectations. A couple of stone weight loss won’t make you look 29. Weirdly, I mean that to be comforting 😶

moderationincludingmoderation · 23/12/2023 16:12

My DH is 55, I'm a young looking 40, and our DD is 10.
When DD was little people often mistook my DH for being her GF and my DF. We laughed it off.
But it's understandable it would make you feel a bit shit! I think its more just because after 40 it all starts getting real and being mistaken for GM instead of M would feel shit!

InfamousPartyAnimal · 23/12/2023 16:10

It depends. Some people in their early/mid 40's still look 'vibrant' if not younger than their age. I'm thinking hair done, discreet nicely applied makeup and well fitting clothes. Some people of the same age have salt and pepper hair, wear ill fitting clothes and could do with plenty of moisturiser for their face!
It's obvious which one would get the 'grandma' comments!!
Most of the older mums I know take care of themselves and no-one has asked if they are the grandma, it wouldn't enter people's minds to ask.

Mintygoodness · 23/12/2023 16:07

I also think if the couple who said this were older they were BabyBoomers and young adults in 1965-1985. In the 60s and 70s it was very typical to get married in your early 20s and have kids, so for their generation plenty of their peers would've been grandparents in their 40s/50s. It's from the 1990s onward that the average age of a new mother has crept up to the 30s.

Calliopespa · 23/12/2023 16:07

Not an older mum today OP. Maybe in an earlier generation. I think it can be area specific too. Areas with a higher density of professional women tend to have more older mums.

Tandora · 23/12/2023 16:06

WhichIsItWendy · 23/12/2023 16:01

That may well be the case, but it's not common for dads of 4 year olds to be 50+. Both are probably rare.

I reckon it’s more common for a dad to have a kid at 47 (they would not necessarily even be first child) than at 16 or below (even in the previous generation), but I may be wrong! Either way one is not obviously way more common than other.

Sophierx89 · 23/12/2023 16:02

I wouldn't think too much into it, people make mistakes and they don't know you or your age and have just made an assumption. My dad is 52 and is grandad to my almost 12 year old and gets mistaken for her dad, I've been mistaken for his wife! 🤮😅

WhichIsItWendy · 23/12/2023 16:01

Tandora · 23/12/2023 15:57

Well your DH is for sure far more likely to be a Grandad

For this to be the case , there would need to be two generations who had their kids in their early 20s. Average age for first time dads these days is 33.6 years and women is 30.9.

If a maternal grandfather and mum had kids at average age, then the generation before dad would have needed to be 16 to make him 47 when twin DC were born. If a paternal grandad he would have needed to have them at 13!!

So basically it’s bollox that he’s far more likely to be granddad.

Edited

That may well be the case, but it's not common for dads of 4 year olds to be 50+. Both are probably rare.

WhichIsItWendy · 23/12/2023 15:58

Chances are you look slightly older than your age and your 50yr old husband probably sways peoples views too. 50 is old for having 4 year olds, that's not a judgement, its just reality. In my child's Y1 class, most dad's are 30s and then maybe 25% are in their early-mid 40s.

You're going to have to grow a thicker skin and accept that's what comes with being an older mum. People wouldn't say it to be cruel, they obviously just see you as more of a grandparent age.

I have a mum friend who's 43 and looks amazing, in no way does she look like a grandma. But if you look older, then you can't blame people assuming that. Again, no judgement, there's no shame in looking older; we all look as we look.

Mintygoodness · 23/12/2023 15:57

My brother's eldest son was born when his parents were 17 in 1989. They subsequently went on marry other people and have two more kids each. This son (call him Dan) joined the army and had a daughter with his gf when they were 28. So my bro was a grandad when he was in his 40s (and me a great-aunt 😄). He absolutely loves it so has a 6 year old granddaughter and he is 53. Of course if Dan had become a dad at this same age as his parents my bro would have been a grandad at 34.

Tandora · 23/12/2023 15:57

KnowThyself · 23/12/2023 11:00

Well your DH is for sure far more likely to be a Grandad and you are at an age where you could be a Grandma. No one has meant to offend you. I just think it’s going to happen. I have taken to deliberately saying oh I thought you were their Mum to women when they say they are a grandma and are under about 75.

Well your DH is for sure far more likely to be a Grandad

For this to be the case , there would need to be two generations who had their kids in their early 20s. Average age for first time dads these days is 33.6 years and women is 30.9.

If a maternal grandfather and mum had kids at average age, then the generation before dad would have needed to be 16 to make him 47 when twin DC were born. If a paternal grandad he would have needed to have them at 13!!

So basically it’s bollox that he’s far more likely to be granddad.

tillytoodles1 · 23/12/2023 15:54

My sister was born when my mum was 41, I was 15.
People always presumed I was the mum and my mum was the granny.

SpiritedSneeze · 23/12/2023 15:49

I wouldn't ve offended by it, as its not like they are assuming you are older than you are. 40s and 50s is perfectly normal and common grandparent age for small children. So you are just as likely to be the childrens grandparents as you are their parents. If you were out with some 20 year olds and they asked if you were their grandparents then that would be rude.

Your partners age probably skews their opinion more, as a man in his 50s will appear to be more grandparent aged as its easy to presume his children would be in their 20s or 30s not under 5.
Its not offensive- they just made a mistake.

Vegetus · 23/12/2023 15:46

Been doing the open day rounds at potential schools last few months and a lot of older mums do look old. I'm not surprised it's knackering running after a 4 year old. I'm just 31 and it's put a decade on me!

NonSequentialRhubarb · 23/12/2023 15:39

If it happens when you're with your husband, it's probably his age skewing things. I probably wouldn't assume a 51 year old was the father of 4 year olds. So if I thought he was grandad, I guess I'd assume you were step-grandma even if you were too young to be biological one (you're not, but you get my point).

If it happens when you're alone, it's strange. Do you live in an area with a lot of younger mothers? As in, 20somethings? That's the only reason I can think of, unless you look significantly older than your age. Older mums aren't the majority where I am, but they're common enough that I don't think people would assume you were grandma.

TiredOfSayingItAgain · 23/12/2023 15:39

I was out with my 6 MONTH old GC recently and was mistaken for the mum! I'm 64 and my eldest AC is 43

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 23/12/2023 15:36

Mairzydotes · 23/12/2023 15:19

I would be annoyed because I hate people making assumptions about me from how they think I look .

That being said , often it's noticeable when kids are with their grandparents because the gp are more relaxed around the children and have different body language ( because the gp know they can send them back to their parents) . Maybe they picked up that vibe from you.
Parents tend to be more frazzled with their kids, and that's not age specific to the parents.

I notice this - you can always tell when they’re the parents because they look frazzled, stressed and like they haven’t had a good night’s sleep in 2 years.

meganorks · 23/12/2023 15:33

I can see why you find it upsetting and I would too. But you are old enough to be a grandma as well. I'm a similar age and plenty of people I went to school with are grandparents. I think you are taking it as you look at least 60 (or at least whatever the grandma image is when it pops into your head!), but that's not how old most grandparents are.

At our school I think we have quite a diverse range of ages of mothers, but veering towards older. Whereas other schools I have visited seem to be mostly young mums. Could it be the area you live in is more on the young mum side?

MaryShelley1818 · 23/12/2023 15:26

I'd be mortified! I'm 45yrs with DS6 and DD2 and it's never happened to me yet luckily.

Swipe left for the next trending thread