Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you don't eat dairy you can't expect everyone to make everything dairy free just for you?

362 replies

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:40

I have a relative. She's gone dairy free. Fine. We'll get some stuff she can eat in for Christmas. But she's been asking what we're having and every time I say something like coronation turkey on boxing day or trifle but don't worry I'll make you something dairy free She's being really annoying and insisting I make it all dairy free so she doesn't miss out. I think she just has to accept a dairy free trifle would be shit and she can't eat the cheese but we're all going to eat it anyway.
As long as there's enough food she can eat I think it's fine.

AIBU?

OP posts:
RedHotAirBalloon · 22/12/2023 09:53

Eating dairy also makes me ill - first a hot red rash, then upset tummy and if I continue eating it I get painful joints.

I would never expect a whole meal or buffet to be dairy free. She is being ridiculous and sounds a bit spoilt and childish.

And I'm another one who says don't bother with vegan cheese. I completely avoid man made in a lab type replacements. I'd far rather have a pizza without cheese (for example) than have palm oil and emulsifiers shaped and dyed to look like cheese.

Benibidibici · 22/12/2023 09:51

I regularly cater for CMPA and it's easy to make things which are naturally dairy free for everyone.

I catered dairy free for a relative for a while who was cmpa. It was easy yes, but everything tasted much, much worse. There is absolutely nothing that works properly in place of cheese.

cezannesapple · 22/12/2023 09:51

I think you are being very unfair saying it is pandering to her if she has an intolerance. It isn’t a choice. I’m not saying you should make everything dairy free but you sound resentful and angry with her. I’d provide enough alternatives that she doesn’t feel left out or ask her to bring one of the dishes.

Cherryana · 22/12/2023 09:48

The issue isn’t with you and what catering you are/aren’t doing. It sounds like you are accommodating being diary free with lots of choices for her.

The issue is to do with her identity (hear me out!).

It’s the difference between I can’t eat dairy and I don’t eat dairy.

People who don’t eat dairy will dismiss others eating cheese etc as irrelevant- because it’s not something they do. Others can do what they want but I don’t.

Someone who sees themselves as can’t eat dairy- they are a lot more fragile in their decision. And so they are much quicker to try and blame, guilt and project out the choice onto others…

Sounds like she is still thinking of herself as a ‘can’t eat dairy’ and so until she comes to terms with it herself you are going to have to prepare yourself for how to manage her moods.

Seaside3 · 22/12/2023 09:48

Lots of dairy free people can eat small amounts. They will often be fine with hard cheese and butter too. (I used to deal with dietaries in a restaurant). Goats and yew cheese is fine too. She's just being extra.

Justlovedogs · 22/12/2023 09:44

I don't get the issues this causes these days. I'm early fifties now, but I can remember having a birthday party aged 7 or 8. Maybe not quite the same, but one of my friends of the same age was diabetic. I can clearly remember her asking my mum what everything was on the tea table and identifying what she could and couldn't eat. No 'it's not fair' about things she couldn't eat, no telling everyone we all had to have diabetic friendly food.
OP - YANBU as long as their are suitable alternatives available.

diddl · 22/12/2023 09:44

If it's a lactose intolerance then lactose free milk & cream is easy enough to find.

Also some cheese are very low in lactose.

Daisies12 · 22/12/2023 09:44

YANBU at all. It’s her choice, ignore her and eat whatever you want. She can bring her own food. I am sick to death of everyone’s fussiness with food.

WorriedMum231 · 22/12/2023 09:41

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:41

Aparantly it's mean if we're eating cheese and she can't have any

lol. It’s shit for her but only for her, not everyone else. She’ll need to find a way to get over it and used to her new normal.

Universalsnail · 22/12/2023 09:41

Shes being unreasonable.

It would be reasonable for her to expect you to provide some dairy free food if you are hosting but it's not reasonable for her to demand it's all dairy free.

That said if I have a dairy free guest I generally try and keep dairy out of it anyway unless its like cheesey or something because it's just easier to make one lot of food and nicer if everyone can have some and stuff like butter and milk are easy swaps.

Tarmacadamia · 22/12/2023 09:41

kikisparks · 22/12/2023 09:30

I wasn’t doing any of that though, just noted that presumably the vegans wanted trifle since you tried to make one, you said the one you made was minging so was offering a suggestion if they wanted to try again. Obviously if they’re happy without trifle and have now decided they don’t want to recreate any dishes they previously enjoyed that is fair enough.

No you weren't, you were being helpful and I appreciate that. But there have been people on this thread saying, "you can easily make it all dairy free, there are so many alternatives available" etc and I was making the point that no, many people don't necessarily want that. The OP is offering to cater for her dairy free guest, but has been told that's not enough and everyone should go dairy free - that's not reasonable, as many people have agreed.

ApoodlecalledPenny · 22/12/2023 09:39

Just adding to the chorus of people saying don’t only buy vegan cheese. It’s absolutely rank.

forgotmyusername1 · 22/12/2023 09:38

tell her to bring a dairy free desert we can all enjoy and some vegan cheese so she can have her own cheese board.

ChaToilLeam · 22/12/2023 09:37

She sounds an absolute pain. You can’t expect everything to revolve around your dietary needs at a large gathering. Coronation chicken is easy to do dairy free and as long as there is plenty she can eat, SIBU to make a fuss about it. I have a few friends with food allergies and they are very appreciative when I work around them, not demanding!

OhwhyOY · 22/12/2023 09:37

It's obviously up to her not you but if she's fairly mildly lactose intolerant she could take lactase and still have the dairy, my friend does that. Otherwise the non dairy suggestions others have made sound good.

forgotmyusername1 · 22/12/2023 09:36

i mean... dairy free trifle is a bowl of jelly surely?

RedToothBrush · 22/12/2023 09:35

Three things

It's easier than most people realise to substitute for dairy free alternative ingredients when cooking. And these days you won't notice the taste difference. So if you can do it, it's not a huge deal.

But.
She has to cope with living in a world where there will be things she now can't eat.

And on that note, I wouldn't be giving up my cheese for Christmas on the basis that she can't eat it. That's just unlucky.

So I'd do what I could for items it didn't make a difference to me but I wouldn't ban all dairy.

BarbaraofSeville · 22/12/2023 09:35

kimchio · 22/12/2023 09:26

I didn't realise coronation chicken could be done with out dairy so thats on me. I'll sort it out by looking online.

It's chicken mixed with mayonnaise, curry powder, dried fruit and mango chutney.

I don't understand how it would have dairy in it.

Brandyginger · 22/12/2023 09:35

I’m dairy and gluten free as recommended by doctor following various tests (not allergic or coeliac though). No way would I expect any special catering, I bring my own or go hungry and quaff wine with a smile on my face (latest party I went to!).

Jk8 · 22/12/2023 09:32

😂 make her bring the dairy free meal/dessert so 'you' don't miss out

RocketDog101 · 22/12/2023 09:32

Reading through I'd say this isn't just about the trifle or indeed the dairy intolerance. I get the impression there's a bit of tension outside of this between you both - I wonder if the way you talk about your relative is how you'd talk about a friend (that you like haha). I gets vibes that this relative frequently expects everyone to cater to her needs and complains when asked to compromise or doesn't agree with her. This attitude makes all the difference when catering for others 🙄 I would go out of my way to include any friends dietary wishes (and have done) but also know they wouldn't expect the whole spread to be catered to them (unless a serious allergy/airborne etc). If my guest liked trifle (or indeed was a main desert) and needed it adapted, I would do it, because I know they'll appreciate the effort/thought (even if rank ha) and continue with optional extras 😉 they would offer to share with those who want to try as it's polite, but would accept if others said "no, thank you"...they also wouldn't be preaching to others their dietary requirements nor how little accommodations have been made. For my friends (and family) I would likely even go overboard as I would be keen to make them feel happy and included - they would for me too (and have!).

This isn't a dietary issue, this, is a "I'm not looking forward to a Christmas with this relative" issue lol (IMO)

Needmoresleep89 · 22/12/2023 09:31

Asda have a small vegan cheeseboard with a selection of cheeses for £4 in the Christmas range.

My dc are allergic to milk and I wouldn’t expect everything to be dairy free. It’s lovely when something can be found that is suitable and everyone will enjoy, but I’m happy to do that. I wouldn’t expect other people to.

kikisparks · 22/12/2023 09:30

Tarmacadamia · 22/12/2023 09:22

Thanks. I don't think we've had the elmlea one to be fair, I haven't seen them in shops round us. The vegans are happy eating other stuff that's nice in its own right, rather than trying to recreate something that really should have dairy in it - their opinion, not mine.

I think my point though, was that some people just love dairy and don't want to eat a vegan alternative. It's quite wearing when vegans are constantly trying to persuade non-vegans that the alternatives are just as good, and not respecting that eating meat/dairy is a choice and a preference for other people. I happily eat a lot of vegan food, but am not prepared to give up things I love because of other people's diets.

I wasn’t doing any of that though, just noted that presumably the vegans wanted trifle since you tried to make one, you said the one you made was minging so was offering a suggestion if they wanted to try again. Obviously if they’re happy without trifle and have now decided they don’t want to recreate any dishes they previously enjoyed that is fair enough.

Trytheweebabyquiche · 22/12/2023 09:29

Baffledandalarmed · 22/12/2023 09:26

I mean...I get the shits when I consume dairy and I have IBS. But at Christmas I just eat anything cos it's a faff for all my relatives to start fannying around making special foods for me.

It's Christmas. I'll take the shits and tummy ache over forcing extra work on those hosting any day. But judging by the responses you've received, OP, I am in the minority!

This is my wife’s view- she is vegan and allergic to lots of things.

When we go to dinner parties/buffets she eats anything that won’t make her actually ill- if there is enough salad and couscous, brilliant. If not she will eat potatoes with butter in them, or cheese straws or whatever, rather than place unreasonable pressure on the hosts.

Zarah123 · 22/12/2023 09:28

OP, why is this twat even invited? She has no concept of what it means to be a gracious guest.

There are lots of things I can’t eat, I would never to presume to dictate to my hosts as your relative is doing. I just accept the veggie food and bring in anything else I need myself.

Does she make you dairy food when she hosts? Does she even ever bloody host?