Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give our mum presents for Christmas

87 replies

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:19

My brother and I have the misfortune of having a complete waste of space for a mother. She drinks, but that's only part of the problem. The selfishness runs deeper than that.

He came back into her life after decades. He made an effort to have a relationship with her but she just let's him down, as she has me all of my life.

I'm low contact with her but for his sake agreed to go for a meal with him, mum and SIL to celebrate his birthday and recent wedding. He really wanted her to come.

She agrees to come and says how lovely it will be then turns her phone off on the day. I finally get hold of her two days later, pissed, and she just says she mixed the days up. No apology or call to my brother. Nothing. She knows he has left me with a present for her.

It's obvious she hasn't bothered getting us or any of the kids anything for Christmas, not even a card, so WIBU to just not bother taking hers over?

I'm so angry with her because I know she has hurt him. Again.

OP posts:
shepherdsangeldelight · 22/12/2023 15:39

All I’m saying is find out her story before you judge. Be prepared. It won’t be pretty.

OP can both understand and sympathise with her mum's alcoholism and any trauma that may have caused it AND decide that she is not prepared to put up with her mum's behaviour.

This is not about judging. It's about protecting herself.

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 15:20

There’s an awful lot to untangle here. What trauma led to your mum becoming an alcoholic OP? I’m pretty certain she didn’t wake up one morning and decide to become dependent on alcohol.

You say your brother was taken into care and later adopted yet you stayed in the care of your mother. There’s a story right there.

Your mum probably wanted to attend your brothers birthday bash. However, if she is an alcoholic her priority would be “How can I have a drink when I’m with other people. I want to be there. I want to make a good impression for my son. But I can’t. I know I can’t”.

Having an alcoholic for a mother is not easy. God knows I lived it. It was only when my mum died did I learn her story. I cannot believe she managed to survive through the trauma she did. I guess she had no choice than to live through and was then cast out by her family.

Has your mum explained to your brother the true reason he landed up in care? He seems to have time for her - when others don’t.

All I’m saying is find out her story before you judge. Be prepared. It won’t be pretty.

Nobody becomes an alcohol for no reason.

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 13:58

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 12:35

What makes you think that?

asking you
his sister
knowing she has a very negative relationship with her mother
knowing the effort this involves for you
knowing the toxic childhood you both endured

LimeCheesecake · 22/12/2023 12:50

Oh OP - you need to really stop covering for your mum, you have stopped taking her to get gifts, but you still agreed to go visit her to cover that she couldn’t turn up for your brother.

message him and say you aren’t going to go to visit her soon, and is he ok with you posting his gift? Go to the post office today and get it gone.

in the future, don’t say you’ll take things for her to save your brother having the stress, he’s a middle aged man, it’s not your role to save him from Mum caused stress.

perhaps you also need to be clear to him that you won’t be taking care of your mum or seeing her.

shepherdsangeldelight · 22/12/2023 12:48

I called her two days later and told her I had her Christmas present from him so to let me know when she wanted to meet me somewhere for it. She hasn't bothered calling and was probably too pissed to even remember the call.

So you've already carried out a reasonable action and it's now on your mother. It's not up to you to bend over backwards to enable her bad behaviour. Shove the present in a cupboard. If she's not arranged to pick it up by the end of January ask your brother whether he wants it back or whether you should donate it to charity.

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 12:47

LittleGreenDragons · 22/12/2023 12:22

Ah right, well that's ok then..🙄

Don't be silly. The point of my post is that trying to get an alcoholic to do normal, every day things is not possible. You need to understand the limitations so you stop getting so hurt. It's a form of therapy that is specifically designed for families dealing with addiction. If you refuse to understand that she will never act how a normal mother/person will act then you will always be setting yourself up for pain. You know she's an alcoholic, you know she doesn't function/think like normal people so why do you keep expecting her to behave like one?

Anyway back to your original question - message her that you have his present to her and she can come and pick it up (at set time/date). Don't make a special trip to take it.

Sorry, I do see where you're coming from.

Where I'm concerned I don't tend to have many expectations of her as I don't have much to do with her at all, but in my brothers case he has a bit of hope that she'll care / make an effort. It's his disappointment and upset that hurts really.

He didn't grow up under mums care whereas I did. It's a long and complex story but the short version is that he was adopted as a child and came looking for her as an adult and they reunited 6 years ago. He sees alot of good in her that just isn't there.

I had no idea he existed until about 6 months before we met.

We clicked straight away and have built a good relationship. Mum made an effort to start with but soon reverted to type as shes completely disinterested in nurturing any sort of relationship with either of us, meanwhile me and my brother are in pretty regular contact so I know he still holds hope for a closer relationship with her so things like this make him feel abandoned all over again.

I was gutted when she let him down, because I know it hurt him and he deserves better.

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 22/12/2023 12:42

OP, you and your brother are doing great, so be very proud of having peaceful and functional lives. Be even more proud that you have managed to put very firm boundaries in place to manage your mother. My god that's a long painful journey but you have done it

I would not be putting myself out in any way over this. I would text her and say you have a present, and ask her to come and get it or meet you to pick it up. She probably won't show up, but you've given her the option. That's the end of your responsibility. Im so sorry that you're dealing with this x

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 12:35

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 12:06

your brother sounds thoughtless and insensitive

What makes you think that?

OP posts:
MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 12:34

Clarinet1 · 22/12/2023 12:02

I am sorry for your situation. It sounds very sad and difficult. However, the bit I don’t understand is why you have to be the go-between for your brother? Why can’t he post or deliver the present himself?

Ah I forgot to mention he doesn't live in the same city as us. He came last weekend for a pre arranged meal expecting her to be there so he could give it to her directly, but as she wasn't there he passed it over to me along with gifts for me nd my DC and I said I'd make sure she gets it.

I called her two days later and told her I had her Christmas present from him so to let me know when she wanted to meet me somewhere for it. She hasn't bothered calling and was probably too pissed to even remember the call.

OP posts:
LittleGreenDragons · 22/12/2023 12:22

Ah right, well that's ok then..🙄

Don't be silly. The point of my post is that trying to get an alcoholic to do normal, every day things is not possible. You need to understand the limitations so you stop getting so hurt. It's a form of therapy that is specifically designed for families dealing with addiction. If you refuse to understand that she will never act how a normal mother/person will act then you will always be setting yourself up for pain. You know she's an alcoholic, you know she doesn't function/think like normal people so why do you keep expecting her to behave like one?

Anyway back to your original question - message her that you have his present to her and she can come and pick it up (at set time/date). Don't make a special trip to take it.

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 12:06

your brother sounds thoughtless and insensitive

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 12:06

Clarinet1 · 22/12/2023 12:02

I am sorry for your situation. It sounds very sad and difficult. However, the bit I don’t understand is why you have to be the go-between for your brother? Why can’t he post or deliver the present himself?

exactly

this is a middle aged man presumably with full mental and physical capabilities

ReindeerShelter · 22/12/2023 12:04

YABU. This isn’t about her, or you. Your brother gave you the present in good faith to give to her.

Drop it off on her doorstep and leave it at that.

Clarinet1 · 22/12/2023 12:02

I am sorry for your situation. It sounds very sad and difficult. However, the bit I don’t understand is why you have to be the go-between for your brother? Why can’t he post or deliver the present himself?

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 11:51

ok so the fact she is an alcoholic is actually irrelevant to the issue.

She has always been horrible

in which case, i would have said years ago to my brother that i believe this is someone who is a profoundly negative person in our lives and, as a consequence i do not want to be exposed to her anymore. i love you, and i am concerned about you having a relationship with her but, as a grown assed man, that is your prerogative

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 22/12/2023 11:47

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:23

That's why I'm conflicted, as it's from him.

She lives a reasonable distance from me and it'll be a faff going all the way over there on public transport and I really don't want to see or deal with her.

But then it'll be him I'm letting down 😔

Ask your brother ...... given the situation does he still want mum to have his present?

If so, wait until you next see her and give it to her then. Why would you make a special trip? or he can collect it from you and drop it off to her if he wants her to have it sooner.

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 11:43

I don't actually expect presents from her. I already know she doesn't care so that's just another way she makes that obvious really.

No, she wasn't a good mother to me. Very emotionally immature and unavailable. She did the bare minimum and even begrudged that.

My brother is in his 40's, just married no children yet but TTC.

We've both done alright really, considering.

OP posts:
youneveractually · 22/12/2023 11:36

how old is your brother? he’s married, with children?

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 11:35

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:27

Not anymore no, i don't allow it. My youngest has only seen her a handful of times in his life.

rather optimistic then to expect presents from her

She’s an alcoholic. As was my mother. It is hell. Was your mother otherwise a good mother pre drinking problem ? your childhood?

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 11:05

Thank you for the suggestions, I'll consider the options.

In the past I've been guilty of shielding him from just how shit she. An example of this would be for birthdays in previous years, I'd go with her and choose something from her to him, go with her to post it to make sure it gets posted. I'd chase her up when we had a meet up planned and tie myself in knots to try and make sure she was sober for it and turned up.

Those days are long gone, I just won't take responsibility for her anymore. I don't bother with her at all unless completely unavoidable.

I also realised that whilst my intentions were good, trying to spare his feelings, I'm not helping anybody and actually he should see just how selfish she is.

OP posts:
VeronicaMars2023 · 22/12/2023 10:51

I wouldn’t withhold it, but I also wouldn’t go out of my way to get it to her, I’d just let he know that “I have a gift for you from DB, let me know when you are able to collect”

It won’t be colllected, but that’s on her, not you.

MarleyandMarleyWoooo · 22/12/2023 10:49

You poor thing. I’m sorry for you and your brothers troubles, your mother sounds very difficult.
I wouldn’t bring her present to her but, as a kindness to my brother, I would post it to her. And then I would go on living my life without making one iota of effort towards her, and refusing to allow her to disrupt my peace wherever possible.

Paperbagsaremine · 22/12/2023 10:45

Post it and then go live your best life.

If you have any doubts, imagine a sensible man in your position doing what you'd like to do, and ask yourself, would I think he's being a dick or not? (I think women are often influenced into treating themselves worse than other people, which is barmy when you think about it).

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:44

LittleGreenDragons · 22/12/2023 10:40

Alcoholics live in a different world. Only alcohol features in it, nothing else. You wouldn't expect a heroin addict to think rationally and alcohol addiction can be very similar.

I suggest you get some support from the AA family group so you can understand this horrible addiction better and how to accept her limitations without it hurting you as much.

Ah right, well that's ok then..🙄

OP posts:
LittleGreenDragons · 22/12/2023 10:40

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:30

Yes, we know.

Why does that absolve her of taking one hour out of her time to turn up to something that is really important to her son?

She couldn't even be arsed to buy and send a £1 card.

Alcoholics live in a different world. Only alcohol features in it, nothing else. You wouldn't expect a heroin addict to think rationally and alcohol addiction can be very similar.

I suggest you get some support from the AA family group so you can understand this horrible addiction better and how to accept her limitations without it hurting you as much.