Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you don't eat dairy you can't expect everyone to make everything dairy free just for you?

362 replies

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:40

I have a relative. She's gone dairy free. Fine. We'll get some stuff she can eat in for Christmas. But she's been asking what we're having and every time I say something like coronation turkey on boxing day or trifle but don't worry I'll make you something dairy free She's being really annoying and insisting I make it all dairy free so she doesn't miss out. I think she just has to accept a dairy free trifle would be shit and she can't eat the cheese but we're all going to eat it anyway.
As long as there's enough food she can eat I think it's fine.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ConnieCroydon · 22/12/2023 19:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 22/12/2023 18:59

Also not sure if it’s being mentioned yet but Birds custard powder is vegan. You just need to make it using a dairy alternative.

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 22/12/2023 18:58

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 18:27

Where on earth have you found "quite good" vegan cheese @CleverLilViper ?
I've been looking for 20 years and the best I have come across might be described as barely edible. Spill the beans!

Cathedral city plant based is nice.

That being said the best vegan cheese is still the cashew based ones; e.g Tyne Chease. You can’t get those in supermarkets however and they are expensive.

jamimmi · 22/12/2023 18:57

Dd is coeliac an quite happy to see us eat cake and gluten things. They make her feel.dreadfull so it's not an issue. Just have to watch Cross contamination so the sausage meat is wheat free. She is being completely un reasonable if you are ensuring she has an option. I've found a gf chocolate log so I'm super mum this year!

Tacotortoise · 22/12/2023 18:47

AnonnyMouseDave · 22/12/2023 14:58

I am both a somewhat fussy eater and a vegetarian. My take is that if you are such a person, and you are going somewhere for a roast dinner, then you eat whatever suits the host to cook - maybe baked potato, or pizza / pasta bake ready meal - something that takes almost no effort. It would be nice if the host made an effort and made sure the starter was a vegetarian soup, not a meat-based soup, but to demand anything else is rude and entitled.

Asking that the host goes to a lot of trouble to make what will probably be a less-nice version of what they were cooking anyway is outrageous - whether you are expecting the dairy-free option to be served to everyone or just you.

You have a really low bar. I'd be wondering wtf I was being asked to dinner if they couldn't be bothered to do more than stick a ready meal in the oven.

My Christmas guests are a mixed lot including veggies, vegans, coeliacs, 2 haters of mushrooms and 1 person who's allergic to any form of capsicum. Not everyone can eat everything but I don't have an A menu and a B menu.

Zarah123 · 22/12/2023 18:32

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 18:29

I love it when meat-eaters say meat-free alternatives are ultra-processed.

Yes, because pigs meat naturally comes out looking like sausages and cow's meat comes out looking like burgers and steaks 😂

I eat very little meat but saying steak is as processed as Quorn for example is crazy.

telestrations · 22/12/2023 18:32

I'm lactose intolerant, don't expect this and actively try to stop people putting themselves out for me

I'm also intolerant of people who think the world evolves around them so...

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 18:31

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 18:27

Where on earth have you found "quite good" vegan cheese @CleverLilViper ?
I've been looking for 20 years and the best I have come across might be described as barely edible. Spill the beans!

A lot of them can be poor-but I quite like Violife. It's not the same as regular cheese-hence the reason I can never go vegan-I love cheese too much 😆

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 18:29

Soontobe60 · 22/12/2023 08:59

Dairy alternatives are, on the whole, pretty grim in my opinion. As are meat alternatives. They both can be really ultra processed too.
If I were catering for a vegan, I’d ask them to send me a recipe and do my best to make something edible.

I love it when meat-eaters say meat-free alternatives are ultra-processed.

Yes, because pigs meat naturally comes out looking like sausages and cow's meat comes out looking like burgers and steaks 😂

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 18:27

Where on earth have you found "quite good" vegan cheese @CleverLilViper ?
I've been looking for 20 years and the best I have come across might be described as barely edible. Spill the beans!

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 18:24

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:56

Vegan cheese is not the same food as cow cheese.

To be honest, I was initially on your side and my previous post suggests that-however, the more you post, the more unreasonable you seem.

I absolutely think it's fine for you and your guests to enjoy your cheeseboard and dairy trifle. However, it's a sign of a good host to provide alternatives for those who can't have them. Vegan cheese isn't the same as "cow" cheese-that's the damn point-isn't it?

Why are you against providing some vegan cheese and dairy free trifle (that you can pick up pre-made from the store) for your guest so she doesn't feel left out?

It just seems a bit churlish to act as if you couldn't possibly lower yourself to provide your guest with options whilst you all enjoy your feast as normal. Then again, you could easily suggest she brings her own alternatives that she likes as well.

So, in this, you're both unreasonable. She's unreasonable to demand everyone goes dairy-free to suit her and you're unreasonable for not wanting to provide alternatives for your guest to enjoy without getting the shits.

CleverLilViper · 22/12/2023 18:15

I'm a vegetarian and I wouldn't dream of demanding anyone changes their diet/meals to suit me.

Provided I have an option to eat-and/or can bring my own-I'm quite happy. It's ridiculous to expect people to change their diets to suit yours, even if it is a medical condition.

A compromise could be providing some vegan cheeses (which are actually quite good) and dairy-free trifles for her, but absolutely keep all your usual options available for the rest of you.

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 17:54

I see what you mean @Blueroses99 but I think what you wrote inadvertently said the opposite of what you wanted to get across!
Really the message needs to be that there are lots of reasons why someone might need to avoid particular foods including that their immune system is going to react to it, they can't digest it properly or they can't metabolise it. They are all nasty, all have the potential to be serious and some can be life threatening and they all need to be respected.
But a lot of people who have not had personal experience think that they know what an allergic reaction is and if they don't see what they expect then all too often they just assume the person is lying. Of course it doesn't help that there are unscrupulous companies telling people that they are sensitive to all kinds of things based on totally unscientific "tests".
In a strange way I think DS is quite lucky to have IgE mediated allergies as well as his non IgE ones. I gave up trying to explain the difference to most people a very long time ago and now he just lists his forbidden foods, waves his EpiPen and bingo, he's usualy taken seriously. If he only had the non IgEs I think he would struggle to get people to believe him, particularly as if he does have a non IgE reaction it's usually significantly delayed so the non believers never see it. There's a lot of education still needed around the subject.
(Apols to the OP for the derail!)

Melroses · 22/12/2023 17:49

kimchio · 22/12/2023 08:55

I don't want a coconut trifle

Coconut custard and cream with pineapple and Bacardi underneath = Pina Colada trifle. 😋

Don't forget the marachino cherries on the top.

🍹

Blueroses99 · 22/12/2023 16:59

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 16:36

No, a non IgE mediated allergy isn't synonymous with an intolerance. My son was diagnosed with bith IgE and nin IgE allergies by a paediatric immunologist about 17 years ago. It's not a "re-labelling" or anything new, they're different things.
A non IgE mediated allergy is exactly what it says it is - an allergy mediated by a component of the immune system other than immunoglobulin E, via other immunoglobulins or cells. IgE mediated reactions give us what people generally would recognise as allergic phenomena like urticaria right up to full blown anaphylactic reactions. Non IgE reactions are much more varied and do include but are not restricted to stomach problems.
An intolerance can be due to a variety of things that are absolutely nothing to do with the immune system. Lactose intolerance for instance is a digestive enzyme deficiency and fructose intolerance is a genetic inability to metabolise fructose. Still unpleasant and potentially serious of course but not allergies.
You are right of course that the tendency to view intolerances as mild and allergies as serious is wrong, but it sounds like you're suggesting that allergy activists are calling intolerances non IgE mediated allergies to make them sound more "credible". They're not, and they're different things. I'm sure you don't mean to but muddying the water by incorrectly labelling conditions potentially increases confusion and makes things worse for those who are affected.

Sorry if my phrasing was clumsy but I think that there is a tendency to sweep up anything that isn’t an IGE reaction as an intolerance when actually it might be a non-IGE allergy. They are different things but I don’t think non-IGE allergies are well understood.

My DC has thankfully grown out of non-IGE CMPA so I may not be fully up to date.

Blueroses99 · 22/12/2023 16:50

raffegiraffe · 22/12/2023 16:01

What protein?

Milk contains two proteins whey and casein. People can be intolerant to cows milk protein or they can be intolerant to the lactose (the sugar). Milk/dairy intolerance can mean either.

MrsAvocet · 22/12/2023 16:36

Blueroses99 · 22/12/2023 15:29

Haven’t RTFT so this might have already been said but on allergies vs intolerances, I’ve noticed in allergy groups that these are being re-labelled as IGE-allergy and non-IGE allergy. Stomach problems etc would fall into the latter category. ‘Intolerance’ often minimises the effect. Just cos it won’t cause an anaphylactic reaction doesn’t mean it can’t be really harmful.

No, a non IgE mediated allergy isn't synonymous with an intolerance. My son was diagnosed with bith IgE and nin IgE allergies by a paediatric immunologist about 17 years ago. It's not a "re-labelling" or anything new, they're different things.
A non IgE mediated allergy is exactly what it says it is - an allergy mediated by a component of the immune system other than immunoglobulin E, via other immunoglobulins or cells. IgE mediated reactions give us what people generally would recognise as allergic phenomena like urticaria right up to full blown anaphylactic reactions. Non IgE reactions are much more varied and do include but are not restricted to stomach problems.
An intolerance can be due to a variety of things that are absolutely nothing to do with the immune system. Lactose intolerance for instance is a digestive enzyme deficiency and fructose intolerance is a genetic inability to metabolise fructose. Still unpleasant and potentially serious of course but not allergies.
You are right of course that the tendency to view intolerances as mild and allergies as serious is wrong, but it sounds like you're suggesting that allergy activists are calling intolerances non IgE mediated allergies to make them sound more "credible". They're not, and they're different things. I'm sure you don't mean to but muddying the water by incorrectly labelling conditions potentially increases confusion and makes things worse for those who are affected.

BonjourCrisette · 22/12/2023 16:36

Lurkinglaughinglearning · 22/12/2023 08:56

Has she tried the pills that deal with this? Maybe not all the time but on special occasions it is almost certainly the best solution.

Yes, they are really good. I probably wouldn't risk a trifle, even with pills but for eg soft cheese they are really effective. A lot of hard cheese has only minimal quantities of lactose, anyway, so depending on how bad her intolerance is she might be able to eat this.

And vegan cheese is horrible so I wouldn't eat that under any circumstances. I'd rather not have any cheese at all!

inloveandmarried · 22/12/2023 16:25

I cater for a fussy vegan....

You can get her two or three vegan cheeses from the supermarket. There is choice now in recent years. Serve this alongside your cheese board so no extra work as the rest is ok for vegans.

Do her a mini trifle at the same time you make your base so that's not extra work for you, top with vegan custard carton (easy and quick to get this) and on the day use vegan squirty 'cream' to finish it. It's actually a really nice alternative and tastes of vanilla topping but looks like squirty cream.

I'd not mention this to her again so you are not irritated by her requests as it's quite unfair for her to expect everyone to eat her choices. I personally won't eat vegan cheeses they are too fake for me. And I love cheese! So UANBU at all.

aSwarmOfMidgies · 22/12/2023 16:17

Diary free trifle can be fantastic ( oatly whipping cream )

But no ( as a dairy avoidant person ) she shouldn't expect everyone to eat dairy free

raffegiraffe · 22/12/2023 16:13

Fair enough 🤷‍♀️

kimchio · 22/12/2023 16:11

raffegiraffe · 22/12/2023 15:42

My kids are both lactose intolerant so I've read a lot about it. You can buy lactose free cheese and milk with added lactase enzyme but also lots of cheeses are low in lactose. You basically need to avoid the sweeter cheeses. Chedder is very low lactose. Might be something for her to try

Up to her. I'm not going to experiment on her. If she wants non dairy she will get non dairy

OP posts:
DoneByWeds · 22/12/2023 16:03

My 9 year old daughter sounds more mature than your relative!!

She has a dairy allergy and behaves politely when missing out on some items served and is complimentary when dishes are specifically served for her. Just realised how proud I am of her!!!

Zanatdy · 22/12/2023 16:02

Whether it’s a choice or necessity it’s tough and other people are going to eat their stuff and she should be grateful you’re making dairy free alternative. Very rude to want to make everyone eat something different

raffegiraffe · 22/12/2023 16:01

What protein?

Swipe left for the next trending thread