Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed by these comments from MIL? How to respond?

194 replies

mamamanda · 22/12/2023 21:08

Just arrived at MIL's house for Xmas and the comments are already pouring in from her. Any good responses? She always saying similar things

A) we arrive today and my husband asks if she minds washing a jumper that our DC spilt juice on on our way here. Her response "oh did Amy [me] not have time to wash it at home?!"
B) acts like I'm not in the room. So says things like "oh finally!!! I've missed you two so much" ie my DH and DC. Not even a "hello" to me until about 5mins after I've entered
C) "you're looking slim! Is mummy not making you nice food?" to my DC who is nearly 3
D) "ah why are they taking you away? You'd have so much more fun here with me!" about the fact we are leaving them mid next week to spend some time with my side of the family
E) when she discovered my bilingual DC doesn't know some English nursery rhymes (knows a lot more in my language, I'm a SAHM) "oh does mummy never sing with you?!"

I don't want to start explaining myself or justifying my choices like "oh actually I do sing!" Or "she has fun with my family too!" because I shouldn't have to justify my choices to her...but I do want to stand up for myself.

Never had a big argument and she just started being cold shortly after our engagement (5yrs ago)
DH either says he didn't hear something she said, wasn't there or she doesn't mean anything by it.

OP posts:
Beago1dfish · 22/12/2023 21:51

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 22/12/2023 21:43

"ah why are they taking you away?"

"Because you're a cow"

Bloody love this 😂😂😂😂

Avatartar · 22/12/2023 21:51

isthewashingdryyet · 22/12/2023 21:15

When you DH comes back in the room,

darling listen to this, so funny, your mum thinks I don’t sing with our baby. Tell her I never stop

your mum is making me laugh so much, she thinks we won’t have fun with my family, tell her about my dad making you laugh last t8me we were there

sweetheart, your mum thinks I don’t feed our baby, go on, tell her how much the baby eats

all said with a huge smile on your face as if she is the funniest person you have ever met.

the tinkling laugh is useful here too.

she is not a nice woman at all is she

Yes go with this, not criticising her but giving her remarks a full audience to amplify her attempt to undermine you

minicheddars87 · 22/12/2023 21:51

You'd have to be very wilfully obtuse to not see how these remarks are hurtful. I have no doubt that she knows what shes doing.

I second the poster who suggested the 'silly granny' comments. Two can play at being a passive aggressive bint.

PercyPigInAWig · 22/12/2023 21:50

Zanatdy · 22/12/2023 21:39

Sorry but I think you’re being unreasonable and overthinking what are probably innocent remarks. Stop looking for fault and try and enjoy Christmas, she may not be your favourite person but she’s your partners mother and I’m sure he loves her.

I don’t know if you’re naive or what but they are definitely not innocent remarks, they’re little jibes just at OP. My MIL does this about all the DILs, my DH calls her out on it every time she does it about me, and some of the time when she does it about the others. We are very low contact because she’s so annoying.

I just don’t stoop to my MILs level. I’m not going to play games.

Your main problem at present @mamamanda is your DH. He needs to stand up for you because there is no way on earth that she should be disrespecting you but especially not in front of your children. I would pack up and go home early. One of DH’s brothers and his wife did just that and it stopped MIL’s nonsense for a good 6 months 😂

Namefleeting · 22/12/2023 21:49

Zanatdy · 22/12/2023 21:39

Sorry but I think you’re being unreasonable and overthinking what are probably innocent remarks. Stop looking for fault and try and enjoy Christmas, she may not be your favourite person but she’s your partners mother and I’m sure he loves her.

Bloody hell!

Humbugg · 22/12/2023 21:48

I would say “excuse me, what did you say?” Or “pardon please can you repeat that” when she says rude things.she knows she’s being rude.

I’d then say “wow Mary that’s not a very nice thing to say is it?” Like you’re talking to a toddler. Do it with a mumsy tone

Eekmystro · 22/12/2023 21:47

The whole family really worships MIL and no one ever says a word against her.

^ oh lord op. This is not good. I really think a big talk with your DH after this visit about what you will and won’t put up with is in order. I’d say visits won’t happen unless you are treated decently. It’s not asking a lot to not be spoken rudely. Get it sorted before you have 10 more horrible visits.

