Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the new rules on no fault eviction - means people won't want to be landlords?

267 replies

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 19:31

What do you think?

OP posts:
Alcyoneus · 23/12/2023 02:42

People who advocate for these kind of things always make it worse for renters. Like the idiotic Scottish government. Rent controls in Edinburgh have meant that rental prices there have gone up faster than UK average.

The stupidity of socialist zealotry will never seize to amaze.

EmmaEmerald · 23/12/2023 00:43

ErrolTheDragon · 22/12/2023 19:42

The change is likely to result in decent people quitting being landlords. It'll just be the tough ones who stick with it.

Yes, tough ones, companies and big corporations.

what happens if an individual landlord wants to sell for any reason? Will that be considered acceptable reason to give notice under new rules?

I can see prices going up as the only willing landlords will be those I've mentioned.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 23/12/2023 00:41

I don't see it makes much difference to be honest, because a LL can still evict if wanting to sell up. Renters are really no better protected than before, sadly.

MyCakeyBakeyHeart · 23/12/2023 00:38

The one addition to the reform that I think is the most unreasonable is that landlords will no longer be able to refuse pets without reasonable grounds, and mentions the tenants would need pet damage insurance.

If you ring the insurer after the tenants leave, saying your house and all your furnishings now stinks of dog you’re hardly going to get anything. Or the tenants dog destroys your mint condition four year old expensive sofa, insurer will likely devalue the asset yearly making the payout value next to nothing. Then when you take into account inflation when buying the even more expensive like for like replacement you’ll be thinking where ministers can stick this particular aspect of the bill.

Additionally freeholders are still allowed to ban leasehold owners from having pets with no justification needed.

Livelovebehappy · 23/12/2023 00:16

Eekmystro · 22/12/2023 19:38

People acting like it would be the end of the world if people stopped being landlords and sold up. Erm the houses don’t disappear, they’d still be on the market in some form. Maybe in fact it would be more affordable for people to buy if there were less people using property for an income.

People rent for a reason. Because they can’t afford to buy, or their credit ratings are so crap that no bank will touch them. Or just prefer to rent because their jobs mean they can’t settle in one place. We need landlords, but they are leaving because there are too many rules introduced which tip too far in the tenants’ favour. I rented privately because I couldn’t raise a deposit to buy a house. I would have been absolutely screwed if there were no private landlords.

LumiB · 22/12/2023 23:54

As we are starting to see more and more companies are becoming landlords..this will have an impact on those renting becuasr those companies will be u likely to tske on tenants who are high risk in others on benefits.

So whilst its good renters are being more protected the long term future might not be so great.

Tatumm · 22/12/2023 23:51

It’s a good rule because it will force out some of the cowboys and amateurs. Renting a property in the UK needs to be a more stable way to live, as it is in many mainland European countries.

MulledWineBeMine · 22/12/2023 23:42

thefallen · 22/12/2023 20:17

The only thing worse is people with holiday homes, pricing locals out of the area and leaving the houses empty for months at a time. It should be banned.

@thefallen. & how do you propose that would work?

how do you propose it would be monitored?

...and think hard before you would support the government knowing where you spend every night of the year?

Ginsoakedcatlady · 22/12/2023 23:17

I don’t get why it a bad thing at all? Landlords would still be able to evict people for not paying rent, damaging property etc. in fact as I understood it the reforms would make that easier? And also if they want to sell. So why would it force decent landlords to sell up?

user1477391263 · 22/12/2023 23:09

I've seen a lot of discussion along the lines of "These rules won't mean more houses come onto the market for sale - people will just leave them empty or put relatives inside them!"

But when my grandmother's house came to us a couple of years ago, we (my family) literally made the decision to sell it rather than try renting it out, because my father knew the way the wind was blowing, and had this long talk with us (me and my sister) about how the picture is gradually shifting in favor of tenants and this will make renting out properties very stressful and just not worth it in terms of time, money and energy.

So we sold it, and someone else owns it now.

I would be really surprised if the new rules did not at least increase the number of properties for sale to an extent. Yes, there will be some cases where people will leave properties empty rather than sell or lease them, but a lot of people will choose to sell and keep their lives simple.

Paradise404 · 22/12/2023 23:05

Densol57 · 22/12/2023 23:00

Im a good landlord and Im selling up all my houses when the tenants move out rather than reletting .... apart from the one I bought for my son to live in.

Too much grief, no financial incentives anymore. Im not a charity.

Good luck to all the renters needing a place with an ever decreasing pool of landlords, you wont be able to rely on social housing

I can 100% confirm that all the people bleating 'LL's are parasites' don't rent. Either sat pretty in social housing or their own homes.
As a very recent buyer .. people bidding on rents. Insane.

Densol57 · 22/12/2023 23:00

Im a good landlord and Im selling up all my houses when the tenants move out rather than reletting .... apart from the one I bought for my son to live in.

Too much grief, no financial incentives anymore. Im not a charity.

Good luck to all the renters needing a place with an ever decreasing pool of landlords, you wont be able to rely on social housing

Elvis1956 · 22/12/2023 22:56

Kannet111 · 22/12/2023 22:29

Well pre2008 100% mortgage where common. It led to
Disaster. There is no easy answer

Actually it didn't I worked with many lenders providing both prime and sub prime mortgages including Lehman brothers.
It lead to an increase in house prices, but the lenders learnt from the early 90s shit show where they foreclosed on mortgages without even talking to customers. In the 08 problems which stemed from investors no longer providing money to lenders and lenders being able to lend more then they could afford (new Labour deregulation) , lender's spoke to customers...allowed the small number who defaulted to extend their loans, pay a bit less etc.
The real problem was allowing lenders to lend more than they could ever raise in assets. The money market panicked. The Labour government conned Lloyds into buying halifax....and the pack of cards almost crumbled.

My partner worked for Lloyds and about a year before we bought shares at £10 each...just look at the price today...thank you Gordon Brown

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 22:54

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 22/12/2023 21:02

Grow up!

WHy do you think its going to be beneficial?

OP posts:
BMW6 · 22/12/2023 22:50

The naievity of one or two posters is laughable.

Private LL's are selling up in droves - its not driving down house prices so everyone who rented can buy!!

It's just driving UP the rental market making it much harder for the poorest to get somewhere they can rent!

And if course a LL will 99% of the time prefer a tenant who is not on benefits. They want a tenant who can pay the rent after all.
It's Business, not Philanthropy.

DorisDoesDoncaster · 22/12/2023 22:36

Agreed but not everyone can find a lender willing to give them a mortgage due to poor credit history. Not every tenant wants to buy due to risk of losing a job if they were to fail professional exams that are required post secondary or tertiary education. Some people only want to rent whilst going through a break up etc etc.

Kannet111 · 22/12/2023 22:29

Shadowsindarkplaces · 22/12/2023 20:40

If tenants can afford to pay market rents, and keep up payments they can afford a mortgage. It needs a scheme to cover deposits. I know many paying more than a mortgage amount in rent!

Well pre2008 100% mortgage where common. It led to
Disaster. There is no easy answer

updownleftrightstart · 22/12/2023 22:29

Some landlords are parasites of course, but not all. Our landlord could sell our house and would get way more money just by sticking the capital in the bank and collecting the interest. We had to move for work and were desperate for a property to rent and the recent changes mean landlords are selling up in droves and there’s just not enough houses to rent, so we offered £150 a month more than asking. They turned down the extra and said they were happy with the amount they originally asked for. Not exactly consistent with a parasite who is only out for what she can get

AShiningThongOfAngels · 22/12/2023 21:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It wasn't intended to be a clever comeback.

I just get fed up with people who slag landlords off without knowing the first thing about why someone might become a landlord in the first place.

But on the whole, people who only see things in black and white aren't going to be convinced that there are also shades of grey.

Sumerian · 22/12/2023 21:47

The thing is, that its so easy to blame landlords. They are parasites, they have no morals, they are the cause of the housing crisis. So they are an easy target for a government policy, lets show we're clamping down on them. Popular and easy vote winner.

However, if there was sufficient stock of good quality affordable social housing then the rental crisis wouldn't be happening. If someone who was issued a S21 could go to their council and be offered alternative accommodation straight away then life would be vastly different for hundreds of thousands of tenants.

