Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the new rules on no fault eviction - means people won't want to be landlords?

267 replies

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 19:31

What do you think?

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/12/2023 12:34

The naievity of one or two posters is laughable
Private LL's are selling up in droves - its not driving down house prices so everyone who rented can buy!!
It's just driving UP the rental market making it much harder for the poorest to get somewhere they can rent!

Those capable of thought know this, but to the all-landlords-are-bastards crowd it doesn't matter; all that counts is another opportunity to spout hate because someone else has got something they haven't

What's often forgotten is that the endless new requirements on LLs are the result of government/local authorities wanting to shift the results of the housing crisis they've created onto anyone but them. They don't care about those struggling, just so long as they can dodge picking up the pieces

So instead off the LLs/tenants at the end of the chain, blame those who've created this - especially by selling off so much housing stock

Seymour5 · 23/12/2023 11:54

ChallahPlaiter · 23/12/2023 10:30

Lots of people should get priority for social housing. Having priority for something that doesn’t exist in any meaningful form is fairly pointless.

There’s another thread on here about an over 60 who is losing his (awful) private rented flat. He has secured a social housing tenancy, because his age gives him priority for older people’s housing. In some parts of the country, councils are still able to rehouse homeless families within a relatively short time.

EmmaEmerald · 23/12/2023 11:21

Has the legislation been fully formed?

I can't see what would be considered an acceptable reason to ask a tenant to leave.

my neighbour inherited and his mum's flat has been empty for a year. Probate is taking a long time. Not worth the hassle of renting it out.

ChallahPlaiter · 23/12/2023 10:54

It’s not “socialist zealotry” - whatever that is - that’s at fault. It’s 40 years of an entire lack of housing policy that actually addresses ordinary people’s needs rather than being designed to buy votes or enrich the already wealthy.
This time last year in Wales, landlords were issuing s21 notices in their droves owing to the Renting Homes (Wales) Act which ended the practice of evicting with less than 6 months notice. Because of this, and the years-long freeze to LHA imposed by the Westminster government, a housing crisis has become a disaster. That’s not to say I disagree with the end of no-fault evictions; I don’t. But before you can put that type of legislation in place you need a holistic approach whereby an alternative is provided through social housing and the simultaneous capping of private rents. Obviously that’s never going to happen because of the aforementioned neoliberal zealotry of housing policy!
Incidentally you appear to misunderstand socialism which in fact involves the collective ownership of public assets for the common good. Imagine if this applied to rented housing? Unfortunately people who misrepresent socialism encourage others to vote for the continuation of the present situation - housing as a driver of profit rather than an essential need.

ChallahPlaiter · 23/12/2023 10:30

Lots of people should get priority for social housing. Having priority for something that doesn’t exist in any meaningful form is fairly pointless.

Cedar13 · 23/12/2023 09:58

We rent out a flat. I got left a small amount of money by my gran 20 years ago and used it as a deposit for a 1 bed flat. We've had the same tenant for 16 years. We charge less than market rent because he's looked after the place and always paid his rent on time.
But it is increasingly difficult for us to afford to pay the mortgage and the increased tax, insurance and upkeep.
In a year's time when our fixed rate comes up it definitely won't add up and if we keep it we will have to put the rent up a lot, but the market value rent won't even cover everything.
There's some bad landlords but there's plenty of good ones! Unfortunately though the ones which do it properly and look after the property are going to be forced out and at the end of the day it is an investment for my retirement. It's an investment and there's nothing wrong with that!

NutellaNut · 23/12/2023 09:42

There is so much ridiculous bile on here about landlords. Of course they are not parasites. Without landlords, where would most people who can’t afford to buy a property live? The waiting lists for council houses and social housing are off the scale. The vast majority of landlords are indeed providing a useful service and of course they earn money from it like any business.

