Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be really pissed off with nursery about this?

305 replies

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 16:31

I know I’ll probably be flamed for this but have been trying to potty train ds, obviously not very well. But FIVE piss wet through pants? He does pee on the potty when told, so AIBU to wonder wtf is going on?

OP posts:
Vavazoom · 22/12/2023 18:43

My DS took ages to potty train at 3. It was an absolute nightmare but luckily the preschool were quite pragmatic. He was ready, he is just extraordinarily stubborn and liked the ease of using his nappy. He got there in the end once he finally accepted the nappy wasn’t coming back and was dry at night from that point on as well. His understanding was quite good so whilst I didn’t tell him off I did tell him that it made me sad when he pooed in his pants. Your DS will get there in the end. It’s just a long and painful journey at times.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 22/12/2023 18:42

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 16:43

Guys, I do know he isn’t potty trained: I haven’t said he is. I have said we’re trying to potty train. I do know I’m obviously not going a very good job and it is getting me down a fair bit but I do think a few reminders are reasonable.

I don’t think it’s just catching wees as he does hold on for them. But doesn’t initiate the I need a wee conversation and I know we have to get there - just have no idea how Sad

I swear it is the most shitty thing ever pardon the pun.

Give yourself and him a break, pit him back in nappies for a month/6weeks and have another go…when they’re ready, they do it inside a week

MolkosTeenageAngst · 22/12/2023 18:41

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:35

I think the problem is many are assuming he’s having five accidents a day which isn’t the case. Many days go by with no accidents. I do think going back to nappies is really a bad idea - we’ll never get anywhere if we do that. And nursery haven’t indicated in any way that they feel it would be better for him to be in nappies.

So does he go most days at nursery with no accidents? If so it seems a bit mean spirited to be complaining about them, on the last day of nursery before Christmas where presumably the staff are exhausted and the kids all tired and over-excited and where they’ve probably been doing lots of Christmas activities all day whilst the staff also try to get everything closed down ahead of being closed for the period - fridges emptied, toys wipes down and cleaned etc. If this is just one unusual bad day and he’s usually dry then I think you really are over-reacting being annoyed in the first place! Maybe he was just too excited ahead of Christmas to tear himself away from the activities today when prompted, it might also be that he’s eaten or drunk something which has caused his bladder to be overactive. Foods/ drinks like squash, caffeine and some food colourings irritate my bladder and make me need to go a lot more frequently than normal and make it harder to hold. Have they had any Christmas treats to eat/ drink today at nursery?

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:35

I think the problem is many are assuming he’s having five accidents a day which isn’t the case. Many days go by with no accidents. I do think going back to nappies is really a bad idea - we’ll never get anywhere if we do that. And nursery haven’t indicated in any way that they feel it would be better for him to be in nappies.

OP posts:
Bertiesmum3 · 22/12/2023 18:32

Saschka · 22/12/2023 18:25

Rubbish, lots of children need prompting right through primary school. They don’t have the foresight to think ahead about access to toilets. DS has been potty trained since he was 2, he still needs the occasional reminder aged 7 if he is engrossed in something.

If OP tells her child to go to the toilet at breakfast, lunch, tea and bedtime, and he is dry in between, he is potty trained. She doesn’t need to wait until he knows he needs to go completely independently to start training him.

Your child needs the occasional reminder, OP child needs prompting all the time, there’s a difference

MolkosTeenageAngst · 22/12/2023 18:30

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:14

The thread is very divided between those who would only wait for a child to be ready (I am not sure what constitutes being ready) and those who would encourage first. I’m in the latter camp but understand why others feel differently. However, it might be helpful if the thread wasn’t just full of ‘he’s not readys’

Sorry if you find suggesting he’s not ready unhelpful. Maybe it is just that you’re doing a poor job of training but you sound like you are doing the right thing and haven’t given up at the first hurdle, if people were saying he’s not ready after a few days of trying I’d understand disagreeing but a month is enough time to get an idea of whether it is clicking or not. Has he ever actually recognised the need to wee or taken himself to the potty without a reminder yet?

If somebody was complaining their 17-month-old wasn’t walking yet despite doing lots of exercises to try and get them there I think people would be saying you can’t push and force these things, children all do it at their own pace and just become some children walk at 9 months and quickly go from toddling to running doesn’t mean some babies don’t need longer. Personally I think it’s the same with toilet training, some kids just aren’t ready until later than others and you can’t necessarilly ‘train’ for it anymore than you can ‘train’ a baby to walk. There are things you can do to promote and encourage the skill, but if they’re not working yet even after a month it might indicate that your child isn’t at that stage of development yet and is just going to be later to master that skill than average. You wouldn’t push baby to crawl or walk or talk etc, personally I don’t know why toilet training is completely different. When a child is truly ready it does just click within a few days, if it’s taking weeks/ months you’re not really training you’re just choosing to spend the time between now and when he’s ready for it to click with him in wet pants and lots of stress for everyone. If it’s not going to click for another month or two (and it doesn’t sound like it will) my opinion would be you may as well just go back to pull-ups until that time and then start again and get it cracked in a few days rather than slog out the next few months with pants until he’s ready. But obviously your child your choice, it’s reasonable not to want to put him back in nappies until he’s ready, but then obviously don’t complain about wet pants if you’re choosing that path!

macaronicheezepleeze · 22/12/2023 18:29

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:14

The thread is very divided between those who would only wait for a child to be ready (I am not sure what constitutes being ready) and those who would encourage first. I’m in the latter camp but understand why others feel differently. However, it might be helpful if the thread wasn’t just full of ‘he’s not readys’

Those who encourage it first may be saying that only because they happened to get lucky with a child who was ready when they wanted to start potty training.