JustMarriedBecca · 22/12/2023 21:46

Twenty years later I finally cracked the code and it's genuinely not to care. She's bitter and jealous and you go home with her darling boy.

I get comments all the time.

"I don't think we're doing too bad a job" (pause) "do you?" and repeat.

Lulubo1 · 22/12/2023 21:43

I'm sorry you have to deal with this. My MIL regularly ignores my existence as well and makes passive aggressive comments. You are NOT being oversensitive as one PP said. That was insensitive of them. Try not to let it rob you of your joy during this season.

I saw something amazing online that said that when a MIL says "oh, we don't hear from you/see you as much", rather than explain or give an excuse say "Yep. You don't." Stops them in their tracks. My MIL was shut down immediately when I said that. Maybe say something like "of course my child is fed" a plain and simple statement that needs no explanation. You don't need to explain anything. For the first scenario: "You heard DH say juice was spilt on the journey" MIL like this are draining on your emotions! Stand strong and get DH to have your back. You don't need to explain yourself to anyone, let alone your MIL. Hugs xx

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 22/12/2023 21:43

"ah why are they taking you away?"

"Because you're a cow"

mamamanda · 22/12/2023 21:42

MeridianB · 22/12/2023 21:37

I don’t think you’re being over sensitive here. I think she knows exactly what she’s doing and almost certainly times as much as possible to be out of earshot from your DH

Ignoring you when you first arrive is so weird. This is all about control and territory and being queen bee.

i like the idea of getting her to repeat every snipe. But I really think your DH is letting you down here. He needs to have your back and show a united front.

Is there a FIL? Is DH an only child?

Yes there's a FIL and a SIL. SIL doesn't have any kids and didn't bring her boyfriend this year or previous years.
The whole family really worships MIL and no one ever says a word against her.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 22/12/2023 21:40

mamamanda · 22/12/2023 21:14

In fairness to A) my husband responded with "yeah I didn't have time to wash it because DC literally spilt it on the journey" ... I meaning him, DH. He kinda corrected her.

But overall to him MIL can do no wrong and we can't call her up on anything or she gets upset so he gets irrationally upset that she's upset.

Then you have a very big DH problem

Ask him why his mother is more important to him than his wife

Zanatdy · 22/12/2023 21:39

Sorry but I think you’re being unreasonable and overthinking what are probably innocent remarks. Stop looking for fault and try and enjoy Christmas, she may not be your favourite person but she’s your partners mother and I’m sure he loves her.

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 22/12/2023 21:38

I don't want our child to turn into an overweight fatso like you, Granny.

Is that too subtle?

MeridianB · 22/12/2023 21:37

I don’t think you’re being over sensitive here. I think she knows exactly what she’s doing and almost certainly times as much as possible to be out of earshot from your DH

Ignoring you when you first arrive is so weird. This is all about control and territory and being queen bee.

i like the idea of getting her to repeat every snipe. But I really think your DH is letting you down here. He needs to have your back and show a united front.

Is there a FIL? Is DH an only child?

Eekmystro · 22/12/2023 21:37

mamamanda · 22/12/2023 21:08

Just arrived at MIL's house for Xmas and the comments are already pouring in from her. Any good responses? She always saying similar things

A) we arrive today and my husband asks if she minds washing a jumper that our DC spilt juice on on our way here. Her response "oh did Amy [me] not have time to wash it at home?!"
B) acts like I'm not in the room. So says things like "oh finally!!! I've missed you two so much" ie my DH and DC. Not even a "hello" to me until about 5mins after I've entered
C) "you're looking slim! Is mummy not making you nice food?" to my DC who is nearly 3
D) "ah why are they taking you away? You'd have so much more fun here with me!" about the fact we are leaving them mid next week to spend some time with my side of the family
E) when she discovered my bilingual DC doesn't know some English nursery rhymes (knows a lot more in my language, I'm a SAHM) "oh does mummy never sing with you?!"

I don't want to start explaining myself or justifying my choices like "oh actually I do sing!" Or "she has fun with my family too!" because I shouldn't have to justify my choices to her...but I do want to stand up for myself.

Never had a big argument and she just started being cold shortly after our engagement (5yrs ago)
DH either says he didn't hear something she said, wasn't there or she doesn't mean anything by it.

I think there’s 2 routes to go. Either go high road - rise above it and do a lot of ignoring or dealing with it directly OR go low road- and beat her at her own game.