My step daughter recently became an ‘accidental landlord’ as she and her partner split up and can’t afford to sell now as they only bought last year at the property peak and are in negative equity. They are also locked into a mortgage deal with a large financial penalty if they sell now. So, they have rented out their house. They are £175 a month out of pocket after mortgage costs, insurance and estate agent fees. They have no other choice as they can’t afford to leave it empty. On the plus side, the house is providing a much needed home for a family with 2 young kids, while they have to rent elsewhere themselves. Hardly parasites.

In answer to the OP’s question about the rules putting off landlords, I’d say yes definitely, in some cases. My siblings and I inherited a house from my late mother, which has been on the market for sometime because the housing market is slow in the area. We could rent it out long term and provide a home for someone, and this has been suggested. However we all agreed no fucking way do we want tenants in the house who we could never get rid of. It’s certainly put us off being landlords, so the house stays empty for as long as it takes.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 23/12/2023 09:23

I think it will put people off but it wont deter them from the market, it will lead to competition to buy run down houses on the cheap and doing them up to sell on.

Which will continue to price people out of affordable housing and a cash in hand buyer with no chain is always in a good position.

Longma · 23/12/2023 09:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

StragglyTinsel · 23/12/2023 09:16

ErrolTheDragon · 23/12/2023 09:07

Maybe HA could buy from the landlords who are selling up

With what?
They wouldn't want mixed use properties either, eg small shops with residential flat above.

People say this stuff - the local authority or housing association should just buy/take over all the property - with absolutely no thought to the economics or the practical logistics of it.

Apparently there are endless resources for this stuff. And suddenly we’ll be knee deep in beautifully maintained property that can be rented in alignment with local housing allowances (even though there capped to cover the cheapest 1/3 of properties in an area anyway).

It’s dangerously naive. And also driven by some sense of vindictiveness in many cases.

ErrolTheDragon · 23/12/2023 09:07

Maybe HA could buy from the landlords who are selling up

With what?
They wouldn't want mixed use properties either, eg small shops with residential flat above.

updownleftrightstart · 23/12/2023 08:55

sashh · 23/12/2023 05:55

Maybe HA could buy from the landlords who are selling up.

Financially this won’t make sense in a lot of areas.
Where I live the HA allowance for a 3 bed is £520 a month. A 3-bed will cost about £280k to buy. A HA isn’t likely to pay that for a house that they will only get £520 a month for. It would take a long time for that house to become profitable for them. Here the only way the HA acquires new properties is when there’s a new build estate and they are allocated a proportion of the houses cheaply because the ones that are listed for sale are priced to allow for this (and usually those houses are at a lower spec than the ones that go for sale)

whirlyhead · 23/12/2023 08:34

i wish I made a profit on my flats! The mortgages are all higher than the rents I charge so I subsidise them all, and the service charges keep going up. They’re all flats with cladding/fire safety issues so I can’t sell them as they’re not mortgageable and are worth less than was paid for them. I am being taxed on the mortgage interest too.

I didn’t choose to be a landlord - I married a person with rental properties. The whole thing is anathema to me but yeah, I’m a parasite. Whatever.

Boomer55 · 23/12/2023 08:22

brainworms · 22/12/2023 20:14

@DragonMama3 they're parasites.

I’m not a landlord, but, to be fair, some tenants are also parasites.

They see paying rent as an optional extra, and trash the place.🙄

Grandmasswag · 23/12/2023 08:16

Livelovebehappy · 23/12/2023 00:16

People rent for a reason. Because they can’t afford to buy, or their credit ratings are so crap that no bank will touch them. Or just prefer to rent because their jobs mean they can’t settle in one place. We need landlords, but they are leaving because there are too many rules introduced which tip too far in the tenants’ favour. I rented privately because I couldn’t raise a deposit to buy a house. I would have been absolutely screwed if there were no private landlords.

Some people. A large number of people in rented have no choice. They earn very well as evidenced by the fact that they are paying thousands of pound per month rent, they just can’t ever save enough for deposits because it’s all taken in rent! Stuck in a viscous circle. It’s completely immoral to allow people to profiteer the way LL have been.

EasternStandard · 23/12/2023 08:05

Riverlee · 23/12/2023 08:01

https://www.simplybusiness.co.uk/knowledge/articles/landlord-report-2023/

Article says that a quarter of landlords plan to sell in the next year, citing the reasons why.

Together with fewer new landlords due to the same pressures paints a grim picture.

Renting can be tough but renting in a squeezed market with low supply is hard

Some cities o/s are really bad and friends said how much of a dire bun fight it was to get a place

Prices shooting up and you need to be fast

Z1hun · 23/12/2023 08:02

tescocreditcard · 22/12/2023 19:38

It's possible that more housing stock coming onto the market will reduce the price and make home ownership more affordable so that some of the people who used to rent will be able to buy.

That's wishful thinking. It won't happen. Still too much demand and properties will likely increase.

Riverlee · 23/12/2023 08:01

@Phineyj lists the same pressures.

Phineyj · 23/12/2023 07:58

It's not the regulatory changes in themselves that are the issue. It's the regulatory changes plus the tax changes (which have changed gradually over time and were known about) plus the increased mortgage costs (interest rate increases were expected at some point but the Truss/Kwarteng debacle wasn't). Plus the knock on effect of Covid where some landlords were stuck with bad tenants for years due to temporary suspension of the existing laws on evictions in 2020-2 plus huge backlogs in the court system.

So three different expected factors driving up costs (it would have been four but the government seem to have stepped back on making all properties reach EPC of C) plus two one-off shocks.

I did actually discuss some of this with my tenant (wanting to prepare her for a likely rent rise well in advance) and she was entirely unaware of any of it apart from the interest rate rises and didn't understand what connection those had with mortgage rates.

One benefit of being a tenant is not having to risk bear on this.

And before anyone jumps on my head, I am a good landlord and rent to her at a loss. Because she's a great tenant!

EasternStandard · 23/12/2023 07:31

Alaimo · 23/12/2023 07:02

I'm a landlord. In Scotland, where all these things have already been implemented. They don't bother me.

I am currently working and living overseas, where I'm renting an apartment. I have the benefit of renting in a country where there are strong tenant rights, where landlords cannot reasonably refuse pets, and where tenancies are of an indefinite length, and I'm happy to provide a home to my tenants in Scotland on the same basis.

Doesn’t supply come into it and if you limit that in any way as some pp are keen on rental prices go up

‘The Scottish Government introduced a rent cap in autumn 2022 which remains in place, but a lack of supply relative to demand has put pressure on the cost of renting property in Scotland, meaning that the nation has the biggest gap proportionately between owning and renting costs of anywhere in the UK.’

Alaimo · 23/12/2023 07:02

I'm a landlord. In Scotland, where all these things have already been implemented. They don't bother me.

I am currently working and living overseas, where I'm renting an apartment. I have the benefit of renting in a country where there are strong tenant rights, where landlords cannot reasonably refuse pets, and where tenancies are of an indefinite length, and I'm happy to provide a home to my tenants in Scotland on the same basis.

hattie43 · 23/12/2023 06:48

ErrolTheDragon · 22/12/2023 19:42

The change is likely to result in decent people quitting being landlords. It'll just be the tough ones who stick with it.

This .

I'm a very good landlord , same tenants for 10 yrs , no rent rises , always do repairs quickly , don't interfere , all safety checks done .

I'm leaving the BTL market . Only have the one property but don't want to run the risk of not getting the property back when I retire .

sashh · 23/12/2023 05:55

Doingtheboxerbeat · 22/12/2023 19:43

It's easy for someone who is housed that's either bought or like me are in a secure tenancy to say "to hell with private landlords" but that's just silly and shows a great deal of privilege.
What's the alternative, since building more social housing won't happen at all overnight.

Maybe HA could buy from the landlords who are selling up.