Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What historical event do you think would have changed history if it had turned out differently?

370 replies

MaryQueenofKnots · 22/12/2023 02:49

Here's mine:
What if Edward VI had lived?
What if JFK hadn't been shot?
What if Edward VIII hadn't abdicated?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
beguilingeyes · 24/12/2023 12:33

I read this week that Johnson's bosses at The Telegraph leaned on him to write the anti-EU column.
They should have least made it a super-majority. Destroying the country for 4% was insane.

ToWhitToWhoo · 24/12/2023 11:52

With regard to the Brexit topic: if Boris Johnson, who prepared two speeches, had decided to go with the Remain speech, the vote might well have gone the other way,

Apart from that: if that coronavirus had not evolved in a way that made it able to jump species!

C8H10N4O2 · 24/12/2023 10:13

Most of the world's big events would not be changed by removing single triggers - the direction was still there.

However in terms of more recent politics the LibDems/Clegg's determination to jump into bed with his public school chums instead of standing with Labour (as promised by many Liberal canvassers) lead to the decade of austerity, Brexit and the fiasco governments of recent years.

Propping up Cameron at that time enabled the 2015 result, continuation of a form of austerity which forgot the bottom half of society because they simply didn't care about them.

People didn't vote Brexit because they were stupid - they voted because they had nothing to lose under a government which forgot that pain and benefits need to be shared across the population, not split with one half receiving all the pain and the other the benefits.

Clegg of course, fucked off to be chief liar for Meta, living in his gated community of millionaires - such was his commitment to making the UK a better place to live.

EasternStandard · 24/12/2023 09:54

I put outcome of WW2 below and that’s a biggie, but the race to the atomic weapon was a huge part. It was so huge and all consuming, took so many scientists, many of whom had fled from Nazi Germany that considering the outcome if the Nazis had had the weapon first doesn’t bear thinking.

On a more domestic recent level, David Miliband instead of Ed.

But also Dominic Cummings on Brexit campaign, and leading party gate campaign

LizzieW1969 · 24/12/2023 09:22

True, he shouldn’t have caved in on a referendum. But I suspect that he would have been forced out by the ERG if he had refused with another PM chosen by the Tory Party who supported a referendum.

I think the referendum became inevitable once the Tories won an overall majority in 2015.

Goatymum · 24/12/2023 08:48

The obvious one is the Nazis invading England, but also bloody Cameron not pushing for the Brexit referendum.

sashh · 24/12/2023 08:46

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 23/12/2023 09:03

Except if he was king he couldn’t have married her. Hence why he had to not be king for that relationship to work. He may well have married someone else eventually I guess.

There was a suggestion that they could have a morganatic marriage. But the government of the day used Simpson as an excuse to get rid of a bad king.

They subtly kyboshed any 'soft' influence they could have had by not giving Simpson an HRH. At the time things like where you were sat at dinner depended on your social status / titles. So if they were invited anywhere the ex king would have been placed nearer the host but she would be seated further away.

Actually it probably does still dictate where you are seated if you are eating with royals.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 24/12/2023 05:52

By later I meant later in life like people do and there would be no "show". Just a famous person dying, obituaries and that would be it.
That was not well said, sorry!

Sauerkrautsandwich · 24/12/2023 05:51

Rocksonabeach · 23/12/2023 23:24

She was young. Given an average life expectancy - she would be alive now and very much involved with her children I think and might even have remarried and had more children - who knows!!

Yeah absolutely. Probably do some charity work as she did. She would not become the phenomenon she is now. She would just be there, like the others, do her work and that would be it.

Rocksonabeach · 23/12/2023 23:24

Sauerkrautsandwich · 23/12/2023 16:44

She would just die later without all the hysterical outpouring.
Only reason why this was such a big thing was that she was currently in news a lot and it was uite a tragic ending. Tragic ending without the news wouldn't cause such wffect, nor would normal ending while in newspapers.
She would just... Die. Like many others before and after.
May sound brutal but that's it.

She was young. Given an average life expectancy - she would be alive now and very much involved with her children I think and might even have remarried and had more children - who knows!!

Sagealicious · 23/12/2023 22:38

Sauerkrautsandwich · 23/12/2023 16:44

She would just die later without all the hysterical outpouring.
Only reason why this was such a big thing was that she was currently in news a lot and it was uite a tragic ending. Tragic ending without the news wouldn't cause such wffect, nor would normal ending while in newspapers.
She would just... Die. Like many others before and after.
May sound brutal but that's it.

Why would she have died later? There's every chance she'd still be alive today if it wasn't for the accident. Unless you're going down the conspiracy theory route and it was all set up...

roundcork · 23/12/2023 21:28

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

EmpressaurusOfCats · 23/12/2023 20:53

TripleDaisySummer · 23/12/2023 10:41

If Neanderthals hadn’t died out.

They kind of didn't in that Neanderthals and Denisovans and some other unknow species bred with Homo sapiens likely at several different times and locations and today their genetic code can be seen in populations of those areas. They didn't so much die out as merge with the bigger numbers of Homo sapiens incoming to areas they were.

Yes sorry, I could have phrased that better.

If Neanderthals had remained a distinct species.

tobee · 23/12/2023 20:47

Yeah I know @TripleDaisySummer! I have a mild obsession with the outbreak of WWI and the first few months! Xmas Wink

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/12/2023 17:32

Candleabra · 22/12/2023 09:01

If Margaret Beaufort hadn’t given birth to a son at the age of 13 (Henry VII) - and they both survived - who then founded the Tudor dynasty and all subsequent monarchs are descended from him. I often ponder the unlikely set of events that led to his birth (and also feel so sorry for Margaret, imagine what she must have gone through as a child herself).

Yes. She apparently had a very traumatic and painful birth- not surprisingly, poor child. And, though she survived, she was probably left permanently infertile, as she remarried twice but had no more children.

Henry must have had a strange childhood, with no father (he died of the plague before Henry was born) and a child-mother. Though royals were doubtless brought up mostly by servants.

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/12/2023 17:17

Thomasina79 · 22/12/2023 07:17

If hitler had been shot befor ww2 started and the war didn’t happen as a result

Yes. Or better still, if he hadn't been born.

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/12/2023 17:15

WavingCatsandDogs · 22/12/2023 03:58

Well no, her uncle was King and his kids, if he had any, would have been next in line.

Elizabeth was Queen because her uncle abdicated, her Dad was then king and she was next in line,

He didn't have any kids, so Elizabeth would still have been the next heir, but would have become Queen in 1972 (when Edward died) instead of 1952.

Assuming that everything else had stayed the same. If it had contributed to a Hitler victory, then a lot of things would have been different. Including that I would never have been born, as my mother would have been murdered for being Jewish.

Angrycat2768 · 23/12/2023 17:05

housethatbuiltme · 23/12/2023 10:45

Lilith was formed as an equal with free will but forced to be subservient to a man she didn't even want to be with so she ran away from Eden by choice.

God then demonized her by cursing that children would die until she finally returned to Eden. She refused and never returned so her stubbornness is now blamed in religion for all child deaths when all she wanted was to be left alone. She is often depicted in religious art as eating children.

Then god made Eve, she was created from Adam not clay so she would HAVE to be subservient to the man who she 'owed' life too.

The angel Samael stood up for Lilith's right to equality and freedom and helped her escape and married her. He then returned and also offered Eve the Apple so she could also choose knowledge, equality and freedom too even if it meant leaving Eden.

God was so annoyed by the concept of a woman being equal (and being defied TWICE) that he cast Samael out of heaven (where he fell and became the devil) for helping them and cast Adam & Eve into the wasteland to be punished forever.

They where prisoners of a controlling abuser and they CHOOSE to leave Eden, their abuser then blackmailed and spread rumors to make them the bad guy. When that didn't work he punished humanity for eternity (even killing children) while in a rage.

Its basically like if a woman posted here saying her ex-DH keeps her locked in the house, she tried to run away but he murdered their kids and told everyone she did it so now everyone hates her. He now abuses his new naive wife who he also keeps locked up and when she spoke to someone else and learned she was being abused and there was another life she could have he got so angry he threw her out the house in the cold with nothing and nowhere to go.

Its pretty much the most abhorrently sexist story that ever existed. The fact that for thousands of years Lilith and Eve are still automatically blamed not God for HIS anger says a lot about how sexism is still present.

I thought she was to endlessly give birth in hell, so she is the mother of all demons. Lilith was badass!

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/12/2023 17:04

Some relatively recent ones:

If Galtieri hadn't invaded the Falklands in 1982. Apart from the general benefits of avoiding a war, the specific implications for the UK are that Thatcher would probably have lost the 1983 election, and a lot of things would have been different here.

If John Smith had not had a fatal heart attack in 1994. He, rather than Blair, would have become PM in 1997, and, while many things would have been similar, we probably would have not been involved in the Iraq War.

This one is more speculative, but: if America and the West had encouraged a more gradual transition from communism in the former Soviet Union in the early 90s, rather than wanting to rush things as much as possible, perhaps Russia would now be a democracy and not have bloody Putin in charge.

Angrycat2768 · 23/12/2023 17:02

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/12/2023 16:49

Very much agree!

While the fuss over Mrs. Simpson seems pretty silly in itself, it's likely that it was an excuse to get rid of a king with divided loyalties and VERY dodgy views.

I agree too. Weren't there letters between him and Hitler that indicated an agreement that he would be installed as a puppet King if Hitler had succeeded? He was a traitor, yet people blame Wallis Simpson. A woman made a scapegoat for this whole thing for decades afterwards.

SwordToFlamethrower · 23/12/2023 16:54

Labour winning in 2019

ToWhitToWhoo · 23/12/2023 16:49

MariaLuna · 22/12/2023 03:04

What if Edward VIII hadn't abdicated?

I heard he was MADE to abdicate because he had Nazi sympathies.

Imagine Hitler having tea in Buck House. The horror!

England - and by extension - UK is lucky that fucker never set foot on British soil.

Very much agree!

While the fuss over Mrs. Simpson seems pretty silly in itself, it's likely that it was an excuse to get rid of a king with divided loyalties and VERY dodgy views.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 23/12/2023 16:44

Figmentofmyimagination · 23/12/2023 15:39

What if Diana hadn’t gone to Paris?

She would just die later without all the hysterical outpouring.
Only reason why this was such a big thing was that she was currently in news a lot and it was uite a tragic ending. Tragic ending without the news wouldn't cause such wffect, nor would normal ending while in newspapers.
She would just... Die. Like many others before and after.
May sound brutal but that's it.

greengreengrass25 · 23/12/2023 16:14
Smile
LizzieW1969 · 23/12/2023 16:12

greengreengrass25 · 23/12/2023 15:47

I remember watching a documentary about Tyndal a long time ago

I thought Henry VIII did want him dead so he fled to Flanders

Wasn't Henry like this with anyone who had more radical Christian views or wanted to make the bible available for everyone

It was mainly Thomas More who was opposed to him because he saw him as a heretic. (More was a devout Catholic.)

Henry initially liked him, because Anne Boleyn showed him one of his books, in which he opposed the Pope and supported the idea that the King could be the Head of the Church in England instead. Naturally, Henry liked that idea.

But then Tyndall dared to speak out against him for divorcing Catherine. So then yes, Henry did want to kill him!

Swipe left for the next trending thread