Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What historical event do you think would have changed history if it had turned out differently?

370 replies

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 02:49

Here's mine:
What if Edward VI had lived?
What if JFK hadn't been shot?
What if Edward VIII hadn't abdicated?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SirCharlesRainier · 22/12/2023 17:16

billycat321 · 22/12/2023 16:44

The Queen would have inherited anyway as Edward VIII and Wallis were unlikely to have children. She was Heiress Presumptive during Edward's reign, the Heiress Apparent during her father's.

I think you're right that she was always considered likely to inherit the crown somehow, but just out of interest it looks like you've got your heirs a bit mixed up.

QEII's father (not QEII herself) was heir presumptive during Edward VIII's short reign.

QEII was heir presumptive during her father's reign.

There was no heir apparent in either reign, as a son would have leapfrogged straight to first place.

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 22/12/2023 17:07

billycat321 · 22/12/2023 16:44

The Queen would have inherited anyway as Edward VIII and Wallis were unlikely to have children. She was Heiress Presumptive during Edward's reign, the Heiress Apparent during her father's.

Not if EVIII decided to make some changes - which by all accounts he was planning to do. He wanted to be as close as he could get to world domination, he would have fought hard for it too

billycat321 · 22/12/2023 16:44

The Queen would have inherited anyway as Edward VIII and Wallis were unlikely to have children. She was Heiress Presumptive during Edward's reign, the Heiress Apparent during her father's.

LakieLady · 22/12/2023 16:19

TerrorAustralis · 22/12/2023 03:04

If the French had been the victorious colonisers of Canada and the United States, the world would be quite different, but I am not sure exactly how.

If the French or Dutch had colonised Australia, I wouldn’t exist.

And if the French had won the Napoleonic wars, all the former British colonies would have been French (well, apart from the USA, as that was independent before then).

We might all be speaking French, and still in the EU.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/12/2023 16:17

If the UK's revenue from North Sea gas had been invested in something like Norway's Sovereign Wealth Fund instead of being wasted ...

EdithStourton · 22/12/2023 16:04

TheTripThatWasnt · 22/12/2023 11:01

This whole thread is really interesting, and is making me realise how little I know or understand about history. And it's such a fascinating subject. I did it at school (to GCSE), but it was one of those subjects I never saw the point of as a 14/15 year old. And now I'd like to know more.

What's a good way of 'getting into history'? It's SUCH a wide subject, and reading this, I just want to KNOW EVERYTHING! I'm not a big reader, but I find myself now wanting to understand more about the big events nationally and globally that have shaped the current day. Where to start???

Find an event, era or person that really interests you and start there with the good films and documentaries, and the better books. The old series 'World at War' is still brilliant for WWII (except for Asia, which is given about half an hour).

Some historical fiction is also excellent for setting the scene and getting you into a time and place.

ConnieCroydon · 22/12/2023 15:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

NeedWineNow · 22/12/2023 15:50

What a fantastic interesting thread. Thank you for starting it OP.

SirCharlesRainier · 22/12/2023 15:48

I think the tragic, wasteful decline of this country over the last 13 years can all be traced to Gordon Brown's "bigoted woman" moment.

Austerity, Brexit, partygate, Trussonomics... all might have been avoided if the press and electorate hadn't lost their minds over one (accurate) private comment and so thrown their lot in with what would become the most corrupt, incompetent and downright wicked government in living memory.

How different life might now be if someone had turned his microphone off.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 22/12/2023 15:46

I agree with pps that ww2 would happen even without Hitler.

ru53 · 22/12/2023 15:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Yes good point! I suppose we are at a similar moment with AI in many ways

Snazzysausage · 22/12/2023 15:43

If Henry VIII and Katherine of Aragon's son Prince Henry had lived to adulthood,it would have been very different. No Anne Boleyn so no Elizabeth I's golden age, no break with Rome. The succession would have taken a different route altogether.

PhotoDad · 22/12/2023 15:29

Mine is about the Roman Emperor Constantine. He had a vision/dream in which he saw Jesus, and converted to Christianity. He later spread it throughout the whole Empire and gave Imperial backing to the Church.

If he hadn't, it's a fair bet that Christianity would have been completely wiped out before the collapse of the Empire, and things worldwide would be very different today.

LoobyDop · 22/12/2023 15:24

@KylieJennersMakeUpSponge I’m so sorry you’ve been made to feel like this. The only tiny thing I can do is keep saying “not all of us” 💐

EtonMessy · 22/12/2023 15:23

What if the Library of Alexandria hadn’t burned down? Would civilisation be 1000 yrs ahead of where it is now ?

EmpressaurusOfCats · 22/12/2023 15:23

If Elizabeth Woodville’s 1st husband hadn’t been killed in battle, & she hadn’t married Edward IV, Henry VIII would never have been born.

Isseywith3witchycats · 22/12/2023 15:21

If the person who shot Adolf Hitler during world war one had succeeded in killing him who knows the total tragedy of world war two probably would not have happened

StuckinaMUD23 · 22/12/2023 15:19

What if Atlantis still existed ?

StuckinaMUD23 · 22/12/2023 15:18

I believe that many people involved in WW1 & WW11 hoped that would be the end of all wars. I believe that it has been the end so far of nuclear war so far. However, it seems that there is no end to wars in all parts of the world.

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 22/12/2023 15:13

The one that springs to mind is if the Cuban Missile Crisis had gone tits up. half of us wouldn’t even be here.

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 22/12/2023 15:12

XelaM · 22/12/2023 03:14

If Germany had won WWI.

WWII and holocaust would never have happened.

It would have happened somewhere else. Antisemitism was absolutely rife in the early 20th century Europe and actually Ukrainians slaughtered 100,000 of their own Jewish people in 20 years before WW2 even began. They were blamed for the turmoil of the Russian revolution. The Holocaust was so destructive that people buried their anti-senitism, but not for long. Once again anti-semitism is one of the most prevelant and disproportionate forms of racism today less than 80 years since 6 million Jewish people were murdered, and as always it’s a very scary time to be Jewish Sad

Mayorq · 22/12/2023 15:04

LilyLemonade · 22/12/2023 08:33

If Al Gore had been declared the winnner in the tightly contested election rather than George W Bush.

This.

Republican crackpots want to talk about a stolen election, then this is what they should focus on.

The SC giving an election to one party and then confining their ruling to the facts of that case to avoid repetition.

No war in Iraq, no fake wmds, and a us leader focused on sustainability.

See also the dems treatment of bernie in the primaries using super delegates when bernie won the popular vote.

beguilingeyes · 22/12/2023 14:54

Ponoka7 · 22/12/2023 13:29

What was moral about picking a city, which turned out to be Liverpool to experiment carrying out a managed decline? Or the Hillsborough cover up? It plunged people into poverty, meant that grade 1 and 11 buildings had to be demolished and at the same time drug use was allowed to spiral. Let's not forget ger best friend was Jimmy Savile, her and Prince Charles made him untouchable. She knighted Cyril Smith after he was exposed as a pedophile. She blocked Peter Hayman from being named and protected other pedophiles. What personal values and principles were at play there?

Tragically, today's Tories do treat the public purse as if it's their own money... except it means spending like there's no tomorrow and giving it away to their family/mates.

housethatbuiltme · 22/12/2023 14:31

Butchyrestingface · 22/12/2023 14:05

Adam and Eve. Should have left that fecking piece of hanging fruit well alone.

Well its not historical its theological but I'll bite:

No, women should have been subservient and abused forever under coercive control... the fact the first two women both defied god because he was treating them shit and where forever punished for it does not saying anything bad about the women but rather god.

lljkk · 22/12/2023 14:19

C. of Aragon did have sons, they just didn't survive.
What if Henry Fitzroy had lived, & claimed the throne?

What if indigenous Americans had resistance to typhoid, smallpox, etc? What if they had colonised Europe instead of Europe colonising them?