Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give our mum presents for Christmas

87 replies

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 10:19

My brother and I have the misfortune of having a complete waste of space for a mother. She drinks, but that's only part of the problem. The selfishness runs deeper than that.

He came back into her life after decades. He made an effort to have a relationship with her but she just let's him down, as she has me all of my life.

I'm low contact with her but for his sake agreed to go for a meal with him, mum and SIL to celebrate his birthday and recent wedding. He really wanted her to come.

She agrees to come and says how lovely it will be then turns her phone off on the day. I finally get hold of her two days later, pissed, and she just says she mixed the days up. No apology or call to my brother. Nothing. She knows he has left me with a present for her.

It's obvious she hasn't bothered getting us or any of the kids anything for Christmas, not even a card, so WIBU to just not bother taking hers over?

I'm so angry with her because I know she has hurt him. Again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 23/12/2023 09:54

Thank you. I expect their relationship will fizzle out now i have stopped acting as middle woman unfortunately as mum just won't make the effort. It's shit for DB but nobody can change her, she is who she is.

OP posts:
Member984815 · 23/12/2023 09:48

Please ignore the people suggesting you haven't done enough , you have . She doesn't want to change . Please take care of yourself , if your brother wants a relationship allow it to be separate from his relationship with you.

caringcarer · 22/12/2023 20:26

ReindeerShelter · 22/12/2023 12:04

YABU. This isn’t about her, or you. Your brother gave you the present in good faith to give to her.

Drop it off on her doorstep and leave it at that.

Why is it OP having to make a special trip to drop her gift from brother. He could post it or drop it across himself.

caringcarer · 22/12/2023 20:25

Well I'd not be making a special trip to drop it over. Let her fetch it if she wants it or wait until she does turn up. I'd warn your brother again about how unreliable she is and I'd go full NC with her myself.

AtrociousCircumstance · 22/12/2023 20:24

OP you have every right to distance yourself. I hope you have a peaceful Christmas and please do not for one moment feel any of the guilt that some (very few) posters are trying to lay on you for their own reasons.

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 20:23

Nicole1111 · 22/12/2023 20:21

What on earth have I stumbled upon?! A thread where the op talks about repeatedly being let down by her mother who appears to have almost no capacity for change despite her daughter and numerous services trying to help her, and somehow this has turned in to op being criticised. No apparent thought for the likely impact of her experiences on the op, respect for her having boundaries that protect her and her children or admiration for how she’s trying to protect her brother with seemingly little thought for her own feelings. You couldn’t write it.
Op I applaud you for breaking the cycle and I wish you a very very merry Christmas. Your family are lucky to have!

Edited

Thank you so much ❤️

OP posts:
MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 20:21

Gymnopedie · 22/12/2023 20:19

OP do you realise that in trying to protect your brother from the reality of your mother you are now parentifying him? He's 11 years older than you, you have to let him find out the truth for himself. You don't need the stress of shielding him on top of everything else you've had to cope with in your life.
And yes, put the ball back in his court on the present.

That dawned on me today as I've read back through the thread yes. Old habits die hard eh. I've made the decision not to shield him from it any more, it's not fair on anybody least of all him.

OP posts:
Nicole1111 · 22/12/2023 20:21

What on earth have I stumbled upon?! A thread where the op talks about repeatedly being let down by her mother who appears to have almost no capacity for change despite her daughter and numerous services trying to help her, and somehow this has turned in to op being criticised. No apparent thought for the likely impact of her experiences on the op, respect for her having boundaries that protect her and her children or admiration for how she’s trying to protect her brother with seemingly little thought for her own feelings. You couldn’t write it.
Op I applaud you for breaking the cycle and I wish you a very very merry Christmas. Your family are lucky to have!

Gymnopedie · 22/12/2023 20:19

OP do you realise that in trying to protect your brother from the reality of your mother you are now parentifying him? He's 11 years older than you, you have to let him find out the truth for himself. You don't need the stress of shielding him on top of everything else you've had to cope with in your life.
And yes, put the ball back in his court on the present.

Justcallmebebes · 22/12/2023 20:16

I had an alcoholic mother too OP, so I get why you're tying yourself in knots. I have no advice because every situation is different, but I understand why this is difficult xx

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 20:13

I had a conversation with DB last month when we were arranging to meet and I was open about how much I've had to pull back and why. I made clear, in as nice a way I could put it, that I was only agreeing to the dinner with her for his sake. I told him I didn't want to be the reason he didn't see her when I knew he really wanted to.

He lives a considerable distance away and doesn't come here much, so he wanted to see us both together.

I do worry that he might reach the same conclusion as some posters on here, that I should be doing more to support her and checking on her all of the time.

Fortunately he hasn't seen her at her worst and hasn't had the years of shit that I've had, so he still has a bit of an idealistic view of her and thinks she's a really kind hearted person.

He's never had to deal with her drunk, or the fallout from it. Years ago after they reunited I would tie myself in knots to make sure she was sober on the day she was meeting him, even pleading with her to stay at my place the night before so I could be certain she'd 1) not drink and 2) actually turn up.

So when he saw mum he wasn't getting the version I get 6 days out of 7. For a couple of hours on that one day she was fine, then she'd hit the bottle again and it was another week of hell for me. Sleepless nights wondering if something had happened to her. Calling the police to do welfare checks. Endless calls to adult social services and the people who work at her housing complex. It never ended. Round and round it went. She would turn her phone off for days at a time so I'd rush over there to make sure she was OK. She always was, she just didn't want me to know she'd been drinking. I used to beg her to keep her phone on and said I don't care if she's drunk when she answers I just need to know she's safe and well.

Then there was the hospital trips. Sitting in A&E with her at 1 week post cesarean section, newborn in tow, because she fell over outside. She thought all of that was hilarious and was cracking jokes about having a CT scan on her head.

My DB wasn't witnessing any of this and I didn't want to burden him with it so I dealt with it myself as he shouldn't have to deal with that.

I felt responsible for her as I'd been the parent in the relationship since I was a child myself.

Round and round we go. Weekly, for years. Abuse. Panic. Stress. Anxiety. Anger. Rinse and repeat.

She hits rock bottom early last year and winds up in hospital. She had 'mild' liver damage (a miracle in itself) but was physically in a bad way in general. She tells them she wants to quit the booze so she has an inpatient medical detox. I cared for her when she came out.

6-7 months of sobriety followed with me supporting her every step of the way.

The time comes to have some tests done on her liver, I assume to see if it had healed.

She reports good news, shes "alright now", then goes straight back to drinking that day.

She was counting down the days until she could get away with it. A choice at this point.

That's when I thought bollocks to this I'm not going through all of that again, I'm not having my children exposed to that anymore now they're reaching an age they'd know something was amiss.

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 22/12/2023 20:10

Give the present back to your brother and then he can decide what to do with it, this isn't your responsibility.

Princessfluffy · 22/12/2023 20:04

YANBU OP.

You need to protect yourself from the painful impact of your mother's behaviour. Don't try to protect your brother from your mother, this isn't your job as he is an adult now. It's also obviously not your responsibility to cure your mother's alcoholism.

It's shit to have an alcoholic parent Flowers

AtrociousCircumstance · 22/12/2023 20:02

@MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 Send your DM’s address to @PurpleParrots and @ShonaShoop so they can immediately sacrifice their time, health and sanity to trying to support your DM. Sounds like they’re willing.

coronafiona · 22/12/2023 19:43

Post it to her. The balls in her court then

Mumof2NDers · 22/12/2023 19:43

PurpleParrots · 22/12/2023 19:28

I was born to two drug addicted parents. I grew up in foster care going round and round the care system until I left care. Then I lived with GP’s. By then my father had died from his addiction. Thankfully my DM’s family managed to get her the help she needed to kick her addiction. She is now a fully functioning GM and very much loved by her family and GC.

Im not perfect. My dysfunctional childhood didn’t set me on the right path.

I hope that helps

I’m truly sorry to hear that. It’s great that your DM got the help she needed. It does sound like OP has tried many times to help her DM but at some point self preservation is a must. I had a very narcissistic FIL. We tried time and time again to have a relationship with him but in the end went NC, His behaviour was affecting our whole family. Every olive branch was thrown in our faces. You can’t help someone if they don’t want to be helped. I hope you and your family have a lovely Christmas

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 19:42

mottytotty · 22/12/2023 19:23

So you couldn’t drag your own alcoholic mother out of her living hell but you feel qualified to judge OP and make passive aggressive comments about OP’s mum finding peace and compassion with praying emojis?

You are in no position to preach to anyone.

I’m not sure any 15 year old could drag a parent from a living hell tbh?

I’m not preaching to OP. I understand, totally, what she’s been through. I’m sorry I hoped her mother may find support and peace before it’s too late. I’m obviously wrong. I give up 🤷🏻‍♀️

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 19:32

I'm glad some people understand why I've had to step away. Thank you. Please be under no illusion that I haven't tied myself in knots for years trying to support her into sobriety.

I'm really, really upset.

You can't "get" somebody help. You can take a horse to water but can't make them drink. Surely Purple you should understand that?

OP posts:
PurpleParrots · 22/12/2023 19:28

Mumof2NDers · 22/12/2023 19:17

Did you grow up with an alcoholic mother?

I was born to two drug addicted parents. I grew up in foster care going round and round the care system until I left care. Then I lived with GP’s. By then my father had died from his addiction. Thankfully my DM’s family managed to get her the help she needed to kick her addiction. She is now a fully functioning GM and very much loved by her family and GC.

Im not perfect. My dysfunctional childhood didn’t set me on the right path.

I hope that helps

Eekmystro · 22/12/2023 19:27

Op I’m so sorry it sounds like your mother has let you down ever since you were born. It’s absolutely ok to not see her to pass on your DBS present.

I think contact DB and let him know you have chosen not to see your mum so won’t be able to pass the present on. It might be helpful for him to see someone else having boundaries, but also he is old enough to choose to deliver the present himself if he thinks it is important for her to have it.

Sounds like you and DB are lucky to have each other and it sounds like you care for him a great deal. It does sound like you are taking too much responsibility for the situation though. If he is let down by your mum that is on her. You shouldn’t feel you have to mitigate the impact on him. Just focus on your own relationship with him, I’m sure he values that immensely.

ItsMyPartyParty · 22/12/2023 19:26

OP I can see where your brother is coming from - he will have had years of building a picture of her in his head, and coming to terms with the fact that is not reality will be difficult. But you don’t have to protect him from the reality of what your life was like. Whether that means a solid boundary: “my life with her was hell, I understand you want a relationship with her but I will not be a part of that” or whether you actually give him the detail.

For the present - I’d tell him you won’t be taking it to her, that you’ll hang on to it for him to do whatever he wants with it.

And some of the posters on here are utterly ridiculous. You do not have to bear responsibility for someone who just puts you through hell for years and years.

mottytotty · 22/12/2023 19:25

Lottapianos · 22/12/2023 19:14

@PurpleParrots, I don't know why you felt the need to write such nasty and unhelpful posts

@MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 , I hope you know that plenty of people on here completely understand why you need to maintain your hard-fought-for boundaries with your mother, and I hope you can ignore any spiteful nonsense

I agree, I’ve reported some of these posts to MNHQ.

@MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 you have no need to apologise to anyone. You have done nothing wrong.

mottytotty · 22/12/2023 19:23

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 19:15

Sorry? I cared for my alcoholic mother until I was forced to live with my abuser(s).

My mum was not easy to live with. In fact it was Hell on Earth at times. My only regret is that I had no idea about the trauma she had suffered until it was too late. Now I am aware of what she went through I can totally understand why she hit the bottle.

I wish my mum had had someone to help drag her out of the living Hell she endured. hope your mum finds the helps she desperately needs.

I can totally understand why you are angry but I’ll leave you to it.

So you couldn’t drag your own alcoholic mother out of her living hell but you feel qualified to judge OP and make passive aggressive comments about OP’s mum finding peace and compassion with praying emojis?

You are in no position to preach to anyone.

MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 19:19

ShonaShoop · 22/12/2023 19:15

Sorry? I cared for my alcoholic mother until I was forced to live with my abuser(s).

My mum was not easy to live with. In fact it was Hell on Earth at times. My only regret is that I had no idea about the trauma she had suffered until it was too late. Now I am aware of what she went through I can totally understand why she hit the bottle.

I wish my mum had had someone to help drag her out of the living Hell she endured. hope your mum finds the helps she desperately needs.

I can totally understand why you are angry but I’ll leave you to it.

I'm so sorry, I quoted the wrong person that was for Purple Parrots.

OP posts:
MeRrYcHrIsTmAs2023 · 22/12/2023 19:18

I'm angry because I've done everything you think I should be doing, 100 times over, so much so it was taking my attention away from the people I actually have a responsibility for. My children.

You've read one snippet of what has happened over the years. I went through sheer unrelenting hell as a child, teenager and then adult. I've got bucket loads of my own trauma, half of which happened on her watch.

She has taken so much from me. No more. It took me a long time to get here but i'm glad that i have.

I'm truly sorry for your loss.

OP posts: