Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What historical event do you think would have changed history if it had turned out differently?

370 replies

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 02:49

Here's mine:
What if Edward VI had lived?
What if JFK hadn't been shot?
What if Edward VIII hadn't abdicated?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ru53 · 22/12/2023 19:39

TheTripThatWasnt · 22/12/2023 11:01

This whole thread is really interesting, and is making me realise how little I know or understand about history. And it's such a fascinating subject. I did it at school (to GCSE), but it was one of those subjects I never saw the point of as a 14/15 year old. And now I'd like to know more.

What's a good way of 'getting into history'? It's SUCH a wide subject, and reading this, I just want to KNOW EVERYTHING! I'm not a big reader, but I find myself now wanting to understand more about the big events nationally and globally that have shaped the current day. Where to start???

I recommend The Rest is History podcast they cover a really wide range of topics and you can just dip in and out of ones that look interesting.

CampsieGlamper · 22/12/2023 19:37

If the colonists in America had been defeated in the war of independence ...
Likely that with the need to reinforce the colony with a large garrison, to suppress and future uprising, and deploy a large fleet of warships to support said garrison, the number of units to defend the UK would be massively reduced so when the French revolted, we may have become a republic. And or a vassal to France.

greengreengrass25 · 22/12/2023 19:31

@enchantedsquirrelwood

Wasn't a great move on Tony's part

It has caused so many problems

Angrycat2768 · 22/12/2023 19:24

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 19:02

@Angrycat2768 they most definitely would have caught up if not matched or excelled. The indigenous people of Latin America were head and tails above the west in many areas, notably women's rights. They conceived of the number zero and invented the wheel to make carts although strangely only for children's toys not use in farming.

Absolutely. The Incas, Maysns, Egyptians, ancient Indians, Mongols, Persians were way ahead of Europeans, and were building huge structures, etc, while Europeans were farming and living off the land. China has produced more carbon in 40 years than Britain has since the Industrial Revolution ( although they are now also world leaders in future carbon neutral technologies). Europeans have been top of the tree for 3-400 years. Not since the beginning of humanity.

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 19:02

@Angrycat2768 they most definitely would have caught up if not matched or excelled. The indigenous people of Latin America were head and tails above the west in many areas, notably women's rights. They conceived of the number zero and invented the wheel to make carts although strangely only for children's toys not use in farming.

OP posts:
saoirse31 · 22/12/2023 19:00

What if Ireland hadnt won independence from Britain... Would other countries, India etc?

What if USA hadn't won independence fron UK? What about France then?

Think its lucky that the desire for independence and freedom was strong. Good for the world as a whole.

Angrycat2768 · 22/12/2023 18:57

flowerchild2000 · 22/12/2023 04:59

It would be heavenly! I think about it a lot. That's exactly the world I want to live in.

But you can't say that the indigenous peoples of America or Australia etc woukd not have progressed in the same way as Europeans have and they would have continued to be nomadic people living off the land. Without the marginalisation and discrimination of European colonisers they have just as much capacity to be viracipus developers and consumers as Europeans. Much European wealth was taken from Africa, the Americas and India. Those countries would have been hugely wealthy without it. To say they would not have done what Europeans did and had their own industrial revolutions, built their own machines, exploited their own natural resources ( as Brazil, India, China etc are doing now) is a bit silly, and mildly racist, as if only European brains were clever enough to invent machinery to simplify farming, built industrial machines etc. They would just be the ones on top and people in Europe would have been the poor. I say ' they', I would not have been born here without colonisation of India by Britain and Portugal.

sprigatito · 22/12/2023 18:55

If Elizabeth I had died of smallpox in 1562.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:51

Brilliant idea for a thread by the way OP.

The Stephen Fry book about Hitler and being careful what you wish for is "Making History".

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:50

MargaritaThyme · 22/12/2023 18:36

If Tony Blair hadn’t decided not to enforce the UK’s right to limit freedom of movement from the 2004 EU accession countries (Poland, Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovakia etc etc), there wouldn’t have been a massive wave of immigration into this country and we would probably still be members of the EU.

Yes.

And also the Libdems going back on their promise not to increase university tuition fees when in coalition with the Tories which meant they lost loads of seats and David Cameron could call his referendum.

So many factors for "what were the causes of Brexit". I like the one about Gordon Brown's microphone being switched off too!

captainsudoku · 22/12/2023 18:47

If Isabella and Ferdinand of Spain had been less religious.

Barbadossunset · 22/12/2023 18:39

I believe it sped up the dissolution of the aristocracy of the time.

Confessions, how did the sinking of the Titanic speed up ‘dissolution’ of the aristocracy and in what way were they dissolved?
There were a number of rich Americans also on board - was America affected by it in the same way?

Giggorata · 22/12/2023 18:36

PhotoDad · 22/12/2023 15:29

Mine is about the Roman Emperor Constantine. He had a vision/dream in which he saw Jesus, and converted to Christianity. He later spread it throughout the whole Empire and gave Imperial backing to the Church.

If he hadn't, it's a fair bet that Christianity would have been completely wiped out before the collapse of the Empire, and things worldwide would be very different today.

Edited

I was going to say this.
if only…

MargaritaThyme · 22/12/2023 18:36

If Tony Blair hadn’t decided not to enforce the UK’s right to limit freedom of movement from the 2004 EU accession countries (Poland, Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovakia etc etc), there wouldn’t have been a massive wave of immigration into this country and we would probably still be members of the EU.

EasternStandard · 22/12/2023 18:36

Janinejones · 22/12/2023 18:33

Suppose their was no or little antisemitism in Germany and the Jews were of equal standing to Aryans.
The Jewish scientists and engineers would have been working flat out to win for Germany.
Jet Engines, Rockets, V3?, They would have been developed much earlier and before us.
We would have lost, early. Would the USA have joined the Allies?

Yes so many Jewish scientists fled and worked towards the bomb. Fearing Germany would get there first

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:34

GaslitlikeaVictorianparlour · 22/12/2023 07:53

Here's mine:
If Henry VIII had been satisfied with a daughter there would have been no union of the crowns, without the union of the crowns the formation of the U.K wouldn't have hapoened, the Jacobite rebellion wouldn't have happened, the British Army would have been weaker without the massive influx of destitute Highlanders after 1745, the British Empire wouldn't have been so large so quickly, the British wouldn't have been in such a good position to dominate North America, Spanish and French interests would have held their territory and the USA as we know it wouldn't exist.

Yes his reign was definitely a watershed.

I suppose the real "what if" moment is if Arthur hadn't died and had been king instead and had a son with Catherine.

Janinejones · 22/12/2023 18:33

Suppose their was no or little antisemitism in Germany and the Jews were of equal standing to Aryans.
The Jewish scientists and engineers would have been working flat out to win for Germany.
Jet Engines, Rockets, V3?, They would have been developed much earlier and before us.
We would have lost, early. Would the USA have joined the Allies?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:32

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 22/12/2023 07:33

More recent - but I suspect that the UK would be a much better place if John Smith hadn't died in 1994.

Maybe. Do you think Labour would have still been elected though? Like him or not, I think they needed Tony Blair to get into power.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:31

jojom10 · 22/12/2023 07:23

I always think how the royal family might have evolved if Princess Charlotte hadn't died in childbirth in the 19th century and her unborn child had lived. The original 'people's Princess'.

I was thinking about that as well.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:30

Daisy03 · 22/12/2023 04:40

Far more recent, but if labour had won the 2015 election, we'd still be in the EU.

Yes.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 22/12/2023 18:28

TooBigForMyBoots · 22/12/2023 03:04

Things would be different if Catherine of Aragon had had a son.

I was thinking the same! The Reformation would have happened anyway, but English history would have been different.

Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard might have been happily married and kept their heads and died of natural causes, too.

The other one is if Kaiser Bill's older brother hadn't died. Maybe WW1 wouldn't have happened then, or not in the same form - and therefore not WW2.

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 18:25

I don't think Hitler was necessary for the holocaust. My presumption had always been that the final solution came from the nazis not really knowing what to do with the Jews but in fact this awful rhetoric that the Jewish race must be stamped out and eradicated was long standing, since the thirties. It's abhorrent to think of that being a major policy of their party. Similar levels of antisemitism was on the rise in most places in Europe so I have no doubt that it could have been any other country if not Germany.
Truly grim and sad to read about but I think it's necessary so that we can be alert for warning signs if that sort of party with similar rhetoric starts to gain popularity. Antisemitism is rife now and must be challenged by us all.

OP posts:
GasDrivenNun · 22/12/2023 18:12

Sauerkrautsandwich · 22/12/2023 04:38

My dad always used to say things would be completely different if Franz Ferdinand had normal car with roof and windows, not open one in Sarajevo. Can't disagree

Same applies to JFK

greengreengrass25 · 22/12/2023 18:01

Plexie · 22/12/2023 08:13

Catherine of Aragon and Henry VIII? No no no.

If Catherine's first husband, Arthur, Prince of Wales, hadn't died young, Catherine wouldn't have married Arthur's younger brother Henry. If Catherine and Arthur had had a son, Henry might not have become king at all.

Very good observation

Sdpbody · 22/12/2023 17:55

If we had not shut the economy down for covid. We did not need to lockdown.