Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he should maintain current contributions?

310 replies

Polewire · 22/12/2023 09:54

I know there’s been a few threads about child maintenance etc but this is slightly different.

my ex and I split up 4 years ago. We have 2 children, 6 and 5. He left me for a woman 15 years younger than him, she was about 24 at the time I think, they maintain they didn’t have an affair but I’m 99% sure they did. That’s another story though. To be honest, I thought it was a mid life crisis and would never last but fast forward to today and they’ve bought a house, have a baby and are getting married in a few months time. Based on what my DC tell me (they stay with ex and his partner every other weekend) it’s a happy home.

i haven’t physically spoken to my ex since we split. All communication is done on an app. I hate him for breaking up our family. I hate the fact that he never wanted to do anything with us, was out every night of the week and weekend with work/sports/hobbies and now he seems to have given up all that to spend time with his partner and their child. It’s not fair on my children that they’ve seen their dad transform into this wonderful dad and partner with the new baby and partner when he wasn’t like that with us.

anyway - this is my issue. His partner has a really good job and is going back to work soon. He’s reducing his hours (she gets paid probably 3x as much as him) in order to look after their child so my maintenance is going to go down because it’s solely based on his hours.

as it stands I just get by with the amount he pays each month and if he drops down hours then I’ll lose out and they’ll still be living their high life - fancy jeep, hotel stays all the time, stuff I wouldn’t even be able to dream of doing with my children. Would it be unreasonable to message him on the app and outline that although it’s based on his income, given that he’s reducing his hours for his other child and given the fact shes earning well that he should maintain the amount he’s currently paying for our children?

OP posts:
Ostryga · 22/12/2023 12:41

Op I would be very careful, what you’re saying borders on parental alienation. If your ex can prove it he could very easily go for full custody of the children.

You need to take all emotion out of this, and stop worrying about his wife. What’s happened has happened and you can’t change that. Model good behaviour for your children and don’t put them in the position of having to deal with your bitterness because that is not fair on them at all.

GabriellaMontez · 22/12/2023 12:41

Britpop123 · 22/12/2023 12:38

Read the thread…

I have thanks. Parental duties include financially supporting all of your children.

margotrose · 22/12/2023 12:39

My childcare arrangements aren’t costing me anything so it would be of no benefit him having them more anyway.

Except for the benefit of your children spending quality time with their dad and their baby brother?

It's not about you and what's convenient to you.

123sunshine · 22/12/2023 12:39

I believe that the CMS calculation would reduce anyway due to the new child as he now has two families to support. I’m sure it is difficult seeing everything play out, but I think you need to focus on building your own life and not making comparisons.
When I split with my ex husband I made it very clear that he didn’t get to just walk away and be a part time dad, I really don’t believe in every other weekend, it’s just not enough contact. I would also suggest you look at your own situation and how you can better yourself for yours and your children’s futures . I had been a Stay at home mum for 7 years when I was left by my ex. I got a part time job around the kids, and began studying to renew my professional exams from my previous career. I knew I didn’t want to have a life which meant relying on tax credits, maintenance payments and a low paying job. I now have no interest in what my ex husband and his new family earn or don’t earn as though he does still contribute a modest maintenance payment for the last child in education, I am financially independent and doing well for myself as the investment I made in bettering myself paid off.

Lovemusic82 · 22/12/2023 12:39

All you can do is ask him?

Chances are he knows that his payments will be reduced if it goes through CSA and that’s probably why he’s reducing his hours and she isn’t. They are his dc and her wedges have nothing to do what he pays towards them.

You still seem very angry towards him and his new partner (her age doesn’t really have anything to do with it). My ex doesn’t pay much at all towards his 2 dc and hardly sees them so I just manage with what we have, my ex would probably do exactly what yours is doing if he had the chance because that’s what he’s like.

A lol you can do is talk to him and ask if the amount will remain the same.

Britpop123 · 22/12/2023 12:38

GabriellaMontez · 22/12/2023 12:28

That's awful. Wishing him bad karma and a lottery win for you.

This is just another way men get to opt out of parental duties.

