Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the new rules on no fault eviction - means people won't want to be landlords?

267 replies

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 19:31

What do you think?

OP posts:
LumiB · 24/12/2023 07:27

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 23:25

I did read it. I just don't see it as a virtue or something to boast about.

Market prices are that high because the society and politics made them that high. It is just another part of the same story where current social setup disproportionately benefits owners.

Seriously. Okay wait until its mostly corproations who are landlords who will have no empathy, they won't say oh hey its hard times lets not raise the rent like that posters mum has done. They won't give a fig. And before you say it won't happen it already is, my company is doing it, two major banks announced they are going to doing it, one supermarket has announced the same.

Then you will really have something to be mad about.

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 23:25

LumiB · 23/12/2023 22:47

Well you ignored the whole part where she said her mother who currently owns them isn't even renting them at market rate because she understands the hardship right now. But instead of actually reading that and seeing that they are clearly good landlords you just glossed over it and preferred to just drag em down like they are awful people

I did read it. I just don't see it as a virtue or something to boast about.

Market prices are that high because the society and politics made them that high. It is just another part of the same story where current social setup disproportionately benefits owners.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 23/12/2023 23:12

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 22/12/2023 19:45

Exactly this.
I lost my home of almost 9 years this year, just like that.
Because my landlord cottoned on that he could make more on it as a student property.
Myself and my children were suddenly homeless.

We've found somewhere else eventually, but it's turned our lives upside down.
Miles away from family, uprooted kids to different schools.

It's ridiculous that landlords have that sort of power over people's lives.
I won't write on here what I want to happen to my scumbag of an ex landlord, or my comment will disappear.

Edited

I am sorry you have found yourself in this situation. I am a landlord, I feel a great responsibility to make sure my properties are in very good condition. I promise you I treat my tenants well. Very well. But my husband and I purchased our properties during our working lives. We made many sacrifices to do so, they are our pension and as such a business. I know there are rogue landlords out there but there are also decent people.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 23/12/2023 22:53

sprigatito · 22/12/2023 19:33

I think if people don't want to be the sort of landlord who can support decent treatment of tenants, then they probably shouldn't be landlords.

@sprigatito , I am a landlord and I completely agree with you.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 23/12/2023 22:51

brainworms · 22/12/2023 19:32

Landlords are parasites.

@brainworms WOW! That’s some statement. Would you be kind enough to explain/expand?

LumiB · 23/12/2023 22:47

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 22:13

Yes, when the OP says that their family has been landlords since 1850, I made an assumption they were renting properties out. Do you have any alternative theory?

I am not totally against private ownership as a concept. I'm just saying, that the owners are massively benefiting from the current social setup and I want owners to fairly contribute to the society which first and foremost protects our ownership.

Well you ignored the whole part where she said her mother who currently owns them isn't even renting them at market rate because she understands the hardship right now. But instead of actually reading that and seeing that they are clearly good landlords you just glossed over it and preferred to just drag em down like they are awful people

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 22:13

LumiB · 23/12/2023 21:53

You aren't even making sense, a property or properties are passed on down generayios you don't know the whole history whether all of them were rented or some where lived in by family etc. You just made a massive assumption and accused them of hoarding properties. If you weren't jealous or bitter you wouldn't have.

I look forward to you not passing on your property to your children otherwise you will be what u accused them for doing hoarding property.

Yes, when the OP says that their family has been landlords since 1850, I made an assumption they were renting properties out. Do you have any alternative theory?

I am not totally against private ownership as a concept. I'm just saying, that the owners are massively benefiting from the current social setup and I want owners to fairly contribute to the society which first and foremost protects our ownership.

ChallahPlaiter · 23/12/2023 22:10

Yes you’re absolutely right. I think working in cities can sometimes skew your view and it can seem as though everywhere is in desperate crisis - of course that doesn’t apply across the board.

LumiB · 23/12/2023 21:53

You aren't even making sense, a property or properties are passed on down generayios you don't know the whole history whether all of them were rented or some where lived in by family etc. You just made a massive assumption and accused them of hoarding properties. If you weren't jealous or bitter you wouldn't have.

I look forward to you not passing on your property to your children otherwise you will be what u accused them for doing hoarding property.

Xenia · 23/12/2023 21:49

One reason people like our Western democracies is that you can own property (unlike under socialism) and subject to inheritance tax can pass it down to children just as you can pass on your genes and in a sense the way you brought them up. Passing on property is not a moral wrong unless you have a standpoint which is fairly communist. It is instead why our society is fairly stable.

The student issue is a problem in England if laws are changed - I saw a Sky news on it today - because if the student landlords have no guarantee students will leave under the new system (or they leave sooner than the 12 month tenancy) it just does not work in the student market. I hope an exception can be made for it for the sake of students.