But theres a shortage of housing, especially social housing. Councils are London are so stuck with demand that they are moving families into deepest darkest Kent and beyond. Because there is no housing available locally.

No govt is going to say, yeah we've had 30 or 40 years to fix this, anyone coupd see it coming, but instead we've continued selling off social housing and haven't increased supply significantly. It's our fault. We'll build endless homes with our non available local council money, and we'll reset the market.

So the govt has blamed landlords. Because then its not their fault. They've changed tax rules, they've made evictions take months in court, they've basically made being a small landlord as unappealing as possible.

What i believe will happen is that small landlords with 1-4 properties will leave the market and huge venture capitalist type business will move in. And these huge venture capitalist type conglomerates will then use their lobbying powers to eventually erode tenants rights further, because they will be big enough to impact govt policy

Don't blame bastard landlords, blame the lack of housw building and the sell off of social housing. Blame austerity.

Paradise404 · 22/12/2023 21:43

Beezknees · 22/12/2023 20:46

True, but the difference is everyone needs a place to live, and they don't have the luxury of choice. I don't need to buy a coffee from Sharon's little coffee shop if I don't want to, but I need somewhere to live and the landlord has all the power to decide what rent to charge, I have no choice. (Not me personally as I live in social housing but that's the gist).

Yeah - because the gov withdrew from its responsibility by allowing RTB and not building new homes! Relying on private LL's to fill the gaps. They now want to drive them out and replace with their big corporate cronies.
I've stayed in 10+ places for the better part of a decade. The worst properties were owned by faceless foreign companies. In fact, many flats in London are. They don't care about tenants, complaints/legal battles etc mean nothing to them.

The individual ones were lovely, mostly. Renting out their former homes having moved in with a partner, etc they did not want to see anybody unhappy in their home.

For all PP's complaining about LL's. When they sell up. These corps are the ones who can afford to and will be buying the homes as investments. Not current renters who can finally 'get on the ladder.

Gov could just provide enough housing then people wouldn't need private LL's but as it stands, they don't. So we do.

bjjgirl · 22/12/2023 21:38

Also the cost of the interest rate increase will naturally be passed down- you pre delusional to think it wouldn't be
.

If the cost of production of crops increases would you expect to pay the same in the supermarket?

This lack of understanding is really concerning

DixonD · 22/12/2023 21:37

brainworms · 22/12/2023 21:19

@TravelInHope
I'm comfy where I am thanks. Don't pretend you care about folks you rent to.

You’ve really got a chip on your shoulder haven’t you 😂

DorisDoesDoncaster · 22/12/2023 21:37

My brother has just been served with a Section 21 because his landlord can no longer afford to pay tax on on ‘profit’ that he has not actually received.

His landlord offered to sell him the house below market value (and was renting it to him below market value) but my brother has a poor credit record so was declined for EVERY mortgage he applied for.

His landlord earns ca. £45k a year but the rent he receives takes him into higher rate tax (40%) meaning that landlord can no longer deduct the mortgage interest (which rocketed this year when he had to remortgage) so he gets taxed on fake profit.

Landlord cannot afford to pay tax on profit he has not received, whilst paying the mortgage on his own home and supporting his own family.

To continue to pay a similar level of rent as what he is paying now, my brother is having to uproot his son from his school during A-levels.

Landlord wanted to wait until the of A-levels but simply could not afford this or any risk of my brother not being able to pay a higher rent, then trashing landlord’s credit history.

Well done Shelter and George Osborne…

WillowCraft · 22/12/2023 21:36

App13 · 22/12/2023 21:22

There are big barriers to entry here. So if the landlord market shrank as they sold up, people with sizeable deposits would be able to buy as the mortgage market is now far more strigent. People that can't buy will be exposed to an even tighter rental market, as rents would rise, as supply would shrink.

So in a roundabout way Supply does not equal demand.

Rented homes and owned homes are two separate (although linked) markets. If supply increases and demand remains the same, prices drop. That applies equally in either market, unless the government controls rents or meddles in house prices

Swipe left for the next trending thread