Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Gastric Sleeve is the only real way now?

85 replies

teltic · 21/12/2023 19:02

I don't really want a Gastric Sleeve, but I think it is the only realistic way of losing weight for me now. I think the hormone Grehlin that they remove during surgery is what ai need to lise weight.

•Tried Ozempic
•I have an under active thyroid
•Have mobility issue that prevents exercise or even walking. Exercise has always just made me starving anyway.
•I enjoy nutritious natural cook from scratch food, but I have a massive appetite and it ruins my slimming efforts. It is definitely physical hunger.
• I cannot sleep if I'm hungry
•I am very short
•PCOS
•PERIMENOPAUSAL
•I have a mood disorder and have to take anti depressants.
•Doctor has referred me for ADHD ASSESSMENT
•Probably not an exhaustive list of the unlikely hood of being able to shed 4-5 stone

AIBU to just bite the bullet and get a Gastric Sleeve?

YABU There are many other things you could try before something so drastic.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cherry35 · 22/12/2023 16:12

Yes, unfortunately for many of us is the only solution. I had the gastric sleeve after 20 years of dieting, pills, gyms, and trying every single alternative method for weight loss.

The surgery was life changing. It doesn't mean that you can eat whatever you want without gaining weight. If you eat only crap food you can still gain weight, but you do can have normal balanced meals without gaining weight.

If anything, I would have had the bypass instead of the sleeve. Even on the sleeve, I still have to take some supplements.

You usually regret more the things that you didn't do than the things you do.

Only people really obese or morbid obese can really understand what you're going through, so be careful who you listen. Many people think that obese people can easily change their situation by just dieting or doing exercise which is not as simple in most cases.

tescocreditcard · 22/12/2023 14:54

Best thing I ever did

TwinklingLightsEverywhere · 22/12/2023 14:25

I can't believe people suggest calorie counting to severely overweight people, it's not as though that won't have occurred to you. A diet doesn't work unless you can stick to it, if you can't stick to it that is the diets fault, it is not suitable for you.

Also calorie counting is seriously old fashioned and well debunked for sustained weight loss, but that's another thread.

I am sure there is more to try, but it doesn't much sound like you have the heart for it. I am surprised ozempic hasn't worked for you, but again it's not too much use for long term weight loss unless you stay on it.

It does sound like you need your meds sorting, you've a lot to treat there and some will change your appetite.

Longer term, weight loss is about the food you eat. Not calories but what you eat, how your body processes it, when you eat, how often and how much. So one or more of those is out of sync. Exercise is a red herring, over a long time frame a couch potato burns a similar (proportionate) amount of calories as an ultra marathon runner. You don't need to know this but too many people say 'I'm overweight because I can't exercise' so it's good to take it out of the equation.

Anyway, get on the wait list for that sleeve and in the meantime get your meds sorted and see what you can do about what you eat - type, time and frequency. The Zoe program is good if you can afford it, it's not for weightless but for figuring out the best diet for your unique situation. Best of luck.

LoveSkaMusic · 22/12/2023 14:19

I lost 5 stone on the cambridge diet. My theory was, if I was willing to eat hardly anything after a major operation like bariatric surgery, then I should try that before having the surgery.

I lost 5lb per week and after the first week, it got a lot easier to handle. I'm not saying VLCD's are for everyone, but I would seriously consider all non-permanent methods before opting for surgery.

Whichever way you go, I wish you all the luck in the world with it.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 22/12/2023 14:14

Christmassss · 22/12/2023 14:11

Is there any chance your antidepressants are playing a part in this? Mine make me really hungry and I gain a lot every time I end up back on them

Same here, I put on one and half stone in six weeks when I went on them a few years ago. I was so unbelievably starving, I remember going for a gentle winter walking activity a few christmas’ ago and getting the shakes half way around and having to get a hot chocolate or I didn’t think I’d make it back to the car. I wanted carbs, carbs, carbs all the time. I ditched them in the new year.

Same with carbs for me and my friend, carbs carbs and more carbs and feeling starving all the time.

Christmassss · 22/12/2023 14:11

Is there any chance your antidepressants are playing a part in this? Mine make me really hungry and I gain a lot every time I end up back on them

Same here, I put on one and half stone in six weeks when I went on them a few years ago. I was so unbelievably starving, I remember going for a gentle winter walking activity a few christmas’ ago and getting the shakes half way around and having to get a hot chocolate or I didn’t think I’d make it back to the car. I wanted carbs, carbs, carbs all the time. I ditched them in the new year.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 22/12/2023 14:04

Is there any chance your antidepressants are playing a part in this? Mine make me really hungry and I gain a lot every time I end up back on them. The first time I went on them I went from being really underweight, from being sick, to obese. Gained nearly 6 stone. When I went off them to TTC the weight that wouldn't shift for over a decade didn't exactly fall off, but my weight lose efforts actually resulted in weight loss and I went back down to a healthy weight. After my youngest was born I had to go back on them again and the weight and hunger came back. I'm really sensitive to medication and haven't found any other antidepressant I can tolerate. For me the weight gain is better than the effects of not taking this particular antidepressant. I have a friend who has a similar situation with a medication she needs to take,. it's not a uncommon side effect unfortunately.

NorthCliffs · 22/12/2023 13:21

The long term statistics are an average of 50-60% excess weight still lost after 10 years. So, some people keep less off, some more. Like a PP said I can eat 10 digestive biscuits in one go (thanks cluster feeding!) but not two apples.

Hellzbellz25 · 22/12/2023 13:18

Make sure you think about it really carefully, my friend had one done about 4 years ago, she's lost 12 stone but hates her loose skin and she is in and out of hospital with low sodium which they think was caused by her op, she says she'd rather be fat and happy again, it's not a bed of roses

NorthCliffs · 22/12/2023 13:17

Echoing a PP, I had a sleeve gastrectomy 11 years ago. I lost 13st, then had four children and regained 8st. It's a lifelong tool that you have to use - it's easy to regain. I've managed to lose the 8st again and I intend to keep it off this time.

Member869894 · 22/12/2023 13:09

I had a gastric sleeve about 5 years ago now and have mixed feelings about it .I wasn't that fat to start with to be honest; about 4 stone overweight. Size 18-20. I lost 3 stone really easily afterwards and am still 2 stone down but its creeping up. I'm a 16-18 ,now. I can still eat a tube of pringles at a sitting etc when the mood takes me
I would love to see long term statistics on gastric sleeves and see how people are 5-10 years after surgery. It really is just a tool and doesn't address why we overeat in the first place x

IdaPolly · 22/12/2023 12:58

Outofmydepthnow · 21/12/2023 19:23

Had mine 5 years ago at 55 and 22 stone (5'7") had done all the usual stuff.

Anyone suggesting calorie counting as a means to weight loss for the severely obese needs to do some research. The expert in the field is Prof. Rachel Batterham. (UCL ) If you look her up on YouTube you will see that the statistics for sustained weight loss to a healthy weight through calorie counting and exercise are incredibly small (1:677) for women - and of those'1s' more than 78% of those who succeeded put it all back on and more after 5 years -

Those odds were too much for me. Luckily the NHS agreed. I am 11stone 8 now so still 'overweight' but it has changed my life.

It's not a silver bullet. I calorie count and go to the gym 5 days a week . It's hard work but worth it to live a normal (and much happier healthier ) life.

No regrets here.

You are right. It's definitely better to listen to medical experts in obesity than the average mumsnetter giving diet advice. Some experts backing up what you say in this article
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-57419041

Sarah

Living with obesity: The people who are hard-wired to store fat

Specialist health professionals say obesity should be regarded as a complex illness, and people with the condition shouldn't be blamed for it.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-57419041

Willywanker1 · 22/12/2023 12:53

Four and a half years ago. Best ten grand I ever spent. Had it booked within weeks. You won't regret it

gabsdot · 22/12/2023 12:46

I had gastric sleeve surgery 2 years ago. i lost 100lbs. I'm a new person and I'm so grateful that I did it.
My advice would be to go for it.

ideallyno · 22/12/2023 12:41

Worriedmum159 · 22/12/2023 12:38

@ideallyno that’s a great loss. Well done. What was the hardest part? I’m 19 days away from my op. Starting LRD on New Years Eve.

Thank you so much! The hardest part is the pre op diet for sure. I was so used to eating whatever I wanted to with no real consideration for what I was putting inside my body. Going from that to very very small calories for 2 weeks was extremely hard, but worth it in the end! X

Worriedmum159 · 22/12/2023 12:38

@ideallyno that’s a great loss. Well done. What was the hardest part? I’m 19 days away from my op. Starting LRD on New Years Eve.

ideallyno · 22/12/2023 10:45

I'm 25, had the surgery 2 years ago. I have gone from 23st to 13.5 and am so so happy. However, please be aware that the hunger hormone isn't removed for everyone. It depends on which part of the stomach it is residing in.

Merryoldgoat · 22/12/2023 10:42

I know two people who have had bariatric surgery - both are still really overweight - like look barely any different.

Both had complications during surgery and were in hospital for a long time.

Ive refused it because I think I’d not be able to stop eating and I’d do myself damage. I have an eating disorder and I don’t think cutting out my stomach will help me but some people obviously do amazingly so it’s a good option if it’s suitable for you.

Merryoldgoat · 22/12/2023 10:39

I’ve never succeeded with calorie controlled diets. I’ve always plateaued really fast.

Only keto for me and when I add in IF it really helps. I love IF because if I want a break I just stick to only eating for 8-6 hours and it doesn’t affect my loss - I won’t lose but won’t gain back.

Christmassss · 22/12/2023 09:55

Anyone who thinks I could have achieved this without the op then try living on 1200 calories a day! If I went up to 1500 then I plateaued. More than 1500 and the weight creeps back on

I think this is the case for lots of women, especially short women. I need around 1400 to maintain, I lose weight I’d I eat under 1200 and gain quickly if I go over 1500. So for example if I go out and have steak and chips (approximately 1050 calories where I go) then I have to either eat hardly anything else that day, perhaps an egg, slice of ham and mushrooms/tomatoes for lunch or eat very lightly the next day.

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 22/12/2023 09:41

I have just seen the post where someone has mentioned whether the NHS should fund bariatric surgery.
When I had mine I weighed 27 stone and the doctor predicted I had around 5 years to live and most of that could be in a wheelchair. I didn't have diabetes, my cholesterol level was fine but I did have PCOS and Crohn's disease. It was hurting just walking home. I had the therapy leading up to the operation and I'm glad I did. My consultant told me I was the healthiest morbidly obese person he knew. I was going to the gym three days a week and had cut my calories down to 1200 to lose the weight I did before the operation.

Yes the operation cost the NHS money but since then I have very rarely used their services. I do now have sciatica. I am still obese. I have loose skin which I deal with myself because I would have to pay to have it removed as it is cosmetic. I am still alive ten years on and looking after myself. Hopefully I am actually costing less than I would have if I had not had the operation.

Anyone who thinks I could have achieved this without the op then try living on 1200 calories a day! If I went up to 1500 then I plateaued. More than 1500 and the weight creeps back on.

Unabletomitigate · 22/12/2023 07:24

Take a look at Dr Eris Westman and his KetoAdapt diet.

banjocat · 22/12/2023 07:16

You'll get a lot of people along on here telling you to count calories and have willpower and try various diets etc. It sounds like you already have, and it hasn't worked.

There's only so much you can do, OP.

Obviously, the best way to lose weight is through diet and exercise - you know that - and if there is any way whatsoever that you can do it that way, it will be much better for you and your health. A gastric sleeve isn't an easy way out, it's major surgery. My friend had one a few months ago and although she is doing well, it was a big deal. She had to be on a liquid diet for a long time.

So if there is anything you can think of that you haven't tried, try that first. Have you had a personal trainer? That is what worked for me. (The friendly supportive type who has experience with overweight people with injuries etc - not the shouty type!)

Sometimes you need external motivation - a life coach, a nutritionist, a trainer, a counsellor. It seems expensive but you will spend a lot of money on a gastric sleeve, so it's worth looking into thse sources of support if you haven't tried them. You need someone who understands your situation including the mental health side and potential ADHD.

I really, really would encourage you to do all of this before going for the gastric sleeve.

But if you have done all of that, given it a year or two (it takes time), and still haven't shifted any weight, then I would definitely recommend to start thinking about it. My friend is doing well, her life is completely changed of course, she can't eat anywhere near as much as she used to, but the weight is coming off albeit very slowly. She is very obese but is still only losing half a pound a week, it's still very slow.

Good luck, whatever you decide.

adultsizedogbed · 22/12/2023 07:08

@teltic it's been around 2 years . There is no way she will regain the weight .

She has completely changed her eating habits and can't eat the volume of food she did .

As I said it's been life changing for her .. she is size 8 from a 24 and doesn't even have that much loose skin despite being overweight all her adult life !

Also no exercise ! It's unreal!

ownedbymydog · 22/12/2023 06:29

Hi OP, not exactly advice but I have just read Jenni Murray’s book ‘fat cow, fat chance’ about how she put on weight - a lot of weight - and then her weight loss surgery. It’s a bit cliched in parts but really fascinating about the results of the surgery, so might give you a bit of insight whilst you’re deciding. Good luck with whatever you choose, I can really relate to that ‘never full no matter how much I eat’ feeling!