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 21:39

LumiB · 23/12/2023 20:39

Wow your jealousy just oozes from your comment. They haven't hoarded properties its been passed down generations which is still legal as far as I know. Omif you own a property are you going to insist its sold when you die and not passed onto your children if you have any? The poster said her mother doesn't even charge the going rate she is clearly a decent landlord.

I am not jealous. I work, I earn money and I bought my home (not so long ago).

I just don't see renting places out for generations as any kind of virtue - it is a situation enabled by post-feudal concept of land ownership. And the main reason why the ownership is respected is the society. Those who are inheriting should be grateful and pay relevant inheritance taxes and so on, because they benefit the most from the current society setup.

CapitalKnockers · 23/12/2023 20:55

I sold my rental house this year after 5 years of letting it out (I moved in with my partner but kept my place). Over that time it just became far too expensive to run, I never made a profit, just enough to pay the mortgage and a small amount so I had a pot for maintenance. When I tried to sell up, nobody was interested in buying with tenants in situ, then when I served notice on the tenants so I could sell it empty they refused to move and I had to go via court then get the bailiffs in. It was horrible for everyone.

House eventually sold...to a couple moving out of London. A house gone from the rental market. If I could have made ends meet I would have stayed as a landlord. But I couldn't.

Most landlords I've met don't deserve the vitriol they get.

LumiB · 23/12/2023 20:39

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 20:01

So your family hoards properties for 1,5 centuries and your predecessors got them for peanuts from today's point of view. No wonder you defend the status quo, because the current system protects your inherited privilege.

Wow your jealousy just oozes from your comment. They haven't hoarded properties its been passed down generations which is still legal as far as I know. Omif you own a property are you going to insist its sold when you die and not passed onto your children if you have any? The poster said her mother doesn't even charge the going rate she is clearly a decent landlord.

Musntapplecrumble · 23/12/2023 20:24

As a landlord all my tenants are happy, they have made their homes, they ring me when they need anything sorting, I'm fair to them and expect the same in return. I've had a few that have just upped and left, leaving me all their rubbish etc to deal with and a house to get back to letting standards. I'm really not a parasite! However, we seem to be getting penalised more and more and in some cases it's just not a viable business. And eg if a mortgage is coming to an end and I need to sell a property - this would be a no fault eviction. I would give my tenant as much notice as possible but at the end of the day I need to sell. So if this avenue is going to be taken away, what would I do if the mortgage is coming to an end/renewal and I can't afford it? What else can I do? This is a huge fear that will surely put people off being a landlord!

ZiriForGood · 23/12/2023 20:01

DragonMama3 · 23/12/2023 17:28

My family have been landlords since 1850.

So your family hoards properties for 1,5 centuries and your predecessors got them for peanuts from today's point of view. No wonder you defend the status quo, because the current system protects your inherited privilege.

Paradise404 · 23/12/2023 19:18

CoatOfArms · 23/12/2023 17:33

YANBU.

There is a massive problem with student accommodation in the private sector in Glasgow because the Scottish government have changed the law so much in favour of the tenant. Landlords aren't interested in renting to people for 9 months or a year, knowing they have no power to get them out at the end of the agreement if they choose not to go.

There are lots of people who do not want to own a home for all manner of reasons - students, people working on a 1-year or other short term contract, people sussing out an area before committing to buy etc etc.

Au contraire students/short-term contracts are better as the tenant is guaranteed to go, churn is the downside of course but renting to students, HMO year after year it's profitable hence why so many family homes have converted to HMO.
'Long-term' tenants are harder, especially if you keep the rent below market rate. It might be difficult for them to afford anywhere else.
However if they've been good tenants for a long while you have benefited from the stability worth the wait IMO.

Even though I might be in this situation I can see the tenant POV. Not their fault the council won't house them until they've been thrown out on their ear.

App13 · 23/12/2023 19:05

WillowCraft · 22/12/2023 21:36

Rented homes and owned homes are two separate (although linked) markets. If supply increases and demand remains the same, prices drop. That applies equally in either market, unless the government controls rents or meddles in house prices

As they are separate markets as you rightly point out... demand will overshoot by a sizeable amount, supply will fall for the rental market. And the price will rise to a point that will price those the most needy out of the market. At micro local levels the equilibrium will be reached where supply =demand and anyone that cant afford it will be displaced (made homeless, or move away).
Just because supply of homes increase due to landlords selling up, doesnt mean the renters will be the end beneficiaries. The price may drop but will be buoyed by those that want to and can buy.