Your son sounds like he needs reminded far too regularly and so you're not actually seeing how good is bladder control is. He's a biddable child who is willing to sit on the potty when reminded. That's not the same as a child who is actually ready to be out of nappies, as evidenced by the frequent accidents when he's not got someone constantly reminding him to go and pee.

By the time he finally cracks it you'll be thinking "see I knew he was ready" when you could have saved yourself months of accidents and started him the week before.

Everyone saying they cracked it in a few days or a week had children who were actually ready.

Merryandbright1170 · 22/12/2023 18:27

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 16:37

I know he isn’t potty trained but he will go if told. I don’t think telling three year olds to go to the potty should be beyond them.

They have a load of other children to look after, they can't keep constantly reminding your DS to go on the potty. As you said he isnt potty trained and needs to be told

Saschka · 22/12/2023 18:26

sprigatito · 22/12/2023 18:16

Lots of three year olds aren't ready, especially boys. I think you should put him back in pull-ups and take the pressure off him. Toilet training too early is damaging, and if you're having to "force them a bit" then it's too early.

Telling a three year old to go to the toilet before lunch is not “damaging”.

CrebillionFils · 22/12/2023 18:25

Not sure if you follow them (or if someone has already recommended them) but the women behind ‘Big Little Feelings’ (on Instagram) do a potty training made simple online class that all my friends with older children swear by.

Saschka · 22/12/2023 18:25

Bertiesmum3 · 22/12/2023 18:13

If he’s only going to pee when prompted, he’s not ready to be potty trained, he needs to stay in nappies for longer, a colleague tried to potty train her child too early and it had a negative impact on him.
Wait until he tells you he needs to use the potty, not you havto tell him, he’s only 3!!

Rubbish, lots of children need prompting right through primary school. They don’t have the foresight to think ahead about access to toilets. DS has been potty trained since he was 2, he still needs the occasional reminder aged 7 if he is engrossed in something.

If OP tells her child to go to the toilet at breakfast, lunch, tea and bedtime, and he is dry in between, he is potty trained. She doesn’t need to wait until he knows he needs to go completely independently to start training him.

margotrose · 22/12/2023 18:20

However, it might be helpful if the thread wasn’t just full of ‘he’s not readys’

Do you not think everyone is telling you that for a reason, though?

People aren't saying it to be mean or to upset you, they're saying it to try and help you.

sprigatito · 22/12/2023 18:16

Lots of three year olds aren't ready, especially boys. I think you should put him back in pull-ups and take the pressure off him. Toilet training too early is damaging, and if you're having to "force them a bit" then it's too early.

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:14

The thread is very divided between those who would only wait for a child to be ready (I am not sure what constitutes being ready) and those who would encourage first. I’m in the latter camp but understand why others feel differently. However, it might be helpful if the thread wasn’t just full of ‘he’s not readys’

OP posts:
margotrose · 22/12/2023 18:14

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:11

@margotrose five accidents a day is not typical: if it was fair enough.

He can hold on.

I understand that, but he obviously can't hold it consistently and regularly which is why people are focusing on him needing to ask.

Either they need to be at the stage where they can hold it until they reach a toilet, or they need to be able to say "I need a wee please" every single time.

Bertiesmum3 · 22/12/2023 18:13

If he’s only going to pee when prompted, he’s not ready to be potty trained, he needs to stay in nappies for longer, a colleague tried to potty train her child too early and it had a negative impact on him.
Wait until he tells you he needs to use the potty, not you havto tell him, he’s only 3!!

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:12

It isn’t impossible @JoyeuxNarwhal , although no other symptoms.

OP posts:
Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:12

@steppingcarefully they certainly haven’t communicated that to me, the opposite in fact.

If nursery said ‘look, we really don’t feel he’s ready’ I’d listen to that, but they haven’t, and in fact have been reassuring re accidents.

OP posts:
JoyeuxNarwhal · 22/12/2023 18:11

5 in a day @Undertheladder? Is it possible he has a UTI?

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:11

@margotrose five accidents a day is not typical: if it was fair enough.

He can hold on.

OP posts:
steppingcarefully · 22/12/2023 18:11

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 16:45

@Extratoebeans the staff ratios for 3 year olds are one to eight. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask one adult to remind eight children to go to the toilet every couple of hours, I really don’t.

You clearly have never worked in a nursery!
Do you think this is the only thing a nursery worker has to do, monitor eight children and remind them to go to the toilet? If only! A child not potty trained with a parent insisting on sending them in pants is one of the most frustrating parts of the job.

margotrose · 22/12/2023 18:08

HolidaysPleaseNow · 22/12/2023 17:53

To be fair, I have a child who has been toilet trained for two years now. She STILL doesn't initiate going to the toilet. She never has accidents though and never has, she can hold the toilet for hours and hours. But she only eventually goes when she's made to.

So for some kids, this is how they are. You can't just keep a kid in nappies forever till they tick every box

But your DD isn't having accidents - that's the difference. If OP's son could hold it until say, a break or lunch, it would be fine, but he clearly can't.

SparklyOwls · 22/12/2023 18:07

Seriously please just take a deep breath. Why the hurry, are you comparing to other children? My son didn't really get it until he was nearly 4.

Undertheladder · 22/12/2023 18:06

Thanks. I’m honestly not really annoyed, was just a bit frustrated and feeling like we’d taken a massive step back but I think it was just a bad day. I realise others would go back to nappies but genuinely believe that’s not right for us at this time. I’ll try commando in the new year. We are making progress, just slow!

OP posts:
supersonicginandtonic · 22/12/2023 18:06

My daughter has been in pants since July and is always dry when with me, but still has accidents at nursery. It's because they are occupied and engrossed in their play. It's not nurseries fault.