High road-
If taking the high road then I’d keep notes (mentally if these examples) and in a quiet moment asks “Mary have I upset you in some way. I’ve noticed you have made a few comments at my expense and I am wondered if you are upset with me?” Many people can’t deal with directness. She’ll probably say “oh no what are you talking about”. Then when she next said something I’d address it right then - “Mary you have just asked my child if I don’t make her any nice food. That is the type of comment I spoke to you about earlier. I’m not happy to you speaking about me disrespectfully to my child”.

Low road options- go extreme with replies to her jabs.
“oh did mummy not make you any nice food”
”no all I feed her at home is a slice of dry bread a day and water. She’ll be so happy she’s allowed to eat fruit.”

In response to ignoring you when saying hello- “oh Mary HELLO It’s sooo lovely to see you. Come for a hug”.

You do really need to talk to your DH about it. He can’t be that ignorant.

uclpp · 22/12/2023 21:32

What the fuck is wrong with people like your MIL who make these stupid comments? She just sounds like a miserable bully.

MamaToABeautifulBoy · 22/12/2023 21:32

Your mother in law is a massive arsehole and you have the patience of a saint not to react!

Your DH needs to grow a backbone and support you.

Blushingm · 22/12/2023 21:31

Sounds like my ex mil!!

Whataretheodds · 22/12/2023 21:29

PrimoPancake · 22/12/2023 21:20

Use the magic phrase 'silly granny' to beat her at her passive aggressive game

A) Silly granny, doesn't she know your jumper got juice on it in the car?
B) Ignore
C) Silly granny, does she think mummy doesn't feed you?!
D) Silly granny, doesn't she know you have fun with both sides of your family?
E) Silly granny, does she think you only sing English rhymes?

Not recommended long term as it doesn't set a good model of behaviour for your kids but if you stick with it then it can knock it on the head now !

If she says anything about you saying silly granny, just say she needs to stop saying silly things and you'll stop pointing them out !

This but tweak - "granny's being silly" not "silly granny". Classic behaviour not person, means it's clear she can choose to do otherwise.

NotManyDaysTilChristmas · 22/12/2023 21:27

I had one like this and for what it’s worth it doesn’t get better. It’s so fucking tedious. I wish I had stood up for myself and if I had my time with her again I definitely would have. Your H sounds weak. Make alternative plans next year. Good luck.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 22/12/2023 21:26

"Oh, grandma is worrying for nothing, you're going to have SO much fun with your other cousins, aren't you!"

"Yes, the nurse was so pleased that she's such a perfect weight for her height"

"Sweetheart, shall we sing your favourite song to grandma?" (And proceed to sing something in your language, but with your attention solely on your DC).

"Oh gosh, it's so nice to be missed, isn't it sweetheart?" (Again, talking to your DC). Just pretend that the greeting was for you too, and ignore the fact that you were ignored.

The juice one, I would hope your DH said something. Tell him "you KNOW your mother is being rude, stop pretending it's not happening."

You could also use those opportunities to say something to your DD in your language, your MIL will seethe over not understanding what you're saying.

Pretend she's being polite though (and sometimes respond to something completely different to what she has said or asked) and respond gushingly back. She will have to do one of 2 things. Either she will have to grudgingly accept that you will not be "put in your place", or she will have to ramp it up and even your "head in the sand, pretending nothing bad is happening" DH will be forced to respond/act.

ughChristmas · 22/12/2023 21:26

I find with these kind of people that as soon as you call them out, and it rarely takes more than once or twice, they stop. They don't mind dishing it out but they can't take it back.

Lifeasiknowitisout · 22/12/2023 21:25

I would go with

A - oh is your heating starting to fail? He said the juice got spilt on the journey.

B- oh you noticed I was here?

C - please don’t say things like that to our child. What do you mean by tasty food?

D - this one wouldn’t have bothered me

E - I speak more than one language as you know. Or have you forgotten.

Or point out that she is being rude (and possibly xenophobic) every time ‘I am sure you don’t realise but that comes across very rude’
Or tell your dh to speak to her and if she doesn’t stop it you and the child will be leaving.

Greenpolkadot · 22/12/2023 21:24

Pull her up on everything in front of dh.
He's protecting her but why isn't he sticking up for you ?
He's an arsehole