Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he should maintain current contributions?

310 replies

Polewire · 22/12/2023 09:54

I know there’s been a few threads about child maintenance etc but this is slightly different.

my ex and I split up 4 years ago. We have 2 children, 6 and 5. He left me for a woman 15 years younger than him, she was about 24 at the time I think, they maintain they didn’t have an affair but I’m 99% sure they did. That’s another story though. To be honest, I thought it was a mid life crisis and would never last but fast forward to today and they’ve bought a house, have a baby and are getting married in a few months time. Based on what my DC tell me (they stay with ex and his partner every other weekend) it’s a happy home.

i haven’t physically spoken to my ex since we split. All communication is done on an app. I hate him for breaking up our family. I hate the fact that he never wanted to do anything with us, was out every night of the week and weekend with work/sports/hobbies and now he seems to have given up all that to spend time with his partner and their child. It’s not fair on my children that they’ve seen their dad transform into this wonderful dad and partner with the new baby and partner when he wasn’t like that with us.

anyway - this is my issue. His partner has a really good job and is going back to work soon. He’s reducing his hours (she gets paid probably 3x as much as him) in order to look after their child so my maintenance is going to go down because it’s solely based on his hours.

as it stands I just get by with the amount he pays each month and if he drops down hours then I’ll lose out and they’ll still be living their high life - fancy jeep, hotel stays all the time, stuff I wouldn’t even be able to dream of doing with my children. Would it be unreasonable to message him on the app and outline that although it’s based on his income, given that he’s reducing his hours for his other child and given the fact shes earning well that he should maintain the amount he’s currently paying for our children?

OP posts:
QueenCoconut · 22/12/2023 12:09

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:01

I can’t deny that I do feel some element of bitter feeling. They’re getting married soon and he wouldn’t marry me yet he done a big fancy proposal for her after a year and they planned a wedding straight away. I’m more upset for my children to be honest. He wouldn’t do anything with us and if he did, it was an argument yet he’s all over social media posing with her and the child taking them to see Santa. My children come back from his house feeling lousy because he spends all his time with the baby. I understand a baby has more needs but surely she could just take him when my children are there so they actually get some time with their dad? I just think it’s exceptionally unfair that they can live the high life and contribute so little to my children. I don’t think that’s unreasonable. The children don’t want more contact with him. My childcare arrangements aren’t costing me anything so it would be of no benefit him having them more anyway.

The benefit would be the father and children building a bond for life and having a normal relationship, which currently you are preventing from developing. They are his children do you understand that? They are his just as much as they are yours. It is not for you to judge how much contact he should be allowed.

you should adjust the schedule to 50/50 as the first step. The second step would be to develop a long term career plan that will take you to a place where you can afford to buy luxuries for your children and not feel bitter about other women earning more.

no sympathy from me, sorry.

TypicalCoach · 22/12/2023 12:08

I hope you can try make time to try and enjoy life yourself, you deserve it, he isn't anything special I get why your angry but you can do so much better than wasting time being bitter over someone so average.

Sintel · 22/12/2023 12:08

It's a very hard situation emotionally for you OP but I think you need to separate out the finances from your feelings. You need to outline all the things your kids will miss out on or that you'll struggle to buy if he lowers his contribution to them. If he's willing to buy things for them then send him a list of what uniform etc needs replacing. But you'll need to decide if it's worth your mental energy. As he will be under no obligation to comply.

Britpop123 · 22/12/2023 12:07

Grilly · 22/12/2023 11:41

To be fair, OP’s not being unreasonable with her initial question, to ask that maintenance stays the same if he’s voluntarily reducing his income.

She’s being hugely unreasonable to withhold and minimise access, and to be so bitter about her ex and his new partner though. Mostly it’s unreasonable to her own children.

And the fact he didn’t reduce it until she had an argument about money

Grilly · 22/12/2023 12:06

OP you say your children don’t want more time with their dad. Why, given you say it’s a happy home in the OP? It’s because they feel loyalty bonds to you.

Grilly · 22/12/2023 12:04

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:01

I can’t deny that I do feel some element of bitter feeling. They’re getting married soon and he wouldn’t marry me yet he done a big fancy proposal for her after a year and they planned a wedding straight away. I’m more upset for my children to be honest. He wouldn’t do anything with us and if he did, it was an argument yet he’s all over social media posing with her and the child taking them to see Santa. My children come back from his house feeling lousy because he spends all his time with the baby. I understand a baby has more needs but surely she could just take him when my children are there so they actually get some time with their dad? I just think it’s exceptionally unfair that they can live the high life and contribute so little to my children. I don’t think that’s unreasonable. The children don’t want more contact with him. My childcare arrangements aren’t costing me anything so it would be of no benefit him having them more anyway.

Can’t you see how if you let the children spend more time with their dad, they’d have more of a chance to do these fun activities? Why should his new partner have to schedule fun things for one day a fortnight just because you withhold access?

jm9138 · 22/12/2023 12:03

I was paying £650 whilst I had mine 45% of the time. Then my son goes to uni and my daughter has lived with me 80% of the time and my ex stopped working and moved her multimillionaire partner in. I know I will not get a penny so don’t even ask. Life is just shit sometimes and I feel your pain.

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:01

I can’t deny that I do feel some element of bitter feeling. They’re getting married soon and he wouldn’t marry me yet he done a big fancy proposal for her after a year and they planned a wedding straight away. I’m more upset for my children to be honest. He wouldn’t do anything with us and if he did, it was an argument yet he’s all over social media posing with her and the child taking them to see Santa. My children come back from his house feeling lousy because he spends all his time with the baby. I understand a baby has more needs but surely she could just take him when my children are there so they actually get some time with their dad? I just think it’s exceptionally unfair that they can live the high life and contribute so little to my children. I don’t think that’s unreasonable. The children don’t want more contact with him. My childcare arrangements aren’t costing me anything so it would be of no benefit him having them more anyway.

OP posts:
Bartlebum · 22/12/2023 11:59

Sorry that this has happened to you. It sounds unbelievably hard and I understand how impactful his behavior has been to all of you.

I'm a child of this situation, younger wife, replaced family, playing the system to reduce the maintenance as much as possible, living the high life while the old children suffer (my sister's were taken to Disneyland up to three times a year and we could barely afford a camping trip once a year). I felt really upset for you reading this.

I did vote YABU because legally he's allowed to do what he's doing, however really it's a moral dilemma for him. It's definitely worth a well worded conversation. Unfortunately some dads do replace their old family and prefer the new, that's my experience even now in my mid 30s and it's very painful.

I hope you manage to come to a compromise of sorts. All the best to you and your children, you're doing a great job and I know how hard you're trying.

Grumpsy · 22/12/2023 11:57

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 22/12/2023 11:42

Op is allowed to be upset and jealous about this. I would be too- why does this mean other woman get her man, nice stuff, and indirectly cause op's money to be reduced. But op I think you shouldn't mention any of that in your message to the father as it will derail

Her man - people aren’t property 🙄

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 22/12/2023 11:55

Forgotmylogindetails · 22/12/2023 11:49

Sorry I’ve just read some more of your posts , in the nicest possible way get some therapy x

I agree this really helped me process my break up while pregnant

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 22/12/2023 11:54

cadburyegg · 22/12/2023 11:46

I'm a single mum too OP and I'm sorry but you're both unreasonable. Morally your ex should keep the same level of payments, legally he doesn't have to. The fact he had to fight to get them every other weekend speaks volumes - he sounds like an ass but you sound very angry and bitter still and you'll be projecting your thoughts about him onto your children whether you realise it or not. Parental alienation is a thing and no matter what your ex has done, your children deserve to have a relationship with their father.

Have you considered having counselling so you can move forward? What do you do on the nights he has them, do you have friends you can spend time with, a hobby you can do? I would strongly suggest finding something to do in your spare time so you can start moving on from this situation and enjoying yourself when you don't have the children.

I know in these circumstances it's really hard to be upbeat about your children's ex in front of them. My ex has £100k in the bank after I bought him out of the family home and yet he has paid a grand total of £40 this month in maintenance. You cannot let your opinion about money and contact arrangements filter down to your children.

Your ex is disgusting

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 22/12/2023 11:53

It's none of your business what she earns / drives / buys in the way of new cars / wedding costs etc.

What is of your concern is your maintenance from HIM and only him.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 22/12/2023 11:52

@Polewire if he's said yes to buying them more stuff if they need it, this might be the angle to go down.
Would he agree to fund eg all swimming lessons, all new trainers and school shoes and coats? This might more than make up for the money lost if you already know you're paying for them, he'll be more likely to agree to it as he'll know it's going to dc and not on your Botox and nights out like many exes seem to think it does. It also creates a chore for him to do to free up more time for you to have fun with your dc?

dickiedavisthunderthighs · 22/12/2023 11:51

You're weaponising your children and as they get older this won't be lost on them. Your husband has a right to a happy future with ALL of his children. You also have a right to a happy future and I think you should seek therapy to part ways with your anger, as the only person who will lose here is you.
If your husband is paying less because he has more time, which is right by CMS, then he can spend more time with them. Don't be 'that' ex-wife.

Forgotmylogindetails · 22/12/2023 11:49

Sorry I’ve just read some more of your posts , in the nicest possible way get some therapy x

Forgotmylogindetails · 22/12/2023 11:48

@Polewire i get what you are saying but it’s not his new wife’s job to provide for your children.

why Are you so invested in what she earns what she drives etc ?

He is the problem , it’s horrible what happened to you and life’s not fair. When you get to the level of not caring what they do you will be so much happier.

im not digging you out I was in the same boat a long time ago x

Wolfpa · 22/12/2023 11:47

I think your feelings are clouding your judgement here making you bitter and twisted. Keep this up and you are going to have a miserable life. Find a way to let some of this anger go

cadburyegg · 22/12/2023 11:46

I'm a single mum too OP and I'm sorry but you're both unreasonable. Morally your ex should keep the same level of payments, legally he doesn't have to. The fact he had to fight to get them every other weekend speaks volumes - he sounds like an ass but you sound very angry and bitter still and you'll be projecting your thoughts about him onto your children whether you realise it or not. Parental alienation is a thing and no matter what your ex has done, your children deserve to have a relationship with their father.

Have you considered having counselling so you can move forward? What do you do on the nights he has them, do you have friends you can spend time with, a hobby you can do? I would strongly suggest finding something to do in your spare time so you can start moving on from this situation and enjoying yourself when you don't have the children.

I know in these circumstances it's really hard to be upbeat about your children's ex in front of them. My ex has £100k in the bank after I bought him out of the family home and yet he has paid a grand total of £40 this month in maintenance. You cannot let your opinion about money and contact arrangements filter down to your children.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 22/12/2023 11:45

Birdcar · 22/12/2023 10:16

Her child is well funded because of her, not because of him. You can't expect her to also fund your children.

He should be doing everything he can to support all of his children but by the sounds of things he's not going to.

But the ow is able to maintain her good career and reduce childcare bills by having a house husband to do childcare. The house husband work is also important (if he does it properly) and the father is making a choice to do this which means he wil be financially less able to support his older kids- you'd think they would have some sort of arrangement in place

Katypp · 22/12/2023 11:44

This is such an interesting thread and really well illustrates what I have said many times on MN.
The default setting is always the bloke is wrong and the woman the brave victim soldiering on in the face of his awfulness.
When the reality - as is so well demonstrated here - is not always immediately apparent.
No he should not reduce maintenence but as this is clearly an ongoing feud, I can see why he might as revenge for have to go to court to see his own children. Not right, but there are many instances of mum preventing her ex seeing his kids as revenge for losing money, so there you go.
OP, out of interest. Do you think up excuses why contact can't take place as planned and convince yourself it's in the child's interest? And have you put the idea into their heads that they feel pushed out by the new baby? Have you 'warned' them they might have to go without things they like because daddy won't pay as much because if the new baby? I bet you have. Textbook PAS

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 22/12/2023 11:42

Britpop123 · 22/12/2023 10:13

This gives the game away. All about her and what she earns and has bought.

payments are his responsibility and based on his income along. Rightly. He has more time so could have the kids more, that’s not an unreasonable ask.

Op is allowed to be upset and jealous about this. I would be too- why does this mean other woman get her man, nice stuff, and indirectly cause op's money to be reduced. But op I think you shouldn't mention any of that in your message to the father as it will derail

pinkzxmas · 22/12/2023 11:42

I've read all your replies OP and it sounds like you are hung up on the new woman.
You are coming across bitter and jealous; understandable if your ex had an affair with her. However, you need to put it all aside and get over it - it hasn't freshly happened - it's 4 years - move on.
Your children are going to grow up and realise you was the one stopping / preventing / putting obstacles in the way of their dad and will resent you.

Your ex is a grown adult.
He can make his own adult decisions. If he has served you a court order to see the children - then he obviously wants to see them.
You need to accept that the children are not solely yours.

You know your ex as a person from 4 years ago. People change. You don't know him now - the court order / reducing payments is his right as a parent.
Imagine you was the NRP would you be happy with paying more when you have less income? No you wouldn't.
Would you be happy with weekend contact? Bet you wouldn't.

He is entitled to reduce his hours / days at work. This in turn means his cms contributions will go down. (Same if you was the NRP)
Her working / money is nothing to do with your children at all. Their wedding / lifestyle isn't anything to do with you either.
Good on her for succeeding in her career!

Offer him to have the children on his days when he's at home with the new baby if you're concerned about the disparity between the homes - then they get more time with their dad & the use of the things at his house. Offer 50/50 - you probably won't because you like the control.

wronginalltherightways · 22/12/2023 11:41

It is 100% not unreasonable to point out how what he's doing will affect his children with you, and that he's being grossly unfair to them. Not only with proposing to decrease child maintenance, but by visibly showing them day in and day out that he really only cares about his new wife and baby. Because that IS what he's showing them.

Unfortunately, that's not how CM works formally, and as he sounds like a total dick, he won't care.

I'm sorry, OP.

Grilly · 22/12/2023 11:41

Britpop123 · 22/12/2023 11:31

This thread is a great example of how skewed an op can be. It’s done to gain support but then with a bit of questioning the whole story emerges and it’s very different

To be fair, OP’s not being unreasonable with her initial question, to ask that maintenance stays the same if he’s voluntarily reducing his income.

She’s being hugely unreasonable to withhold and minimise access, and to be so bitter about her ex and his new partner though. Mostly it’s unreasonable to her own children.

Swipe left for the next trending thread