Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 21:01

Deliria · 21/12/2023 20:49

Unlikely a diagnosis is required for a reasonable adjustment. It will be evidence of functional incapacity that is likely being sought.

I'm not very familiar with the Children and Families Act 2014 but this places duties of cooperation on local NHS services to to cooperate with LAs to assess and meet childrens' special educational needs. So this request would not necessarily fall outside the NHS's remit?

It would be outrageous for children with long term health conditions not to be provided with a suitable education simply becuase their family couldn't lay hands on £40.

Do you have experience working in a GP practice? You really don’t sound like you do.

GPs do and can charge for forms filling in - it is classed as private work. They may work along side other local services but they do not work for them and they have no obligation to provide a non NHS service free of charge. Other services whether it be education etc are classed as third parties and not directly anything to do with the NHS. The only time a GP tends not to charge for a form filling is if it’s for another NHS organisation .

Diversion · 21/12/2023 20:53

I was absolutely disgusted when my Mum's GP charged £87 to sign her death certificate. It must have taken him all of 10 seconds. On the other hand we needed to visit a Solicitor so that my Dad could sign a declaration which was witnessed. Solicitor took the time to explain to ensure he understood and we spent at least 20 minutes with her. She charged him £5

Deliria · 21/12/2023 20:49

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 18:21

Writing a sick note for depression and anxiety is not the same as being diagnosed with an actual medical mental health condition where a patient has to be referred and seen by a specialist psychiatrist, mental health worker, CAHMS etc so that argument does not stand up. Yes they can write sick notes for general depression and anxiety and maybe other mental health conditions where a patient has been DIAGNOSED by a specialist in that area and the GP has written factual correspondence filed in the patient’s records that have come from that specialist stating a patient’s diagnosis. A sick note is a legal document and is written based on FACTS and because they have either assessed that patient or they have factual information from a specialist. They do not magic things up out of thin air

I do love posts like this where people who have no experience in general practice decide that a doctor can do this, that and the other lol

Edited

Unlikely a diagnosis is required for a reasonable adjustment. It will be evidence of functional incapacity that is likely being sought.

I'm not very familiar with the Children and Families Act 2014 but this places duties of cooperation on local NHS services to to cooperate with LAs to assess and meet childrens' special educational needs. So this request would not necessarily fall outside the NHS's remit?

It would be outrageous for children with long term health conditions not to be provided with a suitable education simply becuase their family couldn't lay hands on £40.

Trez1510 · 21/12/2023 20:21

I'd imagine most people in the situation described by OP already claim DLA. DLA being the benefit provided for exactly this type of situation i.e. additional expenses associated with disability.

If OP has not already applied for DLA, she should do so.

If OP is already in receipt of DLA, she's a CF.

gocompare · 21/12/2023 20:13

We had to fill in a bupa form this month for my husband. He gets it through work.

No one at the surgery knew how to fill it in so my DH did and they just signed it. Cost us £50 for a signature.

Sirzy · 21/12/2023 20:09

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 20:05

Yup - there are even some medications that even a GP cannot prescribe and can only be prescribed by a specialist at a hospital or other care provider. But some people just don’t seem to understand this and seem to think GPs just choose to do stuff willy nilly.

Exactly. It drives me mad that each month as well as ordering ds meds from the GP I have to order from three different specialist routes but I know that’s not the GPs fault, or anyone’s fault really, it’s just the complexity of the situation of making sure things are right!

Sirzy · 21/12/2023 20:07

BettyBakesCakes · 21/12/2023 20:02

I believe the latest guidance says 6 days now (for illness).

Thankfully I haven’t had need to read the document in a few years but if that is the case even better!

although getting them to do what the should be in a whole different issue

Keepingthingsinteresting · 21/12/2023 20:05

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:28

Also, it could be the OP who's requesting the online learning, the GP just has to write something-or-other about her child's medical condition.

Exactly, all they have to write is that child seen, reported mental health issues due to health condition and how it affects them at school, awaiting referral made to CAHMs.

2-3 lines written in box on form put in front of them.

Could have been done during an appointment on NHS time but they won’t give me one.

But @FrostedFancy the work of the form isn’t covered by the NHS, so they can’t do it in the appointment. I get you’re upset, but you’re asking for a service so you have to pay.

If you don’t like it think about who you voyage for at the next election.

hope your daughter starts to improve soon

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 20:05

Catza · 21/12/2023 19:51

GP cannot “prescribe” anything that is not medical and that is not outlined in NICE guidelines. Why is it so difficult to understand? If anything, OP needs to see an occupational therapist as they are much better placed to identify what non-medical adjustments are needed to mitigate the condition. But god forbid the practice receptionist ever suggests you see someone either than your GP. They will be labelled “GP police”.

Yup - there are even some medications that even a GP cannot prescribe and can only be prescribed by a specialist at a hospital or other care provider. But some people just don’t seem to understand this and seem to think GPs just choose to do stuff willy nilly.

BettyBakesCakes · 21/12/2023 20:02

Sirzy · 21/12/2023 19:28

But the form shouldn’t be needed. After 15 days out of education (not necessarily all in one go) the local authority are legally obliged to provide an alternative education. That doesn’t require a GP with minimal knowledge of the situation to fill in a form!

I believe the latest guidance says 6 days now (for illness).

Catza · 21/12/2023 19:51

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 17:47

I don’t think it is entirely different. It’s prescribing something that will mitigate a medical condition. Medication prescribed by a dr also mitigates a medical condition. In each case the patient wouldn’t need what’s being prescribed if it weren’t for the fact they’re suffering from a medical condition.

The GP’s salary could be relevant in some circumstances. There’s an issue of fairness,, for example, if a partner GP earning £100k is charging a patient struggling to make ends meet in the current CoL climate. I would hope there would at least be some leeway for patients struggling financially, though some will find it embarrassing to ask.

GP cannot “prescribe” anything that is not medical and that is not outlined in NICE guidelines. Why is it so difficult to understand? If anything, OP needs to see an occupational therapist as they are much better placed to identify what non-medical adjustments are needed to mitigate the condition. But god forbid the practice receptionist ever suggests you see someone either than your GP. They will be labelled “GP police”.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 19:37

Sirzy · 21/12/2023 19:28

But the form shouldn’t be needed. After 15 days out of education (not necessarily all in one go) the local authority are legally obliged to provide an alternative education. That doesn’t require a GP with minimal knowledge of the situation to fill in a form!

Exactly! Everyone just likes to drag the GP into it so that the GP can put their name to and sign the document and then if anything goes wrong they can blame the GP for it while everyone else washes their hands of any responsibility

Sirzy · 21/12/2023 19:28

But the form shouldn’t be needed. After 15 days out of education (not necessarily all in one go) the local authority are legally obliged to provide an alternative education. That doesn’t require a GP with minimal knowledge of the situation to fill in a form!

WhichIsItWendy · 21/12/2023 19:24

Playdoughcaterpillar · 21/12/2023 13:41

It's just standard for any non NHS work I'm afraid. Primary care is on it's knees. I would be directing my anger to the school for demanding a form in the first place!

Hmm.. whilst it's on its knees in terms of being fit for purpose, the model means that GP partners run their own businesses. Lots of practices make a very good profit year end which is distributed to partners on top of their salaries. Don't be fooled to think it runs like secondary care; partnership is profitable and whilst SOME income needs to be reinvested (although rarely audited), much of it can be taken as profits year end. To fund kids private educations, large mortgages and healthy pensions.

OP - YANBU. Forms for holidays, fine, chargeable. But forms for a child with a medical condition to access education, absolutely should be free.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 19:20

TenorMachine · 21/12/2023 19:13

It’s interesting. I am a hospital consultant and have filled endless forms in over my career. They never take five mins. You have to find the patient’s notes and then go through them. Extract the right info. Find the up to date meds. Try and answer weird specific questions based on sparse into. Search all the different hospital letters etc.

But I have never charged. Not sure we even can! I just see it as part of my job to be slotted in somehow amongst my other million tasks. It feels a bit off to charge for this, but it’s also annoying that school needs this extra info.

As I have pointed out in my earlier posts though, hospital consultants usually fill out forms that are specific to their area/ specialty of work, however GPs get all manner of forms thrown at them - multiple times on a daily basis. These forms can be anything ranging from passport forms to filling out a form for a patient to get a discount on their council tax. Then there are the forms that come in from
the benefits agency, solicitors requesting medical reports, the DVLA requesting medical reports, patients bringing in forms for their holiday insurance as they have had to cancel their holiday, patients wanting a reference for immigration purposes hence why GPs are more likely to charge. I imagine you yourself would only need to complete forms for a patient if that form is related to the specific area of work you deal with and I bet you don’t have to complete more than 5 of these forms on a daily basis. Being a hospital consultant is a completely different kettle of fish to being a GP

TenorMachine · 21/12/2023 19:13

It’s interesting. I am a hospital consultant and have filled endless forms in over my career. They never take five mins. You have to find the patient’s notes and then go through them. Extract the right info. Find the up to date meds. Try and answer weird specific questions based on sparse into. Search all the different hospital letters etc.

But I have never charged. Not sure we even can! I just see it as part of my job to be slotted in somehow amongst my other million tasks. It feels a bit off to charge for this, but it’s also annoying that school needs this extra info.

MrsAvocet · 21/12/2023 19:10

Free at the point use has to end universally
It already isn't universal. Probably never truly has been and I'm sure never will be in the future as the range and costs of available treatments increase and life expectancy continues to rise.
There are loads of things that aren't covered by the NHS, but people don't realise that until it impacts upon them personally. I'm sure lots of us could start threads about how terrible it is that our/our children's healthcare needs aren't fully met by the NHS. I'd quite like my DS's medically essential dietary needs to be prescribed, even in part, but they're not. From an idealistic point of view it is terrible that there are so many gaps but pragmatically, heathcare is a bottomless pit and there will always be something that can't be funded.* *
**Things could be managed better for sure but moaning about frontline staff rarely if ever changes things. People need to make their views known to their political representatives and vote accordingly. And almost certainly to be willing to pay more tax if they want better services. I'm not holding my breath.

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 19:00

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 18:52

Generally professionals do work ‘overtime’ for ‘free’. Certainly solicitors, accountants etc. Those working in careers of similar standing to that of a GP. Those sort of jobs don’t involve clocking in and out for your contracted hours only. The pay and conditions reflect this.

Really, the people I feel for most with this is those who are struggling financially. I’d love to know what provision is made for people in this position. Nobody has explained that yet.

Yes however what I have been saying throughout this thread is not only are you paying the GP for their time, you are also paying for a signed document which has been completed by the GP which holds them legally accountable for the information they have provided.

I also feel for the people struggling financially, myself included but as with all services - you have to pay. You don’t get gas/ electric/ public transport/ mechanics/ plumbers etc for free. So you could ask the same question for every service everywhere that is being provided for a charge.

WashItTomorrow · 21/12/2023 19:00

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 18:52

Generally professionals do work ‘overtime’ for ‘free’. Certainly solicitors, accountants etc. Those working in careers of similar standing to that of a GP. Those sort of jobs don’t involve clocking in and out for your contracted hours only. The pay and conditions reflect this.

Really, the people I feel for most with this is those who are struggling financially. I’d love to know what provision is made for people in this position. Nobody has explained that yet.

They most definitely don’t work for free. They work in 10-15 minutes sections and each is measured and billed to the client. Billable hours is how they are rated.

cerisepanther73 · 21/12/2023 18:55

@FrostedFancy

No it's not what you call profitering from your and anyone's child's well being needs at all,

You are paying for a medical form and your doctors expertise in the process,

I know in lockdowns there was enough 🌈 rainbows symbols about connected to the Nhs,
but L.o.l 😊there isn't a Croc of gold treasure at the end of Nhs rainbow's somewhere waiting to be discovered,

The fact is it's common knowledge that the NHS is showing its age and its allmost on its knees,
desperate for 💉 injections of funding from Gov ect, as its been underfunding for so long.

I think 🤔 paying £40 for this medical form from your doctor's, consirdering the benefit to your daughter's well being in the near future,
Money well spent...

Stop ✋️ the whine fest ...

be grateful we still have NHS here like we do in the UK not like the American health care system...

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 21/12/2023 18:53

NeverTrustAPoliceman · 21/12/2023 14:00

Our GP surgery has a very comprehensive price list clearly displayed in Reception. It is absolutely acceptable for them to charge for work like that.

I paid £25 45 years ago for a medical letter.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 18:53

Alittlewordinyourear · 21/12/2023 18:32

I do think it’s ridiculous but I’m not surprised, really exemplifies how broken the National Health “service “ is

Yes.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 21/12/2023 18:52

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 18:10

So they should work overtime for free then? Because a lot of GPs do stay way over the time they were supposed to have finished to complete such forms! It may cover a medical information but the information was requested by a 3rd party that is non NHS and as I have stated many times before on this thread that once a GP fills out and signs this form it then becomes a legal document that they can be held accountable for. Not only that, it is very time consuming for the GP to complete such forms. And that is why they charge, not just for their time of doing private work outside of their normal NHS work but due to the fact they are signing a legal document! Go to any solicitor and they will charge way more for completing any sort of legal document.

Generally professionals do work ‘overtime’ for ‘free’. Certainly solicitors, accountants etc. Those working in careers of similar standing to that of a GP. Those sort of jobs don’t involve clocking in and out for your contracted hours only. The pay and conditions reflect this.

Really, the people I feel for most with this is those who are struggling financially. I’d love to know what provision is made for people in this position. Nobody has explained that yet.

whenlifegivesyoulemonssuckonthem · 21/12/2023 18:42

Free at the point use has to end universally.

I wonder how many special considerations would be needed if people had to pay for it.

Heatherjayne1972 · 21/12/2023 18:42

It’s normal
I’ve just had to approach the gp for a letter/ copy of a diagnosis for my son’s adhd.
this has come from the exam board via school so he can have extra time in his GCSEs ( school are saying they need ‘proof’ - he’s yr 11 diagnosed yr5. So what they have done with the proof I supplied at yr7 I don’t know )
Gp practice want £30