Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the new rules on no fault eviction - means people won't want to be landlords?

267 replies

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 19:31

What do you think?

OP posts:
Goatymum · 23/12/2023 15:01

Oh and dd at uni has a good landlord this year, so much so they’re staying for next year too.

Goatymum · 23/12/2023 15:00

brainworms · 22/12/2023 19:32

Landlords are parasites.

Don't be ridiculous. Plenty of people, like my dh and his brother came into renting ‘accidentally’ benefiting financially from an inheritance for example. It’s a business, yes and will hopefully be our pension too, but they are fair landlords (we’ve just had 5k worth of work done in the property). We’ve had great tenants in the main, apart from one who was a fraudster and ended up in prison a couple of years after we evicted her for swindling someone else out of a significant amount of money.

EmmaEmerald · 23/12/2023 14:58

Daphnis156 · 23/12/2023 14:56

I have never had a positive experience with a private landlord- the very term "Landlord" is absurd as if the tenant should be a "Serf", subject to a "Lord".

The more of them that get out the better, the rules and laws should leave only professional landlords, who can provide a proper service, set to a legal standard.

How are you defining "professional" landlord please?

Daphnis156 · 23/12/2023 14:56

I have never had a positive experience with a private landlord- the very term "Landlord" is absurd as if the tenant should be a "Serf", subject to a "Lord".

The more of them that get out the better, the rules and laws should leave only professional landlords, who can provide a proper service, set to a legal standard.

EmmaEmerald · 23/12/2023 14:56

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Ah, I see. I think the plan for the future is more of these blocks owned by corporates, but maybe they will offer tenants more security, who knows.

@Alligator456 "I think the government are trying to force landlords to provide social housing because they don't want to but that it isn't going to work."

exactly, that's another reason I think we will see more rental only blocks of flats.

Alligator456 · 23/12/2023 14:53

UK housing market is messed up and the government seems set on making it worse.

A healthy housing market would look like the following.

  1. Ownership for people on normal incomes intending to stay in a place for a while
  2. Social housing for vulnerable people and those on low incomes
  3. Private rentals for students, young people and people moving around for work and other reasons

Squeezing out private rentals will make the present situation worse I think. Some ideas.

  1. Build more social housing and stop the right to buy
  2. Stop this nonsense of insisting that people are voluntarily homeless unless actually evicted. It's clogging up the courts and stressing out both tenants and landlords.
  3. Make interest tax deductible again
  4. Keep section 21 but increase the notice required. Start with 3 months but increase by perhaps a month for every year of tenure up to 12 months total

I think the government are trying to force landlords to provide social housing because they don't want to but that it isn't going to work.

SomeCatFromJapan · 23/12/2023 13:59

What I find frustrating about the tinkering and the knock-on effect of a lack of rental properties is that it makes things extremely inflexible. There are multiple applicants for every property now in many areas as it is. Landlords tend to prefer tenants who are going to stay in the property for a long time, so those looking to rent between property purchases, or having returned to the country from living abroad, or on a work contract, or any number of similar scenaries, now wind up in a situation where they can't actually get rental accommodation.

Paradise404 · 23/12/2023 13:48

SuspiciousSue · 23/12/2023 13:19

DH is desperate to do BTL and this is one of the many reasons I won’t agree to it. I’m just terrified of getting someone in who won’t pay rent and we can’t get them out. I’m so sorry to all the people who pay rent on time but, as usual the minority spoil it for everyone.

Does he even know how BTL works?
Contrary to popular perception the profit generation isn't in the rent, but the capital appreciation of the property.
With house price rises + a chunk of mortgage paid off by rent LL's equity increases, they can then leverage it to buy another house. Or borrow for repairs etc off the back of it, you get the picture.

This house of cards obviously collapses when interest rates shoot up and/or house prices drop. As is happening now! Not a great time to be doing it.

It's different if you inherited a property + a good chunk of cash. Or, have already paid off your mortgage.

We might find ourselves becoming LL's as we might work abroad for a bit but don't want to give up our lovely house. We'd only consider moving if we can get the mortgage down to a small amount... charge below 'market rate' rent and all the money will go straight to a separate account for repairs, management fees, insurance etc especially if the place gets trashed.

At no point in time were we considering that it might make a 'profit', depending on how unlucky we are might even incur losses but it's the price of keeping our family home. If we do decide to settle down abroad we'll sell it, but obviously it takes several years to gain permanent residency and I wouldn't want to have to return to the UK and go through the whole buying process again. It was difficult enough with the chains and whatnot when we first did it

Xenia · 23/12/2023 13:41

Yes someone was telling me about a rented flat going over to being a London serviced apartment at the moment. I am not sure if that complies with the terms of the long leasehold but that is another story.

I am sure the military families mentioned will need decent housing from private landlords. My sons are only letting their one house until either they sell to buy somewhere else they prefer to live or they move into the house.

When the state changed the law so that landlords could not set their main cost (interest on a loan) against the rent loads of landlords had to sell up as they were taxed on profits they did not make. The state has the right to change those rules and it probably did mean more houses went to first time buyers but it is really easy to see why so many landlords left the market couples with the 1.3m new people coming to the UK a year which I think is 740,000 net immigration - it is a perfect storm for shortage of housing in cities where there are jobs and no different from New York, Sydney and many other places. China has a property market collapse at present and lots of new blocks with empty flats in them so I suppose it does depend on the country.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/12/2023 13:40

EmmaEmerald · 23/12/2023 12:44

@Puzzledandpissedoff thank you

so how would things like temporary rentals work? My last rental was a guy who had a two year contract working abroad. He was great, the agency was great etc.

Does that get special exemption?

Is this policy one of these things that gets talked about a lot but actually there's no thinking behind it?

IME there rarely is any thinking behind these things, Emma, so we get the law of unintended consequences and all that (and your example of the difficulties around short-term rentals was a good one)

What government actually want is a nice headline to whip up those who can't - or maybe prefer not to - think beyond "serves the LLs/tenants right".
They say politicians think of the next election and statesmen of the next generation, but unfortunately we don't have many statesmen/women around right now

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 23/12/2023 13:28

brainworms · 22/12/2023 19:32

Landlords are parasites.

Are water companies parasites profiting off an essential need? What about supermarkets? Food is vital so why don’t they sell it at cost price?
What is it about landlords that is different in your view?

Riverlee · 23/12/2023 13:22

I imagine a lot of landlords will change over to air bnb instead, especially if in a holiday area.

AhBiscuits · 23/12/2023 13:20

SuspiciousSue · 23/12/2023 13:19

DH is desperate to do BTL and this is one of the many reasons I won’t agree to it. I’m just terrified of getting someone in who won’t pay rent and we can’t get them out. I’m so sorry to all the people who pay rent on time but, as usual the minority spoil it for everyone.

If they stop paying rent you can evict them, even after the reforms. It does take a while though.

SuspiciousSue · 23/12/2023 13:19

DH is desperate to do BTL and this is one of the many reasons I won’t agree to it. I’m just terrified of getting someone in who won’t pay rent and we can’t get them out. I’m so sorry to all the people who pay rent on time but, as usual the minority spoil it for everyone.

Mamadothehump · 23/12/2023 13:17

brainworms · 22/12/2023 19:32

Landlords are parasites.

Not all thank you very much. One of my tenants has been in my property for 10 years and still paying the same (extremely reasonable) rent. She's a good tenant and I'd rather keep her there.

App13 · 23/12/2023 13:16

My family have been landlords since 1991. I have now taken over management of the properties to help my mother .

All properties are priced 300-500 pounds less market going rent. Because we are decent landlords, we have mutual respect between our tenants. And the oldest has stayed 14 yrs now, the median 7 yrs and the newest 2 yrs.

My mother is barely breaking even but she's adamant we will not raise the rent that our tenants are left in hardship or have to move out.

There are decent private landlords out there. And we intend to stay.

DyslexicPoster · 23/12/2023 13:05

Didn't this come in years ago? The moment when decent landlords leave is when they end section 21 completely.

Gettingcolder · 23/12/2023 13:01

I have been a landlord in the past but never again. With all the costs involved it just isn't worth the aggravation of bad tenants. I may well inherit another house in the near future, but would prefer to leave it empty rather than find a tenant. Given where it is, I may consider using it as a holiday let instead as at least I can then get it back if I want to sell it but I might just use it for myself, family and friends. It's a shame for those trying to rent places, but there is no longer the incentive for investers to go for buy-to-let property.

RAFOfficer · 23/12/2023 12:56

The New Employment Model for the Armed Forces involves most of us using private rentals rather than military-owned accommodation, so there’s going to be an increase in demand anywhere near military bases in a couple of years. We absolutely need private landlords, the council isn’t going to provide houses for military families/individuals.

