Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What historical event do you think would have changed history if it had turned out differently?

370 replies

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 02:49

Here's mine:
What if Edward VI had lived?
What if JFK hadn't been shot?
What if Edward VIII hadn't abdicated?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Sagealicious · 23/12/2023 01:32

The Romanov's. What if Tsar Nicholas had remained in power and the family not assassinated?

DC1888 · 23/12/2023 01:25

ALittleTeawithmilk · 22/12/2023 22:47

‘Peaceful settlers’ stole land and displaced the original people of that land. (Where were they to go?) And often used forced labour.

Massacres via poisoning water holes or shooting people happened more than had been admitted to historically. Certainly when it comes to colonial history very much of it has been white washed.

But disease certainly decimated people with no prior exposure. Also, some evidence supports that diseases were sometimes deliberately introduced.

The "peaceful settlers" line must be a new euphemism for dehumanize ("savages" as labelled by thomas "the pioneer of scientific racism" jefferson in the "declaration of independence"), displace (ethnic cleansing), massacres, and those who are left put in their cages (reservations).

As Hitler glowingly stated in 1928, these peaceful...

....White settlers "gunned down the millions of Redskins to a few hundred thousand, and now keep the modest remnant under observation in a cage"

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/04/30/how-american-racism-influenced-hitler

How American Racism Influenced Hitler

How did a civilized society come to embrace Hitler’s extreme ideas? In 2018, Alex Ross wrote about the scholars mapping the international precursors of Nazism.

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/04/30/how-american-racism-influenced-hitler

DamnUserName21 · 23/12/2023 01:24

WhatWhereWho · 23/12/2023 00:59

Which has been heavily criticised over the years.

Do you mean the book has been criticised?

I should hope so. It's a theory, after all, which incorporates some fact and can form a basis for wider learning.

tobee · 23/12/2023 01:18

Editing my previous post.

“Many people were anti semitic at the time; the Mitfords that were anti semitic and TS Eliot were not unusual in that in the pre ww11 era”

tobee · 23/12/2023 01:16

Also the indigenous people of what became the USA were a mixed bunch and some of them were very much murderous and brutal.

tobee · 23/12/2023 01:15

Some of the responses on this thread are a bit emotional. I think colonialism was a very much more organic thing, coming out of companies wanting to trade with other countries and then it developed into various different things. It wasn't "the British government" just deciding to go over to other countries and immediately engage in genocide. Plenty of different nations have had empires/colonies throughout time. Poor little Belgium, who we ostensibly went into protect in August 1914, for eg, had a hideous colony in what was known as the Belgian Congo.

I don't think the German army were the first to have tanks in WW1. The cavalry actually had their uses in, especially the beginning of WWI. The British had the first tanks and a prototype was adopted in 1916.

Some of the Mitford sisters were anti semitic, and TS Eliot. But many other people were anti Semitic through history. Probably most people would have had relatives with anti Semitic views.

I'm not sure you could describe Ireland as having "won" independence from Britain. The liberal Asquith government was intending to give home rule to Ireland in summer 1914 when the Tories led by Edward Carson were trying to gather a Unionist "army" to keep Ireland part of the U.K. This all became moot when Britain joined WW1.

SammyScrounge · 23/12/2023 01:00

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 03:08

@MariaLuna yes a lot of the aristocracy did, look at the Mitford sisters. It's awful that there isn't more criticism of the antisemitic views held by historical figures, such as TS Elliot and Nancy Mitford.

Anti-semitic sentiments were widely held back then by aristocrats and working man alike. In the last few weeks it has become.clear that many people still hold those views.
By focusing on two famous individuals you fail to recognise the context of the times they lived in. It is rather unfair to single out two individuals among so many for judgment.
.

WhatWhereWho · 23/12/2023 00:59

DamnUserName21 · 23/12/2023 00:49

Excellent book by Jared Diamond:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns,_Germs,_and_Steel

It talks about how and why nation states evolved as they did and the impact. I highly recommend it.

There are so many what ifs--if Britain never colonized, if Hitler's life trajectory went a different way, if Henry VIII kept his dick in his pants, if Constantine hadn't adopted the Christian banner...

Colonization, war, establishment of religion would still occur--just by different people, in a different way.

Which has been heavily criticised over the years.

GingersOwner26 · 23/12/2023 00:52

Catsmere · 22/12/2023 21:38

@Janinejones Stanley and Henry Percy, Earl of Northumberland. Stanley eventually charged on behalf of his stepson Tudor, and Northumberland did nothing.

I read a novel (very Mary Sue) where Richard inadvertently travels in time, spends just long enough in the 21st century to find out what happened at the (for him) upcoming battle, then goes back and wins ... and of course the main character, who's a modern woman, wakes up to find she lives in a Catholic England with a Plantaganet monarch. 😄

Just because I'm curious, what was the novel?

DamnUserName21 · 23/12/2023 00:49

Excellent book by Jared Diamond:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns,_Germs,_and_Steel

It talks about how and why nation states evolved as they did and the impact. I highly recommend it.

There are so many what ifs--if Britain never colonized, if Hitler's life trajectory went a different way, if Henry VIII kept his dick in his pants, if Constantine hadn't adopted the Christian banner...

Colonization, war, establishment of religion would still occur--just by different people, in a different way.

Guns, Germs, and Steel - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guns,_Germs,_and_Steel

Figmentofmyimagination · 23/12/2023 00:14

If Mount Tambora had not erupted in 1815 - world’s worst volcano in modern times, led/contributed to famine, war and massive social upheaval.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9nJDTR6R7Gc

The impact of weather events on history is fascinating.

Mount Tambora: The Year Without a Summer

Go to https://curiositystream.thld.co/geographicsmar for unlimited access to the world’s top documentaries and non­fiction series.→ Subscribe for new videos ...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9nJDTR6R7Gc

BlueBellsArePretty · 22/12/2023 23:44

If James IV of Scotland hadn't married Margaret Tudor.

ConnieCroydon · 22/12/2023 23:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Janinejones · 22/12/2023 23:40

Henry VIII, and Rome. There would still have been the Reformation because it was under way in the Low Countries, Netherlands and Belgium. The leading Philosopher was Erasmus, our Tyndall went to Holland to learn from scholars there. He wanted to provide a Bible in local languages, He did a new translation. Others had only translated the Latin Vulgate version. Henry had him executed, (Tortured to death?)

IvysMum12 · 22/12/2023 23:28

I sometimes wonder what the African Continent would be like if there had been no appalling Slave Trade.

PhotoDad · 22/12/2023 23:19

artyjools · 22/12/2023 22:07

Posters have already mentioned events surrounding Henry VIII. If he had not felt the need to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn, the UK would never have achieved the importance in world history that it achieved. Breaking away from the Catholic Church enabled scientists to thrive, whilst similar men in catholic areas were burned at the stake for heresy. And, of course, there would have been no Elizabeth I. The importance of this woman in UK and world history cannot be overestimated.

Who was burned at the stake? (Apart from Giordano Bruno, and that wasn't really for his scientific theories.)

ladygindiva · 22/12/2023 23:00

SirCharlesRainier · 22/12/2023 15:48

I think the tragic, wasteful decline of this country over the last 13 years can all be traced to Gordon Brown's "bigoted woman" moment.

Austerity, Brexit, partygate, Trussonomics... all might have been avoided if the press and electorate hadn't lost their minds over one (accurate) private comment and so thrown their lot in with what would become the most corrupt, incompetent and downright wicked government in living memory.

How different life might now be if someone had turned his microphone off.

Yup, 100% agree. And what he said was correct anyway.

Purplebunnie · 22/12/2023 22:53

Janinejones · 22/12/2023 21:21

@Catsmere , Battle of Bosworth: Was it the Stanley or the Nevilles army that was waiting to see who was going to win before joining in?
Had they have supported Richard, as they had agreed, the outcome cold well have been different.

Stanley defected to the other side. I've recently read Josephine Tey's Daughter of Time which is why I remember. Good book if you're interested in Richard III

GingersOwner26 · 22/12/2023 22:49

Richard III surviving Bosworth and Henry VII never becoming king maybe? We wouldn’t have had Henry VIII then, at the very least I can think of six people whose lives could have been better as a result of that!

ALittleTeawithmilk · 22/12/2023 22:47

Figmentofmyimagination · 22/12/2023 22:37

It was disease that did for the indigenous people more than war. They had no immunity to common diseases and they died in droves. So peaceful settlers would have been equally fatal.

‘Peaceful settlers’ stole land and displaced the original people of that land. (Where were they to go?) And often used forced labour.

Massacres via poisoning water holes or shooting people happened more than had been admitted to historically. Certainly when it comes to colonial history very much of it has been white washed.

But disease certainly decimated people with no prior exposure. Also, some evidence supports that diseases were sometimes deliberately introduced.

ladygindiva · 22/12/2023 22:44

TooBigForMyBoots · 22/12/2023 03:04

Things would be different if Catherine of Aragon had had a son.

Oooh that's a good one. Huge ramifications.

WavingCatsandDogs · 22/12/2023 22:37

@Firefly If Edward VII hadn't abdicated it would be because he wanted to do his duty. Part of that duty was to produce an heir and a spare. He would probably have married somebody suitable to ensure the succession. I magine he would have liked to have kept Wallis on the side, the way these Royals do.

He didn't have kids but that was becuase he married Wallis and that was the life he wanted, not one of duty.

Figmentofmyimagination · 22/12/2023 22:37

It was disease that did for the indigenous people more than war. They had no immunity to common diseases and they died in droves. So peaceful settlers would have been equally fatal.

ALittleTeawithmilk · 22/12/2023 22:29

Abracadabra12345 · 22/12/2023 21:52

I was coming to say that. More than 30 years ago though. Imagine if it had been taken seriously and the world acted

Yes you are right! They were warning us earlier. (I’ve lost track of the decades.)

artyjools · 22/12/2023 22:07

Posters have already mentioned events surrounding Henry VIII. If he had not felt the need to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn, the UK would never have achieved the importance in world history that it achieved. Breaking away from the Catholic Church enabled scientists to thrive, whilst similar men in catholic areas were burned at the stake for heresy. And, of course, there would have been no Elizabeth I. The importance of this woman in UK and world history cannot be overestimated.