Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is disgusting - GP charging for form

487 replies

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 13:39

GP surgery insist I must pay £40 for completion of a form from school to request online learning for my DD (14) who is suffering from MH issues due to being diagnosed with a serious health condition.

AIBU to think this is absolutely disgusting to profit from a child with medical condition and mental health issues needing access to an education?

Form literally would take 5 minutes to complete.

OP posts:
Deliria · 21/12/2023 23:25

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 21:01

Do you have experience working in a GP practice? You really don’t sound like you do.

GPs do and can charge for forms filling in - it is classed as private work. They may work along side other local services but they do not work for them and they have no obligation to provide a non NHS service free of charge. Other services whether it be education etc are classed as third parties and not directly anything to do with the NHS. The only time a GP tends not to charge for a form filling is if it’s for another NHS organisation .

Do you have much experience of SEND legislation and the responsibilities it places on the NHS?

BestBadger · 21/12/2023 23:13

LadyWithLapdog · 21/12/2023 18:21

They won’t go into the minutiae of how that person should do their job. They might refer to occupational health. Or for a child with various educational needs to , don’t know, the education specialist.

You're right, but the school shouldn't need them to go into detail. If this was a student in FE or HE the institution would work with the student to formulate a support plan. This often does involve remote lectures/seminars and alternative assessments to presentations.

Everything important is under resourced and half-arsed in this country.

Muffins28 · 21/12/2023 23:10

I think as hospital consultants are employed directly by the NHS (and not by a private GP practice that is contracted to do NHS work), this is why it differs.

GPs are not contracted to write the letters, it's not part of their NHS GP contract, and hence falls outside of reimbursement by the NHS to practices. I think as a hospital consultant, these letters are classed as contractual NHS work (just like discharge letters are), meaning you are already being paid by the NHS for this work so you cannot charge extra. Realistically we all know you also have to slot these letters in during admin time as time isn't always alloted, but I think the difference is the differing consultant & GP contracts here.

I'm also not sure how many requests you get for these letters? GPs get quite a lot, often a GP will be asked to write a letter or complete a form for a patient they haven't directly consulted with or know very little about as the patient is registered under them. I think if the NHS added completing these forms into the GP contract they would go bankrupt as the GPs would be doing forms on NHS time (rather than privately on non-NHS time, but on the practices business time) and the number of patients being seen by their GP would plummet.

It would be interesting to hear your perspective a little more on this as I find it very fascinating how our jobs differ so much between primary and secondary care purely due to the contract.

AlbatrosStrike · 21/12/2023 23:07

It really grinds on me that as a society we have become so expectant of healthcare that is free at the point of use

@Muffins28 why would this ‘grind on you’? At the end of the day it’s what we pay NI for. I agree with some of your later points about non-NHS services, but generalising is unhelpful.

If we’re not to expect healthcare that’s free at the point of use, the we should be able to opt out of NI and get private health insurance instead.

Muffins28 · 21/12/2023 23:02

GPs already work multiple hours of unpaid overtime each week to complete their standard NHS work (clinics & admin arising directly from seeing patients). A standard session for a GP is 4 hours & 10 minutes. GPs see 18-20 patients in these sessions & do all of the admin for them.

When you go and see your GP are they often running late? Of course, because lots of things cannot be appropriately managed safely in just 10 minutes. Emergencies also occur & urgent referrals can take time with GPs being stuck on hold to emergency units/the hospital. It is virtually impossible for a GP currently to fit all of the work for 18-20 patients into that 4 hours & 10 minutes. So they inevitably go over this, and work at least 1-2 hours free on top of each session.

Putting that into perspective, if a GP works 2 sessions in a day, they are paid for 8 hours & 20 minutes, so they are paid from 9-5.20 let's say. Add in a lunch break let's then say 9-6 (but being clear, nearly every GP I know works through their lunch break). So why is it most GPs work 8am-6pm/7pm? That's because they cannot physically fit all of their NHS work into the 8 hours 20 minutes. Adding that up for a full time GP, they would on average work 6 hours unpaid every single week. That's absurd, but it's the norm.

Now add on all of these non-NHS jobs, like forms, letters, reports etc. these have to be done outside of NHS contracted time. Well GPs already work many hours for free each week on NHS time, so adding even more free work time is just not feasible. Hence why practices charge so their GPs are fairly compensated for non-NHS work.

I don't think GPs would mind at all the odd form every now & again if they didn't work loads of free overtime every week, but they do work loads of free overtime already and are inundated with requests for forms and loads of other things. They need sleep & time with their families too...

Muffins28 · 21/12/2023 22:47

GPs do not charge for the medical certificate of cause of death as this is NHS funded work. They complete the MCCD, it goes to the registry office & then you collect the death certificate after the registrar creates it from the MCCD & the deceased demographics.

Did you by any chance get an itemized bill from your funeral directors with the £87 charge on as death certificate to the GP? As it is standard for GPs to charge for cremation forms as this is non-NHS work, and the funeral directors pay them the standard £87 for this as laid out by the government. This is routine and has always been the case in the UK.

For your information, a medical certificate of cause of death takes a GP anywhere from 5 minutes (if they knew the patient & history very well & cause of death was clear) to hours in some cases (did not know the patient, more complex history to sort through, multiple factors or potential causes of death). The cremation forms take around 30 minutes to complete as they are detailed & involve a lot of background, they often also involve a visit to the funeral home which takes around 30-45 minutes. So not quick, and actually £87 is very reasonable for that much of a GPs time. Hope that explains.

Muffins28 · 21/12/2023 22:35

This used to frustrate me when I was a student needing these forms, but having been on the other side for some years now, let me shed some light as to why YABU...

GPs receive lots of requests for forms to be completed, or letters to be written as evidence for external services such as schools, benefits system, work etc. the NHS does not pay practices for this work, so it's classed as non-NHS or private work, meaning practices don't get any reimbursement for this work at all.

Some letters may take 5 minutes, the vast majority take much longer. The time it takes to look through the notes & gather the evidence, complete the form/write the letter then send it on is typically more like 10-15 minutes, and with multiple requests, this means a significant amount of a GPs time is taken up doing this. As there is such a huge demand for NHS work (more appointments needed than can be provided), GPs are having to prioritise NHS work, meaning most of the forms have to be done outside of normal working hours or clinical time, leading many GPs to work well over their scheduled hours that they are paid for each week.

The NHS pay for NHS services, like appointments, and if GPs are doing forms, they aren't doing NHS services & hence not recieving any payment. Now do you expect these GPs to work for free, out of their own goodwill, to deliver these forms? Of course the GPs are going to charge for them, as this is private non-NHS work, meaning the patient has to pay for the service provided by the GP in place of the NHS (as they don't fund this), or else the GP is working for free and we can all agree that if they did this, they would be working many hours weekly for no pay, which is not how the world works.

It really grinds on me that as a society we have become so expectant of healthcare that is free at the point of use, that we forget that the NHS is struggling & not all healthcare services are fully or even partially funded anymore, and when we are asked to pay for a private medical service provided by hard working GPs in or outside of their working hours, we get tantrums & moans, yet you would not get the same if you were asked to pay for another service that isn't healthcare related. GPs and all other healthcare professionals should not be expected to work for free, and so it is absolutely correct that they charge for these forms/letters.

if you have an issue with paying for a non-NHS letter from your GP, take it up with the person requesting it, as I can guarantee the GP would much rather not write the letter (they have work coming at them left right and centre and could do without the additional non-NHS work that most of them have to do in their own time outside of normal working hours) as much as you would prefer not to pay for it. Sometimes services ask for these letters (which can cost a lot) when it's not necessary and all that is needed is evidence from the family or school. If it is definetly required, then rightfully you will have to pay to ensure your child gets the help they need.

Hope that makes sense.

DjMac609 · 21/12/2023 22:26

.

Alwaysanotherwine · 21/12/2023 22:18

you shouldn’t have to pay for diagnosis letter

dds letters from consultant to gp have all been forwarded to me as an extra copy via post

anything else in terms of opinion yes you should pay for

dds diagnosis letter was free as i just gave the copy of the consultant to gp letter in

DjMac609 · 21/12/2023 22:12

The reason it was 2 lines loing is because these letters aren't supposed to be requested by the school for this reason. There is a process for pupils who are unwell for an exam and at no point in it is a GPs input required (assuming the child doesnt need gp input for medical reasons). Despite this schools still ask for these letters all the time, however when I write to the school teling them theyll have to pay for it unsuprisingly the GP letter is no longer needed (every single time, none have actually asked for the letter in the end)

MumblesParty · 21/12/2023 22:07

Diversion · 21/12/2023 20:53

I was absolutely disgusted when my Mum's GP charged £87 to sign her death certificate. It must have taken him all of 10 seconds. On the other hand we needed to visit a Solicitor so that my Dad could sign a declaration which was witnessed. Solicitor took the time to explain to ensure he understood and we spent at least 20 minutes with her. She charged him £5

@Diversion in the UK a GP wouldn’t charge for a death certificate. They charge for cremation forms. Again, it’s the time and responsibility. Once a body is cremated, no further investigation can be done into their cause of death, so the doctor signing it has to be 100% sure of the diagnosis. 2 doctors in fact, as 2 doctors have to sign forms now.

MumblesParty · 21/12/2023 22:03

littlebopeepp234 · 21/12/2023 19:37

Exactly! Everyone just likes to drag the GP into it so that the GP can put their name to and sign the document and then if anything goes wrong they can blame the GP for it while everyone else washes their hands of any responsibility

Edited

Yep, that’s the bottom line, and one of the reasons GPs charge. It’s not just time and effort, it’s responsibility. If people want the buck to stop with someone, that someone has to be paid to take that responsibility.

Soontobe60 · 21/12/2023 22:00

Diversion · 21/12/2023 20:53

I was absolutely disgusted when my Mum's GP charged £87 to sign her death certificate. It must have taken him all of 10 seconds. On the other hand we needed to visit a Solicitor so that my Dad could sign a declaration which was witnessed. Solicitor took the time to explain to ensure he understood and we spent at least 20 minutes with her. She charged him £5

When my MIL and DSis died, their GPs provided their MCCD - medical certificate of cause of death. With my DF and DM, as they died in hospital a Junior doctor completed their MCCDs. In all cases, the copies went electronically to the registrars who we then had to attend to register the deaths. We then received the death certificates, and we had to pay for additional copies.
GPs cannot provide death certificates!

Soontobe60 · 21/12/2023 21:48

dammit88 · 21/12/2023 15:06

This - you have explained it perfectly. It's all part of treating the Childs medical condition.

Maybe the GP thinks that the best treatment for the child is to go to school.

StarlightLime · 21/12/2023 21:47

Diversion · 21/12/2023 21:43

@HonoriaLucastaDelagardie The cause of death was very obvious, a form of cancer which she had for the last 10 years which had almost led to her death due to complications several years before this. It was not unexpected as her notes (scans, blood tests etc) showed that the cancer was widespread and had affected several of her organs. Please do not jump to conclusions, I would never ask anyone to sign nor would I sign anything without knowing the full details.

They have to check... Anyone could have decided to hasten her end.
You do sound as though you think he should have signed without knowing the full details, what's your gripe otherwise?

Christmasbrie · 21/12/2023 21:47

GPs aren't allowed to charge to sign death certificates but they do charge for signing the cremation forms which is fair enough (well, via the funeral director). If they did indeed charge for the death certificate then report them.

MrsAvocet · 21/12/2023 21:45

Diversion · 21/12/2023 20:53

I was absolutely disgusted when my Mum's GP charged £87 to sign her death certificate. It must have taken him all of 10 seconds. On the other hand we needed to visit a Solicitor so that my Dad could sign a declaration which was witnessed. Solicitor took the time to explain to ensure he understood and we spent at least 20 minutes with her. She charged him £5

Sorry, I think you must be mistaken. Both my parents have died and I definitely didn't pay the doctor to certify the death. It was about £10 each for copies of the certificate but no fee to the doctor. In fact I just Googled and found a list on the BMA website of certificates that doctors are not allowed to charge for and death certificates are amongst those.
Are you sure it wasn't for a cremation certificate? I recall there being fees for that. About £80 each to 2 doctors if I recall rightly. Again, Google tells me that 2 doctors need to independently examine the body of the deceased before each completing a form that is 7 pages long. Obviously there needs to be a thorough process as there's no way to ever examine the body again if foul play or something is later suspected. Doesn't sound like a 10 second job to me.

Diversion · 21/12/2023 21:43

@HonoriaLucastaDelagardie The cause of death was very obvious, a form of cancer which she had for the last 10 years which had almost led to her death due to complications several years before this. It was not unexpected as her notes (scans, blood tests etc) showed that the cancer was widespread and had affected several of her organs. Please do not jump to conclusions, I would never ask anyone to sign nor would I sign anything without knowing the full details.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 21/12/2023 21:32

I was absolutely disgusted when my Mum's GP charged £87 to sign her death certificate. It must have taken him all of 10 seconds.

You want the GP to just spend ten seconds scrawling his or her name on the certificate without taking any steps to establish the cause of death?

Any time a GP signs anything, that's his or her professional reputation and livelihood, maybe even personal liberty, on the line.

Are you in the habit of signing your name to anything that's put in front of you, without taking time to etablish what you're signing and whether it's truthful and accurate?

HorMon · 21/12/2023 21:31

If the online learning is required for a medical reason then the form should actually be filled in by the professional who has recommended it. They will be the person who knows all the details around the health condition, how school is affecting the child and how online schooling will benefit them

StarlightLime · 21/12/2023 21:28

LadyWithLapdog · 21/12/2023 21:19

Are GPs meant to be telepathic? How would they know how your particular DC’s mental health is affected by f2f schooling and predict that online learning will be better? What if your DD decides in years to come that the GP was fucking wrong and scuppered her career chances etc.

It’s not a 5 minute job and, frankly, it’s not a GP remit.

Exactly. The notion that the gp should just meekly write whatever the parent demands is mind boggling, tbh.

LadyWithLapdog · 21/12/2023 21:21

@Diversion you didn’t pay £87. I think your funeral director did. He probably also charged you ££ for flowers or whatever, but that’s ok.

LadyWithLapdog · 21/12/2023 21:19

Are GPs meant to be telepathic? How would they know how your particular DC’s mental health is affected by f2f schooling and predict that online learning will be better? What if your DD decides in years to come that the GP was fucking wrong and scuppered her career chances etc.

It’s not a 5 minute job and, frankly, it’s not a GP remit.

coffeeaddict77 · 21/12/2023 21:05

FrostedFancy · 21/12/2023 16:28

Also, it could be the OP who's requesting the online learning, the GP just has to write something-or-other about her child's medical condition.

Exactly, all they have to write is that child seen, reported mental health issues due to health condition and how it affects them at school, awaiting referral made to CAHMs.

2-3 lines written in box on form put in front of them.

Could have been done during an appointment on NHS time but they won’t give me one.

How would they know how it effects them at school without looking into their records and maybe other research. It doesn't sound like a five minute job.