Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he should maintain current contributions?

310 replies

Polewire · 22/12/2023 09:54

I know there’s been a few threads about child maintenance etc but this is slightly different.

my ex and I split up 4 years ago. We have 2 children, 6 and 5. He left me for a woman 15 years younger than him, she was about 24 at the time I think, they maintain they didn’t have an affair but I’m 99% sure they did. That’s another story though. To be honest, I thought it was a mid life crisis and would never last but fast forward to today and they’ve bought a house, have a baby and are getting married in a few months time. Based on what my DC tell me (they stay with ex and his partner every other weekend) it’s a happy home.

i haven’t physically spoken to my ex since we split. All communication is done on an app. I hate him for breaking up our family. I hate the fact that he never wanted to do anything with us, was out every night of the week and weekend with work/sports/hobbies and now he seems to have given up all that to spend time with his partner and their child. It’s not fair on my children that they’ve seen their dad transform into this wonderful dad and partner with the new baby and partner when he wasn’t like that with us.

anyway - this is my issue. His partner has a really good job and is going back to work soon. He’s reducing his hours (she gets paid probably 3x as much as him) in order to look after their child so my maintenance is going to go down because it’s solely based on his hours.

as it stands I just get by with the amount he pays each month and if he drops down hours then I’ll lose out and they’ll still be living their high life - fancy jeep, hotel stays all the time, stuff I wouldn’t even be able to dream of doing with my children. Would it be unreasonable to message him on the app and outline that although it’s based on his income, given that he’s reducing his hours for his other child and given the fact shes earning well that he should maintain the amount he’s currently paying for our children?

OP posts:
rwalker · 24/12/2023 16:27

Britpop123 · 23/12/2023 13:46

Then how can you suggest asking him to have the kids more when op has done the exact opposite of that in the past and has stated she does not want him having them more?

Sometimes in life you have to look at the whole picture and consider the 3 other people involved
not just what you want to do there no mention of Abuse or neglect the fact he went to court to get more access clear shows he wants his kids

it’s difficult not to assume withholding the kids and reducing contact is weaponising kids and done out of spite

x2boys · 24/12/2023 09:35

zaazaazoo · 24/12/2023 07:33

@Happilyobtuse
The OP says he was a disinterested father to his first dc and has transformed to a great father to his new baby. Thus hardly screams good and loving dad.

Also buying things rather than giving maintenance smacks of control. It also means the OP will have to go with her begging bowl every something is needed. He sounds awful

The Op also said that she reduced contact and he had to take her to court to get more that doesn't sound disinterested .

Chocolatebuttonns · 24/12/2023 09:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Chocolatebuttonns · 24/12/2023 09:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Lochness1975 · 24/12/2023 08:36

OP you just sound bitter. You’re the one who’s going to end up with a poor relationship with your dc when they are older from all the negative talk of their father. You really need to let it go. You can’t expect your exdp’s soon to be wife to sub your lifestyle. It doesn’t work like that.

Brainworm · 24/12/2023 08:22

It sounds as if something has changed for the father, resulting in him becoming a better father and partner (albeit for his new partner). This is positive for his older children too.

The OP seems to be taking up the position of as he wasn't a good father to their children in the past, she won't allow him to be in the future. Or, she won't allow him to be because they came as a package, and in rejecting her, he has to lose them too.

I also think it's reasonable for the partner who pays an agreed amount of maintenance to want to know why additional monies are needed. I would want to have an idea of what my payments were intended to cover (eg a proportion of utilities, clothes, food, transport, uniform etc.). If it wasn't covering this, I'd be keen to revisit. If it was, but other items not included in the calculation arose, I'd be happy to contribute- but would want to know what I am contributing to. Framing this as going with 'a begging bowl' isn't how I see this.

The bottom line is that breakdowns in relationships are painful and damaging. It can be very difficult to be mature and objective about the future. Anger and resentment gets played out through childcare and finances - sometimes in material ways and other times through how actions are perceived (the storying of what is happening).

I really feel for the OP. Her life hasn't gone as she'd hoped, or maybe as her ex promised. Not only does she have to live with this, she sees someone else living the life she wanted. On top of this, her tine with her children and her finances are compromised as a result of her ex having this new life. All of this is really grim for her.

It takes a lot to be able to boundary one's pain for the sake of others, not least when doing so benefits people that you feel already have taken too much from you.

Cabdiraxman · 24/12/2023 08:04

Your ex can pay wat CMS have calculated and is not legally obliged to pay more. He can request his current partner to open a CMS case for the children he has with her and this would reduce the CMS you receive even further.

Katypp · 24/12/2023 08:02

@zaazaazoo you sound as if you can put a negative spin on anything the ex does.

zaazaazoo · 24/12/2023 07:33

@Happilyobtuse
The OP says he was a disinterested father to his first dc and has transformed to a great father to his new baby. Thus hardly screams good and loving dad.

Also buying things rather than giving maintenance smacks of control. It also means the OP will have to go with her begging bowl every something is needed. He sounds awful

Happilyobtuse · 23/12/2023 22:56

zaazaazoo · 23/12/2023 13:07

@Happilyobtuse merrily reorganising one's life in a way that means your first set of dc will be struggling financially is a peculiar path for you to admire.

I never admired the OP’s ex partner’s choice of reducing his hours, you are choosing to misunderstand. I suggested she inform her ex exactly how their children will be impacted by him reducing his hours so that he understands where she is coming from. The OP has mentioned that her ex partner has said he would buy things for the kids which they need but not hand over more cash. So objectively making a list and discussing it seems like the smart thing to do. The OP keeps saying that her partner has left his children and when he is affectionate with his new partner he is rejecting their children. That is immature. Their relationship wasn’t working, they broke up. He still loves his kids as he has taken her to court for custody and he pays maintenance. Her trying to make him leaving her as him rejecting the kids is really poisoning the children’s minds and using them as weapons in her sadness/unhappiness in him moving on with his new partner. Unfortunately people fall out of love and move on, it doesn’t mean they hate their children.

Katypp · 23/12/2023 14:58

WithACatLikeTread · 23/12/2023 14:22

Unless she has beaten her children or starved them then one deserves to have their kids taken away. Stop being stupid.

Does that go both ways? As long as dad has not beaten or starved his children he does not deserve to have his kids taken away? Because that's exactly what the OP is trying to do.

WithACatLikeTread · 23/12/2023 14:22

GuinnessBird · 23/12/2023 10:13

Yeah I'm now crossing my fingers that he goes for full custody.

Children should not be used as weapons.

Unless she has beaten her children or starved them then one deserves to have their kids taken away. Stop being stupid.

x2boys · 23/12/2023 14:15

zaazaazoo · 23/12/2023 13:05

I agree, using dc as weapons is unconscionable. You know what's worse though? Abandoning your first set of dc to the benefit of your second. That's waaaaay worse. Why in heavens name would you want a man like that to have full custody.

You seem to have a warped sense of right and wrong.

He didn't abandon his kids though did he ?
In fact he took the Op, to court to get MORE time with his kids as the OP seems to think she owns the children and can reduce contact on a whim
people are allowed to leave unhappy relationships in fact women are often told on here to get their Ducks in a row etc .
I think its you who has a warped sense of right and wrong

Brainworm · 23/12/2023 13:57

Whilst OP has stated she doesn't want him to 'have the kids more', many posters are pointing out that it shouldn't be about what she wants. What is in the children's best interests should be paramount.

Britpop123 · 23/12/2023 13:46

rwalker · 23/12/2023 13:44

I’ve read the thread thanks

Then how can you suggest asking him to have the kids more when op has done the exact opposite of that in the past and has stated she does not want him having them more?

Forgotmylogindetails · 23/12/2023 13:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

rwalker · 23/12/2023 13:44

Britpop123 · 23/12/2023 13:35

Another one who hasn’t read the thread.
she cut his access, he went to court to get it back. She’s clearly stated it’s out of the question for him to have them any more time. It’s just money she’s after

I’ve read the thread thanks

Britpop123 · 23/12/2023 13:35

rwalker · 23/12/2023 13:30

You need to take everything about her out of the equation

if he pays less ask him to have the kids more

Another one who hasn’t read the thread.
she cut his access, he went to court to get it back. She’s clearly stated it’s out of the question for him to have them any more time. It’s just money she’s after

Britpop123 · 23/12/2023 13:33

zaazaazoo · 23/12/2023 13:05

I agree, using dc as weapons is unconscionable. You know what's worse though? Abandoning your first set of dc to the benefit of your second. That's waaaaay worse. Why in heavens name would you want a man like that to have full custody.

You seem to have a warped sense of right and wrong.

Again the word “abandoned” being used to describe a dad who had us access cut and went to court to get it back. Abandoned? Really?

rwalker · 23/12/2023 13:30

You need to take everything about her out of the equation

if he pays less ask him to have the kids more

Riverlee · 23/12/2023 13:26

Ex left when the children were young, both under two. It’ll be interesting to see whether history repeats himself with the new young baby.

However, as the above post has concluded, he’s continuing to be an active part of his kids life, despite the op trying to prevent this.

Lucyintheskywithadiamond · 23/12/2023 13:21

DragonMama3 · 22/12/2023 18:42

She's hurt. He's married the wealthier woman and not her. Kids are her only weapon in her arsenal.

Kids are not a weapon, that’s fucked up thinking.

Mrsttcno1 · 23/12/2023 13:15

zaazaazoo · 23/12/2023 13:05

I agree, using dc as weapons is unconscionable. You know what's worse though? Abandoning your first set of dc to the benefit of your second. That's waaaaay worse. Why in heavens name would you want a man like that to have full custody.

You seem to have a warped sense of right and wrong.

Could you show me where the OP has said or even suggested that her ex has done this though? I’ve just read back over all of OP’s posts and actually she’s repeatedly said she does not allow him to have more time with his children, in fact she tried to reduce his time even further and he actively took her to court so that he could have more access to his kids.

OP has also stated that financially he has said he will buy things for them which they need if not covered by his CMD amount, he just won’t hand over extra money, but will directly buy other things that they need which is fair enough really.

Where does it say or even suggest he has “abandoned” his kids? He actively fought to see them more, it is OP preventing that. He left OP, he didn’t leave his kids. That’s something OP seems to be struggling to accept hence her constant comparisons to his new partners proposal, wedding, holiday, job, jeep. There’s a lot of bitterness and jealousy plain and simple and while that’s hard, it is OP who is letting this affect the children at this stage.

I’m not saying her ex should have full custody, but OP is essentially saying “wah wah wah, he left us he needs to step up for his kids its not fair” and he says “brilliant I’d love to have them xyz days a week I want to be a dad, I went to court to be a dad”, to which OP then replies “oh, no, I just wanted more money, not for you to be a dad”!

zaazaazoo · 23/12/2023 13:07

@Happilyobtuse merrily reorganising one's life in a way that means your first set of dc will be struggling financially is a peculiar path for you to admire.

zaazaazoo · 23/12/2023 13:05

GuinnessBird · 23/12/2023 10:13

Yeah I'm now crossing my fingers that he goes for full custody.

Children should not be used as weapons.

I agree, using dc as weapons is unconscionable. You know what's worse though? Abandoning your first set of dc to the benefit of your second. That's waaaaay worse. Why in heavens name would you want a man like that to have full custody.

You seem to have a warped sense of right and wrong.