Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What historical event do you think would have changed history if it had turned out differently?

370 replies

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 02:49

Here's mine:
What if Edward VI had lived?
What if JFK hadn't been shot?
What if Edward VIII hadn't abdicated?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
tobee · 23/12/2023 09:53

Alcyoneus · 23/12/2023 03:12

If Franz Ferdinand’s coachman had taken a different route.

No WW1 or WW2.

Hmm coachman? The Archduke and his wife were driven by motor car.

SirCharlesRainier · 23/12/2023 09:52

Alcyoneus · 23/12/2023 09:26

Trump had decided to run even before the Brexit referendum was decided upon.

The real cause of the Brexit/Trump phenomenon was the start of low skilled mass migration into the West at the turn of the century.

A swing of less than 1% would have lost the Brexit referendum, and Trump only squeezed in thanks to a few electoral college votes, having lost the popular vote (i.e. the "will of the people" was against him).

You can't possibly believe the much-evidenced significant illegal interference didn't have a large impact on nudging them both over the line.

Catsmere · 23/12/2023 09:34

Figmentofmyimagination · 23/12/2023 08:27

Lots of people have talked about the broader political implications of the reformation, but what always gets me about it was the unforgivable wanton destruction of priceless works of art - thousands of manuscripts trampled or desecrated eg used as butchers’ paper or thrown in the river, triptychs and alter pieces burned, stained glass windows smashed - and also the immense significance on the ordinary ways people ran their lives - last summer I went on a walking holiday through Slovenia and it was all ‘left at the second shrine’, right at the third well to st so and so. So many normal aspects of your life just done away with. Very traumatic. And then the civil war finished the job. Decimated our medieval art heritage.

Yes! I loathe the Reformation for this reason, among others.

daisychain01 · 23/12/2023 09:33

EmpressaurusOfCats · 23/12/2023 09:30

Thank you for that one - I had to Google, hadn’t heard of them!

If Neanderthals hadn’t died out.

If Neanderthals hadn’t died out

The last time I checked on the Relationships board, they are alive and kicking and increasing exponentially

daisychain01 · 23/12/2023 09:31

What's staggering and depressing is that humans have at their disposal all that they need in retrospect to learn lessons from the cockups and successes from history, but do they learn from those events and outcomes to make the world a better place?
do they fuck-

EmpressaurusOfCats · 23/12/2023 09:30

HilaryThorpe · 23/12/2023 08:59

If Robert, Duke of Normandy hadn't spotted Arlette / Herliva doing her washing.

Thank you for that one - I had to Google, hadn’t heard of them!

If Neanderthals hadn’t died out.

Alcyoneus · 23/12/2023 09:26

Halfemptyhalfling · 23/12/2023 09:22

Brexit - the social media manipulation was then repeated in the US which led to trump's election. Brexit and trump emboldened Putin leading to Ukraine. Back in the UK, Brexit caused an exit of talent from government, leading to the current miserable degeneration

Trump had decided to run even before the Brexit referendum was decided upon.

The real cause of the Brexit/Trump phenomenon was the start of low skilled mass migration into the West at the turn of the century.

Halfemptyhalfling · 23/12/2023 09:22

Brexit - the social media manipulation was then repeated in the US which led to trump's election. Brexit and trump emboldened Putin leading to Ukraine. Back in the UK, Brexit caused an exit of talent from government, leading to the current miserable degeneration

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 23/12/2023 09:03

Rocksonabeach · 22/12/2023 11:33

If he had married Wallis - he did - he wouldn’t have married anyone else - so she would of inherited as Wallis & Edward produced no heirs

Except if he was king he couldn’t have married her. Hence why he had to not be king for that relationship to work. He may well have married someone else eventually I guess.

HilaryThorpe · 23/12/2023 08:59

If Robert, Duke of Normandy hadn't spotted Arlette / Herliva doing her washing.

MrsMurphyIWish · 23/12/2023 08:53

I am loving this thread. I often go down wormholes of “what if?” from small things such as “what if I had become pregnant on a different day then I would still have children but they wouldn’t be the children I have now” to the historical events mentioned on this thread.

Thanks for the posters who recommend the podcast too!

Janinejones · 23/12/2023 08:39

My 'Big Picture' thought is that the Stuarts of the 17&18C were doomed. They had this obsession about Divine Right of Kings. The mood of the country had changed and ordinary people were happy with Protestantism. They also believed that other Catholic countries would rescue (finance) them.

Figmentofmyimagination · 23/12/2023 08:27

Lots of people have talked about the broader political implications of the reformation, but what always gets me about it was the unforgivable wanton destruction of priceless works of art - thousands of manuscripts trampled or desecrated eg used as butchers’ paper or thrown in the river, triptychs and alter pieces burned, stained glass windows smashed - and also the immense significance on the ordinary ways people ran their lives - last summer I went on a walking holiday through Slovenia and it was all ‘left at the second shrine’, right at the third well to st so and so. So many normal aspects of your life just done away with. Very traumatic. And then the civil war finished the job. Decimated our medieval art heritage.

cakeorwine · 23/12/2023 08:16

If God had created the world and forgot to make humans...

Now that would have been interesting.

Catsmere · 23/12/2023 08:15

BlueBellsArePretty · 22/12/2023 23:44

If James IV of Scotland hadn't married Margaret Tudor.

Or had won at Flodden.

readymealeater · 23/12/2023 07:21

SammyScrounge · 23/12/2023 01:00

Anti-semitic sentiments were widely held back then by aristocrats and working man alike. In the last few weeks it has become.clear that many people still hold those views.
By focusing on two famous individuals you fail to recognise the context of the times they lived in. It is rather unfair to single out two individuals among so many for judgment.
.

Yes, I read a lot old Victorian novels and there is some really eye-opening stuff in there! Also, even in later books eg 1950s.

Also, a Victorian novel where an Italian and Catholic child is talked about in the most racist terms when it turns out he may have a claim to a country pile.

readymealeater · 23/12/2023 07:16

housethatbuiltme · 22/12/2023 14:31

Well its not historical its theological but I'll bite:

No, women should have been subservient and abused forever under coercive control... the fact the first two women both defied god because he was treating them shit and where forever punished for it does not saying anything bad about the women but rather god.

I thought that the Garden of Eden was supposed to be heaven on earth so I don't think either Adam or Eve were being abused?

Although I suppose if they wanted to eat from the Tree of Knowledge, encouraged by the snake, they couldn't have been 100% satisfied with their lot either.

It's an interesting thought.

mathanxiety · 23/12/2023 04:28

Firefly1987 · 22/12/2023 04:47

Yes but he didn't have any children? So Elizabeth would've been Queen anyway when he died in 1972, having outlived Elizabeth's father by that point.

He had no children at the time he abdicated, but had he remained on the throne and had he and Wallis married and had children, they and their descendants would be the house of Windsor.

No children, even if he hadn't abdicated - yes, Albert and his descendants would have taken the reins.

mathanxiety · 23/12/2023 04:25

If the Restoration hadn't happened. ..

sashh · 23/12/2023 04:17

CHIRIBAYA · 22/12/2023 10:46

If the native American Indians had defeated the colonisers. Their way of life was opposite to everything that is toxic, harmful and destructive about Western industial culture: exploitation of the environment, waste, dehumanising and objectification of people, the marketising and commodification of just about everything, the obsession with money and materialism, greed, competition, futurising and endless dissatisfaction with what we have. They understood the fundamental inter-connectedness of all living things and the necessity of maintaining connection to experience harmony.

They are diverse groups of people, they should not be lumped together. There were and still are very different practices / faiths / language even the traditional diet is different.

TerrorAustralis · 23/12/2023 03:37

Alcyoneus · 23/12/2023 03:12

If Franz Ferdinand’s coachman had taken a different route.

No WW1 or WW2.

WWI still would have happened without the assassination of Franz Ferdinand. There just would have been a different trigger on a different day. All the involved parties were gearing up for war and it was just a matter of someone striking first.

Alcyoneus · 23/12/2023 03:12

If Franz Ferdinand’s coachman had taken a different route.

No WW1 or WW2.

SinnerBoy · 23/12/2023 03:08

MariaLuna · Yesterday 03:04

Imagine Hitler having tea in Buck House. The horror! England - and by extension - UK is lucky that fucker never set foot on British soil.

I haven't read the thread, but he was an art student in Liverpool, between 1912 and 1913...

Pemba · 23/12/2023 03:02

KylieJennersMakeUpSponge · 22/12/2023 20:25

He’s definitely not infertile he had an illegitimate son

Many people - myself included - believe that Wallis has actually horrified by the abdication and didn’t want him to step down. But it wasn’t for the love of her but the fact he was discovered as a Nazi sympathiser and had a target on his back

@KylieJennersMakeUpSponge I Googled and found several references to historians believing Edward Viii was infertile, due to a case of mumps he had at the age of 13 whilst at naval college. Wallis Simpson also once made a joke apparently that Edward was 'not heir-conditioned'.

What illegitimate son? Perhaps you are getting mixed up with another of the Edwards.

JustOneMoreBaileys · 23/12/2023 02:44

It's always so hard to know the path not followed.

Eg we could argue that if Catherine if A had a son, England would be Catholic but we don't know what that son - and all those people that came about after - would have done.

Maybe that son would have gone to to turn England Protestant for some other reason. Or one of his dependents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread