Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give our mum presents for Christmas

87 replies

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:19

My brother and I have the misfortune of having a complete waste of space for a mother. She drinks, but that's only part of the problem. The selfishness runs deeper than that.

He came back into her life after decades. He made an effort to have a relationship with her but she just let's him down, as she has me all of my life.

I'm low contact with her but for his sake agreed to go for a meal with him, mum and SIL to celebrate his birthday and recent wedding. He really wanted her to come.

She agrees to come and says how lovely it will be then turns her phone off on the day. I finally get hold of her two days later, pissed, and she just says she mixed the days up. No apology or call to my brother. Nothing. She knows he has left me with a present for her.

It's obvious she hasn't bothered getting us or any of the kids anything for Christmas, not even a card, so WIBU to just not bother taking hers over?

I'm so angry with her because I know she has hurt him. Again.

OP posts:
Mumof2NDers · 22/12/2023 19:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Did you grow up with an alcoholic mother?

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 19:15

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 19:02

Do you think people reach low/no contact lightly?

ACOA's spend years of their lives trying to save and help their AP and are dragged right down with them.

'Someone' HAS tried to get her the help she needs MANY, MANY times. She doesn't engage and doesn't want it.

You sound completely dim and out of touch with the world. People like you are the reason ACOA's are kept in the trenches longer than they ever should be.

Even Al-Anon tells you to detatch.

Just go away. Please. You will never understand and for that you should be thankful.

Edited

Sorry? I cared for my alcoholic mother until I was forced to live with my abuser(s).

My mum was not easy to live with. In fact it was Hell on Earth at times. My only regret is that I had no idea about the trauma she had suffered until it was too late. Now I am aware of what she went through I can totally understand why she hit the bottle.

I wish my mum had had someone to help drag her out of the living Hell she endured. hope your mum finds the helps she desperately needs.

I can totally understand why you are angry but I’ll leave you to it.

Lottapianos · 22/12/2023 19:14

@PurpleParrots, I don't know why you felt the need to write such nasty and unhelpful posts

@MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 , I hope you know that plenty of people on here completely understand why you need to maintain your hard-fought-for boundaries with your mother, and I hope you can ignore any spiteful nonsense

PurpleParrots · 22/12/2023 19:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 19:02

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 18:55

I hope your DM finds peace at Christmas. I hope someone cares enough to make sure she’s ok and to offer her the compassion she deserves. Hopefully someone will get her the help she needs 🙏

Do you think people reach low/no contact lightly?

ACOA's spend years of their lives trying to save and help their AP and are dragged right down with them.

'Someone' HAS tried to get her the help she needs MANY, MANY times. She doesn't engage and doesn't want it.

You sound completely dim and out of touch with the world. People like you are the reason ACOA's are kept in the trenches longer than they ever should be.

Even Al-Anon tells you to detatch.

Just go away. Please. You will never understand and for that you should be thankful.

OP posts:
ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 18:55

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 18:45

Excuse you. You have no idea how many years I spent trying to keep her on the straight and narrow to my own detriment. I'm not even going to entertain such a narrow minded comment with an explanation.

People that get it, get it.

I hope your DM finds peace at Christmas. I hope someone cares enough to make sure she’s ok and to offer her the compassion she deserves. Hopefully someone will get her the help she needs 🙏

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 18:45

PurpleParrots · 22/12/2023 18:25

It's about protecting herself

That’s stating the obvious! 😂

How is your mother spending Christmas OP? Has anyone bothered inviting her to spend Christmas with her family or is her Christmas going to be spent with her drowning in whisky/vodka/gin/(insert her favourite blockout). Because that’s what alcoholics do right? Like they have a choice.

It’s no secret that alcoholics don’t function like normal people. Did you and your brother make a fuss on your mother’s birthday? Or are only mothers expected to push the boat out to cajole their adult offspring?

It’s up to you whether you give your mother a gift from her son tbh. It hardly warrants a thread asking opinions from strangers. Either give her the gift as agreed or send it back to your brother to do with as he pleases. Or shove it in the back of a cupboard if it’s easier.

Will anyone be checking that your dm is ok over Christmas?

Excuse you. You have no idea how many years I spent trying to keep her on the straight and narrow to my own detriment. I'm not even going to entertain such a narrow minded comment with an explanation.

People that get it, get it.

OP posts:
PurpleParrots · 22/12/2023 18:25

It's about protecting herself

That’s stating the obvious! 😂

How is your mother spending Christmas OP? Has anyone bothered inviting her to spend Christmas with her family or is her Christmas going to be spent with her drowning in whisky/vodka/gin/(insert her favourite blockout). Because that’s what alcoholics do right? Like they have a choice.

It’s no secret that alcoholics don’t function like normal people. Did you and your brother make a fuss on your mother’s birthday? Or are only mothers expected to push the boat out to cajole their adult offspring?

It’s up to you whether you give your mother a gift from her son tbh. It hardly warrants a thread asking opinions from strangers. Either give her the gift as agreed or send it back to your brother to do with as he pleases. Or shove it in the back of a cupboard if it’s easier.

Will anyone be checking that your dm is ok over Christmas?

HolyZarquonsSingingSeals · 22/12/2023 17:33

Post the gift back to your brother and let him decide what he wants to do about it.

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 17:06

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 15:45

Alcoholism runs in the family unfortunately. I don't know about any trauma she went through before I was born as she never opened up about anything. My grandparents are deceased and I don't have anything to do with mums siblings who are just as bad.

My brother was relinquished at birth. I was born 11 years later and I didn't know anything about him.

We have different fathers (he is mixed race and I'm not) and she claims not to remember who either of them are, so none of us know where we came from.

She's obviously a very complex woman and no doubt will be carrying things that she doesn't speak of so I have empathy for that. I 'parented' her since I was a child myself, but she treat me dreadfully and let me down at every turn - so I'm past caring about the 'whys' now. Sorry if that sounds harsh. I don't mean to seem uncaring.

Edited

Your maternal family sound very like mine. I was allowed to stay with my mother. My younger siblings were taken into care. Sounds ridiculous but that’s how it was. My life was caring for my “waste of space” mother until I was 15. I was then placed with my father and his toxic mother. They instilled in me a great hatred of my mother. They managed to convince me she deserved nothing but a knife between her shoulderblades. She was everything that is wrong with world….

It was only when my mother passed did I have any incline as to why she became an alcoholic. I'm not going to post my story but in short I was removed from a, then, alcohol dependent woman that I had no choice than to look after and was later removed to live with a cruel, self absorbed, sadistic, lying, abusive bastard. And his equally disgusting mother. They were the very reasons why my mother had to resort to alcohol to drown out the reality of her life. The trauma she endured throughout her life is incomprehensible and I wish I had known this before it was too late.

If you feel your mother doesn’t deserve a gift from your brother then dont give it to her and explain to your brother why. If your mother is anything like mine she won’t come to yours to collect it. My mother couldn’t have even if she’d wanted to.

I hope you feel content with whatever decision you make. Hope you have a lovely Christmas. Everyone deserves to be happy at Christmas… or so the story goes 😏

🎅🏻 🌲 xxx

Newgirls · 22/12/2023 17:03

You are trying to protect/rescue your brother as well as deal with your alcoholic mum. I really feel for you trying to deal with all of it. You don’t have to and can protect yourself too x

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 16:34

You're right. Thank you. I needed to hear these things. I'm going to send him a text shortly.

OP posts:
mottytotty · 22/12/2023 16:21

You can’t protect your brother forever, he is a man in his 40s.

Tell him that you won’t be seeing mum over Christmas after her no show so you’ll wait to hear from him on what to do with her present. Say you’ll post it back to him in the New Year or whatever he wants to do with it, such as a food bank, charity shop etc.

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:19

please send my message to your brother! tonight! don’t waste another thought thinking about this OP

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:18

exactly op

You are 11 years younger than your brother
You didn’t “escape” anything as a child

You need to keep your distance from your mother
and you need to have a fairly direct word with your brother about your stance on your mum and how passing things on to her… is simply not on the cards

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 16:18

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:15

do you though?

I've got my DP and DC 🙂

I don't have a paternal family though as I haven't a clue who he is, nor does my mum.. apparently 🙄

OP posts:
MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 16:16

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:13

he deserves so much better.

so do YOU!!

Thank you 🥺

I've got a habit of putting other people's feelings above my own, that's something I learned from being 'parentified' growing up. I need to give my head a wobble and cop on to the fact that caring about my brother and his feelings doesn't need to mean I neglect my own in the process.

OP posts:
youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:15

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 16:12

As for his adoptive dad, he seems like a decent man and he has a positive relationship with him so it's not all bad. He does have people who care about him.

do you though?

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:13

he deserves so much better.

so do YOU!!

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 16:12

As for his adoptive dad, he seems like a decent man and he has a positive relationship with him so it's not all bad. He does have people who care about him.

OP posts:
youneveractually · 22/12/2023 16:12

I think we both felt awkward about the fact she hadn't turned up and he didn't know what else to do with it at the time other than to just leave it in the bag.

He has a relationship with her, albeit very stunted

You (thankfully) do not,

So just drop him a message and say - “mum’s present was in the bag but obviously i won’t be seeing her any time soon (or at all!), so shall i pass it back to you when we next see each other or do you want me to post? xxx”

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 16:10

He didn't ask me outright to take responsibility for it, but it was in the bag that he gave me containing my present and my DC's.

I think we both felt awkward about the fact she hadn't turned up and he didn't know what else to do with it at the time other than to just leave it in the bag.

Unfortunately his adoptive mother is also an alcoholic, albeit a functioning one (unlike our bio mum)

She moved away a while ago but he sees her every so often.

Actually that just reminded me, she too let him down about going to see him before he and SIL went abroad the week before.

So that's both his mothers who did the same thing in a short space of time.

He's such a good person and I hate how all of that must make him feel, he deserves so much better. Fortunately SIL is amazing and he has plenty of support in her (and me - I love him to bits)

OP posts:
youneveractually · 22/12/2023 15:51

what kind of relationship does he have with the parents who raised him?

youneveractually · 22/12/2023 15:50

it doesn’t make you sound “harsh” in the slightest

This woman catastrophically let you down as a child

what is “harsh” is your much older brother not being sensitive to all this and asking this of you

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 15:45

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 15:20

There’s an awful lot to untangle here. What trauma led to your mum becoming an alcoholic OP? I’m pretty certain she didn’t wake up one morning and decide to become dependent on alcohol.

You say your brother was taken into care and later adopted yet you stayed in the care of your mother. There’s a story right there.

Your mum probably wanted to attend your brothers birthday bash. However, if she is an alcoholic her priority would be “How can I have a drink when I’m with other people. I want to be there. I want to make a good impression for my son. But I can’t. I know I can’t”.

Having an alcoholic for a mother is not easy. God knows I lived it. It was only when my mum died did I learn her story. I cannot believe she managed to survive through the trauma she did. I guess she had no choice than to live through and was then cast out by her family.

Has your mum explained to your brother the true reason he landed up in care? He seems to have time for her - when others don’t.

All I’m saying is find out her story before you judge. Be prepared. It won’t be pretty.

Nobody becomes an alcohol for no reason.

Alcoholism runs in the family unfortunately. I don't know about any trauma she went through before I was born as she never opened up about anything. My grandparents are deceased and I don't have anything to do with mums siblings who are just as bad.

My brother was relinquished at birth. I was born 11 years later and I didn't know anything about him.

We have different fathers (he is mixed race and I'm not) and she claims not to remember who either of them are, so none of us know where we came from.

She's obviously a very complex woman and no doubt will be carrying things that she doesn't speak of so I have empathy for that. I 'parented' her since I was a child myself, but she treat me dreadfully and let me down at every turn - so I'm past caring about the 'whys' now. Sorry if that sounds harsh. I don't mean to seem uncaring.

OP posts: