Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Walked out of family Christmas lunch and cancelled plans for Xmas day as felt ignored

666 replies

Wensleydales · 22/12/2023 16:09

Big family lunch today , MIL kept saying how she thought I looked ‘pale’ and ‘unwell’ going on about why I wasn’t drinking etc etc etc. just generally being irritating and critical.

In the end I told her the truth ( I hadn’t wanted to ruin a family event with bad news) that I’d had a MC a couple of weeks ago . When I said she said nothing ?? Started telling me that actually I just hadn’t been eating properly I thought maybe she hadn’t heard ?? So I explained again and she just said nothing then walked off to talk to SIL??

I burst into tears . We left and dh called her when home and she tried to ignore it again - he then asked her what the issue was with her acknowledging it? She proceeded to say women find out too early now (I had told her I was 12 weeks???) and it’s no more than a heavy period and she can’t entertain my attention seeking over that .

Im so upset that we’ve said we are not hosting them on Xmas day now

OP posts:
momonpurpose · 22/12/2023 22:05

FestiveFruitloop · 22/12/2023 21:55

Hello, OP's MIL.
That's the only possible explanation I can think of for this post.

Clearly mil has a mumsnet account 😆

momonpurpose · 22/12/2023 22:04

Mumtobabyhavoc · 22/12/2023 20:34

Are you kidding? 🤦‍♀️

It must be mil 😆

Youarebeingserious · 22/12/2023 22:03

People who think it’s a heavy period obviously never had a mc at that stage. If she’s clueless she should’ve shut the hell up
Im sorry op, you must be feeling so wounded as it is and it’s a beyond expected knife twist.
I would keep her far away from you

Mydogmylife · 22/12/2023 22:01

Good grief

DancesWithDucks · 22/12/2023 22:01

So in other words, you're supposed to feel bad as MiL is a little unwell, while she is so extraordinarily cruel after you've gone through a miscarriage?

At least you know what sort of stuff your MiL and FiL are made of now.

Glad that your partner is strong and has your back. So sorry for your loss, @Wensleydales

SecondUsername4me · 22/12/2023 21:56

Sharpness19 · 22/12/2023 21:53

Absolutely, I agree with you.

The MIL hounded the OP because she wanted to expose an "I'm pregnant" declaration. Which couldn't have been more wrong. She was asking the OP what was wrong - she suffered a MC that's what's wrong. So the OP told her what was wrong.

The MIL then minimised the experience, and even blamed the OP for her "tenancy to stress" as a direct cause of the MC.

FestiveFruitloop · 22/12/2023 21:55

Sugarsun · 22/12/2023 21:45

I’m sorry but I think you are over reacting.

She was concerned about you because you looked unwell.

Instead of saying that you’re feeling unwell you chose to bring up your MC during your Christmas lunch.
You then got annoyed/upset because she didn’t press you for further details or carry on the conversation.

Considering there have been multiple threads about how offensive it is to say you’re sorry etc after someone’s had a MC, then she probably felt it was better to say nothing at all.

She was wrong to say you found out too early but you/your DH did press her to comment on it and I’m not sure that whatever she said would have been the right thing to say.

I think cancelling Christmas because she didn’t give you the response you want us very OTT.

Hello, OP's MIL.
That's the only possible explanation I can think of for this post.

Sharpness19 · 22/12/2023 21:53

Sugarsun · 22/12/2023 21:45

I’m sorry but I think you are over reacting.

She was concerned about you because you looked unwell.

Instead of saying that you’re feeling unwell you chose to bring up your MC during your Christmas lunch.
You then got annoyed/upset because she didn’t press you for further details or carry on the conversation.

Considering there have been multiple threads about how offensive it is to say you’re sorry etc after someone’s had a MC, then she probably felt it was better to say nothing at all.

She was wrong to say you found out too early but you/your DH did press her to comment on it and I’m not sure that whatever she said would have been the right thing to say.

I think cancelling Christmas because she didn’t give you the response you want us very OTT.

Absolutely, I agree with you.

tachetastic · 22/12/2023 21:53

Wensleydales · 22/12/2023 16:09

Big family lunch today , MIL kept saying how she thought I looked ‘pale’ and ‘unwell’ going on about why I wasn’t drinking etc etc etc. just generally being irritating and critical.

In the end I told her the truth ( I hadn’t wanted to ruin a family event with bad news) that I’d had a MC a couple of weeks ago . When I said she said nothing ?? Started telling me that actually I just hadn’t been eating properly I thought maybe she hadn’t heard ?? So I explained again and she just said nothing then walked off to talk to SIL??

I burst into tears . We left and dh called her when home and she tried to ignore it again - he then asked her what the issue was with her acknowledging it? She proceeded to say women find out too early now (I had told her I was 12 weeks???) and it’s no more than a heavy period and she can’t entertain my attention seeking over that .

Im so upset that we’ve said we are not hosting them on Xmas day now

I am so sorry OP for what must have been an awful experience, being in effect forced to come out about a very painful experience and then being ignored.

You are doing absolutely the right thing. She won't learn to respect both your privacy and the need to acknowledge what you say unless they have an awkward few days sitting in a very quiet house thinking about what could have been. If they are calling to say sorry now, it's because they're sorry you're not cooking their lunch. Not for what she said.

And can I say a big thank you and well done for DH standing up for you against his parents with what seems no questions asked. He only did what he should have done, but there are so many threads on here about husbands trying to avoid arguments with their mothers by expecting their wives to back down. Good for him that he basically said get out and don't come back until you can show my wife the respect she deserves.

Shudacudawuda · 22/12/2023 21:46

Garlicnaan · 22/12/2023 20:54

I'm sorry your blood loss was so bad, but isn't that somewhat irrelevant?

It can still be incredibly traumatic to have a miscarriage, regardless of blood loss.

It's highly relevant in respect to MIL's comment that a miscarriage at 12 weeks is like a late period. She could not be more wrong.

Sugarsun · 22/12/2023 21:45

I’m sorry but I think you are over reacting.

She was concerned about you because you looked unwell.

Instead of saying that you’re feeling unwell you chose to bring up your MC during your Christmas lunch.
You then got annoyed/upset because she didn’t press you for further details or carry on the conversation.

Considering there have been multiple threads about how offensive it is to say you’re sorry etc after someone’s had a MC, then she probably felt it was better to say nothing at all.

She was wrong to say you found out too early but you/your DH did press her to comment on it and I’m not sure that whatever she said would have been the right thing to say.

I think cancelling Christmas because she didn’t give you the response you want us very OTT.

Hickry · 22/12/2023 21:44

Stick to your guns.

They'll manage getting a food shop one way or another.

Her "apology" to you is just as shitty as her initial response. 🤬😡🤬 Let them stew.

User1789 · 22/12/2023 21:42

Canthave2manycats · 22/12/2023 21:33

I am right. Plenty of others have related how common an attitude it was. Your mum is one person's experience. I am here to tell you that some people still trivialised and we are talking early 00s even though I was devastated too!

Yes I remember my mother (late boomer/in her early 60s now) telling me my friends' (and some relatives') miscarriages at 6-8 weeks were just late periods, and wasn't it silly how people tested so soon these days and got upset over a loss at that stage?, in the early 00s. She thought she was being nice and helpful to suggest women shouldn't be going and getting all upset over early losses.

She didn't believe in early testing, thought it just caused obsessive behaviour and upset, and was also quite cross when she went to her GP in the mid-90s with her final pregnancy to be told they weren't going to test her if she had already done a positive pregnancy test herself!

She was pulled up on it and has since changed her tune, as many others of her generation with some actual empathy will have done.

And of course, there will have been some trailblazers/people who questioned the status quo/with some empathy in all generations past. But to suggest that the attitudes the MIL voiced weren't quite typical at a certain time, is actually quite minimising and dismissive, in much the same way those views were then.

DuckyShincracker · 22/12/2023 21:41

Omg you win the worst MIL prize there, sadly. Sending you a hug lovely. Flowers

WhichIsItWendy · 22/12/2023 21:39

girlfriend44 · 22/12/2023 21:35

Just leave it, why do people advocate texting. Don't you think they might then be tempted to text back, then you've got to think of something else. It then goes into tit for texting until someone gives up.

Best advice is to leave it for now. Silence is very powerful. Very powerful indeed. If you do talk, get together face to face not through texting.

We're permitted to have different approaches?

Personally I believe in being honest and open. MIL needs to understand why OP is so upset and needs to work to repair the relationship.

Silence doesn't always say it all. MIL is clearly not emotionally mature enough to know why OP is upset or she wouldn't have reacted the way she did. So what makes you think silence will impact her at all?

Anyway, your approach is different to mine, it doesn't make it superior. OP can use or ignore any advice.

contrary13 · 22/12/2023 21:37

I am so sorry for your loss, @Wensleydales . And for the callous and cruel way that your MIL has treated you and tried to (wrongly) make out that you were at fault in any way.

As someone said earlier, this isn't about generational differences. My grandmother was born in the 1930s - and lost a baby at birth. When I suffered a miscarriage at 10 weeks in my 20s, she went above and beyond to look after me, to make sure that I knew I hadn't done anything wrong, that sometimes nature is just cruel, that it wasn't a case of my body being faulty or me being a shitty mother (which my ex was telling me at the time), it was just something beyond anyone's control or comprehension. Compare that to my mother, who was born in the 1950s, when I had a miscarriage two years ago (14 weeks, needed medical intervention because of the blood loss and stage of pregnancy)... and this is a woman who has endured miscarriage several times herself, mind... and I was made to feel like I ought to crawl away into a hole and just wait it out alone and without any support whatsoever (she did likewise when I suffered a partial miscarriage at 9 weeks with my son's twin 19 years ago - so not really a shock this time around). I know, though, that she has unresolved trauma herself from her own losses, which she has never had therapy for. Actually, I don't think she's ever spoken about them to anyone - I only know because my Dad explained it to me when I had the partial miscarriage and couldn't understand her attitude towards (a) another woman and (b) her own daughter... But then, like you, OP, I have a great partner who stepped up and we went LC for a while until I felt strong enough to deal with her again. She has never mentioned our loss since, To her - it's like it never happened...

Being as kind as I possibly can right now, all I can surmise is that your loss has triggered something within MIL that you and your husband don't - and probably never will - know about. The fact that your husband immediately stood up against the way that she made you feel and told her how unacceptable it is? You've got a keeper, there.

I will never understand why it's always women making other women feel like shite when it comes to pregnancy - one way or another, especially with regards to miscarriage or stillbirths/loss shortly after birth/child loss at all... we ought to support one another. I know that my own experiences have rendered me more sympathetic to those of my friends who have gone through similar, to the point where I now consider my cousin's wife (who I barely knew at the time, but who I said "here to listen if you ever need a shoulder" to) more family than the son of my Aunt whom she eventually married!

Flowers
girlfriend44 · 22/12/2023 21:35

WhichIsItWendy · 22/12/2023 21:26

Yeah, I couldn't forgive that.

I'm really sorry for your loss. Ive had a few miscarriages and they truly broke my heart. Your MIL, I presume, hasn't suffered a loss before and seems to be completely selfish.

I'd be texting her "MIL, I'm so shocked and disappointed at your reaction to me letting you know I've lost my baby. I assure you, every woman knows she's pregnant by 12 weeks, as you've missed 3 periods by then. And I assure you, miscarrying a pregnancy at 12 weeks is painful both physically and emotionally. If you were in emotional pain, I would comfort you. Your lack of understanding and empathy towards your own daughter in law and son speaks volumes. It has nothing to do with attention and everything to do with natural emotions and supporting people we love. I'm sorry you couldn't support us the way you should and for that, I can't spend Christmas with you. I hope you manage to sort out the shopping."

What a prick she is.

Just leave it, why do people advocate texting. Don't you think they might then be tempted to text back, then you've got to think of something else. It then goes into tit for texting until someone gives up.

Best advice is to leave it for now. Silence is very powerful. Very powerful indeed. If you do talk, get together face to face not through texting.

Canthave2manycats · 22/12/2023 21:33

ClairDeLaLune · 22/12/2023 20:54

Just because you’re not a lone voice doesn’t mean you’re right. My mum had a MC in 1965 and was very upset about it, and my dad took her on a special holiday to help her through it. They definitely didn’t treat it as just a bad period.

OP your MiL is awful. I hope she chokes on her lonely Christmas dinner.

I’m very sorry for your loss Flowers

I am right. Plenty of others have related how common an attitude it was. Your mum is one person's experience. I am here to tell you that some people still trivialised and we are talking early 00s even though I was devastated too!

strawberry2017 · 22/12/2023 21:32

I'm so sorry OP, sending love and strength x

MrsAnon6 · 22/12/2023 21:32

Wensleydales · 22/12/2023 16:13

She’s text me to say that she’s sorry but that she thinks I over react and stress too much so that won’t have helped 🤦‍♀️

Has this woman not heard of empathy 🤦‍♀️?

Popcorn23 · 22/12/2023 21:30

I'm so sorry for your loss.

Your MIL sounds awful. You walking away from the lunch and changing Christmas plans is completely understandable. Good on your husband for supporting you too!

DumpseyDaisey · 22/12/2023 21:28

I'm sorry about your baby.

I really don't agree that age excuses such cruelty. My MIL and her 2 sisters were all in their 70s when I was losing my babies, and they couldn't have been kinder or more understanding, not least because they'd either been there themselves or were close to someone who had.

I feel very sorry for your dh who will be grieving too, and now has this schism with his parents too. It sounds like he's got more class and backbone than both his parents put together....Good for him.

I'm not sure if your family are nearby, but if moving a long way from your inlaws is possible, I'd seriously consider it.

fulawitt · 22/12/2023 21:27

My mouth is still wide opened in shock as I read the answer of this "person". What a wack !!! Big hugs to you OP. You deserve a big hug and flowers and I am so sorry for your loss.

WhichIsItWendy · 22/12/2023 21:26

Yeah, I couldn't forgive that.

I'm really sorry for your loss. Ive had a few miscarriages and they truly broke my heart. Your MIL, I presume, hasn't suffered a loss before and seems to be completely selfish.

I'd be texting her "MIL, I'm so shocked and disappointed at your reaction to me letting you know I've lost my baby. I assure you, every woman knows she's pregnant by 12 weeks, as you've missed 3 periods by then. And I assure you, miscarrying a pregnancy at 12 weeks is painful both physically and emotionally. If you were in emotional pain, I would comfort you. Your lack of understanding and empathy towards your own daughter in law and son speaks volumes. It has nothing to do with attention and everything to do with natural emotions and supporting people we love. I'm sorry you couldn't support us the way you should and for that, I can't spend Christmas with you. I hope you manage to sort out the shopping."

What a prick she is.

Inertia · 22/12/2023 21:24

Sorry for your loss. Breathtakingly callous of your MIL, and you are entirely justified in not wanting to see them.

Be warned- there will probably be some fabricated catastrophe on Christmas Day where they will demand your husband dance attendance on them. Glad to see he has your back .

Swipe left for the next trending thread