Ragruggers · 23/12/2023 12:50

I had a house which I let to a homeless family always did repairs and on the day they moved in there were new carpets and everywhere freshly painted.We received the rent through the UC which was good as they had history re rent.I wanted to give them a secure home 4 young children plus a dog a chance.How were we treated beyond awful it cost us small fortune to put it in a good enough condition to sell.Never again.Not all landlords are parasites.

EmmaEmerald · 23/12/2023 12:44

@Puzzledandpissedoff thank you

so how would things like temporary rentals work? My last rental was a guy who had a two year contract working abroad. He was great, the agency was great etc.

Does that get special exemption?

Is this policy one of these things that gets talked about a lot but actually there's no thinking behind it?

Xenia · 23/12/2023 12:43

The state chose to ensure many landlords do not make any profits so landlords have been and are selling which is fine if the state wants that and some of those properties will go to first time buyers. However there will always be some people wanting to rent eg job moves them around like young doctors or just in a City for a year or just left university and want to share with friends for a few years in London etc so that part of the private rental market (not the very low rent bottom end) is the one being hit by the changes - although it looks from the above link someone posted that the changes mentioned on the first post may be delayed. My sons both let out one house each (and still live at home) which one took over from a sibling who was moving as I wanted to help those at home buy a place each rather than wait 10 years and help them then when I might not have the money or might no longer be in work. I don't think now they are no longer students and will pay 40% tax on the tiny profit it will really be financially worth much to bother carrying on letting out not the state is about to take 40% of it all but there you are - at least the state will have all that money to spend wisely (... not))...

When the house was last let i have never seen anything like it (and we let 2 flats out in the 1980s so I have some experience) - 10 couples over one weekend all wanting the house, all producing inducements like guarantors, rent up front and so sad to turn away 9 of them. It is probably now let at about £300 a month less than the market rent there so I suppose that is why they all wanted it.

MrsSlocombesCat · 23/12/2023 12:41

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 22/12/2023 19:45

Exactly this.
I lost my home of almost 9 years this year, just like that.
Because my landlord cottoned on that he could make more on it as a student property.
Myself and my children were suddenly homeless.

We've found somewhere else eventually, but it's turned our lives upside down.
Miles away from family, uprooted kids to different schools.

It's ridiculous that landlords have that sort of power over people's lives.
I won't write on here what I want to happen to my scumbag of an ex landlord, or my comment will disappear.

Edited

To be fair this happened to me in a Housing Association house. After ten years all of the people in my street who were renting from them were given notice to quit so that they could sell the houses. My next door neighbour was in the middle of breast cancer treatment and while the council got her and her two sons a flat, imagine the stress. She died a few months later. I couldn’t believe how callous they were.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/12/2023 12:39

I can't see what would be considered an acceptable reason to ask a tenant to leave

Obvious ones which spring to mind are damage, using the place for illegal purposes and unpaid rent

Trouble is, if this even comes in, I can see councils insisting on some kind of "arbitration", which with the way they work could easily mean LLs would never be able to get someone out - which would suit the minority of nightmare tenants just fine

RAFOfficer · 23/12/2023 12:37

I’m a landlord. Pretty sure I’m not a parasite. I deliberately bought an existing HMO rather than a small family home that first-time buyers might want, then added £50k onto my own mortgage in order to do a complete refurb and make it really nice. My tenants pay £450 a month for an en suite room, but that includes gas, electric, water, council tax, superfast broadband and a cleaner every fortnight.

Between all the bills, insurance, licences, tax, keeping on top of repairs and replacing white goods, plus the 12% I pay the property manager because I get posted to somewhere different in the country every 2 years (or overseas) so can’t do it myself, I don’t actually make any profit. I’ve also had two non-paying tenants who it took many months to get evicted, all while I was paying their bills for them because you’re not allowed to do anything about it! The only reason I don’t make a loss is because I don’t have a mortgage on it - I was ‘lucky’ enough to inherit the money I used to buy it. Between the original purchase price and the cost of the refurb, I wouldn’t get back more than I paid for the place, so in hindsight I’d have been better off just putting the money in savings accounts or buying Premium Bonds. I certainly wouldn’t recommend being a landlord to anyone considering it now.

I have seriously looked at selling, but my current set of tenants are all really lovely, and some of them have been with me for years, so I do feel a social obligation to them. If I sold up it’s likely the house would be bought by a big conglomerate now, and I worry about what they’d do to the rents.

Interestingly, the property next door to mine was also an HMO, then someone bought it and spent a lot of money converting back to a family home before putting it back on the market. It took a year to sell, and the new owner just converted it back to an HMO, so there is clearly still demand for rentals…