NeonSoda · 23/12/2023 18:38

KinS24 · 23/12/2023 15:31

I saw on the news recently that renting is cheaper than buying in most parts of the country.
Even with the current very high rents a quick calculation of what it would cost a landlord proves this - they have to pay 6% interest on purchase cost plus voids plus repairs plus insurance plus agency fees.
The past couple of decades have given profits through price increases but that’s much less likely now.
The people shouting about parasites seem to think the government should just look after everyone and don’t actually care about the reality of discouraging landlords. As long as landlords don’t make a profit sod the people who need a rental.

i bought 12 months ago, and it would certainly be cheaper to rent an identical house after considering mortgage, insurance, upkeep, maintainance, etc.

yes eventually I’ll own the property - but not until after my retirement age, and not until I’ve paid two times the value in interest.

CoatOfArms · 23/12/2023 17:33

YANBU.

There is a massive problem with student accommodation in the private sector in Glasgow because the Scottish government have changed the law so much in favour of the tenant. Landlords aren't interested in renting to people for 9 months or a year, knowing they have no power to get them out at the end of the agreement if they choose not to go.

There are lots of people who do not want to own a home for all manner of reasons - students, people working on a 1-year or other short term contract, people sussing out an area before committing to buy etc etc.

DragonMama3 · 23/12/2023 17:28

My family have been landlords since 1850.

OP posts:
Paradise404 · 23/12/2023 15:38

KinS24 · 23/12/2023 15:31

I saw on the news recently that renting is cheaper than buying in most parts of the country.
Even with the current very high rents a quick calculation of what it would cost a landlord proves this - they have to pay 6% interest on purchase cost plus voids plus repairs plus insurance plus agency fees.
The past couple of decades have given profits through price increases but that’s much less likely now.
The people shouting about parasites seem to think the government should just look after everyone and don’t actually care about the reality of discouraging landlords. As long as landlords don’t make a profit sod the people who need a rental.

People have no idea what 'profit' even means.
Property - BTL or owning your own home is a long game. Most LL's WILL make a profit. Probably. But over a period of several years.
Most people think it's as simple as 'rent = profit!' Even if they acknowledge that mortgage costs have to be deducted from rent they think LL incur no other costs.

KinS24 · 23/12/2023 15:31

I saw on the news recently that renting is cheaper than buying in most parts of the country.
Even with the current very high rents a quick calculation of what it would cost a landlord proves this - they have to pay 6% interest on purchase cost plus voids plus repairs plus insurance plus agency fees.
The past couple of decades have given profits through price increases but that’s much less likely now.
The people shouting about parasites seem to think the government should just look after everyone and don’t actually care about the reality of discouraging landlords. As long as landlords don’t make a profit sod the people who need a rental.

Paradise404 · 23/12/2023 15:21

Daphnis156 · 23/12/2023 14:56

I have never had a positive experience with a private landlord- the very term "Landlord" is absurd as if the tenant should be a "Serf", subject to a "Lord".

The more of them that get out the better, the rules and laws should leave only professional landlords, who can provide a proper service, set to a legal standard.

Wrong. 'Professionals' are worse because they have the money to turn any complaints into a long-drawn out legal battle. They can pay the few that win but the majority of tenants won't have the money to even start. Furthermore, if one company owns, say the majority of property in an area tenants even with valid complaints can be blacklisted.

Also, what exactly is the government going to do if a company is deemed a 'bad landlord'?
The company owns the houses. The government can't take over their management (if they even WANTED to they'd build social housing, no need for all this private landlording in the first place).
As I said the property, tenantless is still an asset so worst case the company can just kick the tenants out and leave it empty. Where do you expect them to go?

'Rules and laws' are only valid insofar as the resources available to defend them. So many naïve people happily bleating on about rules do you know how much going to court costs? How much time, effort paperwork etc even dealing ombudsmans requires (and how they're usually powerless anyway just telling you to taking it up legally?)

I lived in a flat with mould-covered ceiling for a year, currently my mates are living in a London flat with no hot water. Hasn't been for 6 months. Owned by a company, it still hasn't been fixed despite months of complaints, escalation, etc.

What rules do you propose that can make this better exactly. And how would they keep big companies in check better over small private LL's.

Alligator456 · 23/12/2023 15:04

@Daphnis156 Not sure the big company version will be an improvement. There will probably be a call centre with a 60 minute wait to speak to a human if you need a repair.

Also if the government makes conditions too difficult there won't be any company takers for the role either. See care homes and child care for sectors already stuffed up by the government through ill thought regulations and unrealistic levels of funding.

Goatymum · 23/12/2023 15:02

And we are prob asking a bit under the market rate. Would rather have decent tenants than be greedy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread