Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you don't eat dairy you can't expect everyone to make everything dairy free just for you?

362 replies

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:40

I have a relative. She's gone dairy free. Fine. We'll get some stuff she can eat in for Christmas. But she's been asking what we're having and every time I say something like coronation turkey on boxing day or trifle but don't worry I'll make you something dairy free She's being really annoying and insisting I make it all dairy free so she doesn't miss out. I think she just has to accept a dairy free trifle would be shit and she can't eat the cheese but we're all going to eat it anyway.
As long as there's enough food she can eat I think it's fine.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Blueroses99 · 22/12/2023 15:51

raffegiraffe · 22/12/2023 15:42

My kids are both lactose intolerant so I've read a lot about it. You can buy lactose free cheese and milk with added lactase enzyme but also lots of cheeses are low in lactose. You basically need to avoid the sweeter cheeses. Chedder is very low lactose. Might be something for her to try

If it’s an intolerance to the protein then low lactose products won’t make a difference.

raffegiraffe · 22/12/2023 15:42

My kids are both lactose intolerant so I've read a lot about it. You can buy lactose free cheese and milk with added lactase enzyme but also lots of cheeses are low in lactose. You basically need to avoid the sweeter cheeses. Chedder is very low lactose. Might be something for her to try

Blueroses99 · 22/12/2023 15:29

Haven’t RTFT so this might have already been said but on allergies vs intolerances, I’ve noticed in allergy groups that these are being re-labelled as IGE-allergy and non-IGE allergy. Stomach problems etc would fall into the latter category. ‘Intolerance’ often minimises the effect. Just cos it won’t cause an anaphylactic reaction doesn’t mean it can’t be really harmful.

bakewellbride · 22/12/2023 15:04

Yanbu op and I don't eat dairy!

RedToothBrush · 22/12/2023 14:59

daisybe · 22/12/2023 11:56

This. I've tried making alternatives before, too.

Always ended up in disaster. The chocolate cake was literally like crumbly cement that tasted like gasoline (not even joking here)

if you're not practiced and rehersed with tested recipies/alternatives, it's a huge ask of someone to make an entire meal dairy free (or vegan or gluten/sugar/whatever free) not to mention more expensive.

https://bakedbyclo.com/

I'm not vegan.

I've tried a few recipes from here and they've been great. I am NOT a natural cake maker.

BakedbyClo | Vegan Dessert Blog - Easy vegan dessert recipes with simple ingredients

The home of vegan baking and deliciously easy dessert recipes. Start your vegan desserts journey with recipes including lemon drizzle cake, chewy chocolate chip cookies and many more simple recipes!

https://bakedbyclo.com

AnonnyMouseDave · 22/12/2023 14:58

I am both a somewhat fussy eater and a vegetarian. My take is that if you are such a person, and you are going somewhere for a roast dinner, then you eat whatever suits the host to cook - maybe baked potato, or pizza / pasta bake ready meal - something that takes almost no effort. It would be nice if the host made an effort and made sure the starter was a vegetarian soup, not a meat-based soup, but to demand anything else is rude and entitled.

Asking that the host goes to a lot of trouble to make what will probably be a less-nice version of what they were cooking anyway is outrageous - whether you are expecting the dairy-free option to be served to everyone or just you.

firef1y · 22/12/2023 14:54

As a lactose intolerant, gluten free vegetarian, I can say quite emphatically that You are not being in the least bit unreasonable.

She's only recently converted and probably hasn't quite realised that this is what her life with food is going to be like from now on.

Not only will she have to accept that she is continuously going to be surrounded by the "forbidden" food, but she is also going to have to take responsibility for ensuring that anything she eats fits in with her way of eating (there is often dairy in things you wouldn't expect).

If I were your guest all I would ask is that you ensure that any food suitable is in large enough quantities that I would have enough after everyone else had taken some (you'd be surprised at how often I'm left with very little after everyone tucks in to the suitable food as well as the less restrictive stuff. And I'd probably also ask to look at the packaging to make sure there's nothing I'm sensitive to hidden in the ingredients. Remember there's dairy in chocolate and often dairy in enriched breads and caked.

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 14:45

She's being ridiculous. I was dairy free for about 5 years whilst I breastfed 2 consecutive dairy allergic babies and my 18 year old has been dairy free for his whole life ad well as having to avoid multiple other foods due to allergies and another medical condition.We have never expected other people to stick to his dietary restrictions.
Yes, if someone invites us around I would hope they would provide something he can enjoy but not that everyone would eat the same as him. Not unless the meal was naturally free of his forbidden foods anyway. For instance we were invited round to friends this week and the main course was a roast dinner which was fine for DS anyway, but with dessert there was an option of dairy free or dairy ice cream.
Alternatives are better these days but they're not the same as dairy products. Vegan cheese in particular is crap. And there is some skill to dairy free cooking - some of the alternatives definitely have different thermal properties for instance and just don't behave the same as dairy products in cooking. If you are familia with them it is a bit harder than to cook with ingredients that you are not used to.

I wouldn't expect either a host to go to the trouble or other guests to eat things they might not like just because DS can't have them, and neither would he. Life is just not like that. If you have a dietary restriction you have to adapt to it, but it's completely unreasonable to expect the rest of the world to do it with you. The only exception would be an allergy where someone is so sensitive that air borne exposure or even the slightest cross contamination is dangerous to them, but that's obviously not the case here.

Crikeyalmighty · 22/12/2023 14:29

@Strictlymad I've bought my DF and gluten free niece 2 of the Gu little zillionaire pots- I fancy them myself!!

GilesRupert · 22/12/2023 14:23

Elmlea plant is good (make sure it's the whippable one) and another is Oatly whippable, it's really tasty and whips up really nicely. Don't know about Tesco but I get it from Sainsbury's. It's obviously going to have additives in it that dairy cream doesn't but nothing horrendous. If she made a trifle with either of these types of cream I think it would taste great.

Alpro custard is good. Birds custard powder is vegan if you mix it with plant milk. Moma oat and Alpro barista are both good.

As for cheese, there's nothing amazing out there unfortunately. I Am Nut Ok is really good but expensive and I've only found it online to order. Nurrish "brie" is pretty good in sandwiches and M&S stocks Honestly Tasty which was genuinely good when I tried it a few years ago, especially the blue. But I wouldn't bother with the hard cheese alternatives as they just aren't that good. And definitely don't try to heat/melt them.

I hope that's helpful. You could also pass on any suggestions from this thread to your relative and she can get things herself if she wants.

festivetinseling · 22/12/2023 14:10

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:41

Aparantly it's mean if we're eating cheese and she can't have any

😂

ThisIsntThe80sPat · 22/12/2023 14:07

I was dairy free for around 2 years. One year per child... Breastfeeding two babies with cmpa. It was hard at times like Christmas, seeing everyone eating the stuff you want but I would never ever expect everyone else to give up dairy because I'm not eating it.

LakieLady · 22/12/2023 14:02

Boomboom22 · 22/12/2023 10:25

Do try the elmea before you make anything with it. I've bought it by mistake before as they put it with the cream and it is not cream! It is upf flavoured fake cream. Now i see dairy free people say it tastes the same, and alpro custard tastes the same. Maybe if your taste buds are poor, like quorn chicken tastes the same (ie you can taste the difference immediately, quorn is rank and nothing like meat in taste or texture).

While Elmlea fake cream doesn't taste massively different from the real thing imo, what it lacks is the lovely silky feel in the mouth that proper cream has, in the same way that no vegetarian spread feels the same as butter.

The thought of custard made with fake cream just makes me sad, tbh. And as for using fake cream and fake cream custard for trifle, that's just a waste. Why go to all that trouble to make something that's just not very nice? There are plenty of dairy free puddings that are perfectly pleasant, have one of those instead!

PGmicstand · 22/12/2023 13:42

Whenthebirdssing · 22/12/2023 11:11

Sorry. Don’t want to derail but is that a known thing? That would explain a lot if it is.

For me , dairy intolerance developed through my later 40s. My sister is now experiencing issues with milk and cheese, having been a fan of both for decades. Might just be one of those things that is coincidental to menopause for both of us.

Nttttt · 22/12/2023 13:28

@Bumblebeestiltskin you do realise that intolerances can cause severe problems too?

I have a gluten intolerance and ended up in intensive care with stomach problems because I lost a lot of blood a few years ago. I was in a different country and have to be flown back to the UK once I was stable.

They’ve now found that due to the intolerance I’ve done damage which is causing malabsorption and I’m very anaemic and possibly looking at transfusions to correct this.

IncompleteSenten · 22/12/2023 13:23

I'd compromise on some things where possible but not everything.

You need to tell her that you are not doing a 100% dairy free Christmas and if that's going to mean she sits there with a face like a slapped arse then she should feel free to stay home.

Mmmmmmm12 · 22/12/2023 13:21

Yes usually x

To think if you don't eat dairy you can't expect everyone to make everything dairy free just for you?
To think if you don't eat dairy you can't expect everyone to make everything dairy free just for you?
LifeExperience · 22/12/2023 13:19

My son is vegan. My daughter has coeliac. It wouldn't enter either of their minds to demand the entire meal be vegan/gluten free because they are not self-centered and understand that not everything is about them.

Provide some food she can eat and make the rest the way you like it. People are allowed their needs/preferences but they don't get to dictate and demand to everyone else.

RaininSummer · 22/12/2023 13:02

I am adapting things which can be adapted to dairy free for my family and they know there are some things they will not eat. I want them to feel welcome and have nice food.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 22/12/2023 13:01

MotherOfGodWeeFella · 22/12/2023 09:09

Saying accommodating her allergy is "pandering" for starters. You're not exactly coming across as a gracious host. If she provides her own food you want her to do so only for herself too so she can't win.

She's already said, she's intolerant (cough, not a baby cow), it's not an allergy.

Dotjones · 22/12/2023 12:58

Just uninvite her and the problem is solved, she won't have to see other people eating things she can't and she can buy herself whatever she wants.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 22/12/2023 12:57

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:54

I'm not messing with the trifle as I agree with you. It won't work

Morrison's vegan trifle is lovely. Tell her to buy one and bring it if she's going to feel left out!

Bumblebeestiltskin · 22/12/2023 12:54

I vote YANBU, and I'm vegan! She can always not come? I'm perfectly happy going to my parents' for meals most of the year and them eating non-vegan food around me. Personally, I don't like feeling 'left out' at Christmas, so Christmas Day is just me and my daughter at home, eating lovely (vegan) food all day! I would never expect someone else to make everything vegan just for us though.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 22/12/2023 12:50

DH went lactose intolerant, so I've had to find alternatives for him - which I eat too. My experience is that dairy free cheese is awful (though I gave up after one try, so there may be better ones out there) but DF milk, cream, custard & ice cream can be fantastic. During Covid lockdowns we made DF trifles quite often just for fun, adding liqueurs & seeing how quickly they could be made. Our fastest recipe was:

swiss roll (various flavours available) cut up & put in individual bowls
booze of your choice poured over
Dole mandarin segments in jelly, 1 pot per bowl spooned out on top
DF custard on top
glace cherries on top

A chocolate version can be done, using chocolate mini rolls & Alpro chocolate or caramel/ vanilla soya pudding in place of custard.

The fast version is not exactly haute cuisine😁, but it's good fun. OP could just sub the dairy bits of a posh trifle with DF alternatives & that should be OK.

Inertia · 22/12/2023 12:47

Utterly unreasonable of your guest to demand everything is dairy free. I’m veggie, and if I visited my relatives and demanded entirely meat-free meals for all I’d be laughed out of the house.

As long as your guest has an alternative, make all the dairy things you want. If you’re making a trifle, could you make a smaller trifle alongside the main one , and just top the individual trifle with dairy free cream? It should be possible to buy a couple of dairy free cheeses for your guest, and maybe serve ham/ pate/ celery/grapes with them so she gets the cheese board experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread