Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he should maintain current contributions?

310 replies

Polewire · 22/12/2023 09:54

I know there’s been a few threads about child maintenance etc but this is slightly different.

my ex and I split up 4 years ago. We have 2 children, 6 and 5. He left me for a woman 15 years younger than him, she was about 24 at the time I think, they maintain they didn’t have an affair but I’m 99% sure they did. That’s another story though. To be honest, I thought it was a mid life crisis and would never last but fast forward to today and they’ve bought a house, have a baby and are getting married in a few months time. Based on what my DC tell me (they stay with ex and his partner every other weekend) it’s a happy home.

i haven’t physically spoken to my ex since we split. All communication is done on an app. I hate him for breaking up our family. I hate the fact that he never wanted to do anything with us, was out every night of the week and weekend with work/sports/hobbies and now he seems to have given up all that to spend time with his partner and their child. It’s not fair on my children that they’ve seen their dad transform into this wonderful dad and partner with the new baby and partner when he wasn’t like that with us.

anyway - this is my issue. His partner has a really good job and is going back to work soon. He’s reducing his hours (she gets paid probably 3x as much as him) in order to look after their child so my maintenance is going to go down because it’s solely based on his hours.

as it stands I just get by with the amount he pays each month and if he drops down hours then I’ll lose out and they’ll still be living their high life - fancy jeep, hotel stays all the time, stuff I wouldn’t even be able to dream of doing with my children. Would it be unreasonable to message him on the app and outline that although it’s based on his income, given that he’s reducing his hours for his other child and given the fact shes earning well that he should maintain the amount he’s currently paying for our children?

OP posts:
Katypp · 22/12/2023 18:40

It might be non-negociable for you but it will be very negotiable if he takes you to court for more contact now he has more time. You need to lose the mindset that these are YOUR children and yours only, and you have the right to use them to get back at your ex. A court does not like this nowadays I believe. At 4 and 5, they're making a lot of observations during their time there. I expect you are pumping them for information as soon as they get home, so you can put a negative slant in it for them and let them know you are not happy about it. This is classic PAS. You are not being a good mother here. I am sure you think you are and I am sure you can convince yourself you are acting in their best interests but you're not. You are being self-serving and spiteful.

therealcookiemonster · 22/12/2023 18:38

@Polewire I know it really fucking hurts when the person you love doesn't want you. you were never a priority for him. you can't change the past. you can't change him. you can only change yourself and your own reactions.

so woman up, stop poisoning your own heart. he's gone, it's over. you have to find your own happiness and you have to become a neutral party when managing your children's relationship with your ex. your relationship with him is totally irrelevant in that context. and this will be painful but they also need to build a relationship with his new partner. you are preventing this. you are destroying yourself and your children's long term mental health and potential to have intimate relationships out of spite.

you have become fixated on hatred and revenge, that road never led anywhere good.
.

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 18:36

Grilly · 22/12/2023 17:58

You are not only a terrible mother to your children, but very short-sighted and damaging your own chances of happiness too.

Don't punish your children for his mistakes.

Read Making Divorce work.

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 18:33

Grilly · 22/12/2023 12:04

Can’t you see how if you let the children spend more time with their dad, they’d have more of a chance to do these fun activities? Why should his new partner have to schedule fun things for one day a fortnight just because you withhold access?

It might not last. You might meet the most amazing man soon x

Meanoldlady · 22/12/2023 18:25

Op, I really feel for you. You've been through a lot and are completely entitled to feel angry and resentful at the way you've been treated.

BUT....

You are not entitled to use your hurt as a reason to come between your kids and their dad.

Your children are entitled to their own independent experience of their other parent and to be allowed to enjoy time with the rest of their family without limitations or having to think about your opinions.

It's really fucking hard but you have to stop this.

Their relationship is hard to swallow but you have to accept it and move on so that your kids can see their dad and sibling (and step mum as hard as that is!) Without feeling like they're letting you down. That's such a head fuck for a kid. You must see that.

You cannot limit contact based on the way he treated you, provided they are safe. That's not putting them first. It's punishing him for leaving you.

The money situation is shit and unfair.
BUT.... The more you antagonise and argue, the worse its likely to get.
Her money is nothing to do with you.

You have to improve the communication and relationship between you and their dad if you want everything else, including finances to improve. Only communicating through an app and still managing to argue is not helping anyone.

Please get some therapy and try to restart the relationship between you and them so that you can have a decent conversation about what the kids need.

Think of it as a business/working relationship if you have to. The only subject should be the kids.

Mrsm010918 · 22/12/2023 18:07

Mrsttcno1 · 22/12/2023 17:26

Respectfully OP, he didn’t leave “the family”, he just left you. It was you he didn’t want, not the children. In fact he has actively gone to court to fight for MORE time with those children because he doesn’t want to just be a cash point dad.

The only person harming your children’s relationship with their father here is you. YOU don’t want them seeing him more, YOU want more money for them, YOU are keeping track of their wedding costs and new car purchases.

At some point you have to accept that he didn’t want to leave them as their dad, he just wanted to leave you. That may feel unfair to you, but what you are doing now is completely unfair to both him and your poor children.

This with bells on.

You need to get over your bitterness that he wasn't happy with you and that he left you.

He has shown he wants a relationship with the children through going to the court for overnight access. He provides for them when they are with him, and him and his soon to be wife are welcoming to them. They demonstrate a loving and affectionate relationship which is actually a healthy thing for the children to see.

I really hope he takes you back to court for more access if he has to as it sounds like the children would be better off for it. Your anger and pain will be toxic to them and they WILL feel it. It is not something they will thank you for when they are older

Grilly · 22/12/2023 17:58

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

You are not only a terrible mother to your children, but very short-sighted and damaging your own chances of happiness too.

Pickles2023 · 22/12/2023 17:57

Mrsttcno1 · 22/12/2023 17:40

You need to read all posts, their dad actively wants to have his children more. He’s actually doing the opposite of shirking his duties. And OP has already said when the children are with him they have everything paid for there.

You can’t have it both ways, there are dads out there who want nothing to do with their kids and are proper dead beat dads, but this isn’t one of them. He has actively went to court to see these kids more, OP doesn’t want him to be a dad or have any parental role at all, she just wants his money each month.

Oh woops, sorry.

In that case i would take him up on childcare so i didnt have to pay for it 😅😂

Skyblue92 · 22/12/2023 17:46

wordout · 22/12/2023 17:37

Now he's planning on cutting back on his working hours perhaps it's time for you to share the kids 50/50 so you can concentrate on building your own career?

That’s all good but OP doesn’t want this. She hates the fact that he has EOW as it is.

OP honestly, do not cut your nose of to spite your face. If you prevent more access then you will regret it. You may not think you will but when they are old enough and realise what has actually gone on during their childhood, they may resent you and may very well cut you out of their lives because they’ll blame you for the lack of contact. You don’t want him to have more because honestly he stopped loving you. It’s much much worse for children to grow up when it’s clear parents hate each other but are only together for them.

you’re still hurting and that’s fine but being petty about contact will back fire on you. It will only take him to go back to court for more access for that to happen and trust me courts do not like it when the ex is trying to limit contact unnecessarily and use the children as weapons which sadly is exactly what you are doing.

the best thing to do OP is delete any of them from Social Media (if you have them on there), only ask the children. did you have a nice weekend? when they are back from seeing him and stop thinking about them, stop blaming her. You’ll end up much worse off if you continue the way you are.

Mrsttcno1 · 22/12/2023 17:40

Pickles2023 · 22/12/2023 17:30

Although i feel the partner, finances and lifestyle is completely irrelevant and i am the first person to feel people should not be responsible for others children and it is the parents responsibilty..I dont think your partner should drop hours as he does have duties and responsibilities towards his first DC and he is shirking those.

If i was the partner i would expect us to both work, as your children should not be neglected with their financial needs, he made a commitment to them when they were born that should be maintained as a priority unless obviously either of you has some awful incident ect and physically cant.

So no i dont feel you are unreasonable at all. All children should have equal opportunity.

You need to read all posts, their dad actively wants to have his children more. He’s actually doing the opposite of shirking his duties. And OP has already said when the children are with him they have everything paid for there.

You can’t have it both ways, there are dads out there who want nothing to do with their kids and are proper dead beat dads, but this isn’t one of them. He has actively went to court to see these kids more, OP doesn’t want him to be a dad or have any parental role at all, she just wants his money each month.

wordout · 22/12/2023 17:37

Now he's planning on cutting back on his working hours perhaps it's time for you to share the kids 50/50 so you can concentrate on building your own career?

Linosaur · 22/12/2023 17:37

You're only human OP, it fucking hurts when they leave you and become a better partner and a better father by all accounts. You need friends and family around to support you process this and not involve your children though, you dealing with being left is different to what the children are going through.

You'd hope he has accounted for maintenance when working out whether he can afford to drop his hours, but legally he can reduce it in line with his hours. If he sees them more, no reason to believe he won't be successful through court with that so it's a real possibility he will be paying even less- do you have plans for this?

Pickles2023 · 22/12/2023 17:30

Although i feel the partner, finances and lifestyle is completely irrelevant and i am the first person to feel people should not be responsible for others children and it is the parents responsibilty..I dont think your partner should drop hours as he does have duties and responsibilities towards his first DC and he is shirking those.

If i was the partner i would expect us to both work, as your children should not be neglected with their financial needs, he made a commitment to them when they were born that should be maintained as a priority unless obviously either of you has some awful incident ect and physically cant.

So no i dont feel you are unreasonable at all. All children should have equal opportunity.

GonnaNeedABiggerBag · 22/12/2023 17:29

It’s GOOD that he’s now a different person. Allow your children to see the positive in this. Encourage them to enjoy their time with their dad and the other half of their family. It’s great that they’re seeing a happy dad, enjoying his partner and all his kids. They can only benefit from seeing a positive relationship. Your job is to explain that sometimes people fall out of love and that’s sad but it happens - people find love again and Daddy still loves you.

Your bitterness will destroy you and them OP.

Catza · 22/12/2023 17:27

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

Absolute rubbish. My step daughter is spending a lot of time in our house, we are a very affectionate couple which is hugely beneficial for her to see. Her mum is on her 4th husband since my partner and her split up and her house is always full of drama. I wonder why.
My partner hasn't always been brilliant when the kiddo was smaller but they are absolutely inseparable now. She is included in everything and adores her dad.

By limiting your children's contact with their dad, you are not achieving anything but stopping them from developing a relationship. You can't both want him to be a good dad and not allow him equal access to kids. I predict it will come back to bite you in the proverbial once the kids are older and can see that it takes two to tango.

Mrsttcno1 · 22/12/2023 17:26

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

Respectfully OP, he didn’t leave “the family”, he just left you. It was you he didn’t want, not the children. In fact he has actively gone to court to fight for MORE time with those children because he doesn’t want to just be a cash point dad.

The only person harming your children’s relationship with their father here is you. YOU don’t want them seeing him more, YOU want more money for them, YOU are keeping track of their wedding costs and new car purchases.

At some point you have to accept that he didn’t want to leave them as their dad, he just wanted to leave you. That may feel unfair to you, but what you are doing now is completely unfair to both him and your poor children.

Riverlee · 22/12/2023 17:23

Also, the children are young. They won’tremember what daddy was like at home unless you tell them.

justalittlesnoel · 22/12/2023 17:23

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

That's not how your children will think though!! Sounds like you want to keep them away from him.

He's made his choices yes, but you're now making choices out of spite. Your posts are so angry and bitter sounding, if that's how you feel that's totally valid - but your DC are likely to pick up on this sort of thing if it's so badly concealed in real life.

BabaBarrio · 22/12/2023 17:21

YANBU to ask he keep same contributions. You can’t legally require he do so, so I would try and make a case in terms of the welfare of the children.

Riverstep · 22/12/2023 17:20

Op, yes it’s awful that your family was torn apart by your exes shitty actions. People rarely think of the impact it will have on their children when they do such stupid things. But you can’t control his actions- not then and not now. You can control your own though. Don’t spend your life bitter.

Riverlee · 22/12/2023 17:18

Sorry to say this, he sounds happy now. You have stated that your ex and his new dp treat your children well. That’s all you can wish for going forward.

Please don’t be the jealous ex and feed the children poison against their dad.

notlucreziaborgia · 22/12/2023 17:18

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

Then you’re just going to have to suck it up then 🤷🏻‍♀️ you’re not entitled to her money.

Ostryga · 22/12/2023 17:15

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

Your children won’t think like that though, and as they get older they are going to resent you for keeping them from their dad. You’re playing a really risky game with your children’s lives because of jealousy.

The best thing for you to do is probably get therapy so you can be the best mother you can be. Your anger towards their father is going to be obvious, from reading your posts I doubt you are able to hide it from them. That is so so damaging to young children.

I’ve been through exactly what you are going through, and at the end of the day you have got to put your children first. It’s not about you anymore, he’s got a whole new life and you have to move on. Being bitter and angry is going to ruin so many lives.

Polewire · 22/12/2023 17:11

I’ve already said I don’t want them spending more time with their dad, that’s not negotiable. He left this family. He made his choice. They met through a hobby and the first time I saw her I knew I would lose him to her, she was perfect for him and I knew he fancied her before we split and I know it was him who done the chasing. He’s a different person completely. I know people are saying my actions will damage the children but when they’re there he’s all over his partner (the kids have told me this) and always is doing stuff with her and the baby so the kids will be damaged anyway seeing their dad be everything he wasn’t for us and wonder why we weren’t good enough for him to treat us like that.

OP posts:
sparkellie · 22/12/2023 16:30

123sunshine · 22/12/2023 12:39

I believe that the CMS calculation would reduce anyway due to the new child as he now has two families to support. I’m sure it is difficult seeing everything play out, but I think you need to focus on building your own life and not making comparisons.
When I split with my ex husband I made it very clear that he didn’t get to just walk away and be a part time dad, I really don’t believe in every other weekend, it’s just not enough contact. I would also suggest you look at your own situation and how you can better yourself for yours and your children’s futures . I had been a Stay at home mum for 7 years when I was left by my ex. I got a part time job around the kids, and began studying to renew my professional exams from my previous career. I knew I didn’t want to have a life which meant relying on tax credits, maintenance payments and a low paying job. I now have no interest in what my ex husband and his new family earn or don’t earn as though he does still contribute a modest maintenance payment for the last child in education, I am financially independent and doing well for myself as the investment I made in bettering myself paid off.

@123sunshine just out of interest how do you stop him from being a part time dad? You can say that's not what you want, but you can't force him to have his kids if he doesn't want to. I'd love some answers as my ex has the kids 9 hrs a week and never overnight (although he has them more days in the christmas and easter holidays).
Not that thats the situation with the OP anyway. OP, he hasn't evem said he's going to reduce payments. Wait and see what happens before you start throwing your toys out the pram.