Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this obsession with Sundays is unfair

87 replies

luckyc26 · 22/12/2023 12:26

Been with DP 5 years, and MIL/his family expect us to alway be available on Easter Sunday, Xmas, Boxing Day, and the Sunday after any family birthday free, every year without fail.

For everything except Xmas, they usually don’t mention anything until 24-48 hours before, and then call to check that we’ll be there at a location of their choosing, which is always in the town where they live but 25 mins from us. When we’ve suggested meeting in the middle (sometimes for fairness and sometimes for a refreshing change, they say they don’t like the menu or it’s too expensive - which it isn’t, it’s the same as the places they go).

In total this is 9 weekends of the year, including the summer bank hol and the weekend before Xmas. If we say sorry, we can’t do tomorrow as we have plans and nothing had been mentioned by you, they say “well you KNOW we do this on this day every year”. Which is true, but I don’t think we should be so inflexibly bound by their traditions?

DP is so used to this behaviour that he doesn’t question it, which makes navigating the topic very hard. I come from a family where everyone is very relaxed about when we celebrate things, and makes plans far in advance so everyone is clear on what’s going on. I’ve tried to ask for more notice, and suggested perhaps we could do a weekday evening sometimes instead of a whole Sunday. But they won’t budge and always make an excuse.

For context - his family work either part time or don’t work due to disability, and we both work full time Mon-Fri, so our weekends are precious for relaxing, getting housework and maintenance done, and seeing our friends, as well as family.

Am I insane/a control freak who can’t relinquish my diary? Or is this behaviour totally unfair on their part? DP and I have a very healthy relationship and have made our peace with each other about it, but it still causes issues when the family ring to confirm our attendance. Any advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Becgoz7 · 24/03/2024 22:37

luckyc26 · 22/12/2023 12:26

Been with DP 5 years, and MIL/his family expect us to alway be available on Easter Sunday, Xmas, Boxing Day, and the Sunday after any family birthday free, every year without fail.

For everything except Xmas, they usually don’t mention anything until 24-48 hours before, and then call to check that we’ll be there at a location of their choosing, which is always in the town where they live but 25 mins from us. When we’ve suggested meeting in the middle (sometimes for fairness and sometimes for a refreshing change, they say they don’t like the menu or it’s too expensive - which it isn’t, it’s the same as the places they go).

In total this is 9 weekends of the year, including the summer bank hol and the weekend before Xmas. If we say sorry, we can’t do tomorrow as we have plans and nothing had been mentioned by you, they say “well you KNOW we do this on this day every year”. Which is true, but I don’t think we should be so inflexibly bound by their traditions?

DP is so used to this behaviour that he doesn’t question it, which makes navigating the topic very hard. I come from a family where everyone is very relaxed about when we celebrate things, and makes plans far in advance so everyone is clear on what’s going on. I’ve tried to ask for more notice, and suggested perhaps we could do a weekday evening sometimes instead of a whole Sunday. But they won’t budge and always make an excuse.

For context - his family work either part time or don’t work due to disability, and we both work full time Mon-Fri, so our weekends are precious for relaxing, getting housework and maintenance done, and seeing our friends, as well as family.

Am I insane/a control freak who can’t relinquish my diary? Or is this behaviour totally unfair on their part? DP and I have a very healthy relationship and have made our peace with each other about it, but it still causes issues when the family ring to confirm our attendance. Any advice?

9 sundays out of the whole year 🤷‍♀️ seems a bit mean not to go. 25 minutes really isn't that bad.

TheCatfordCat · 22/12/2023 17:33

I work 5 Sundays out of 6 so that wouldn't work for me. When I was married I suppose I would have sent ex-DH alone.

CruCru · 22/12/2023 17:26

whatchagonnado · 22/12/2023 17:01

Can you book a holiday away at Easter? And / or the Summer bank holiday? It might break the pattern of expectations

Yes, go skiing!

whatchagonnado · 22/12/2023 17:01

Can you book a holiday away at Easter? And / or the Summer bank holiday? It might break the pattern of expectations

spriots · 22/12/2023 16:35

On one hand you say you want them to give you more notice but they are very clear - it's the sunday after each event, never changes, and neither does the venue, so they are giving you more than a year's notice for every event!

This struck me as well.

If you want to see your family on Christmas/Easter, of course that is reasonable - though you haven't mentioned that as an issue you have so I wonder if it is a problem?

But otherwise, I think they are giving you plenty of notice, just in a different way to how you're expecting to receive it.

If you can't make one because you want Christmas with your family one year or because you want to go on holiday or whatever, they shouldn't guilt trip you about it and your DP does need to stand up to them about it.

But if you don't want to go because you want to relax or do DIY or something, that comes across as a bit petty? It's not that many occasions in a year. Of course I am assuming that this is otherwise a healthy relationship and he attends family events on your side as well.

OVienna · 22/12/2023 16:18

electriclight · 22/12/2023 12:31

This wouldn't bother me. I expect to see my family at Easter, Christmas and for family birthdays and a 25 min commute is a lot less than the one I do. I am not sure why it's a problem but if it is, can't your dh tell them you need more notice?

what about the OPs family?

easylikeasundaymorn · 22/12/2023 16:16

It doesn't sound particularly unreasonable to be honest - most families see each other over christmas/easter and on birthdays, so I don't see how them doing theirs on the sunday after each event is any more imposing than the normal expectation? If anything it makes things easier as you then have the actual day free to do other stuff.

On one hand you say you want them to give you more notice but they are very clear - it's the sunday after each event, never changes, and neither does the venue, so they are giving you more than a year's notice for every event!

Same with where you meet - if they all live in the same place it makes sense you go to them. All of my family live in one area and I live elsewhere so it's almost always me doing the travelling. Yes it's a bit annoying but it makes sense. Also if the events other than the 2 holidays (easter/xmas) are for their birthdays then they get to choose where they go. Obviously for your/dh/your kids bdays if you'd rather go out somewhere else you get to choose. But it's not unreasonable for the birthday person to choose the venue, and if it's somewhere they know everyone will eat at, who cares if its not the most exciting? You have literally every other week of the year to eat somewhere else.

The only unreasonable bit is you feeling you have to go along with all of them. e.g. I wouldn't not book a holiday because it spans the sunday after SIL's birthday or something. Similarly if its a week like this one, and they want to see you the sunday before christmas (24th) and then boxing day just say no, we don't need to see each other twice in 3 days, we'll just see you on boxing day as planned.

AnnaMagnani · 22/12/2023 16:13

Don't marry or have children with this man until he has learnt how to withstand his parents guilt tripping.

It's perfectly normal that as your kids turn into adults they have other commitments.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 22/12/2023 16:12

electriclight · 22/12/2023 12:33

If it's 9 Sundays maximum, leaving 43 Sundays free, and it's your Easter/Christmas/birthday visit, then that's ok surely. Would some people not see their families for those events then?

Exactly. 9 Sundays to see family sounds fine to me.

KombuchaKalling · 22/12/2023 16:10

I think boundaries are needed as it all sounds a bit much and the rigidity about where / when sounds excessive. Especially the back story about them not working so most likely have way more free time. I can see why it gets in the way of you seeing your family which isn’t fair. As others have said how about some of the time you both go and at others just your partner does?

My ex husbands family were quite like this. They used to fixate a lot about Easter but sometimes l had to work, sometimes l wanted to see my family (they didn’t live near where we did) and sometimes l wanted to relax. Set in stone arrangements don’t work for me

DancesWithDucks · 22/12/2023 16:09

Can your DP stand up to the guilt tripping, without resenting you? "Yes Auntie Guilt-Us-Up, we are missing this meetup but we'll be there for the next and thoroughly looking forward to it!" Rinse and repeat.

IF he can't then you're going to have to let him go alone or go along with it yourself ... forever. Or decide to go separate ways.

I'd take a good hard long look at his behaviour and his parents' expectations for how things are going to be if you have kids.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 16:04

electriclight · 22/12/2023 12:33

If it's 9 Sundays maximum, leaving 43 Sundays free, and it's your Easter/Christmas/birthday visit, then that's ok surely. Would some people not see their families for those events then?

Well the OP might want to see her own family.

Or go on holiday, especially over Easter,

SiobhanSharpe · 22/12/2023 16:03

This all sounds tedious as fuck to me, OP. Always a standard pub-type lunch, or similar, in a venue that's not great for you, and it's not to be changed in any way.
I wouldn't care for the set-in-stone aspects one bit. Is this highly uncompromising behaviour likely to extend to all your interactions ? What would happen if you decided to have a few days away at the Bank Holiday weekend? Or to spend Christmas in a hotel?
Time to opt-out, just leave it to your DH. (At least on some of the occasions. And best of luck!)

luckyc26 · 22/12/2023 16:00

Thanks everyone - it’s really helpful to hear different opinions outside of mine and DPs.

To clarify, it’s not just those 9 days that we see them - MIL is on the phone every few days asking when DP/we can go round next even if we’ve just seen her a few days before, which I also find quite overbearing. We see them at least once a month together on top of the ‘Sundays’ and he sees her 1 on 1 a lot more than that.

Fully appreciate the comments around 25 mins - I wasn’t saying that’s far at all, it’s more the principle of why do they NEVER want to come to us, and refuse if we suggest it. My family are always happy to chop and change if we go to them or vice versa, so again it’s just oddly strict to me.

Have tried setting boundaries, and DP tries to reason with them in advance around “we can’t do this Easter we’re already doing this” etc, but then has received guilt tripping texts from family members saying he’s upset his mum/aunts etc by bowing out. And as some PP’s have said, I’m concerned it will become a real issue if children come into the mix eventually.

Ultimately I just feel guilty and awkward being seen as the ‘difficult’ one if I don’t go, but also I see it as a common courtesy to ask someone if they’re free as opposed to demanding it. Maybe it’s just an inevitable ongoing clash as our families are so very very different, so our expectations are too!

OP posts:
XiCi · 22/12/2023 15:49

I think most people see their families around those times and 25 mins travel is nothing

Fivepigeons · 22/12/2023 15:44

It would be fair enough if they actually reminded you and gave you notice but I do think it's selfish of them not to consider that you work and have a busy life that doesn't revolve around theor birthdays so might need reminding or to be flexible on dates and places sometimes

Changingplace · 22/12/2023 15:44

ZenNudist · 22/12/2023 14:08

This. It's not a lot to expect to see family on birthdays Christmas and Easter and you live nearby.

I travel much further to see in law's for similar occasions.

It would only be an issue if your family didn't get a look in.

People on mumsnet always want to ditch their DH family in favour of pottering around their own home or seeing their own family more. I hope my ds wants to see me for family birthdays when we are older.

The OPs family clearly aren’t getting a look in, hence why this is an issue :)

GrumpyPanda · 22/12/2023 15:42

electriclight · 22/12/2023 12:31

This wouldn't bother me. I expect to see my family at Easter, Christmas and for family birthdays and a 25 min commute is a lot less than the one I do. I am not sure why it's a problem but if it is, can't your dh tell them you need more notice?

You see your own family for holidays and you really and truly can't work out that OP might have a problem because she wants to do likewise and see HER family on at least some of these occasions?

Andylion · 22/12/2023 15:38

If we say sorry, we can’t do tomorrow as we have plans and nothing had been mentioned by you, they say “well you KNOW we do this on this day every year”.

Then you say “Yes, I know that’s what we’ve always done but this year we want to…. that’s why we’re telling you in advance.”

MolkosTeenageAngst · 22/12/2023 15:37

9 Sundays a year isn’t very many for seeing ILs, it’s less than once a month. 25 minutes is hardly any distance at all, lots of popl have longer commutes to work and school! If the Sundays they are the same every single year I would argue they have been booked in advance by default, if you know that they’ll want to see you the Sunday after a birthday they don’t really need to arrange it. That said, if there is a conflicting event on one of these Sundays you want to attend it wouldn’t be unreasonable to let them know in advance, ‘Just to let you know we won’t be free on the Sunday after DHs birthday as we’ve got other plans, let us know if we can see you another day that week.’

SantaExpress · 22/12/2023 15:37

@NeverDropYourMooncup
Good post!👏 so right about children in this sort of situation

bellac11 · 22/12/2023 15:36

What do you mean 'more notice', if these dates are fixed in stone then you know when they are, why do you need specific notice, you're already on notice

And 25 mins from where you live isnt far at all.

SantaExpress · 22/12/2023 15:35

Def opt out!!
My DP mum and dad have form for this.. it’s more of a command than an invite and any plans we have are immediately binned in favour of the trek over there to do jobs and drink brutally strong tea!
Oddly, DP is not so keen to go if I dig in and refuse to go with him!! We have spent many a sunny Sunday in their dark living room yelling at his Dad who won’t use his bloody heating aid!!
Join my ‘Opt Out’ club!
(and bugger that with the X amounts of weekends a year… absolutely not!! Very intrusive and tone deaf of them)

OwlWeiwei · 22/12/2023 15:34

This wouldn't bother me at all. 25 minutes in no travel time at all! And I'd want to celebrate family birthdays. I'd take it in turns with Christmas/Boxing Day/Easter between in-laws, own family and celebrating on our own though.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/12/2023 15:34

Being pessimistic, knock the ritual of every major Sunday, the ones before, the ones after now, because if you have children, it's expected to continue - and then if you split up, there's an entire lifetime (the children's) of precedent where they always go to his family for Christmas/Easter/Bank Holidays/always having to take holiday before being back in time for the 'massive family events that they would be excluded from and luckyc's harming the children' by wanting to go on holiday/etc.

My mother kicked off when my sister decided to go as a family to her MIL's for Boxing Day and come round 24 hours later 'But Boxing Day's MY DAY'. As though she wasn't around 365 days of the year.