Read the thread…

Luxell934 · 22/12/2023 12:33

Well I'd wait until he actually reduces the payment before deciding to do anything. But if he does it wouldn't be unreasonable to ask him how he's going to make up the shortfall for your shared children and make him aware this is going to be difficult for you and will have an impact on his children. Unfortunately if he decides to do this there isn't much you can do. It's a really shit situation.

You have to stop blaming the new partner though, I know it does seem unfair but her wage, what she buys, what she pays for etc is nothing to do with you and your children. This is about your ex. He is the one with the responsibility for your shared children.

Katypp · 22/12/2023 12:33

GabriellaMontez · 22/12/2023 12:28

That's awful. Wishing him bad karma and a lottery win for you.

This is just another way men get to opt out of parental duties.

Yeah. The easiest way is to block contact. Hth

Inertia · 22/12/2023 12:31

I think you’ve copped a bit of a hard time on here to be honest. Yes, you feel bitter, but it’s understandable. However, you have children together so there has to be an ongoing relationship- you need to figure out how to make that work for you and you’re children.

As others have said, the new partner’s finances have nothing to do with what your ex has to pay. Perhaps a way forward is to get him to actually buy/ directly pay for things the children need e.g clothes, shoes, school dinners etc. I probably wouldn’t raise the issue of him paying less - make him broach the subject, and then ask what he thinks his children need to go without.

Have you checked whether you are claiming any benefits you are entitled to?

The system is shit. There’s definitely an argument for state payments going directly to the RP, with the govt recouping the cost from current/future earnings from the NRP.

Saharafordessert · 22/12/2023 12:31

It’s not about her, it’s about you and your ex. You sound very jealous and bitter so try and concentrate on you and your children, make a happy life for them and maybe look at some therapy to help you move on. New year = new you.

Katypp · 22/12/2023 12:30

Did you ask your children if they wanted to see daddy more? While looking sad and making it clear that that was not what you wanted.
Did you tell them it was their choice but you would protect them if he got angry with their decision?
Did you tell them that daddy probably hasn't got as much time for them now he has a new baby?
I'm projecting now, but classic PAS

Whataretheodds · 22/12/2023 12:30

Polewire · 22/12/2023 10:24

I don’t want him to have any more contact with them. I hate the fact he even has them every other weekend. It used to be every Saturday and then I reduced it to every other Saturday and he served a court order for sleepovers every other weekend.

He is their father. I know it must really hurt but if you don't work through your anger about this it will eat you up and impact your relationship with the kids.
Do you want your children to be posting on here in 20 years time about how stressed they are that their parents can't be in the same room for their wedding? Or to welcome their firstborn child?

GabriellaMontez · 22/12/2023 12:28

That's awful. Wishing him bad karma and a lottery win for you.

This is just another way men get to opt out of parental duties.

Pineapplewaves · 22/12/2023 12:26

Has your ex said that he won't continue to pay? Surely he considered this when he agreed to reduce his hours?

Think very carefully before you open your mouth - If you rock the boat he could take you back to court for 50/50 access, then he wouldn't have to pay you anything. He'd have good grounds to have them 50/50 if he's working part time and able to do school runs and after school care.

HeedlessAndUnbridledConcupiscence · 22/12/2023 12:20

When I briefly worked for CMS I worked on a case where the NRP gave up work completely. He took on all school runs and after school care for his partner’s children and started a hobby business.

I've watched some live family court streams on YouTube. It's fascinating to learn about the men who try to 'voluntarily donate' their services to their employer so they can avoid paying CMS in parts of the USA. (The tax position round this is very odd but apparently it's a well known strategy in some states.)

confusedaboutclothes · 22/12/2023 12:18

There was a very similar thread to this a while ago OP but I believe from the other perspective…but like many other posters have said… the new girlfriend could be a multi millionaire and it would have no bearing on your maintenance.

Having said that, i wanted to say i know exactly how you feel.
To watch a man become for a new baby the man you begged him to be for your children for years, is devastating.
The best thing you can do those is make peace with it, just because they have all these nice things, and an expensive wedding, doesn’t really mean a lot.

Chances are, he will leave her high and dry the way he did you…leopards never change their spots!

cadburyegg · 22/12/2023 12:18

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:10

I don’t think she would want them there 50/50 anyway to be honest. It wouldn’t fit in with the picture perfect life. I think she’s happy with the current arrangements because he hasn’t put up any fight since every other week was agreed.

OK, but there is a middle ground between 50/50 and EOW - 2 nights EOW is more like 85/15.

My ex has our children 3 nights EOW and I think he should spend more time with them, not less. IMO EOW is the bare minimum. Think about how long the school holidays felt when we were children - to go nearly 2 weeks without seeing a parent is a long time for a child, even though it's not much to us. What about 1 night during the week too?

GuinnessBird · 22/12/2023 12:17

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:10

I don’t think she would want them there 50/50 anyway to be honest. It wouldn’t fit in with the picture perfect life. I think she’s happy with the current arrangements because he hasn’t put up any fight since every other week was agreed.

Eh? He took you to court to get the current arrangements as you were blocking contact.

Honestly you aren't coming across very well here.

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 22/12/2023 12:17

Stop making it about her!

Barbiegirl2013 · 22/12/2023 12:17

OP, in the kindest way, you are coming across as quite resentful and bitter towards your ex and his new partner. Lots of assumptions and comparisons between your relationships. I know it is difficult when you see an ex act the way you’d have liked, with someone else, but it is not a reflection on you that he feels differently towards his new partner. Try to stop making these comparisons and harbouring this jealousy. Perhaps talk to someone about your emotions and focus on your children. If they say it is a happy home, let them spend more time there and don’t speak so negatively about their other family to them - it is bound to impact them. They probably feel completely torn in this situation and i feel very sorry for them. I hope you can resolve your own issues and create a less toxic environment for all.

Mrsttcno1 · 22/12/2023 12:17

It is a hard situation OP and I do feel for you.

Ultimately though I think the best thing you can do for our own mental health and for your children is to try and let all of this anger go. The reality of the situation is that he is entitled to reduce his hours, and his pay, and that does mean he will be able to pay less via CMS to your shared children. You can ask for him to keep up the current contributions, but considering he’s the kind of person who previously reduced payments (due to telling CMS about his baby) as a reaction to an argument with you about money, he isn’t going to say yes. Or if you catch him on a good day, he might say yes, but you’re then going to pussy footing around and waiting for the day you argue again and he then says no.

You need to accept that he has met somebody else, he’s moved on, and it’s pointless you winding yourself up about what she earns, how much their wedding costs, what car she’s bought because that is HER money, HER life. Her income and salary has nothing to do with your children or you, and so dwelling on that and winding yourself up over it isn’t helpful.

The sooner you can put that anger behind you the happier you will be, there’s a lot of power to be found in accepting that there are some things you can’t change. X

Grilly · 22/12/2023 12:16

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:10

I don’t think she would want them there 50/50 anyway to be honest. It wouldn’t fit in with the picture perfect life. I think she’s happy with the current arrangements because he hasn’t put up any fight since every other week was agreed.

Because they had to go to court for that, which is very stressful and expensive! They probably don’t want to rock the boat more with you. Offer it, and I’m sure they’d snap you hands off.

Britpop123 · 22/12/2023 12:13

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:10

I don’t think she would want them there 50/50 anyway to be honest. It wouldn’t fit in with the picture perfect life. I think she’s happy with the current arrangements because he hasn’t put up any fight since every other week was agreed.

He had to fight to get that!

tomatoontoast · 22/12/2023 12:13

I think you're going to regret all this bitterness you feel.

If I was in the new girlfriends shoes I wouldn't give a penny of my money towards your maintenance based on what you're saying about her.

You don't like her and that's fine but don't expect her to then contribute towards your maintenance which is what she will be doing if your ex reduces his hours..

Polewire · 22/12/2023 12:10

I don’t think she would want them there 50/50 anyway to be honest. It wouldn’t fit in with the picture perfect life. I think she’s happy with the current arrangements because he hasn’t put up any fight since every other week was agreed.

OP posts: